Acquital for Zimmerman

My understanding is you are innocent until proven guilty. Therefore not guilty is a statement that the prosecution has not proven you guilty of any thing therefore your status of innocent has hot changed.

at the same time acquittal is not proof or even evidence of innocence. OJ Simpson was acquitted at criminal trial, yet found liable civilly.
 
I can't see 'stand your ground' being an issue here with respect to either party. Martin was going somewhere. GZ did not stop him from going anywhere. Also, the CNN lawyers spoke of that law in terms of broadening the 2nd Amendment for gun owners in that they can stand their ground in defending their homes and not have to mitigate or retreat before using their weapon to defend themselves. I can't see that applying to TM here.

Here is the law:

(3) A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony.

If TM confronted Z and demanded to know why he was being followed, and Z then pulled a gun on him, that law entitled TM to use deadly force to stop the threat.

Moreover it entitled TM to stand his ground and demand an explanation, he had no obligation to flee or retreat from Z.
 
Stand-your-ground involves not having a duty to retreat if you can in a public place. In this case there was plenty of evidence that G.Z. was unable to retreat so stand-your-ground wasn't even raised.


Ok, I'll buy that, but it's interesting to note that the juror who spoke on CNN wrote to them yesterday and said they were still instructed (by default, as one of the lawyers commented) by the judge as to the SYG law, and said juror felt that lawmakers should change that law, implying that she considered that law in their decision, when it probably wasn't an issue per se as you've explained.

As an aside, doesn't SYG also mean that you don't have to retreat if it's your home (and that you can defend yourself in your home from an intruder with your gun)?
 
'Martin had every right to confront Z and demand to know why he was following him'.
Yeah......? Is that what you'd do in real Life, Mr. Fuji? That is, when you're not sitting at you computer talking about things you don't know about on an internet chat forum....? Sincerely, Jon .
 
Here is the law:

(3) A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony.

If TM confronted Z and demanded to know why he was being followed, and Z then pulled a gun on him, that law entitled TM to use deadly force to stop the threat.

Moreover it entitled TM to stand his ground and demand an explanation, he had no obligation to flee or retreat from Z.


First of all, if TM threw the first punch, he engaged in an unlawful activity (aggravated assault).

Secondly, if GZ responded to that punch with force, that is NOT an attack.

Thirdly, GZ's following of TM is NOT an attack.

TM's confrontation is just that. A confrontation, giving GZ, IF he was able to retreat (as aptly explained by Aardvark154), the right to stand his ground and defend himself, not TM. TM's acts do not involve the SYG defence or right IMHO.
 
Here is the law:

(3) A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony.

If TM confronted Z and demanded to know why he was being followed, and Z then pulled a gun on him, that law entitled TM to use deadly force to stop the threat.

Moreover it entitled TM to stand his ground and demand an explanation, he had no obligation to flee or retreat from Z.

i don't think GZ had to pull his gun. the young boy could have felt his life was in danger when a creepy guy following him gets out of his car
 
'So, just so I understand you right, you're saying...' 'At this point she says she heard a bump and faintly heard Martin say "get off."
Yeah..... If anyone can understand her.... Lol... She was clearly uncertain on this point under Defence questioning( 'it could've'... 'it could be'...). And her talk of someone taking a 'whoop ass' was revealing... Sincerely, Jon .
 
First of all, if TM threw the first punch, he engaged in an unlawful activity (aggravated assault).

Unless Z had already pulled his gun on him and of course Z may have thrown the first punch.

Thirdly, GZ's following of TM is NOT an attack.

Sure but it is creepy and TM had every right to confront his stalker and demand an explanation. It is likely at this point that hot headed Z pulled his gun.
 
As an aside, doesn't SYG also mean that you don't have to retreat if it's your home (and that you can defend yourself in your home from an intruder with your gun)?
In that case we are discussing what is commonly termed the Castle Doctrine (as in "a man's home is his castle").

So, yes and no. Yes, in that SYG is an extension of the Castle Doctrine, no in that most states which do not have STG laws, do have either Castle Doctrine laws or case law that has effectively eliminated the need for a statutory law.

There are only three jurisdictions that are outliers: Washington, D.C. (gee are you surprised), Vermont, and New Mexico. New York is sometimes considered to have a "weak Castle Doctrine" as New York law only allows for the use of "reasonable force" when defending yourself against Home Invasion - hence leading to the possibility of being charged if your use of deadly force is second guessed.

I should add that in many "Castle Doctrine" states there is still a requirement that you reasonably believe that there will be imminent use of unlawful force. (Hence if others can testify that they heard the home owner say "stop, lie down on the floor face down with your arms extended" and that the home intruder did not do that and that all this happened before the homeowner shot and killed the intruder it is likely to go much better for the homeowner - rather than Bob climbed in the window, Peter shot him dead before he even had both feet on the floor).
 
....


Sure but it is creepy and TM had every right to confront his stalker and demand an explanation. It is likely at this point that hot headed Z pulled his gun.
This is the part we haven't examined.

Martin allegedly (and reasonably) asked Zimmerman what his problem was.

Then ????

Then Martin allegedly threw the first punch.


From a moral (not legal) perspective, the way Zimmerman responded has a huge bearing. Based on Zimmerman's history, he likely didn't respond in a way to deescalate the situation as an actual cop should have.
 
It seems that this SYG law has effectively legalised duels and O.K. Corral style shootouts. Whoever wins just claims that they were standing their ground.

There will generally be a great deal of uncertainty about how it started and the winner will just say he feared the loser.
 
It seems that this SYG law has effectively legalised duels and O.K. Corral style shootouts. Whoever wins just claims that they were standing their ground.

There will generally be a great deal of uncertainty about how it started and the winner will just say he feared the loser.

thats my take as well
 
This is the part we haven't examined.

Martin allegedly (and reasonably) asked Zimmerman what his problem was.

Then ????

Then Martin allegedly threw the first punch.

From a moral (not legal) perspective, the way Zimmerman responded has a huge bearing. Based on Zimmerman's history, he likely didn't respond in a way to deescalate the situation as an actual cop should have.

I would suspect that Z had a paranoid fear of blacks and when he was confronted by an angry black on a dark night at close range he panicked and pulled his gun.

TM would then have attacked to prevent the gun coming up all the way and firing. At close range it is possible to close inside arms length and fight for the gun. A struggle that involved rolling around and Z getting his head smashed before he came up with the gun and shot TM.
 
Unless Z had already pulled his gun on him and of course Z may have thrown the first punch.



Sure but it is creepy and TM had every right to confront his stalker and demand an explanation. It is likely at this point that hot headed Z pulled his gun.


Your position is based on pure speculation, is illogical and not supported by the evidence.

Your application of the SGY law is incorrect too.

RJ even believes that TM threw the first punch. Who had the bloody or broken nose? If GZ first pulled his gun, how on earth could he end up under TM?

Whether GZ was following him or watching him from behind, and whether it was creepy or a nuisance, he didn't prevent TM from being where he was. And even if TM stopped to respond to GZ, he wasn't attacked by GZ. There's no evidence of TM being attacked. He was on top and the separation of his dangling shirt from the gun shot wound to his abdomen as well as GZ's back-of-head injuries confirm this.

(Me thinks you make things up to incite comments or responses if not fuel the flames).
 
It seems that this SYG law has effectively legalised duels and O.K. Corral style shootouts. Whoever wins just claims that they were standing their ground.

There will generally be a great deal of uncertainty about how it started and the winner will just say he feared the loser.
thats my take as well
Going back to #409,

"The whole reason that 60 percent of the states in the U.S. now have "stand-your-ground" laws are prosecutions that the public saw as being unfair (there have been discussions of such cases in the GTA here on TERB). Where (my opinion) overzealous prosecutors, looked at cases and said well the defendant didn't retreat long enough or far enough before they turned and confronted their attacker."

So how do you two propose to solve this problem? Particularly given that 30 state legislatures were so stupid that they were unable to figure out any other way than a SYG law.
 
I would suspect that Z had a paranoid fear of blacks and when he was confronted by an angry black on a dark night at close range he panicked and pulled his gun.

TM would then have attacked to prevent the gun coming up all the way and firing. At close range it is possible to close inside arms length and fight for the gun. A struggle that involved rolling around and Z getting his head smashed before he came up with the gun and shot TM.

I seriously doubt that fuji.

What I expect happened is after Martin questioned Zimmerman, George responded in an aggressive way feeling tough instead of calming the situation like an actual cop should. How much of his tough attitude was because he knew he had a gun and how much was just his normal attitude I don't know. The next reasonable step is Martin thew a punch.

Zimmerman likely acted like he wanted a fight which he promptly lost and pulled his gun.
 
SYG has nothing to do with being prevented from going somewhere GP. Read it. I posted it above.

The version I related is just as well supported by the facts as Z's version. The uncertainty about which is the truth is why both men are innocent. There is a reasonable doubt as to which of them is to blame.