Acquital for Zimmerman

The vast majority of the evidence presented at trial is available online, and much of it has been linked by various individuals in this and other related threads.

But those who blame Zimmerman for the events of "that night" still have a lot of explaining to do: the evidence holds that Zimmerman lost sight of Martin when he (Martin) went down the sidewalk which runs between the rows of residences between Twin Trees and Retreat View Circle (google map it or click : http://goo.gl/maps/8lFPF).

There is evidence that Zimmerman, having parked his vechicle on Twin Trees, walked past that sidewalk, from Twin Trees over to Retreat View Circle, and was heading back again.

Yet, in the time from when Zimmerman lost sight of Martin, until the time Martin was shot, Martin progressed about 20 feet south along that sidewalk. He was staying at a home about 70 to 100 yards further south along that same sidewalk, so a lot depends on whether he had enough time to continue home - as his defenders claim he was "just walking home".

Some believe that Zimmeran "stalked" Martin, and apparently caught up with him and dragged him back to where Martin was shot in cold blood.

Others believe that Martin circled back, confronted Zimmerman, sucker-punched Zimmeman in the face (breaking Zimmerman's nose), tusseled with Zimmerman in the grass, slammed Zimmerman's head into the sidewalk, and when Zimmerman's gun became exposed told Zimmerman something to the effect of "Tonight, you die!", at which point Zimmerman shot Martin, not believing at first that he actually hit Martin.

Zimmerman claims that as he was passing the "T" back to his vehicle Martin shouted to draw his attention, and the two exchanged words in a loud voice, with Martin eventually shouting words to the effect of, "Well, you got a problem now!" Witnesses reported hearing loud talking before hearing fighting, prior to the gunshot.

But if a teenager, who is reported as "running" on a call to police can only move 10 feet in about two minutes, in the rain, then he must be the victim. Believe it if you will. The rest of us will believe the facts.

WAit I thought GZ got out of his car to look for a street sign..... sounds like he walkd further than necessary. Also, when was the last time you had to get out of your car to read a street sign? And forget about the rain. I provided a link earlier showing that in sanford on feb 26 it rained 5 mm (for the whole day).... so I doubt the rain proved to be a probelm for visibility. Also, if he can determine from a distance that this kid looked suspisiouc why did his eyes fail him when look for a street sign?

Also, I find it far fetched that a kid being followed would double back and assault the guy with no provocation.

I do believe that words were exchanged and I highly doubt that GZ was calm and cordial as something must have been said to elicit the response of "well you got a problem now"
 
Frankcastle you are trying very hard to prove your inability, over and over and over again, to accept testimony, admitted evidence in this case and the jury's unanimous verdict.

The tragic incident took place in a very dark area behind units, and the unit numbers were on the front of the houses facing the street. Zimmermans statements and walk through showed that he claimed to have walked from behind the houses towards the front of the houses, in fact, in a different direction than he thought Trayvon Martin had gone. He went stratight, he said Trayvon went right down the T- path a cement walkway with the only lights on the back of the units, not over the walkway - on which he later claims his head was being smashed. In this case, darkness trumps rain.

It is highly probable that a kid who was into fighting (not admitted as evidence, but it was Mr Martins reality ) would size up Zimmerman from a vantage point, and make the (fatal) decision that he could whoop his ass. Why? because he was a craccka? bcuz he could then brag about it on his twitter feed, build up his street cred? bcuz he felt like it? who knows, but it is NOT far fetched.

The defence did a brilliant job of proving that Trayvon Martin had choices and options. He had MINUTES to simply walk, run or crawl away- to a unit less than 80 yards away where he would have been home. Did you review the defences closing arguments? you should, this part of it was genius, powerful and persuasive.
 
You guys are pathetic. Stand your ground applies to the white guy but not the black guy?

Martin is guilty because he "had options" to flee from the white guy but instead he chose to stand his ground and confront the creep who was hunting him?

Martin stood his ground rather than fleeing, confronted his assailant, who drew a gun on him at close range. A struggle ensued in which Martin fought for his life trying to get the gun from his attacker, but lost.

That is not only possible but perhaps likely and Martin is entitled to that presumption of his innocence.

Racism here reveals itself in the way a different standard is applied to the two. Zimmerman is entitled to stand his ground but Martin is guilty since he didn't take the option to flee.

Martin's passing involvement with firearms is relevant but we are to ignore the fact that Zimmerman literally got a gun and hunted down a black man.

Martin once got into a fight so he clearly must be responsible but Zimmerman's criminal history of violence is not relevant.

Seems like posters here are not giving each man the same benefit of the doubt at all!
 
You have trouble reading English? Is our perhaps not your first language? I clearly stated that Z is innocent.

There is a reasonable doubt as to who initiated the fight and thus that are both presumed innocent.

What I am pointing out I is the astonishingly obvious point that a not guilty verdict for Z does not make TM guilty.


Correct but TM would be guilty of what if he were guilty? Assault? In any event, it's academic if not irrelevant.
 
You guys are pathetic. Stand your ground applies to the white guy but not the black guy?

Martin is guilty because he "had options" to flee from the white guy but instead he chose to stand his ground and confront the creep who was hunting him?

Martin stood his ground rather than fleeing, confronted his assailant, who drew a gun on him at close range. A struggle ensued in which Martin fought for his life trying to get the gun from his attacker, but lost.

That is not only possible but perhaps likely and Martin is entitled to that presumption of his innocence.

Racism here reveals itself in the way a different standard is applied to the two. Zimmerman is entitled to stand his ground but Martin is guilty since he didn't take the option to flee.

Martin's passing involvement with firearms is relevant but we are to ignore the fact that Zimmerman literally got a gun and hunted down a black man.

Martin once got into a fight so he clearly must be responsible but Zimmerman's criminal history of violence is not relevant.

Seems like posters here are not giving each man the same benefit of the doubt at all!

There is absolutely zero evidence that Zimmerman HUNTED Martin. HUNTED is a loaded word, it implies mal intent and the eventual outcome of killing the thing being hunted.

Martin was not on trial here. The state brought an action on his behalf. Why do you insist on spewing about his guilt or his innocence? That was not the purpose of the trial and evidence/ witnesses did not attest to Martins guilt or innocence one way or the other. In my view there is ample evidence that he did commit a crime, assault and battery.

Whose judgement is it that Zimmerman was a creep? Martins, expressed through Jeantel? Yours? how did that assessment effect Trayvon Martins behaviour?

I will venture into muddy water now, Lets stipulate that Martin exercised his right to stand his ground, (an argument that wasnt asserted in this trial by Zimmermans defence, they claimed self defence, i.e. he was getting beaten by Martin so he defended his life before he turned into a vegetable or was killed by Trayvon Martins head bashing ). Martins decision to "stand his ground" turned into a fatal mistake, because he ended up dead, as the other guy who was equally "standing his ground" had a gun.

The jury, fairly selected, based solely on evidence admitted in this trial, did not find that Zimmerman committed second degree murder or manslaughter.

In Zimmermans case it was tragic too, he killed another human being and will have to live with that. No winners here. Martin obviously paid a much much bigger price for his part in this incident.

There are several perspectives and discussions in play here, which confuse the discussions ;
1. The trial. It was decided on the evidence allowed into the courtroom and presented to the jury. the prosecution had every opportunity to get evidence into this courtroom that would convince a jury that Zimmerman committed second degree murder or manslaughter. They failed.
2. The court of public opinion- where all of these others un-admitted facts, innuendos , impressions, real and fake claims, biases, prejudices, etc... are being included in posts /// this is much more difficult to render a solid opinion because people can agree or disagree on what is and is not true, or relevant.
3. Those with agendas- like the lawyer who stated on Greta VanSusterns show that she is a social engineer. Like those now trying to "open dialogue" on stand your ground rules, gun laws, gin up racial divisions, etc...

Fuji, i would place you in my #3. You have an agenda, maybe it is just trolling? I don't know, or really care. You are a proven pita. And it is obvious to those whom you call pathetic that is merely a reflection of your own chronic ineptitude.
 
Correct but TM would be guilty of what if he were guilty? Assault? In any event, it's academic if not irrelevant.

People here are claiming that he initiated the confrontation as though the acquittal of Z makes that proven fact when really it still seems quite unlikely.

Everyone should respect that the jury had reasonable doubt as to whether Z was the aggressor but that does not mean that Z's version is fact.
 
Yes... I agree. By the way, could you please show us Mr. Zimmerman's 'criminal history of violence'? Sincerely, Jon .

My comment here is on the biases of people here and I brought that up to highlight the racism present in this thread.

He was charged with resisting arrest with violence and also had restraining orders against him for allegations of domestic violence. The charges were waived when he voluntarily accepted diversion to a substance abuse programme.

I am bringing this up in reply to another poster who used similar information about TM to insinuate that must have started the fight.

So apparently it is OK to smear the black guy by referring to minor incidents in his past, but not the white guy. Ditto with respect to their involvement with firearms. Ditto with respect to the application of stand your ground.

In each case a different standard is being applied to the black guy by the usual suspects around here.
 
People here are claiming that he initiated the confrontation as though the acquittal of Z makes that proven fact when really it still seems quite unlikely.

Everyone should respect that the jury had reasonable doubt as to whether Z was the aggressor but that does not mean that Z's version is fact.


Correct BUT how can TM end up on top of a bigger guy like GZ? It's reasonable to say that TM suckered punched him, or surprised him, meaning he was possibly if not probably the aggressor? (In any case, it still may be irrelevant if TM was bashing GZ's head against the ground such that GZ thought he would pass out or die and felt threatened enough to stop TM with deadly force).
 
I wanted to add (got interrupted by spellcheck and downloaded that add-on program ieSpell) that a friend of mine told me that GZ called 911 46 times in the past couple of years or so to report 'suspicious black males', IIRC.

Perhaps he is a bit of a looney but unfortunately, we still can't call him a racist or vigilante.
 
So was Trayvon walking through the neighbourhood that night looking for a fight? I doubt that.

Or was he provoked into one? Well when he said "you got a problem?" must mean that George was taking a stroll through his neighbourhood and Trayvon walked up to him randomly and asked "you got a problem?" RIGHT? since Trayvon is the one who apparently caused all the events of that night right?

Trayvon was probably the aggressor and initiated the fight - but anyone with the slightest of common sense would know what they're getting into when you attempt to confront someone who you "believe" is suspicious, thuggish looking, black, etc. George knew something COULD happen and he went anyway because he had his gun.

Not saying Travyon is some sweet innocent black kid - far from it. But if you think George is some honourable saint who protected his neighbourhood you're just as delusional as Al Sharpton. Also, you can have colored friends, and even a coloured signfiicant other and still be a racist - it's a continuum.
 
So was Trayvon walking through the neighbourhood that night looking for a fight? I doubt that.

Or was he provoked into one? Well when he said "you got a problem?" must mean that George was taking a stroll through his neighbourhood and Trayvon walked up to him randomly and asked "you got a problem?"

Trayvon was probably the aggressor and initiated the fight - but anyone with the slightest of common sense would know what they're getting into when you attempt to confront someone who you "believe" is suspicious, thuggish looking, black, etc. George knew something COULD happen and he went anyway because he had his gun.

Not saying Travyon is some sweet innocent black kid - far from it. But if you think George is some honourable saint who protected his neighbourhood you're just as delusional as Al Sharpton. Also, you can have colored friends, and even a coloured signfiicant other and still be a racist - it's a continuum.

You are probably right!

That juror who said on CNN that GZ's heart was in the right place made an asinine remark (hey, the auto-spell check worked - download ieSpeller folks!) because I think that was too presumptuous of her to say from all that I've read up to this point.

As someone said to Spiderman, with great power comes great responsibility (therefore, if you have a gun, don't fucking alarm if not provoke someone needlessly, especially if yours is concealed).
 
question: If it wasn't for the stand your ground law in florida, might gz be guilty of manslaughter or is it still self-defense?
 
question: If it wasn't for the stand your ground law in florida, might gz be guilty of manslaughter or is it still self-defense?
As has been mentioned several times the defence never raised the issue of stand your ground the defence was entirely based upon self-defence.
 
Frankcastle you are trying very hard to prove your inability, over and over and over again, to accept testimony, admitted evidence in this case and the jury's unanimous verdict.

The tragic incident took place in a very dark area behind units, and the unit numbers were on the front of the houses facing the street. ....

Speaking of ignoring testimony...

George told the police that he got out of his car to check the street sign to better report to the cops as he was trained (lets forget there are only three streets in the neighbourhood that he was watch for and should therefore have known the area like the back of his hand). Then instead of that, he walks down a dark lane to another street.

As I said, he was found not guilty by the law but the evidence shows quite clearly that was playing cop.
 
Speaking of ignoring testimony...

George told the police that he got out of his car to check the street sign to better report to the cops as he was trained (lets forget there are only three streets in the neighbourhood that he was watch for and should therefore have known the area like the back of his hand). Then instead of that, he walks down a dark lane to another street.

As I said, he was found not guilty by the law but the evidence shows quite clearly that was playing cop.

Im pretty sure he said he was checking for unit numbers, not street names ..... and the numbers were on the front side of the units. So in order to see the number of the unit he was behind, so according to him he could accurately describe his location TO THE COPS, he had to walk to the front of the unit in order to get that number

I disagree with your other conclusion, the evidence is clear that he knew the difference between Neighbourhood watch and Cop. He knew enough to call the cops and keep them on the phone.

im curious? care to withdraw your conclusion/
 
question: If it wasn't for the stand your ground law in florida, might gz be guilty of manslaughter or is it still self-defense?

What I find interesting is if instead of being dead, Martin was charged with assault, he could have easily used Stand Your Ground as a defense.
 
Im pretty sure he said he was checking for unit numbers, not street names ..... and the numbers were on the front side of the units. So in order to see the number of the unit he was behind, so according to him he could accurately describe his location TO THE COPS, he had to walk to the front of the unit in order to get that number

I disagree with your other conclusion, the evidence is clear that he knew the difference between Neighbourhood watch and Cop. He knew enough to call the cops and keep them on the phone.

im curious? care to withdraw your conclusion/

Again, read the testimony. He said the only reason he got out of his car was to check the street sign. Even if you don't believe that, once he got out of his car, he would have had a 10 ft walk to the nearest house to check the sign but instead he walked down a dark alley to another street.

Why would I withdraw my conclusion? He clearly was following Martin instead of doing what he was trained.
 
Correct but TM would be guilty of what if he were guilty? Assault? In any event, it's academic if not irrelevant.
Probably aggravated assault about eight to ten years imprisonment, plus of course a civil suit for medical costs, pain and suffering etc. . . .