Acquital for Zimmerman

You mis read Danmand's post. While you are barred from introducing evidence of the ACCUSED'S prior bad acts, the prior bad acts of the alleged vic can be introduced where relevant and especially so in when a defence of self-defence is raised. As such, the defence could have argued TM's bad character if it was relevant to the defence. Relevance would include drug use, propensity to break the law and propensity to violence - or its symbols such as firearms. These all suggest that TM might potentially be a person who would attack and do violence to GZ.
True of course Oagre, and there were other reasons why the Defence didn't bring them up. However, Jfire999 was writing of G.Z.'s prior bad acts.
 
160713shirt.jpg
 
ROBERT ZIMMERMAN (7/13/2013): He's a free man in the eyes of the court, but he's going to be looking around his shoulder for the rest of his life. There are factions, there are groups, there are people that would want to take the law into their own hands as they perceived it or, you know, be vigilantes in some sense.

George's brother is worried about armed vigilantes. this should be added to the OED as the text book example of irony.
 
You almost have it there Fuji. The trial is only one part of it.

The law says Zimmerman is ALWAYS INNOCENT, until proven guilty.

He WAS, and still is, INNOCENT.

in the end, the trial did not change his status.

Yes. However Martin is also presumed innocent and since all the Z trial did was raise a reasonable doubt about who attacked, his status has not changed either.
 
The verdict was right based on the available evidence and facts. It doesn't mean Zimmerman is innocent, but there was no way to prove without a reasonable doubt that he was guilty. Since nobody knows exactly what happened, there is plenty of reasonable doubt to go around. That is the letter of the law and the system worked.

To call the verdict racist is completely misguided.

Well said, except that he actually is innocent.

You can follow whomever you want, suspicious person or not. Being a follower, a creep, a wannabe cop is not illegal. You nor anybody else knows who confronted who or who attacked who first. I don't believe Zimmerman attacked Trayvon. He's a small soft spoken weakling. He may have confronted Trayvon and by confront I mean he may have asked Trayvon what he was doing in the area. I was a teenager once and I suspect Trayvon got pissed that some stranger had the nerve to not mind his own business and a physical altercation started. Being stronger, he ended up on top.



I completely disagree with the first sentence. Zimmerman has the right to walk wherever he wants or follow who he wants. He is not responsible for another person attacking him.

The rest of your argument about confronting someone was already dealt with and is nothing but conjecture. It's just one aspect of the case where reasonable doubt comes into play.



The case has little to do with a pro or anti-gun agenda, at least when the facts of the case are looked at objectively.

Nailed it. Nicely put. I didn't read any further in this thread.
 
BTW instead of arguing with fuji over the word innocent.... I see what he is saying. Which is that the court did not have enough evidence to erase reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury that GZ was innocent. But that doesn't mean that GZ was not responsible (just that the court couldn't prove it past the necessary point)

I found it interesting readin the interview with one of the jury members. There's seems to be a difference between their gut feeling and what's right vs the law.

That's the point of the verdict. He wasn't found innocent, but rather not guilty beyond reasonable doubt. Next stop civil court, call me when that's over.
 
It is not. But the rule is one famous or infamous in hearsay.

I don't think that is how the Courts view it in Canada. In Canada it would be assessed as similar fact evidence - but it would likely be inadmissible in the end regardless of whether it is assessed as similar fact evidence or some version of the hearsay rule.
 
I don't "believe" anything but you are embarrassingly wrong in stating that the defence proved that Zimmerman is innocent.

It is very very basic to our legal system that the defence only needs to raise a reasonable doubt. They do not, and are not required to, prove their client innocent.

The difference is subtle and if you consider only Zimmerman the difference is irrelevant, but that difference is extremely relevant if you start trying to use the verdict to make claims about what Martin did.

A reasonable doubt is enough to have Z presumed (not proved) innocent but it gives NO INFORMATION on whether M was even remotely culpable.

You should be ashamed for not knowing this.

In any case you are entirely wrong to say that either OJ or Z was legally proved innocent. They are presumed innocent which is very very different.


Correction. The burden of proof is 'beyond a reasonable doubt'. I've also heard or read 'beyond a reasonable doubt to a moral certainty'.

But you're right. They may not be innocent or negligent free.
 
Yes. However Martin is also presumed innocent and since all the Z trial did was raise a reasonable doubt about who attacked, his status has not changed either.

Oh really???? certainly TM status HAS CHANGED!

Ill take GZ 'innocent' status anyday!
 
Still think they will have real problems getting past self-defence. Further, big difference between the assets of O.J.S. and G.Z. (not that O.J. has ever paid one thin dime).
The talking heads on CNN said there might be a civil suit for two possible reasons.
1) On point of principle.
2) In case GZ strikes it rich in the future (maybe a book deal, lottery win, etc.).
 
Still think they will have real problems getting past self-defence. Further, big difference between the assets of O.J.S. and G.Z. (not that O.J. has ever paid one thin dime).

From what I understand, OJ had a good personal liability insurance policy. Maybe they collected on that.