Thank a union it's friday

What a silly response
No we move forward and evolve

Buggy whips , VHS and beer bottle openers all had a period were they were useful, however they did become obsolete
Same for unions
Only the added bonus of eliminating unions in the public sector would be balanced budgets, manageable debt loads and the taxpayer might finally get a break
There is no need to pay the ridiculous salary and benefits which are being extorted in the public sector


Brilliant! Don't think of it as clawing back any advances that have been made, think of it as "moving forward" and "evolving".On a going-forward basis, I for one am super pleased at the prospect of us evolving out of having any rights or protections as workers. Buggy whips, VHS, unions, universal healthcare, human rights... all outdated concepts, right? It'll just be think-outside-the-box time for everyone, and a golden age where we can all be entrepeneurs! See you in the bread lines!
 
I was a member of a union for 30-plus years. When I joined the company labour negotiations involved getting better benefits from the company. When I left it was a matter of the union fighting for our jobs and its existence. The company played different areas of the firm against each other, offering certain areas better benefits for a positive vote for a contract that included such things as getting rid of other areas by outsourcing work.

Older workers were offered a sweet buyout. In the next contract negotiations the company wanted the right to hire future employees on a contract basis and no benefits, effectively killing the union. Of course the older workers voted for it because they didn't want their buyout threatened.

Now companies are hiring people under the guise of unpaid internships, using the excuse it's experience. I bet my former union won't exist within five years.

I don't think my former employer -- for sure well known to everyone on this board -- is any different from any other big corporation.
 
I was a member of a union for 30-plus years. When I joined the company labour negotiations involved getting better benefits from the company. When I left it was a matter of the union fighting for our jobs and its existence. The company played different areas of the firm against each other, offering certain areas better benefits for a positive vote for a contract that included such things as getting rid of other areas by outsourcing work.

Older workers were offered a sweet buyout. In the next contract negotiations the company wanted the right to hire future employees on a contract basis and no benefits, effectively killing the union. Of course the older workers voted for it because they didn't want their buyout threatened.

Now companies are hiring people under the guise of unpaid internships, using the excuse it's experience. I bet my former union won't exist within five years.

I don't think my former employer -- for sure well known to everyone on this board -- is any different from any other big corporation.

The real problem with unions is many take an us vs. them mentality.
Faced with an antagonistic and threatening opposition, management is forced into taking a similar stance
This leads to a counterproductive relationship.

Unions need to recognise that company owners are risking their capital to run the business and need to see return on this capital
Other inputs into the process include management time and expertise, raw materials, the ability to secure clients and labor
Unskilled labor is the least difficult of all these to replace and has many substitutes including: automation, outsourcing to other companies or other countries.

Management needs to ensure they provide a safe environment to work in, adhere to all applicable laws and pay a wage and benefit which will entice workers to stay.
That does not translate into agreeing to pay to a specified standard of living

The owners will receive the return on their investment or they will sell or close down the operation
Faced with uncooperative labor partner, they will take steps to reduce the impact of that relationship on their operations.

There has been an uncooperative relationship between management and unions for decades, so no one should be surprised that union influence has been reduced and will continue to be reduced as management looks to remove this negative impact

Unions need to recognise two very important trends
1. They are being minimized because they are being viewed as a negative influence on the business, rather than as a valuable partner
2. Their survival is dependant upon establishing a new relationship with management. Us vs. them is not working and will not work going forward.
 
Brilliant! Don't think of it as clawing back any advances that have been made, think of it as "moving forward" and "evolving".On a going-forward basis, I for one am super pleased at the prospect of us evolving out of having any rights or protections as workers. Buggy whips, VHS, unions, universal healthcare, human rights... all outdated concepts, right? It'll just be think-outside-the-box time for everyone, and a golden age where we can all be entrepeneurs! See you in the bread lines!

Universal healthcare and human rights are government policies, and reflect the electorates values
They are not the result of unions

See you in the bread lines? If you continue to think your future is secured by joining a union, then you might wind up there
Best way to avoid a bread-line is to obtain skills which are in demand
 
I agree with you except that dealing with the us vs. them mentality should be a two-way street. Management should stop thinking of workers as "human resources" but as real people who are willing to give a life-long commitment in return for decent wages and living conditions. Not a resource that can be replaced by interns, outsourcing or hiring foreign workers. Or, am I being too naive?

The real problem with unions is many take an us vs. them mentality ... etc.
 
Tell that to Tommy Douglas and the CCF, a political party formed from various labour groups that became the government of Saskatchewan and introduced universal health care. Sure, it was government policy that reflected electorate values, but it wouldn't have come about without the contribution of unions.

Universal healthcare and human rights are government policies, and reflect the electorates values
They are not the result of unions

See you in the bread lines? If you continue to think your future is secured by joining a union, then you might wind up there
Best way to avoid a bread-line is to obtain skills which are in demand
 
Marketable skills

Love em or hate em, truth is, no employer would give any anything - pay and benefits would be in the dark ages. And many non-union positions gain increases and benefits to keep "in line" with Unions.

Everyone can talk tough, truth is wages and benefits would just stagnate. Not to mention working conditions.

And most important of all "fiscal restraint" would prevail, and none of us would have any money to spend on the good ladies here.

I don't understand the logic here,...your saying that pay and benefits for EVERY job is related to what unions have black mailed employers for in NONE skilled positions ?

The actual result of unions is,...INCREASING the spread between the unionised none skilled labourer pay rate, and a none unionised labourer‘s rate.
Unions are NOT out there for the "WORKERS",...if they were,...EVERY unskilled labour position would be unionised.

There is absolutely NO justification for some to have a pay rate that is 2 to 3 times some one else for the same type of work,...just because some belong to a union !!!

Working conditions are regulated by governments, have been for a generation.

You CANNOT artificially create a life style or pay rate, at least not in the free world.

But you can bankrupt companies and provinces.

FAST
 
Define

I agree with you except that dealing with the us vs. them mentality should be a two-way street. Management should stop thinking of workers as "human resources" but as real people who are willing to give a life-long commitment in return for decent wages and living conditions. Not a resource that can be replaced by interns, outsourcing or hiring foreign workers. Or, am I being too naive?

Couple of questions,...what is "decent wages and living conditions",...and who and HOW is that determined ?

And, obviously your not talking about a union shop here.

FAST
 
Decent wages and living conditions come from wages that provide sufficient income to meet basic needs. According to the Canadian Labour Congress, "One in three men and 40% of women hold jobs which are part-time or temporary, not full-time, permanent jobs. Almost one in four adult workers in Canada today is low paid, earning less than the amount needed to keep even a single person above the poverty line in a large urban centre."

Couple of questions,...what is "decent wages and living conditions",...and who and HOW is that determined ?

And, obviously your not talking about a union shop here.

FAST
 
The real drag on the economy is the tax rate that companies get away with paying in Ontario. Tax rates for corporations have dropped over 30% in the last 30 years and we pay for everything now.
 
I don't understand the logic here,...your saying that pay and benefits for EVERY job is related to what unions have black mailed employers for in NONE skilled positions ?

The actual result of unions is,...INCREASING the spread between the unionised none skilled labourer pay rate, and a none unionised labourer‘s rate.
Unions are NOT out there for the "WORKERS",...if they were,...EVERY unskilled labour position would be unionised.

There is absolutely NO justification for some to have a pay rate that is 2 to 3 times some one else for the same type of work,...just because some belong to a union !!!

Working conditions are regulated by governments, have been for a generation.

You CANNOT artificially create a life style or pay rate, at least not in the free world.

But you can bankrupt companies and provinces.

FAST

I have to assume that "NONE skilled positions" should read unskilled labour?
Assuming that,do you really believe a plumber,electrician,mill wright,welder is unskilled?It's a 5 yr apprenticeship combining school work and practical work.This country is in desparate need of these what you call unskilled labour.
The big 5 banks have shown how easy it is to replace an IT employee.
Yes I am in a union.Do I agree with everything they do..No.Have they kept my wages from falling behind inflation...Yes.
My personal opinion is people who hate unions are mad because they don't have the same protection from shitty empolyers.Listen,they have good points and bad.Do the Toronto firefighters deserve the raise they got,probably not.Do teachers deserve what they get,probably not.
I thank unions everday when an employer kills a worker because they don't want to follow saftey laws and the empolyer gets their ass fined.Not to many workers know they can refuse unsafe work.Unions let workers know their rights under the law.Employers don't like that because it costs $$ to have a safe workplace.Ask the construction workers up 20-30 stories building all those condos in Toronto if the would do that work without a fall arrest harness.Thank the unions for letting them know they can refuse the work instead of being splattered all over the sidewalk below.
Have some unions put companies or regional governments in bad fiscal shape..maybe.But don't forget the companies and government leaders can allways say NO.Look at the salaries of CEO's and MP's.Are they deserved..NO.
 
Love em or hate em, truth is, no employer would give any anything - pay and benefits would be in the dark ages. And many non-union positions gain increases and benefits to keep "in line" with Unions.

Everyone can talk tough, truth is wages and benefits would just stagnate. Not to mention working conditions.

And most important of all "fiscal restraint" would prevail, and none of us would have any money to spend on the good ladies here.

You comments presuppose no competition in the market place. Labour is a marketplace just like anything else. It is follows the same laws of supply and demand as any other product or service.

I have no love for unions either, so I will state that upfront. One thing that union members seem to thoroughly despise is the concept of merit based pay. In a union things are done by seniority. So there is no incentive for anyone to work any harder than the next guy.

Cheers
 
The real drag on the economy is the tax rate that companies get away with paying in Ontario. Tax rates for corporations have dropped over 30% in the last 30 years and we pay for everything now.

You do understand economics if you truly believe that
Do you think raising corp tax rates will add incremental jobs?
 
I have to assume that "NONE skilled positions" should read unskilled labour? Assuming that,do you really believe a plumber,electrician,mill wright,welder is unskilled?It's a 5 yr apprenticeship combining school work and practical work.This country is in desparate need of these what you call unskilled labour.
Those are skilled jobs and as such will command a higher wage, union or no union

The big 5 banks have shown how easy it is to replace an IT employee.
IT skills have a substitute, offshore IT people.

Yes I am in a union.Do I agree with everything they do..No.Have they kept my wages from falling behind inflation...Yes.
This is where you really go astray. Your expectation is your company will provide you with a standard of living that keeps pace with inflation
If your companies profits grow as fast or faster than inflation, then you have a semi-valid argument
If they do not then you can not expect the owners to give up their return in order to match inflation

We have had benign inflation for many years now, however it will creep back into the equation at some point and probably with a vengeance
If inflation is 5% will you expect a 5% increase or will you first evaluate if your company has been able to grow profits at that rate.

The company does not exist to provide you with employment, it exists to generate a profit for the owners
Union heads think it is the other way around


My personal opinion is people who hate unions are mad because they don't have the same protection from shitty employers.Listen,they have good points and bad.Do the Toronto firefighters deserve the raise they got,probably not.Do teachers deserve what they get,probably not.
You could not be more wrong
The animosity toward Public Sector unions is as taxpayers. We have to pay for these excessive wages and benefits
Do we value the services ?
Yes
Are we willing to pay too much for them ?
No


I thank unions ever day when an employer kills a worker because they don't want to follow saftey laws and the empolyer gets their ass fined.Not to many workers know they can refuse unsafe work.Unions let workers know their rights under the law. Employers don't like that because it costs $$ to have a safe workplace.Ask the construction workers up 20-30 stories building all those condos in Toronto if the would do that work without a fall arrest harness.Thank the unions for letting them know they can refuse the work instead of being splattered all over the sidewalk below.
This is the one and only justification for unions.
However no company wants to have employees injured and most are more than willing to spend $$ to ensure a safe workplace


Have some unions put companies or regional governments in bad fiscal shape..maybe
No if and or buts about this the answer is absolutely yes

.But don't forget the companies and government leaders can always say NO.
And the end result is a strike or refusal of services. example Extra circulars for students cut off by irresponsible teachers
Personally, I wished the govt would say no far more often

Look at the salaries of CEO's and MP's.Are they deserved..NO.
Not at all relevant
CEO compensation is determined by the owners of the company. If unions take an ownership position, they can influence this.
Unless you have an ownership position the CEO compensation it is none of your business
That is jealously and nothing else.


MPs ?
Most of them could replace the MP salary in a heart beat in the private sector because most of them have very unique and in demand skills
This is a area where you can express you dissatisfaction by writing your MP asking to be more respectful of your tax dollars.
1. I doubt you will get very far
2. MP comp is a drop in the bucket relative to excess given away to unions
The latest teachers deal cost ONT an extra $112 MM every year and the education budget is $24B
 
Legislate a life style

Decent wages and living conditions come from wages that provide sufficient income to meet basic needs. According to the Canadian Labour Congress, "One in three men and 40% of women hold jobs which are part-time or temporary, not full-time, permanent jobs. Almost one in four adult workers in Canada today is low paid, earning less than the amount needed to keep even a single person above the poverty line in a large urban centre."

I'm not going to debate those numbers,...especially considering the source,...but just what is "sufficient income", and how do we go about doubling or tripling wages,...need some numbers and methodology here.

And having everybody work for the government, isn't a solution.

FAST
 
Pick one

The real drag on the economy is the tax rate that companies get away with paying in Ontario. Tax rates for corporations have dropped over 30% in the last 30 years and we pay for everything now.

How the hell do companies have a drag on the economy.

If you had a choice between having everybody employed at a good wage and "companies" not paying a single cent in taxes,...or having half of the employable population employed,...and the "companies" paying high taxes.

FAST
 
Those are skilled jobs and as such will command a higher wage, union or no union


IT skills have a substitute, offshore IT people.


This is where you really go astray. Your expectation is your company will provide you with a standard of living that keeps pace with inflation
If your companies profits grow as fast or faster than inflation, then you have a semi-valid argument
If they do not then you can not expect the owners to give up their return in order to match inflation

We have had benign inflation for many years now, however it will creep back into the equation at some point and probably with a vengeance
If inflation is 5% will you expect a 5% increase or will you first evaluate if your company has been able to grow profits at that rate.

The company does not exist to provide you with employment, it exists to generate a profit for the owners
Union heads think it is the other way around



You could not be more wrong
The animosity toward Public Sector unions is as taxpayers. We have to pay for these excessive wages and benefits
Do we value the services ?
Yes
Are we willing to pay too much for them ?
No



This is the one and only justification for unions.
However no company wants to have employees injured and most are more than willing to spend $$ to ensure a safe workplace



No if and or buts about this the answer is absolutely yes


And the end result is a strike or refusal of services. example Extra circulars for students cut off by irresponsible teachers
Personally, I wished the govt would say no far more often


Not at all relevant
CEO compensation is determined by the owners of the company. If unions take an ownership position, they can influence this.
Unless you have an ownership position the CEO compensation it is none of your business
That is jealously and nothing else.


MPs ?
Most of them could replace the MP salary in a heart beat in the private sector because most of them have very unique and in demand skills
This is a area where you can express you dissatisfaction by writing your MP asking to be more respectful of your tax dollars.
1. I doubt you will get very far
2. MP comp is a drop in the bucket relative to excess given away to unions
The latest teachers deal cost ONT an extra $112 MM every year and the education budget is $24B

Some good points John.

I just want to say that I do not expect my company to match my wage increases with inflation.I am saying my union has done a good job negotiating a contract to keep up.My last wage increas was $0.15 but I have COLA rolled in every year.We also have a profit sharing program.
As an investor in the sock market I realize that companies are their to make money for shareholders above anyone else.
What pisses me off is when CEO's make mistake after mistake and keep getting rewarded for screwing the company up.People on the shop floor do quality work and don't get the huge pay raises (% wise) as CEO's whos decisions are highly quetionable.
 
Some,...but not all

I have to assume that "NONE skilled positions" should read unskilled labour?
Assuming that,do you really believe a plumber,electrician,mill wright,welder is unskilled?It's a 5 yr apprenticeship combining school work and practical work.This country is in desparate need of these what you call unskilled labour.
Yes I am in a union.Do I agree with everything they do..No.Have they kept my wages from falling behind inflation...Yes.
My personal opinion is people who hate unions are mad because they don't have the same protection from shitty empolyers.Listen,they have good points and bad.Do the Toronto firefighters deserve the raise they got,probably not.Do teachers deserve what they get,probably not.
I thank unions everday when an employer kills a worker because they don't want to follow saftey laws and the empolyer gets their ass fined.Not to many workers know they can refuse unsafe work.Unions let workers know their rights under the law.Employers don't like that because it costs $$ to have a safe workplace.Ask the construction workers up 20-30 stories building all those condos in Toronto if the would do that work without a fall arrest harness.Thank the unions for letting them know they can refuse the work instead of being splattered all over the sidewalk below.
Have some unions put companies or regional governments in bad fiscal shape..maybe.But don't forget the companies and government leaders can allways say NO.Look at the salaries of CEO's and MP's.Are they deserved..NO.

Obviously my post was in rely to the OPs who were insinuating that unskilled labour had some right to "x" wages, not based on economics.
And also obvious, the trades you mention are NOT unskilled ???,...don't know why you even stated that.

The one rational point you did make about being a shortage of these skilled,...you'll have to check with our often praised, by some anyway, education system.
On that same point,...that also proves that if you have a marketable skill set,...like auto mechanics,...these people are laughing all the way to the bank, and don‘t need a union to black mail their employer for unrealistic wages.

On the safety issue,…I have to agree with you that the government is not doing a very good job in this area,…so we have to rely on unions to help out here,…but you have also to acknowledge that not everybody is unionised,…so the problem is not really solved.

And your still repeating that because you belong to a union,…YOU have a right to be protected from inflation,…and the none unionised some how don’t deserve that.

You mention profit sharing,...the CAW is still in the dark ages on that subject, and THAT is a good example of just why unions have the out of touch reputation they have.

FAST
 
Some good points John.

I just want to say that I do not expect my company to match my wage increases with inflation.I am saying my union has done a good job negotiating a contract to keep up.My last wage increas was $0.15 but I have COLA rolled in every year.We also have a profit sharing program.
As an investor in the sock market I realize that companies are their to make money for shareholders above anyone else.
What pisses me off is when CEO's make mistake after mistake and keep getting rewarded for screwing the company up.People on the shop floor do quality work and don't get the huge pay raises (% wise) as CEO's whos decisions are highly quetionable.

as an investor, you have every right to question the value of CEO compensation for the companies you own
If you feel strongly about it, go to the AGM and voice your opinion

However their compensation must viewed in isolation relative to the value they generate
If they do not generate value or make poor decisions, they should be replaced.
At a minimum, you should lobby to have their pay tied to the performance of the company and the performance of the stock

You can not equate their compensation relative to the comp on the shop floor
Two completely different worlds and a battle you will not win
 
You mention profit sharing,...the CAW is still in the dark ages on that subject, and THAT is a good example of just why unions have the out of touch reputation they have.

FAST

Both the UAW and CAW had an opportunity to accept profit sharing and instead they foolishly insisted on a pension benefits package which ultimately was the millstone which drove GM and Chrysler into bankruptcy.
I wonder how different things might have worked out had the UAW and CAW worked as partners with the auto companies, rather than as antagonists