wente on legalizing prostitution: she got it wrong

big apple

New member
Mar 14, 2011
352
0
0
Why are feminists and other progressive types so enthusiastic about legalizing prostitution? It baffles me. Prostitution is the most exploitative, degrading work on Earth. Despite those stories about high-class call girls, its practitioners are overwhelmingly the most wretched girls and women in society. Prostitution turns women into lumps of meat that are bought and sold for the sexual gratification of men. If you legalize it, you will probably get more. Please explain how that can be a good thing.


The current case before the Supreme Court of Canada argues that indoor prostitution should be legalized in order to improve the safety and dignity of sex workers. Its poster girl is media darling Terri-Jean Bedford, the leather-clad kitten with a whip who was busted way back when for operating an upscale S&M service for clients who paid her to be tied up and thrashed. I admire Ms. Bedford. She is a sharp entrepreneur and a brilliant publicist. But she is no more typical of the sex trade than your Great-Aunt Dorothy. For starters, the dominatrix didn’t have sex with her clients. She told them what to do, not vice versa.

Ms. Bedford’s lawyer is Alan Young, who essentially argues that prostitutes should be allowed to operate legally indoors, and to improve their working conditions by hiring drivers and bodyguards. This idealized portrait of the sex worker as empowered small-business entrepreneur could only have been dreamed up in a women’s studies course. This sordid trade has been heavily sanitized by feminists and the sex-workers’ rights movement, which wants to rescue prostitutes from “victimhood” by abolishing the word “prostitute” (too demeaning) and framing prostitution (sorry, sex work) as a legitimate career choice.

This reframing conveniently omits the huge, destructive influence of pimps and drugs, while invoking human rights as a justification for women’s freedom to use their bodies any way they want. In the words of Vancouver’s Pivot Society, one intervenor in the Supreme Court case, “All sex workers deserve to have their choices respected and be able to work safely, without fear of violence, discrimination and social stigma.”

The enlightened classes have bought into this exalted nonsense. Today, anyone who has qualms about normalizing the sex trade is likely to be labelled as a religious nut, a prude, or an old-style moralist. Perhaps this explains why our media’s coverage of the issue has been so dismally parochial. Most Canadians have no idea that over the past decade, vast experiments with prostitution laws have been playing out in many countries not unlike our own. The results are in. And they are instructive.

Let’s start in Germany, where prostitution became legal in 2002. The change was backed by the Greens and Social Democrats, who aimed to strengthen women’s rights and turn prostitution into a normal profession like, say, bus conducting. So how’s that working out? Today, Germany has become “the cut-rate prostitution capital of the world,” as Time magazine puts it. It is a magnet for migrant sex workers, who are lured from their wretched villages in Bulgaria and Romania and turned into virtual sex slaves in Germany’s 3,000 brothels. Police are nearly powerless to help them. The number of prostitutes has exploded to about 200,000, and prices have been driven to rock bottom. A devastating investigation into the sex trade by Der Spiegel found that tourists can get flat-rate deals – all the sex they want – for less than $100.

Idealists thought the new law would turn prostitutes into independent agents and put them on an equal footing with their customers. Instead, it has been a licence for exploitation on an unprecedented scale.

The Netherlands has fared no better. When prostitution was legalized in 2000, the idea was that prostitutes would join a union and that brothels would be regulated, inspected and taxed. But much of the sex trade operates outside the regulations. Legalization has merely expanded the market and allowed the spread of brothels all over the country. Amsterdam’s red-light district has become a haven for money laundering and drugs. A 2008 Dutch National Police report said, “The idea that a clean, normal business sector has emerged is an illusion.” And a study from the London School of Economics found that human trafficking goes hand-in-hand with legalization, because legalization encourages sex tourism and vastly increases the demand for paid sex.

Several countries where prostitution has been legalized have begun to admit that their policies have been an utter failure. Some have decided they would do better to emulate Sweden, which took a sharply different course after its own experiment with decriminalization failed. In 1999, the Swedes decided to attack prostitution by punishing the exploiters, not the victims – and by offering the victims a way out. This policy is rooted in a progressive feminism of a very different stripe – a belief that prostitution, whether voluntary or not, results in serious harm against women and society. It should be marginalized, not normalized.

The results are persuasive. Street prostitution has been cut in half. Crime and organized trafficking are down. Police say the sex trade has not gone underground. Men who might otherwise have patronized prostitutes have been scared off by the inconvenience and stigma. Many women, with the sympathetic assistance of police and social workers, have found other lines of work. Seventy per cent of Swedes support the law.

In Canada, some women’s groups do not support the case for legalization. Among them are the front-line sexual assault centres and the Native Women’s Association of Canada – groups that work with the worst-off, most damaged, most exploited girls and women of them all. They have no photogenic poster girls like Terri-Jean Bedford. They have no illusions that legalization means empowerment. They know it only means more degradation. Is that what we want? I think not.
 
Thing is that I'm willing to bet that the Supreme Court will write the laws so that the Johns are the ones who will be made criminals.

You just watch.
 
Hmmm... While you point of view is expressed well, I find your tone to be a little too strident to be taken without a grain of salt. You see prostitute as 'victims'? And you say that: 'Prostitution is the most exploitative, degrading work on Earth'? It's 'practioners are overwhelmingly the most wretched girls and women in society'? You refer to this line of work as a: 'sordid trade' and say that the profession has been heavily sanitized by feminists and the sex worker's rights movement'? I happen not to be a prostitute and suspect that you are not either. Perhaps a TERB member who is engaged in the profession could offer another perspective on the central point of your concerns? Sincerely, Jon . writer's edit: to correct a typographical error.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm... While you point of view is expressed well, I find your tone to be a little too strident to be taken without a grain of salt. You see prostitute as 'victims'? And you say that: 'Prostitution is the most exploitative, degrading work on Earth'? It's 'practioners are overwhelmingly the most wretched girls and women in society'? You refer to this line of work as a: 'sorid trade' and say that the profession has been heavily sanitized by feminists and the sex worker's rights movement'? I happen not to be a prostitute and suspect that you are not either. Perhaps a TERB member who is engaged in the profession could offer another perspective on the central point of your concerns? Sincerely, Jon .

It looks like you're not aware the OP didn't write that. He's quoting an article.
 
It looks like you're not aware the OP didn't write that. He's quoting an article.

Knowing Margaret Wente's history, it's quite possible she didn't write it either.
 
The arguments I've seen around not legalizing the sex trade right now revolve around human trafficking and well - the evidence on that part is clear - by making sex work fully legal, the market simply grows faster than supply - so the sex trafficking simply increases.

The best research that I've seen on the topic is here:

http://ideas.repec.org/p/diw/diweos/diweos71.html

Wente is a nutjob though. Human trafficking is just not as large a problem as people think it is. I have yet to see convincing numbers that show that I should be worried that more people are trafficked compared to say - the number of people who get killed by motor vehicle accidents.

Legalizing sex work makes sense - the current laws are absurd where people can be sex workers but they effectively cannot participate fully in society and they are not afforded any legal protections which is *stupid*.

In fact, I'll quote the actual LSE journal article:

The likely negative consequences of legalized prostitution on a country’s inflows of human trafficking might be seen to support those who argue in favor of banning prostitution, thereby reducing the flows of trafficking (e.g., Outshoorn, 2005).

However, such a line of argumentation overlooks potential benefits that the legalization of prostitution might have on those employed in the industry. Working conditions could be substantially improved for prostitutes – at least those legally employed – if prostitution is legalized. Prohibiting prostitution also raises tricky “freedom of choice” issues concerning both the potential suppliers and clients of prostitution services. A full evaluation of the costs and benefits, as well as of the broader merits of prohibiting prostitution,
is beyond the scope of the present article.

*sigh*

tl;dr - Making sex work legal is bad for human trafficking, but trafficking isn't a serious problem anyway. Legalization makes sense if you focus on the safety and rights of sex workers instead of the strawman argument of human trafficking.
 
Last edited:
The arguments I've seen around not legalizing the sex trade right now revolve around human trafficking and well - the evidence on that part is clear - by making sex work fully legal, the market simply grows faster than supply - so the sex trafficking simply increases.

The best research that I've seen on the topic is here:

http://ideas.repec.org/p/diw/diweos/diweos71.html

Wente is a nutjob though. Human trafficking is just not as large a problem as people think it is. I have yet to see convincing numbers that show that I should be worried that more people are trafficked compared to say - the number of people who get killed by motor vehicle accidents.

Legalizing sex work makes sense - the current laws are absurd where people can be sex workers but they effectively cannot participate fully in society and they are not afforded any legal protections which is *stupid*.

In fact, I'll quote the actual LSE journal article:



*sigh*

tl;dr - Making sex work legal is bad for human trafficking, but trafficking isn't a serious problem anyway. Legalization makes sense if you focus on the safety and rights of sex workers instead of the strawman argument of human trafficking.

You're wrong. Even the United Nations considers human trafficking a heinous practice and the numbers are probably greater than we know about. It is a serious problem on a global scale and you're just putting your head in the sand. The problem can not be overcome so long as there are people like you trivializing it.
I'm not saying that sex work shouldn't be legalized but that doesn't excuse women and children........yes, even children being exploited by trafficking. It's an entirely different matter when a woman makes her own choice to be a sex worker as opposed to being forced into the trade.
 
You're wrong. Even the United Nations considers human trafficking a heinous practice and the numbers are probably greater than we know about. It is a serious problem on a global scale and you're just putting your head in the sand. The problem can not be overcome so long as there are people like you trivializing it.
I'm not saying that sex work shouldn't be legalized but that doesn't excuse women and children........yes, even children being exploited by trafficking. It's an entirely different matter when a woman makes her own choice to be a sex worker as opposed to being forced into the trade.

I might be wrong, but that's not a convincing argument.

I'm not disputing that human trafficking exists, I'm disputing that it's a sizable problem that we should consider when weighing it against the rights of sex workers who *actually* exist and they number in the thousands in Canada.

Canada is currently ranked in a Tier 1 status with respect to human trafficking. We do a shit ton to fight that crap.

The number of trafficked individuals *may* be greater than what we know, but the hard numbers for human trafficking are really really small in Canada.

In addition to ongoing investigations, there were at least 32 human trafficking cases before the courts as of late February 2010, involving 40 accused trafficking offenders and 46 victims. All but one of these cases involved sex trafficking. This represents an increase in the number of prosecutions when compared with 12 anti-trafficking prosecutions in
provincial courts that were pending at the same time last year and which involved 15 accused trafficking offenders.

Trafficking In Persons Report from 2010


If you're going to invoke the UN, then I might as well too.

Not only is it unethical not to
protect these groups: it makes no sense from a
public health perspective. It hurts us all
UNAIDS

The World Health Organization: http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/sex_work/about/en/index.html

United Nations General Assembly Report:

Specifically, the failure of legal recognition of the sex-work sector results in infringements of the right to health, through the failure to provide safe working conditions, and a lack of recourse to legal remedies for occupational health issues. Additionally, the distinction between sex work and trafficking is considered, in particular with respect to legislation and interventions that, by failing to distinguish between these groups, are increasingly infringing sex workers’ right to health.
...
Finally, the Special Rapporteur suggests that decriminalization is necessary in
response to each of the aforementioned issues, alongside other measures necessary as part
of a comprehensive right-to-health approach. Such measures include human rights
education, the participation and inclusion of vulnerable groups, and efforts to reduce stigma
and discrimination in respect of these groups.

And finally the United Nations Development Program:

http://www.hivlawcommission.org/resources/report/FinalReport-Risks,Rights&Health-EN.pdf

I agree with you in the general case Petzel - human trafficking is awful and we should do what we can to stop it, but in the context of sex work - focusing on trafficking as a central problem related to sex work is nonsensical.
 
This line is quite telling on the type of person she is: "its practitioners are overwhelmingly the most wretched girls and women in society." Not to mention the scowl on her face. I can almost hear her Harvard law professor voice and see up her up turned nose.
 
Wente is an absolute pompous and plagiarizing nut job, see her article on how married people pity their single friends. Anyways the of trafficking is really over blown in Canada as previously mentioned, even in Western Europe it has connections to an overall anti immigration sentiment.
 
One way to approach the question of how much human trafficking there is (at least into Canada) is to think about our own experiences. I've been going to some pretty dodgy places for a long time and I've seen very few women working whom I thought were trafficked. And I've seen lots of women working of whom I was quite certain they were not trafficked. Even most of the Eastern European girls in strip clubs seemed to be fairly autonomous - they came here because it was a good deal.

That's not saying much for the global problem, war torn, ill-governed countries, etc., but really, here in Canada I suspect the whole discussion of human trafficking is a bit of a moral panic.

Exactly, there's lots of talk but nobody has really ever found a place where there is clearly trafficked women, praise gord.
If someone did, they should be reported, all the women I've met have presented themselves as in control of their lives, I've never even heard of anyone talking about anyone who could have even been a pimp.
 
Why are feminists and other progressive types so enthusiastic about legalizing prostitution? It baffles me. Prostitution is the most exploitative, degrading work on Earth. Despite those stories about high-class call girls, its practitioners are overwhelmingly the most wretched girls and women in society. Prostitution turns women into lumps of meat that are bought and sold for the sexual gratification of men. If you legalize it, you will probably get more. Please explain how that can be a good thing.


The current case before the Supreme Court of Canada argues that indoor prostitution should be legalized in order to improve the safety and dignity of sex workers. Its poster girl is media darling Terri-Jean Bedford, the leather-clad kitten with a whip who was busted way back when for operating an upscale S&M service for clients who paid her to be tied up and thrashed. I admire Ms. Bedford. She is a sharp entrepreneur and a brilliant publicist. But she is no more typical of the sex trade than your Great-Aunt Dorothy. For starters, the dominatrix didn’t have sex with her clients. She told them what to do, not vice versa.

Ms. Bedford’s lawyer is Alan Young, who essentially argues that prostitutes should be allowed to operate legally indoors, and to improve their working conditions by hiring drivers and bodyguards. This idealized portrait of the sex worker as empowered small-business entrepreneur could only have been dreamed up in a women’s studies course. This sordid trade has been heavily sanitized by feminists and the sex-workers’ rights movement, which wants to rescue prostitutes from “victimhood” by abolishing the word “prostitute” (too demeaning) and framing prostitution (sorry, sex work) as a legitimate career choice.

This reframing conveniently omits the huge, destructive influence of pimps and drugs, while invoking human rights as a justification for women’s freedom to use their bodies any way they want. In the words of Vancouver’s Pivot Society, one intervenor in the Supreme Court case, “All sex workers deserve to have their choices respected and be able to work safely, without fear of violence, discrimination and social stigma.”

The enlightened classes have bought into this exalted nonsense. Today, anyone who has qualms about normalizing the sex trade is likely to be labelled as a religious nut, a prude, or an old-style moralist. Perhaps this explains why our media’s coverage of the issue has been so dismally parochial. Most Canadians have no idea that over the past decade, vast experiments with prostitution laws have been playing out in many countries not unlike our own. The results are in. And they are instructive.

Let’s start in Germany, where prostitution became legal in 2002. The change was backed by the Greens and Social Democrats, who aimed to strengthen women’s rights and turn prostitution into a normal profession like, say, bus conducting. So how’s that working out? Today, Germany has become “the cut-rate prostitution capital of the world,” as Time magazine puts it. It is a magnet for migrant sex workers, who are lured from their wretched villages in Bulgaria and Romania and turned into virtual sex slaves in Germany’s 3,000 brothels. Police are nearly powerless to help them. The number of prostitutes has exploded to about 200,000, and prices have been driven to rock bottom. A devastating investigation into the sex trade by Der Spiegel found that tourists can get flat-rate deals – all the sex they want – for less than $100.

Idealists thought the new law would turn prostitutes into independent agents and put them on an equal footing with their customers. Instead, it has been a licence for exploitation on an unprecedented scale.

The Netherlands has fared no better. When prostitution was legalized in 2000, the idea was that prostitutes would join a union and that brothels would be regulated, inspected and taxed. But much of the sex trade operates outside the regulations. Legalization has merely expanded the market and allowed the spread of brothels all over the country. Amsterdam’s red-light district has become a haven for money laundering and drugs. A 2008 Dutch National Police report said, “The idea that a clean, normal business sector has emerged is an illusion.” And a study from the London School of Economics found that human trafficking goes hand-in-hand with legalization, because legalization encourages sex tourism and vastly increases the demand for paid sex.

Several countries where prostitution has been legalized have begun to admit that their policies have been an utter failure. Some have decided they would do better to emulate Sweden, which took a sharply different course after its own experiment with decriminalization failed. In 1999, the Swedes decided to attack prostitution by punishing the exploiters, not the victims – and by offering the victims a way out. This policy is rooted in a progressive feminism of a very different stripe – a belief that prostitution, whether voluntary or not, results in serious harm against women and society. It should be marginalized, not normalized.

The results are persuasive. Street prostitution has been cut in half. Crime and organized trafficking are down. Police say the sex trade has not gone underground. Men who might otherwise have patronized prostitutes have been scared off by the inconvenience and stigma. Many women, with the sympathetic assistance of police and social workers, have found other lines of work. Seventy per cent of Swedes support the law.

In Canada, some women’s groups do not support the case for legalization. Among them are the front-line sexual assault centres and the Native Women’s Association of Canada – groups that work with the worst-off, most damaged, most exploited girls and women of them all. They have no photogenic poster girls like Terri-Jean Bedford. They have no illusions that legalization means empowerment. They know it only means more degradation. Is that what we want? I think not.

There is exploitation in many, many jobs. Lots of sewing sweatshops where people are enslaved to produce garments (that horrific building collapse in Bangladesh last month for example). Should we ban the clothing industry? Same with mining agriculture etc etc. All the Swedish prostitutes are now working in FKK clubs in Germany and that is where all the Swedish men go. Do you call that "Success?" I would say that strict polices to ensure non-exploitation need to be in place. Max % and $ the house keeps, criminal charges and kidnapping charges for the house if they hold passports against the girls will. etc etc. What would all those people from wretched villages in Eastern Europe do if they could not work in German FKK clubs? Would they just stay in their wretched villages and rot out of sight? Is that better? BTW I am against street prostitution unless it is in a designated area with cameras to safeguard the women.
 
Some stats on Human Trafficking : (from a bible bashing website)

"Although accurate statistics on human trafficking are hard to obtain, the U.S. State Department estimates that 600,000 to 800,000 people are trafficked across international borders every year. Of these, 80% are women and girls, and up to 50% are minors. The International Labour Organization estimates that there are 12.3 million victims of forced labour (including sexual servitude) at any given time; other estimates range from 4 million to 27 million. The RCMP estimates that 600-800 victims are trafficked into Canada each year, and another 1,500 to 2,200 persons are trafficked through Canada to the United States annually. "

So even on this website, sexual exploitation is barely a footnote.So I would be interested in knowing what % of human trafficking is driven by forced prostitution. Of course for the guilty parties I would suggest very firm sentencing guidelines perhaps making garments in our prisons until the have fully repaid their former slaves financially 2x for the labour they stole and the system for costs.
 
Very interesting topic. I wonder if the world population issue may be a factor in human trafficking. Imagine parents in a 3rd world country with 10 children. The moral question becomes why did they choose to have these children and not why did they choose to sell their underage daughters to pimps (out of necessity and despair perhaps?). Look for the cause, not the symptoms. My question has always been, "Who forced them to make children they can't afford to take care of?" They fuck like rabbits without condoms and then it becomes our problem?
 
Very interesting topic. I wonder if the world population issue may be a factor in human trafficking. Imagine parents in a 3rd world country with 10 children. The moral question becomes why did they choose to have these children and not why did they choose to sell their underage daughters to pimps (out of necessity and despair perhaps?). Look for the cause, not the symptoms. My question has always been, "Who forced them to make children they can't afford to take care of?" They fuck like rabbits without condoms and then it becomes our problem?

I don't think it's a moral question at all; that's way oversimplifying the problem. Fact is the infant mortality rate in many 3rd world countries is very high. There are many reasons, but access to potable water, sanitation, food, and shelter are the main reasons. So they have 10 kids expecting to lose some of them. The ones that survive take care of the parents or tend the land so they can eat. Handing out condoms would prevent multiple births, but the small amount of kids they would still have face the same health hazards.

No one's forcing them to 'fuck like rabbits.' When you're faced with the prospect of losing half of your kids, you have multiple kids to ensure your family's survival.
 
I don't think it's a moral question at all; that's way oversimplifying the problem. Fact is the infant mortality rate in many 3rd world countries is very high. There are many reasons, but access to potable water, sanitation, food, and shelter are the main reasons. So they have 10 kids expecting to lose some of them. The ones that survive take care of the parents or tend the land so they can eat. Handing out condoms would prevent multiple births, but the small amount of kids they would still have face the same health hazards.

No one's forcing them to 'fuck like rabbits.' When you're faced with the prospect of losing half of your kids, you have multiple kids to ensure your family's survival.

If that is the main reason, perhaps they ought to focus on working to better the environment and protect humanity from undue misery and disease rather than fucking to "ensure your family's survival" and sitting on their ass waiting for handouts. Do you see me going around impregnating women for the sake of my family's survival, despite my primal instincts to fuck? You tell me where all the billions of dollars go to help these nations?
 
If that is the main reason, perhaps they ought to focus on working to better the environment and protect humanity from undue misery and disease rather than fucking to "ensure your family's survival" and sitting on their ass waiting for handouts. Do you see me going around impregnating women for the sake of my family's survival, despite my primal instincts to fuck? You tell me where all the billions of dollars go to help these nations?

Might want to live in a 3rd world country for a length of time to see how they "sit on their ass." News flash: they're not sitting in air conditioned houses, on leather sofas, watching Young and the Restless on their iPad and TV at the same time while munching on Doritos. Based on your simplistic, neo-con view of the Third World and its issues, I wouldn't be surprised if you are going around impregnating women. Comparing people in the Third World to people collecting welfare in Canada is terribly sad.

You raise a good question about where aid money goes because it seems that most of it doesn't get to the people that need it. It gets tied up with foreign governments or administration costs of the benevolent charities that "help" the Third World. If you need proof drive on over to World Drive and Hurontario in Mississauga. There you'll find a beautiful building for World Vision Canada and several luxury cars parked in front. Some of its employees in Liberia decided to help themselves to food deliveries and supplies for their own benefit. That was awfully 'nice' of them?!

You are right in that there is an overpopulation problem; overpopulation of the North American lifestyle, which is very wasteful. Think of all the resources we waste everyday (water, food, electricity, fuel) for the sake of convenience or entertainment while billions of other people go without. Maybe us in the First World ought to focus on helping to better the global environment and protect all humanity (not just our own comfortable lives) from undue misery and disease and help them self sustain so they don't need the billions of dollars of aid that we would use to buy fighter jets, guns, corporate bail outs, and iPhones?