clayton ruby strikes again

So now if my neighbor 3 houses down has a large old tree, he can claim that the root structure of the tree also lies beneath my property, therefore I am part owner of the tree? If that tree is rotten and a threat to topple over, am I responsible for some of the cost of having that tree removed? If so, what percentage of the cost is mine & what percentage of the removal cost is the responsibility of the immediate neighbors?

Would it have been too much to ask the judge to use some logic & consider the repercussions of any decision that was going to be rendered. Or maybe these days decisions are made based on the probability of the wacky decision getting the judge's name in the paper.
 
You can't cut down your tree anyway without an arborist recommending it needs to be cut to the city.

One problem is there is a conflict of interest in that the arborist retained to provide an opinion on the tree is usually also the one hired to cut down the tree. There are numerous incidents where the homeowner just wants to cut down a mature tree for convenience without regard to the consequences which are many.

The second problem is the City by-law has no teeth whereas the Ont. Forestry Act does and will make it a criminal act to take down a tree without permission from the neighbour - if it is determined to be a shared tree.
 
I'm with you and Red. The problem is that the tree lobby in Toronto is extremely powerful. They want to turn Toronto into another Amazon Forest.

In its report "Every Tree Counts" http://www.toronto.ca/trees/pdfs/Every_Tree_Counts.pdf the City indicates it wants to increase the tree canopy up to 40% within a fifty year period. It is currently around 18%. We owe our lives to trees which bring a multitude of environmental and economical benefits, cooling in the summer, protection in the winter, stabilization of the water table, carbon sequestration, social calming (less crime per capita in areas with more trees), increase in property values, reduced utility bills.....etc more in the report. Homeowners who are ignorant of these facts are many and they bring down many trees for convenience. Developers may know but they are motivated by profit to bring down trees. I think this is a good ruling but requires further clarification. As the OP said, if a tree is in a yard three houses away, what does that mean in terms of ownership. If it is appealed, hopefully, clarification will be made in this regard.
 
You really don't want any trees within about 20' to 30' of your house.

The root system of a tree is about 1.5 times the diameter of the branches, and a big tree is more than capable of destroying any type of water management in your basement.
 
social calming (less crime per capita in areas with more trees),
Actually in "at risk neighbourhoods" residents want to reduce the number of tress because they provide cover for criminals (e.g. drug dealers, etc.)
Homeowners who are ignorant of these facts are many and they bring down many trees for convenience.
On the other hand, homeowners are aware of the damage caused by roots, fallen branches and trees as well as leaves that clog our sewers, gardens and streets.
 
razorramon, if you care about your anonymity, consider redacting your post. if you put out a few more personal details on other topics, someone may eventually piece together who you are.
 
The city does need a lot more trees, and the goal of increasing the canopy is very sound, for the reasons given by Richard above.

Cutting down one single tree doesn't make a big difference, but it's one of those things where when everybody does it, it adds up to a massive impact. Kind of like people who get fat telling themselves every single day that one more cheeseburger isn't going to make a difference.
 
As the OP said, if a tree is in a yard three houses away, what does that mean in terms of ownership.
I think the judge and the people who write the tree laws should be responsible for taking care of the trees, liable for any damages and do whatever cleanup is necessary with leaves, branches, etc. The problem is that judges and lawmakers make the rules but we are stuck with the consequences.
 
Actually in "at risk neighbourhoods" residents want to reduce the number of tress because they provide cover for criminals (e.g. drug dealers, etc.)On the other hand, homeowners are aware of the damage caused by roots, fallen branches and trees as well as leaves that clog our sewers, gardens and streets.
It is a fallacy that roots cause damage. There is usually a crack in the sewer already and the roots of trees then migrate towards the water leaking from the already damaged pipe. It's true that work is involved to clean up leaves and fallen branches, but most people would rather do that than walk through a smog filled city. There are approx. 10 million trees in the City of Toronto and the trees absorb CO/ CO2 from vehicle emissions equivalent to 325,000 cars per year.it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize what would happen if there were no trees. Regarding criminal activities, this will happen whether there are trees or not, they can hide behind buildings too. Research shows that communities with a nice tree scape exhibit less violent behaviour. There are ways to improve lines of sight to reduce criminal activity without eliminating trees.
 
I think the judge and the people who write the tree laws should be responsible for taking care of the trees, liable for any damages and do whatever cleanup is necessary with leaves, branches, etc. The problem is that judges and lawmakers make the rules but we are stuck with the consequences.

IMHO Trees should not be considered a commodity but more like an endangered species. It will take co-operation from everyone to help trees survive. Our lives and that of insects/animals, in fact, our ecological systems depend upon us being educated about the importance of trees and doing something to stop the indiscriminate removal of trees.
 
razorramon, if you care about your anonymity, consider redacting your post. if you put out a few more personal details on other topics, someone may eventually piece together who you are.

Who cares? I got nothing to hide. I am not married so why would I care if "some" finds out who I am? There are about 200 homes on the street and I would wager 50-60% use male/female escorts.
 
Nice to see how many posters treated the original title as nothing more than a come-on and are discussing a meaningful topic rather than 'Lawyers I Don't Like'. It sure worked though, didn't it?
 
Who cares? I got nothing to hide. I am not married so why would I care if "some" finds out who I am? There are about 200 homes on the street and I would wager 50-60% use male/female escorts.

That would be a pretty wild street. I have always thought that 90% of Canadian homeowners either fuck unattractive civvies their own age or masturbate.