Teachers Taking "Sick Days" - Anyone want to defend this one?

If I were to represent a union, I would use this settlement as a standard (a big tree):

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/busine...se+city+helpless+rein+them/8230333/story.html

BTW, I don't have problem with your premise, but picking on the teachers (a medium-sized tree) alone is useless.

Every dollar counts
They are clearly over-compensated and use kids as negotiating pawns
This group needed crushing

We need to deal with the source of the problem, and the problem is us (the forest). If we as citizens do not push for more and more services, we would not need more and more civil servants to service them,

No need to pay them in the top 5% of all Canadians, while they work 2/3s relative to those that fund them
I have no issue with a reasonable salary for a teacher, but $83K for 2/3 + extremely expensive benefits
It is completely inappropriate
Even more so when the govt is borrowing an unmanageable level of debt to fund this excess
it is so irresponsible to the next generations
 
So, you admit you do not have the in depth training to understand impacts of taxation and excessive govt spending upon an economy

yes

although the doom and gloom predictions about USA government debt never has come true and it has been predicted since the Viet Nam war debt
So you understand how dangerous debt can be

yes

see above
More or less, however the ones who borrowed more than they could afford must shoulder most of the blame
disagree

while they did accept a debt they should not have

the worker ant sees a way to actually get ahead for once and were told by those who should know that they could make money in the housing bubble

it is wall street and the bankers fault as they are the people who are supposed to understand economics not Joe the Plumber yet they lied and deceived in order to get rich while knowingly acting against their own long term interest and the worlds economy

amazing


Too many rules can be just as bad, problem is the one who write the rules are often not the sharpest or have hidden agendas
but we do need rules none the less and it seems to me wall street is making them





100% incorrect
You want to reward those who refuse to do their job (teachers) and create no wealth by stealing from those that actually create GDP, wealth and jobs.
not true

if you produce for the economy u should be rewarded

good for Bill Gates in getting rich as he gave the economy more than he took out with his brilliant hard work and risks

getting wealthy from investing is my problem as the rich get richer because they are rich

u will argue this investment is necessary for capitalistic growth

i argue there must be a better way than a few having it all and that we had better find it before the total implosion that stiglitz and marx predict

BTW Marx has been correct in every comment he ever made about capitalism as far as i know

he did predict great wealth, internationalism, etc

As far as the bay street, this is an area you will not understand properly and an extremely important sector of the economy
Best you read and learn more before determining such an extreme opinion

understood but common sense tells me investment for profit regardless of the consequences (greed is good theory) will cause great human suffering

the great depression and to days problems are only two undeniable examples of man made (they were not a perfect unpreventable economic storm) of economic disasters

there are many other examples such as oil companies accepting (if not orchestrating) civil war then demanding the stability of dictators while that dictator gets rich then leaving nothing but oil cesspools in an unregulated country but hey, we got our the oil before China got it !!

the list is very extensive


Every year there are new millionaires , this year there was a big surge in new Canadians and women who became millionaires.
What separates them from those who work from paycheck to paycheck?
Primarily the thought of having to survive from paycheque to paycheque.
i salute those who make monies while producing value
No sorry, you are proposing communism and we can not have that


certainly not my intention

i agree with Karl Marx on communism when he said "I am not a Marxist"

well there are other nobel prize winning economists who agree with u no doubt

ya know, it is not only very hard - it is impossible - to be totally objective as it is the condition of the human mind to be biased and one cannot escape this sad fact


and so it goes ........
 
Ok if you are quoting and promoting Marx as a solution to issues , you are too far gone and will never understand
You will bang your head against the wall and never ever be happy, because North America is not going commie
 
Work it,...or get out

Ok if you are quoting and promoting Marx as a solution to issues , you are too far gone and will never understand
You will bang your head against the wall and never ever be happy, because North America is not going commie

JOHN,...I think you have to understand that there a few closeted Communists here that, because they have not made anything of them selves, by them selves,...then the system is to blame, and actually HOPE it all comes crashing down,...even if they are worse off,...just to see the free market system fail.

I had to leave school with only grade 12 education to support my family, as my father was unable to find employment.
When things eventually got better, I married an immigrant from a family who "came over on the boat" with nothing.
The wife and I worked hard, put up with ass whole bosses, never in a union, and with no help from our parents, began INVESTING, initially in Canada savings bonds, then stocks and mutual funds, paid off the mortgage in 15 years, when the rate was 3 times what it is now.
Now I am semi retired, drive only what Transport Canada calls "luxury" cars, spend over $10,000 a year on vacations, and watch the "very rich few" make me good money every month.

If you are envious, won't make an effort, and expect things to be handed to you,...your NOT going to be happy in the free world.

FAST
 
..I think you have to understand that there a few closeted Communists here that, because ...FAST

I think there are a lot of hypocrites, not Communists. They want their cake and eat it too. I became aware of the problem when I entered the workforce after I left grad school.

There was this oldster I met, who was a "good old boy" in every sense of the word, suddenly became a rabid Karl Marx when we get to the topic of government pension. You have to see it to believe it.

BTW, it is important to note that I grew up in rooming houses. What separate my siblings and I from our classmates was our ability to handle Grade 13 calculus. To me, it is still an important signal of raw horsepower...
 
Ok if you are quoting and promoting Marx as a solution to issues , you are too far gone and will never understand
You will bang your head against the wall and never ever be happy, because North America is not going commie

oh stop it

should not have mentioned his name

now u think i luv Stalin

first u r wrong as we almost lost capitalism during the great depression

Time magazine included Keynes in their list of the 100 most important and influential people of the 20th century, commenting that:

"His radical idea that governments should spend money they don't have may have saved capitalism."


second marx is correct on many things so get over it

also, Marx never promoted communism IE a state controlled society and neither do I


the one thing about Marx i disagree with is his belief that a workers state will be our nirvana as all attempts have ended in state dictatorship and besides, it goes against human nature as we will always behave in self interest which is what capitalism encourages us to do which is why it produces such great wealth


all systems are flawed and all have eventually collapsed

capitalism is the least flawed and we have to fix those flaws or it too may collapse ( i say may as clearly i do not have a crystal ball)

and there are many bright thinkers who agree with me so i am not naive

the greatest flaw of capitalism being unequal distribution of wealth
 
Last edited:
This John john guy on her sure has a lot to say about teachers, all he does is conplain maybe he should go sit in a classroom for a week or so.
 
This John john guy on her sure has a lot to say about teachers, all he does is conplain maybe he should go sit in a classroom for a week or so.

I get that way when my tax dollars are wasted
I would take you up on your offer and go sit in a classroom for a week or so, but wait, the teachers have all left for their 2 /12 month paid vacation.

Just remember that it takes the full year of Ont tax deductions from 3 average taxpayers to cover what one of these teachers is being paid during the summer, when they provide absolutely zero value to the province
 
Well John your dead wrong read the teachers oct of Ontario teachers get 3 weeks paid vacation, 2 at Christmas and 1 during march break. teachers get paid for only 193 days not the summer. Teachers start at $42000k a year.
 
oh stop it
all systems are flawed

capitalism is the least flawed and we have to fix those flaws

the greatest flaw being unequal distribution of wealth

this cannot go on as fewer continue to have more and more

1. That flaw is what makes the system work. It is called incentive and it is what drives people to innovate, explore, invent, invest, take risks and most importantly sell.
You will forever be disappointed and at odds with the economic system because you will never understand that incentive is grease and the fuel that make the economy run.
You start taking that incentive away by equally distributing wealth and the whole machine breaks down.

2. You are an idealist, who will never understand this concept, because incentive rewards those that strive to attain it, while not taken care of everyone equally and that is not how your ideal world should look to you (time to grow up and face reality)

3. Finally, you are not the guy to decide what is flawed and is not. You live in a make believe world and would create a god awful mess if given any true power
 
Professionals in our society are payed well stop complaining, i guess you think they should be paid $10.00 an hour?
 
Well John your dead wrong read the teachers oct of Ontario teachers get 3 weeks paid vacation, 2 at Christmas and 1 during march break. teachers get paid for only 193 days not the summer. Teachers start at $42000k a year.

I know it is difficult for you, but please do not be so stupid as to think anyone is buying your twist of the words
Teachers may start @ $42K a year, but the average salary is currently $83K.

They get the three weeks you describe, but also do not work from mid June until the start of Sept and still get paid for the full year @ an average of $83K per teacher.
Call it vacation or call it summer break, they provide zero value for this period of time, yet still cost the province $83K in Salary for the year. (Probably well over 100K
all in).

I am curious, did you graduate ?
Who taught you that relabeling a time period and focusing only on starting salary is at all relevant when discussing the costs ?

Are you afraid to look at the real costs ?
Scared it might make you realize, how inappropriate this comp package is ?
Or are you just a tried and true union supporter, blindly towing the line, regardless of right or wrong?
 
1. That flaw is what makes the system work. It is called incentive and it is what drives people to innovate, explore, invent, invest, take risks and most importantly sell.
You will forever be disappointed and at odds with the economic system because you will never understand that incentive is grease and the fuel that make the economy run.
You start taking that incentive away by equally distributing wealth and the whole machine breaks down.

2. You are an idealist, who will never understand this concept, because incentive rewards those that strive to attain it, while not taken care of everyone equally and that is not how your ideal world should look to you (time to grow up and face reality)

3. Finally, you are not the guy to decide what is flawed and is not. You live in a make believe world and would create a god awful mess if given any true power

1 no, i encourage incentive to produce wealth and those who do should become rich and i embrace earned inequalities

good for bill gates in becoming rich as he gave more to the world than he took


2 once again, making money from money until you have it all is not only nuts it seems to be the cause of a lot of economic woes


3 i agree
 
Professionals in our society are payed well stop complaining, i guess you think they should be paid $10.00 an hour?

I will complain as much as I want
Professionals work a full year, have to compete for their position (everyday) and do not use kids as negotiating pawns

Your comparison is foolish an self-serving


I think teachers should well compensated @ average of 60 to 65K , work a full year, be provided with 10 expiring sick days (non-bankable, non-cashable) and teachers should fund their own damn pension.
That is a damn sight better than the average taxpayer receives.

Mark my words, this wasteful spending is going to cause a god awful mess in Ontario in 5 years time
 
they work 193 days a year you said they get 2.5 months vacation and you were wrong. They do get 10 expiring sick days where have you been?. This will cost the tax payer more money in the end!!! the pay 13% of salart into their pension and their pension is woth a few bucks
 
I will complain as much as I want
Professionals work a full year, have to compete for their position (everyday) and do not use kids as negotiating pawns

Your comparison is foolish an self-serving


I think teachers should well compensated @ average of 60 to 65K , work a full year, be provided with 10 expiring sick days (non-bankable, non-cashable) and teachers should fund their own damn pension.
That is a damn sight better than the average taxpayer receives.

Mark my words, this wasteful spending is going to cause a god awful mess in Ontario in 5 years time

When I was teaching, I worked a full year. The summer months were spent tweaking existing lesson plans and creating new ones. There's little time for that during the school year. Work did not stop when the bell rang, either. Papers and tests were reviewed and graded into the late hours. One of the reasons I left teaching was to be able to spend more time with my family. Many teachers also do professional development (seminars, educational excursions) during the summer.

The thing that irked me most as a teacher was the 2.5 months off argument. I worked my *** off when I was teaching.
 
When I was teaching, I worked a full year. The summer months were spent tweaking existing lesson plans and creating new ones. There's little time for that during the school year. Work did not stop when the bell rang, either. Papers and tests were reviewed and graded into the late hours. One of the reasons I left teaching was to be able to spend more time with my family. Many teachers also do professional development (seminars, educational excursions) during the summer.

The thing that irked me most as a teacher was the 2.5 months off argument. I worked my *** off when I was teaching.
Now this sounds like a person who knows what they are talking about this is not an opinion but fact