Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

Right. Here's they hypothesis with the fewest assumptions: Rob Ford is a crackhead.

Here's the hypothesis with the most assumptions: Gawker and multiple Star secretly got together to create a a giant conspiracy that involves some of the mayor's friends and aids and friends, managed to trick the G&M into running a fake story that Doug Ford was a drug dealer, and somehow fooled Rob Ford into being photographed with crackheads at a crackhouse.

No, the OP (regarding the current subject in this thread) said

Who'd a thunk it... a drug dealer with a conscience!
smiley-laughing024.gif


Personally I'm often a subscriber to occam's razor... and there was no (authentic) video to begin with... :rolleyes:

To which you replied

You think that the Occam's Razor answer is a giant conspiracy involving the Star and a foreign news media, a couple of Ford's staffers, the Globe and Mail, and god knows who else?

Kooky.

All I can say to that is, keep smoking whatever the hell it is you're smoking!

Ridgeman said nothing about a conspircy, YOU did, he simply stated there was no authentic video to begin with, which means the 3 people who have claimed to see it, are have been genuinly fooled by the video, therefor no conspiracy, even then he ended his post with a rolleyes smiley.
 
Sorry but there is a lot of circumstantial evidence in addition to the video, and while it's fair to say it doesn't prove anything, it is also fair to say it is a MASSIVE coincidence if the video isn't true. That all adds up to a huge number of assumptions you have to make, to explain away all the unlikely coincidences.

What a big coincidence that his brother was a drug dealer and his sister was a coke addict. What a big coincidence that he was photographed with drug dealers. What a big coincidence that two of his staff have quit saying he needs to check into rehab. What a big coincidence that he claimed to know the address where the video was. What a big coincidence that he has been seen going to a crack house, and is associated with people with major drug problems. What a big coincidence that he was chucked out of a party for acting intoxicated even though he didn't seem to be drunk (no smell of alcohol). Those are a whole lot of whopping big coincidences!

Sorry but that his a huge boat load of assumptions and IN ADDITION you are assuming the Star reporters are so incompetent that they can't tell who is Rob Ford when they see him--they took detailed notes explaining why they concluded it was Ford, and they carefully looked for clues, such as noticing that the clothing he was wearing was unusual and that he had been seen in those clothes before, and so on.

While it is very fair to say that all of this is circumstantial and fails to meet the standard of proof that a court would require in a criminal case, it is just RIDICULOUS to say that Occam's razor demands any other conclusion than "Ford has a substance abuse problem and it resulted in a video".
 
Sorry but there is a lot of circumstantial evidence in addition to the video, and while it's fair to say it doesn't prove anything, it is also fair to say it is a MASSIVE coincidence if the video isn't true. That all adds up to a huge number of assumptions you have to make, to explain away all the unlikely coincidences.

What a big coincidence that his brother was a drug dealer and his sister was a coke addict. What a big coincidence that he was photographed with drug dealers. What a big coincidence that two of his staff have quit saying he needs to check into rehab. What a big coincidence that he claimed to know the address where the video was. What a big coincidence that he has been seen going to a crack house, and is associated with people with major drug problems. What a big coincidence that he was chucked out of a party for acting intoxicated even though he didn't seem to be drunk (no smell of alcohol). Those are a whole lot of whopping big coincidences!

Sorry but that his a huge boat load of assumptions and IN ADDITION you are assuming the Star reporters are so incompetent that they can't tell who is Rob Ford when they see him--they took detailed notes explaining why they concluded it was Ford, and they carefully looked for clues, such as noticing that the clothing he was wearing was unusual and that he had been seen in those clothes before, and so on.

While it is very fair to say that all of this is circumstantial and fails to meet the standard of proof that a court would require in a criminal case, it is just RIDICULOUS to say that Occam's razor demands any other conclusion than "Ford has a substance abuse problem and it resulted in a video"
I actually agree with most of that. The especially damning evidence was that Rinse post made back in March, 2013:

http://www.torontomike.com/2013/03/the_problem_with_rob_ford_and.html#comment-234172

Back when I first heard about Star reporting on that video I was 60% sure Ford was guilty.
Then when his staff quit it went up to 65%.
Then I saw that Rinse post and it went up to 70%.

But this still leaves 30% room for error. And for me it wont get to 100% guilty until I actually see that video
 
Sorry but there is a lot of circumstantial evidence in addition to the video, and while it's fair to say it doesn't prove anything, it is also fair to say it is a MASSIVE coincidence if the video isn't true. That all adds up to a huge number of assumptions you have to make, to explain away all the unlikely coincidences.

What a big coincidence that his brother was a drug dealer and his sister was a coke addict. What a big coincidence that he was photographed with drug dealers. What a big coincidence that two of his staff have quit saying he needs to check into rehab. What a big coincidence that he claimed to know the address where the video was. What a big coincidence that he has been seen going to a crack house, and is associated with people with major drug problems. What a big coincidence that he was chucked out of a party for acting intoxicated even though he didn't seem to be drunk (no smell of alcohol). Those are a whole lot of whopping big coincidences!

Sorry but that his a huge boat load of assumptions and IN ADDITION you are assuming the Star reporters are so incompetent that they can't tell who is Rob Ford when they see him--they took detailed notes explaining why they concluded it was Ford, and they carefully looked for clues, such as noticing that the clothing he was wearing was unusual and that he had been seen in those clothes before, and so on.

While it is very fair to say that all of this is circumstantial and fails to meet the standard of proof that a court would require in a criminal case, it is just RIDICULOUS to say that Occam's razor demands any other conclusion than "Ford has a substance abuse problem and it resulted in a video".

What is the proof that those in that phote were drug dealers ? Prove it, now.
 
Sorry but there is a lot of circumstantial evidence in addition to the video, and while it's fair to say it doesn't prove anything, it is also fair to say it is a MASSIVE coincidence if the video isn't true. That all adds up to a huge number of assumptions you have to make, to explain away all the unlikely coincidences.

What a big coincidence that his brother was an (alleged) drug dealer and his sister was an (alleged) coke addict. What a big coincidence that he was photographed with (alleged) drug dealers. What a big coincidence that two of his staff have quit saying he (allegedly)needs to check into rehab. What a big coincidence that he claimed to know the address where the (alleged) video was. What a big coincidence that he has been seen going to an (alleged) crack house, and is (allegedly) associated with people with major (alleged) drug problems. What a big coincidence that he was chucked out of a party for acting intoxicated even though he didn't seem to be drunk (no smell of alcohol). Those are a whole lot of whopping big (alleged) coincidences!

Sorry but that his a huge boat load of assumptions and IN ADDITION you are assuming the Star reporters are so incompetent that they can't tell who is Rob Ford when they see him--they took detailed notes explaining why they concluded it was Ford, and they carefully looked for clues, such as noticing that the clothing he was wearing was unusual and that he had been seen in those clothes before, and so on.

While it is very fair to say that all of this is circumstantial and fails to meet the standard of proof that a court would require in a criminal case, it is just RIDICULOUS to say that Occam's razor demands any other conclusion than "Ford has a substance abuse problem and it resulted in a video".

I'm CERTAIN Rob Ford has a substance abuse problem. The evidence of it is overwhelming! The substance being JUNK FOOD! One could also make a case for alcohol abuse given recent goings on. But last I checked, both of those addictions are not illegal.

As for crack? Like you said- its ALL circumstantial, and much of which doesn't involve him directly, and is hearsay as well I might add.... So, the jury is still out on that one, and until an authentic video is unearthed, then he gets the benefit of doubt, (and should) from the court of public opinion... (and I don't think I've ever seen an obese crack addict.) :confused:
 
Ridge, I agree wholeheartedly that all the evidence is circumstantial.

However you had set the bar for yourself quite a bit higher than that. You had gone WAY beyond asserting that it was just circumstantial evidence, and you made the outrageous and wholly unsupportable claim that Occam's Razor demanded believing the video wasn't real. That preposterous claim of yours flies in the face of all that circumstantial evidence!

The "jury" is not out on this one. There will be no jury. There is not enough evidence, nor will there ever be enough evidence, to charge Ford with a crime. So there will be no jury here. What we do have is a whole pile of circumstantial evidence that leaves us, on the balance of probabilities, with the conclusion that our mayor has a drug addiction.

And no, not a junk food addiction. Something that results in impaired judgement and public intoxication, and at such a level that two of his close aides and friends now refuse to work with him unless he checks into rehab.
 
Ridge, I agree wholeheartedly that all the evidence is circumstantial.

However you had set the bar for yourself quite a bit higher than that. You had gone WAY beyond asserting that it was just circumstantial evidence, and you made the outrageous and wholly unsupportable claim that Occam's Razor demanded believing the video wasn't real. That preposterous claim of yours flies in the face of all that circumstantial evidence!

The "jury" is not out on this one. There will be no jury. There is not enough evidence, nor will there ever be enough evidence, to charge Ford with a crime. So there will be no jury here. What we do have is a whole pile of circumstantial evidence that leaves us, on the balance of probabilities, with the conclusion that our mayor has a drug addiction.

And no, not a junk food addiction. Something that results in impaired judgement and public intoxication.


finally an unbiased opinion with no preconceived notions about the mayor.
 
I didn't know alleging Mayor of Toronto smokes crack based on statements from a reporter that she allegedly saw a video and a website stating the same...is considered circumstantial evidence without actually providing THE VIDEO. I've been selling this bridge I had in Brooklyn, NY for pretty much dirt price and yet no takers?
 
The G&M referred to Anthony Smith as a drug dealer, as have several other articles.

For example: "Anthony Smith, a drug dealer who was recently shot dead"

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ays-crack-video-doesnt-exist/article12158667/

It also seems that the dead guy may have been the guy with the video, which would explain why it is "gone". Awfully convenient!

Fail. Nothing about a conviction or even an arrest, not a thing.

The caller, identified as “Pam,” also asked the mayor if it was him photographed with his arm around Anthony Smith, a drug dealer who was recently shot dead. The photograph has accompanied the reports about the video.

Globe didn't say it, some caller named Pam did.
 
The G&M referred to Anthony Smith as a drug dealer, as have several other articles.

For example: "Anthony Smith, a drug dealer who was recently shot dead"

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ays-crack-video-doesnt-exist/article12158667/

It also seems that the dead guy may have been the guy with the video, which would explain why it is "gone". Awfully convenient!
Anthony Smith was killed March 28, 2013. The story of Ford crack smoking video didnt go public until 2 months later. So what exactly are you implying?? That Rob Ford had him killed preemptively??

Could you please explain what you mean by "awfully convenient", fuji??
 
Except...

Ridge, I agree wholeheartedly that all the evidence is circumstantial.

However you had set the bar for yourself quite a bit higher than that. You had gone WAY beyond asserting that it was just circumstantial evidence, and you made the outrageous and wholly unsupportable claim that Occam's Razor demanded believing the video wasn't real. That preposterous claim of yours flies in the face of all that circumstantial evidence!

The "jury" is not out on this one. There will be no jury. There is not enough evidence, nor will there ever be enough evidence, to charge Ford with a crime. So there will be no jury here. What we do have is a whole pile of circumstantial evidence that leaves us, on the balance of probabilities, with the conclusion that our mayor has a drug addiction.

And no, not a junk food addiction. Something that results in impaired judgement and public intoxication, and at such a level that two of his close aides and friends now refuse to work with him unless he checks into rehab.

You are assuming all the circumstantial evidence is true. Which (in your mind) means Rob Ford is a crack addict.

I'm not making any assumptions at all. I just prefer to form opinion based on fact. And the fact is.... there is no REAL evidence.

I didn't make any claim that "Occam's Razor demanded believing the video wasn't real". I simply suggested that the lack of any real evidence would seem to support the fact that Mr. Ford, in spite of all his shortcomings, is NOT a crack addict.

What video?

  • The alleged video that is "said" to exist, but hasn't been seen by anyone other than 3 people, 2 of which work for an organization that has had it in for the Ford's for some time, and the 3rd of which stands to profit greatly...
  • The alleged video that is "said" to be recorded on a cell phone by alleged drug dealers?
  • The alleged video that is "said" to be showing Rob Ford allegedly smoking crack?
  • The alleged video that was offered for sale for a sum of $200,000?
  • The alleged video which attained its agreed upon selling price, but then all contact with the alleged dealers, and/ or owners of the alleged video, disappeared?
  • The alleged video... awwforgetaboutit

I have a new theory: Fuji= kook... but I do admire your tenacity, albeit misdirected by hearsay and BS.
 
You are assuming all the circumstantial evidence is true.

Your initial claim was that the reporters had simply been duped by a single video author and thus no conspiracy. Now you are going on to allege a conspiracy -- that all the reports the Star and Globe have published, where they have declined to publish the name of their source, are all a giant lie, that the newspapers and their editors are collectively complicit in a grand conspiracy to publish a bunch of information about Ford that isn't true.

If you are not claiming that, then you have to explain away the huge coincidences, like Ford saying he knew where the video was, like two of his staff refusing to work with him until he checks into rehab, and so on. Those are either true things that happened, or else there's a big conspiracy afoot.

Either way, that is a heck of a lost of assumptions, Mr. Occam!
 
You are assuming all the circumstantial evidence is true. Which (in your mind) means Rob Ford is a crack addict.

I'm not making any assumptions at all. I just prefer to form opinion based on fact. And the fact is.... there is no REAL evidence.

One fact that you make light of is that Ford has a history of lying about substance abuse, having been caught lying twice with national media.
In this case his credibility is already much lower then the two star reporters who witnessed the video.