Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

So now we're down to pedantic nitpicking over what Ford meant and didnt mean.

His denial should be good enough until that video shows up, which so far it hasnt

Um that is hardly pedantic nitpicking. His very specific choice of words and subsequent refusal to answer direct questions were obvious attempts to dodge the issue.

The only people who do not see that are those who are desperate to believe him.

I quit smoking cigarettes 3 months ago and I have not had a craving in about a month now. I could safely say I do not use cigarettes and I am not addicted to cigarettes. See how that works?
 
Did The Star ever retract and apologize for their article falsely accusing the Fords of ordering the destruction of emails?
Some of us who lack your hair-trigger reflexes for judging the Star and what it might have said that merits retraction or apology would appreciate a reference or link to those exact words. Don't take it personally, but a lot of folks posting here seem to believe only what they read into what someone else has said, and don't even bother with what actually was said before they fire up the car-bombs and send in the suicide bombers to kill the messenger yet again.

You don't suppose that what they actually said and printed, was along the lines of:

… 'we got a call from someone who wants to keep their job in Ford's office because they believe in the guy, but they claim to have heard a staffer say, 'now those guy's are gone, we don't need their email and phone accounts and should purge them', and the caller doesn't think that's how the City's supposed to do things'. We asked the Mayor's Office, but they refused to talk to us. We asked the Privacy Commissioner, and she said 'they can't do that; I'm sure they're not, but I'll send a letter', which she did.…

Something like that?

In which case I'd think the subsequent Star pieces (that even I could find) which clearly reported the Privacy Commissioner was aware and that Ford's office had said they were aware, that no such purge should happen, had happened or was contemplated would be enough for any reasonable person to keep truth on track.

But when you point us at this accusing article I apparently missed, I can judge the real evidence for myself.
 
Um that is hardly pedantic nitpicking. His very specific choice of words and subsequent refusal to answer direct questions were obvious attempts to dodge the issue.

The only people who do not see that are those who are desperate to believe him.

I quit smoking cigarettes 3 months ago and I have not had a craving in about a month now. I could safely say I do not use cigarettes and I am not addicted to cigarettes. See how that works?
Okay, but then if you quit cigarettes, and never smoke cigarettes after that again, you are telling the truth.

Lets say Ford (hypothetically) did smoke crack once or twice, but decided he didnt like it and never tried it again. That makes his statement factually correct, and makes Ford no different from Smitherman who also used hard-drugs and claims he quit and is now clean
 
Okay, but then if you quit cigarettes, and never smoke cigarettes after that again, you are telling the truth.

Lets say Ford (hypothetically) did smoke crack once or twice, but decided he didnt like it and never tried it again. That makes his statement factually correct, and makes Ford no different from Smitherman who also used hard-drugs and claims he quit and is now clean

It does if he used them 3 months ago while Mayor of Toronto.
 
You don't suppose that what they actually said and printed, was along the lines of, 'we got a call from someone who wants to keep their job in Ford's office because they believe in the guy, but they claim to have heard a staffer say, 'now those guy's are gone, we don't need their email and phone accounts and should purge them', and the caller doesn't think that's how the City's supposed to do things'.
Staff emails are not allowed to be deleted for at least 7 years.
 
It does if he used them 3 months ago while Mayor of Toronto
Just show us the video, and then you might have a case.

And it was (up to) 6 months ago, according to our highly ethical drug dealers, not 3 months.
And if you add the circus of the last few weeks, its almost 7 months ago now when Ford allegedly smoked crack
 
Okay, but then if you quit cigarettes, and never smoke cigarettes after that again, you are telling the truth.

Lets say Ford (hypothetically) did smoke crack once or twice, but decided he didnt like it and never tried it again. That makes his statement factually correct, and makes Ford no different from Smitherman who also used hard-drugs and claims he quit and is now clean
You have at last put your finger on the problem with Ford's statement. You just haven't let your fingers type it or your tongue say it. In fact, one could truthfully swear (and perhaps pass a polygraph) as long as you believed the pipe you'd had moments before was your last ever. So as it went in the Lake, and the First Moment of the Rest of Your Life began you'd truthfully say "I do not do crack", with the small of it still in your hair.

What Rob said is exactly like the cigarette example: you truthfully say I don't use something, and you truthfully add that you're not addicted to that something but you still haven't said anything about what you did (and perhaps were addicted to) at some time in the past. The past when this video might date from just as a f'rinstance. Would it be so hard to say: 'There's no video of me smoking crack, because: I never have/only did once in a college dorm/only did a few times at the lake without inhaling and no cameras were around' ?

What we got was a good enough denial for one dashed off in the heat of the moment, and even coming a week late it was noticeably calming, but two weeks later, the silence from Ford about the past and about the details the Star and Gawker reported (which as you noted his denial does not cover) starts to resonate in the same way as the absence of the video. The one unsupported story isn't enough to condemn, the other unsupported story isn't enough to exculpate. And then there's the somewhat ominous shift from, 'I can't comment on a video that I don't even know exists' to 'there is no video', and all the subsequent addresses and resignations rodeo.

Who knew Ford nation would be such wild and woolly country? And some of us never wanted to be dragged there to begin with.
 
Here you go fuji, not one, not two, but three Canadian cases. And what do we have here, a Toronto Star reporter who admitted to and apologized for plagiarism :D

http://www.globaljournalist.org/stories/2005/01/01/journalisms-chronic-crisis/

Plagiarism isn't the same thing.

Seriously, this debating strategy -- "I am just going to wholesale refuse to believe news stories I don't like" -- is seriously kooky.

I don't believe 9/11 happened. I think the twin towers are still there. I think James Cameron made all the videos and all the newspapers are in on a giant conspiracy.

KOOKY!
 
Just show us the video, and then you might have a case.

And it was (up to) 6 months ago, according to our highly ethical drug dealers, not 3 months.
And if you add the circus of the last few weeks, its almost 7 months ago now when Ford allegedly smoked crack

A drug test will settle the only question that matters -- is he addicted to crack. If he is, then he has smoked crack this week. If he hasn't smoked crack in the past couple of weeks, he probably hasn't smoked crack in the past couple of years. And in any case, if he has no cocaine in his system, then the whole issue goes away.

I could care less what people, including the mayor, do in private, if it doesn't affect their job performance. If he likes to go to wild gay sex parties and get nailed in the ass by big black men all night while smoking enormous quantities of pot, I really could care less, as it would have no bearing on his performance as mayor.

Crack is one of those things that affects job performance, hence he needs to settle this with a drug test.
 
Plagiarism isn't the same thing
No, plagiarism is much more ethical :rolleyes:

I don't believe 9/11 happened. I think the twin towers are still there. I think James Cameron made all the videos and all the newspapers are in on a giant conspiracy.

KOOKY!
False equivalence, fuji.

9/11 could be proven and was corroborated with video evidence. Therefore it happened.

Ford story is not being corroborated with video evidence so far, therefore we have to keep the option open that the reporters fabricated this story, and didnt expect it would blow up like it did, with even international news reporting on it.

Also fuji, I found almost a hundred cases of Plagiarism/Fabrication journalism, would you like me to post the entire list??
 
False equivalence, fuji.

Turn the worm around -- you are accusing three different reporters of lying, and yet you have no evidence whatsoever that they are lying, no reason to believe they are, no reason to suspect any of them of dishonesty. Further, their story has been validated by the paper's editors and legal team, which again, you have no reason to suspect of any wrong doing. Yet you blatantly accuse them of fabricating a story.

I think it is the Ford Nation types who are actually committing gross and blatant libel against the Star in making these wholly unfounded accusation that three different reporters lied in a giant conspiracy.

Seriously, refusing to believe news stories for no other reason than you don't like the facts -- that's kooky. If you had REASONS to doubt it, that would be different, but you don't have any reasons.

As for equivalence I will have no problem in finding a long list of stories that have not got associated video, do you disbelieve them all? Or do you pick and choose which to believe? And what are your factors -- you just believe the news you agree with, and refuse to believe anything that you don't like????
 
Just show us the video, and then you might have a case.

And it was (up to) 6 months ago, according to our highly ethical drug dealers, not 3 months.
And if you add the circus of the last few weeks, its almost 7 months ago now when Ford allegedly smoked crack

What blows my mind at this point is the insistence from Ford supporters that they will lose faith in their hero if they actually see the video.

Does it not bother you how he has handled the whole mess to begin with? Does it not bother you that he waited an entire week to even say something of aubstance and when he did it was so carefully scripted it atill left major doubt for any objective thinker? Does it not bother you that the leader of our city is not even competent enough to answer direct questions on the issue and sends his goon brother in to do it for him?

He is a shining example of how NOT to handle a crisis and yet he still has those on his side that believe he is capable of managing a major city.

I actually don't even care if he smoked crack. I am more concerned about his childish response since and the fact he is doing nothing to try to rebuild his credibilty. He has lost all his support on council and we now have a lame duck mayor for the next year. All self inflicted wounds by the way but I am sure he'll blame the Star.

I even more curious how anyone can still actually support him. Like him still? Sure. Believe that he disn't do crack? Fine believe what you want. But actually think he is an effective leader and politician? Please tell how someone could be that dumb.
 
Turn the worm around -- you are accusing three different reporters of lying?
No I'm not, I didnt say they were lying. I said we have to keep that option open that they are lying

Further, their story has been validated by the paper's editors and legal team, which again, you have no reason to suspect of any wrong doing. Yet you blatantly accuse them of fabricating a story
It has not been validated by the editor, how could it have been when only 2 Star reporters saw the video, and the editor has to go by their word alone

I think it is the Ford Nation types who are actually committing gross and blatant libel against the Star in making these wholly unfounded accusation that three different reporters lied in a giant conspiracy.

Seriously, refusing to believe news stories for no other reason than you don't like the facts -- that's kooky. If you had REASONS to doubt it, that would be different, but you don't have any reasons
I have reason to doubt because the media has lied, does lie and probably will lie again. They are human, just like the rest of us

As for equivalence I will have no problem in finding a long list of stories that have not got associated video, do you disbelieve them all? Or do you pick and choose which to believe? And what are your factors -- you just believe the news you agree with, and refuse to believe anything that you don't like????
Arent you doing the same right now when you take the Star at their word??
 
What blows my mind at this point is the insistence from Ford supporters that they will lose faith in their hero if they actually see the video.

Does it not bother you how he has handled the whole mess to begin with? Does it not bother you that he waited an entire week to even say something of aubstance and when he did it was so carefully scripted it atill left major doubt for any objective thinker? Does it not bother you that the leader of our city is not even competent enough to answer direct questions on the issue and sends his goon brother in to do it for him?

He is a shining example of how NOT to handle a crisis and yet he still has those on his side that believe he is capable of managing a major city.

I actually don't even care if he smoked crack. I am more concerned about his childish response since and the fact he is doing nothing to try to rebuild his credibilty. He has lost all his support on council and we now have a lame duck mayor for the next year. All self inflicted wounds by the way but I am sure he'll blame the Star.

I even more curious how anyone can still actually support him. Like him still? Sure. Believe that he disn't do crack? Fine believe what you want. But actually think he is an effective leader and politician? Please tell how someone could be that dumb.
He has not handled this crisis well at all. And I already said I'm not sure I'll vote for him again (probably not though).

However, I also dont like seeing someone accused without any evidence, that to me is worth defending. And please note I'm not defending his tenure as a mayor, I'm defending his right to innocence until proven guilty.

Lets see the video
 
…
9/11 could be proven and was corroborated with video evidence. Therefore it happened.
…
'Proven' and 'corroborated' I'll give you, but in a thread where so many are claiming the essential piece of evidence is a video that even amateurs could easily have faked, I think it was unwise to cite "video evidence" as proof of anything.
 
I have reason to doubt because the media has lied, does lie and probably will lie again. They are human, just like the rest of us

Arent you doing the same right now when you take the Star at their word??

I guess you live in a world of your own where you pick and choose what to believe, just ignoring news you dislike. I read the new critically, generally wondering what facts may have been omitted, but I generally trust that all news outlets, right or left, report reasonably accurately.

Hey, maybe you can believe Romney is president.
 
He has not handled this crisis well at all. And I already said I'm not sure I'll vote for him again (probably not though).

I also dont like seeing someone accused without any evidence, that to me is worth defending.
And please note I'm not defending his tenure as a mayor, I'm defending his right to innocence until proven guilty.

Lets see the video
For the umpteenth time: Ford has not been accused of anything in this brouhaha by anyone who could be called responsible, like a newspaper for instance. Although many people have chosen to personally make accusatory statements about him after reading what was said, that's their failing.

Gawker first (and our Phil was right on it, which is why his thread title doesn't mention the Star), and subsequently the Star independently reported a detailed account of a couple of guys flogging a video, that supposedly showed a guy looking like Ford smoking what the reporters were told was crack. That is what they said, and it is not an accusation in any current version of English; it's a report of a disreputable buy and sell of borderline contraband There's no doubt at all that the media rightly judged the public would be interested and they could sell more ads as a result of telling them about it. Which they did with what reads like extreme exactitude in order to avoid accusation. What do you imagine they do for a living? Reporters do sit on lots of this sort of stuff all the time as the Star did, but not when the other guy publishes. The Star was supposed to just abandon six weeks of work by two expensive senior reporters and say nothing? But read again, neither they nor Gawker accused Ford of anything.

Only very rarely, and then only with the utmost care and only with the most solid of evidence do media accuse people. Especially those with the money and motive to sue. That's for their less intelligent readers to do, and blame them for, as so many partisans have in this instance. "They're so careful not to say he did it, that they must think he did it. How dare they say that!"

But 'ya can't fix stupid'. And if that's who you're complaining is accusing Ford without evidence, then save your energy and start encouraging the folks who have given us the few shreds of evidence we do have. The last thing we want is the frightening possibility that we'll be dragging this unresolved mess into the polls in 2014.

Until then, it's only us choosing between "did-didn't".
 
I will have no problem in finding a long list of stories that have not got associated video, do you disbelieve them all? Or do you pick and choose which to believe? And what are your factors -- you just believe the news you agree with, and refuse to believe anything that you don't like????
I tend to believe them when the fabricating reporter admits his/her lies, and then gets fired or quits.

Here's the long list of journalist plagiarism/fabrication scandals. I'm not sure if it adds up to exactly 100, but its a lot. And those were just the ones who got caught:

http://catalog.freedomforum.org/FFLib/JournalistScandals.htm