Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

Holy shit on a stick. I'm never, ever gonna run for office!!!
 
Unless they're dead, or unless Ford got Price to get the video.
Fake videos are nearly impossible to pull off in front of experts.

But we still have these problems:

1) Ford's chief of staff was reportedly fired for telling Ford to go to rehab.
2) His two communications officers resigned after Ford said he doesn't smoke crack and there is no video because they don't believe him.
3) His chief ally now says he thinks there is a video.
4) The police have interviewed his staff about the location of the video.
5) His staff think they know where the video was kept.
6) Ford has twice lied about substance abuse directly to the media, not including this crack episode.

I doubt they are dead...just moved on

The reporters can't be called "experts" now can they. I didn't see anything in their bios to qualify them as such.

1) If you were innocent of this and your chief of staff didn't believe you, would you keep him on? I wouldn't.
2) If they bailed they bailed. No loss really they are just mouthpieces. And press secretaries quit all the time. Most don't last at any level of govt for extended periods. Its a tough demanding thankless job. They also didn't say why they left. The stress may have been enough. But I haven't seen a statement from them as to what you claim is the reason. Please show me this.
3) And he also stated that it should be verified before it is to be believed. I saw the interview. He is sceptical to its verasity
4) They may have been running down a tip. Its their job to be thorough. Perhaps the Star should show the same diligence. As of now I haven't heard that it has led anywhere...have you?
5) Good! Let it come to light and be verified. If its real I'll be the first to call for his head....but if its not.....will you call for the Star's?
6) Two incidents in 10 years do not make for substance abuse. Just too much to drink. Twice in ten years. Hell I'm good for at least once a year myself. Not d judgement mind you. Just being human

Let the video be brought to light. Till then its just conjecture. And I won't convict anyone, no matter how much I dislike his politics, on that.
 
i would almost believe that except an amateur did it in an hour from his home.

Gotta love the amateur visual effects people in the house. Here why don't you take it from someone who worked in vfx a while ago.

1) The main problem with this CG is that it requires a massive amount of resources to do well, time, machines, and commitment. Also if the guy in the picture is actually a lowly auto painter who's interest *Just happens* to be vfx, then I have some swampland in Florida to sell you.
2) It's easy to make a CG character, but harder to make that character believable. Almost impossible for most except the most crack (no pun intended) team of animators. It's because of a property called the 'uncanny valley' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley... which applies to most cg characters. while in most recent years they have gotten better at closing the gap here it usually requires a team of many, and a significant amount of equipment. Having known the products that come out of college, it is NOT possible for students to do this completely satisfactorily in college thanks to the fact that.... no million dollar render farms and no million dollar inferno stations. Actually that people posit that this kind of stuff could have come out of college students is making me laugh. The garden variety cg that you see are created by teams and teams of experts, not pukes coming through school. Shit I have to currently listen to some o fmy friends who are profs of animation complain about the "work ethic" these days - enough to doubt that students did it.
3) So they would have needed a CG Rob Ford, and they would have had to obtain video of dead drug dealer or to simulate that drug dealer in cg which is even harder due to point 2.

Apparently the length of the original Rob Ford video is minutes(?) Just like the jackass in the little vid says that 'the small size of the cel phone' obscures, well so do extremely short clips. The tiny duration of his composite makes it believable. Wait a bit longer aaaand.... yeah that's harder to do... especially with specific dialogue. How much though does the resolution matter? Again the journalists insist that the footage was 'crystal clear'

Presuming that the phone used was an iphone

iphone 4 960x640
iphone 5 1136x640

Now let`s compare with some common visual resolutions that you can usually find on your TV

HD720 1280x720
HD1080 1920x1080

An iphone 5 comes pretty close to almost displaying the same number of pixels as an HD TV... is it as good as one? No. But can you see if video is crystal clear in an iphone 4 or 5.... you be the judge.
 
no one sad it was good quality. i believe the claim was grainy from across the room. doesn't have to be perfect that way, it only has to be good enough.

Robin Doolittle said it was clear and bright.

I follow her on Twitter because I like watching the reporters' tweets during city council meetings. (search for #Topoli on Twitter ~ I'm a geek and enjoy the play-by-play).

She knows what Ford looks and sounds like.
 
And I highly doubt the Somali dealers would have access to the technical expertise required to produce a good quality fake video complete with audio.

Are they Somali drug dealers? All of them? If you were peddling a fake video, what would you say you were?

I'm open minded about this. I want the video, I want the reporters to identify it as the one they saw BEFORE it is tested. So that the truth can come out.

If its real, off with the Mayors Head. He has betraayed the trust of my vote and the message I wanted to send to City Hall

If its fake? What will you say then.

But again I say, I won't convict a man on conjecture, of any political stripe. It is undemocratic.
 
Gotta love the amateur visual effects people in the house. Here why don't you take it from someone who worked in vfx a while ago.

Presuming that the phone used was an iphone

iphone 4 960x640
iphone 5 1136x640

You are saying screen size is irrelevant?? The iphone screen is 2" wide, Ford would be shown smaller than a postage stamp.

Maybe Smith knew Ford, and was fooling around with the programs in his visual arts course at Seneca, and made the video as a joke to practice or show off. Something went wrong.
 
You are saying screen size is irrelevant?? The iphone screen is 2" wide, Ford would be shown smaller then a postage stamp.

Maybe Smith knew Ford, and was fooling around with the programs and made the video as a joke to practice or show off. Something went wrong.

1 - you can zoom on an iphone.
2 - reporters who see, speak and hear Rob Ford every day can surely-recognize his appearance, voice, and manner of speaking.
 
Gotta love the amateur visual effects people in the house. Here why don't you take it from someone who worked in vfx a while ago.

1) The main problem with this CG is that it requires a massive amount of resources to do well, time, machines, and commitment. Also if the guy in the picture is actually a lowly auto painter who's interest *Just happens* to be vfx, then I have some swampland in Florida to sell you.
2) It's easy to make a CG character, but harder to make that character believable. Almost impossible for most except the most crack (no pun intended) team of animators. It's because of a property called the 'uncanny valley' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley... which applies to most cg characters. while in most recent years they have gotten better at closing the gap here it usually requires a team of many, and a significant amount of equipment. Having known the products that come out of college, it is NOT possible for students to do this completely satisfactorily in college thanks to the fact that.... no million dollar render farms and no million dollar inferno stations. Actually that people posit that this kind of stuff could have come out of college students is making me laugh. The garden variety cg that you see are created by teams and teams of experts, not pukes coming through school. Shit I have to currently listen to some o fmy friends who are profs of animation complain about the "work ethic" these days - enough to doubt that students did it.
3) So they would have needed a CG Rob Ford, and they would have had to obtain video of dead drug dealer or to simulate that drug dealer in cg which is even harder due to point 2.

Apparently the length of the original Rob Ford video is minutes(?) Just like the jackass in the little vid says that 'the small size of the cel phone' obscures, well so do extremely short clips. The tiny duration of his composite makes it believable. Wait a bit longer aaaand.... yeah that's harder to do... especially with specific dialogue. How much though does the resolution matter? Again the journalists insist that the footage was 'crystal clear'

Presuming that the phone used was an iphone

iphone 4 960x640
iphone 5 1136x640

Now let`s compare with some common visual resolutions that you can usually find on your TV

HD720 1280x720
HD1080 1920x1080

An iphone 5 comes pretty close to almost displaying the same number of pixels as an HD TV... is it as good as one? No. But can you see if video is crystal clear in an iphone 4 or 5.... you be the judge.
did you watch the recent liberace (sp) movie with mike douglas as liberace. the took mike douglas head and put it on another guys body in a seemless transition.

Robin Doolittle said it was clear and bright.

I follow her on Twitter because I like watching the reporters' tweets during city council meetings. (search for #Topoli on Twitter ~ I'm a geek and enjoy the play-by-play).

She knows what Ford looks and sounds like.

seems to be a fair bit of back peddling now. audio is easy to steal and manipulate. let me ask you if you were being judged as harsh and without proof as ford is would you think it fair ? as of right now there is zero proof but several already have him guilty and a borderline crack fiend.
 
1 - you can zoom on an iphone.
2 - reporters who see, speak and hear Rob Ford every day can surely-recognize his appearance, voice, and manner of speaking.

They were not allowed to handle the phone. They were in a dark car. They never stated how far away from the phone they were.
Not even the model...if it was an Iphone 1 how good is the screen then, after 7 years of usage.
They stated he was incoherent. How does that apply?(Yes I can see the jokes coming on this one folks!) To the way he normally speaks?

A faked video will look like him. That's the point.

The money is waiting for them. Someone has it. Why not collect? They can get the money via gawker right now....so why don't they?
Unless gawker wants to verify it first...if its real then no problem right? But if its a fake.......

Let it come to light. I want it to be verified. And the Star reporters to confirm its the video before it is tested. Then let the truth decide.

Other than that its conjecture....not enough to convict even in the court of public opinion.
 
^^^^ well said, Butler.

Holy shit, I'm gonna start my own Stephen Harper heroin injecting video.

Money to be made, people
 
IIRC the drug dealers wouldnt let the reporters touch the iPhone, they only let them see the video

That's what I remember, but Jennifer might be on to something. The crack dealers might also know you can zoom in on the video. The crack dealers specifically would not allow the reporters to handle the phone, knowing if the reporters did zoom in on the video, they would discover it was a fake.

All making sense now.
 
I think this whole thing is a conspiracy by Rob Ford himself to take the attention off himself for something else
He could very easily have had the video shot of himself, had the reporters see it for authenticity, then made it disappear.
Now everyone is talking about it, the video is nowhere to be found, and he comes out unscathed.
The reporters suffer and then Rob does something that we least expect as the attention is on the crack video.
Seems plausible?
 
They were not allowed to handle the phone. They were in a dark car. They never stated how far away from the phone they were.
Not even the model...if it was an Iphone 1 how good is the screen then, after 7 years of usage.
They stated he was incoherent. How does that apply?(Yes I can see the jokes coming on this one folks!) To the way he normally speaks?

A faked video will look like him. That's the point.

T.



Rob Ford crack scandal: Star reporters tell their side of story

Furtive manoeuvres to get a look at a video allegedly of Mayor Rob Ford smoking crack were worthy of a spy thriller.

We were to come alone and park in front of the Royal Bank at a dingy plaza on Dixon Rd.
Our source would meet us there around 9:45 p.m. He promised to bring “his cousin” — a man he claimed had secretly recorded Toronto Mayor Rob Ford on video smoking crack cocaine.
This man, our source said, was a drug dealer who had recently sold crack to Ford.
This was May 3, more than a month after the source first contacted us and told us about the footage. That call came after the Star published a story about a stumbling, incoherent Ford being asked to leave the Garrison Ball in Toronto. That story also detailed concerns of people close to him that he had a substance abuse problem.
It was the Star’s third attempt to see the video. The dealer always seemed to get cold feet at the last minute. Our source promised that this time would be different.

We arrived early at the dimly lit strip mall. The parking lot was still pretty full despite the fact most of the shops seemed shut for the night. People wandered in and out of a variety store. A group gathered outside a restaurant, smoking.
We drank Tim Horton’s coffee and passed the time theorizing about what was going to happen, if anything.
Would they show us the video right there on the spot? Would we go into the nearby restaurant? Would it be a group of people? Just our source and the dealer? What if they asked us to get in the car and go somewhere? How could we ensure our safety?
At 10:30 p.m., with no source, we were becoming increasingly convinced that there was no video.
And then all of a sudden, a black car pulled up alongside ours. Robyn Doolittle’s cellphone rang. The source looked at us and motioned to the back of his car.
“Leave your cellphones. No bags. No purses. And get in,” he said.
Our source would drive us to the dealer. We were not to have anything that could record what we were about to see.
We got in the car. Doolittle sat in the front, Donovan in the back. The car was clean and new. Our source — who we’d been getting to know over the last four weeks — said he was involved because he wanted to help two young men in the drug trade. They needed money to start a new life, he said. They had a commodity, a video.
He said the price was “six figures,” which we loosely interpreted as at least $100,000. Later he told us their original price had been $1 million but he had convinced the dealers that was too much.
The Star wanted to see the video. Media organizations often pay $500 for a good picture shot by a freelancer, but this price was astronomical. We told him that and continued a negotiation that had already gone on for some time. On the drive to meet the dealer, talk again quickly turned to money. Earlier he told us that another unnamed media organization had offered $20,000, but that the dealers turned it down.
“We need to see it first,” Doolittle said. “Then we can determine what it is worth.”
“If there is a video,” Donovan said, “the people of Toronto need to see it.”
The Star did not pay any money related to the video. Discussions were ongoing as recently as last week as the Star tried to find a way to obtain the video.
The car headed down Dixon Rd. The ride was less than five minutes. We pulled into a huge parking lot alongside a series of highrise towers. In an earlier visit, the source claimed that people who sell Ford drugs live in the complex.
Our source scanned the lot for his “cousin” — who actually only seemed to be loosely related by blood. It was dark outside. Dozens of people were scattered in groups among the many cars. Our source phoned his contact. We’d driven past him.
Our source parked the car and said he’d go get him. He left with his keys in the engine — a good sign for our safety, we thought.
Several minutes later, our source returned.
“He’s coming.”
A few more minutes ticked by before a skinny man appearing to be in his early to mid 20s got in the back with Donovan. He was in dark clothing. He was breathing quickly. His eyes were wide.
We said a brief hello. This man didn’t want to talk. Until this point we did not know what to expect. A smartphone? Ipad? The man pulled out an iPhone. Donovan asked to hold it but the man said no. His eyes darted left to right, scanning the parking lot. Later we learned he thought we were cops and this was a setup. Eventually he relented and held the phone, with Donovan, who tilted it so we could both watch. The man hit play.
The video started to play mutely.


“No sound. Sound’s extra,” the dealer said.
We told him that without sound we could not verify the video.
We explained we needed to hear the sound to help us identify the man we were told was in the video. What he said was relevant to the story.
The dealer spoke to our source in Somali. The dealer eventually agreed to allow sound.


We watched it three times, freeze-framing from time to time and peering closely at the screen.

In the back of the car that night, we had absolutely no way to authenticate the video. What follows is an account of a video showing a man who appeared to be Mayor Rob Ford, to the best of our ability to identify him. He was sitting in a chair, speaking in an incoherent and rambling manner, smoking what looks exactly like a crack pipe.
Later, Ford’s lawyer, who has not seen the video, mused that it is impossible to tell from any video what a person is really doing. Callers to radio shows on Friday wondered if the video was a fake, doctored in some way. An ally of the mayor said videos can be altered and drug dealers can’t be trusted.
The dealer sitting beside Donovan confirmed he had shot the video and said it was Mayor Ford. The dealer appeared to be about 2.5 metres away from Ford.

The image was crystal clear. Prior to watching the video we had looked at numerous videos of Ford at council, on the campaign trail and at public events. The man in the chair was Ford, we concluded.

He was in the centre of the shot. The smartphone appeared to be filming from low.
At this point, we were expecting a poorly lit video at best, with blurry figures shot from a great distance.
That Friday night in the back of the car, when the video finally played we were shocked. The video was clear, lit by afternoon sunlight coming in through a partly shaded window.


In the video, filtered light bathes Ford’s face. Ford is mumbling and waving around on his chair. A man’s voice can be heard off to the left side. He talks to Ford about football. The voice tells him he should be coaching football because that’s what he’s good at.
Ford, slurring and moving slowly, bobs in agreement.
“Yeah, I take these kids … f---ing minorities,” and then he trails off.
He talks about “Everyone expects me to be right-wing, I’m supposed to be this great …” and again appears to lose his train of thought.
He moves the clear pipe to his mouth, flicks the lighter and moves it in a circular motion below the pipe and inhales. He exhales thin puffs of smoke.
The voice moves on to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau. The voice says he wants to shove his foot up the young leader’s “ass so far it comes out the other end.”
Ford: “Justin Trudeau’s a fag.”
Soon after this, a cellphone rings. It’s unclear if it is the phone that is being used to video the scene. Ford looks directly into the camera and says “that phone better not be on.”


The video then goes dark.

We replayed the video twice more, three times in total. We held the video within inches of our face to examine the glass pipe. It did not look like a tobacco or marijuana pipe.

“It’s crack,” the dealer said, growing more agitated and frustrated the longer he sat in the car.
“Are you worried, if this comes out, about your safety? Will the mayor know it’s you?” Doolittle asked.
“Money is safety.”
He left soon after and our source took us back to the Royal Bank, where we spent an hour digesting what we had just witnessed

http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/201..._star_reporters_tell_their_side_of_story.html
 
if there is anything i learned in life is that you can always trust a drug dealer. they never lie. criminals are honest hardworking upstanding citizens.
 
Rob Ford crack scandal: Star reporters tell their side of story

Furtive manoeuvres to get a look at a video allegedly of Mayor Rob Ford smoking crack were worthy of a spy thriller
So JennyPoo, you're saying that Star reporters would never make up stories, or exaggerate stories??!


Simple question, yes or no???
 
You are saying screen size is irrelevant?? The iphone screen is 2" wide, Ford would be shown smaller than a postage stamp.
Maybe Smith knew Ford, and was fooling around with the programs in his visual arts course at Seneca, and made the video as a joke to practice or show off. Something went wrong.

No, and this is the problem that I have with the OTHER video... the guy foists a mediocre little video as if you could do better with just a little more elbow grease with a bunch of art programs. This is fresh bullshit. As I have emphasized, to pull it off in a convincing fashion one would have to have significantly more resources and time than art school

As for the screen resolution, it would have no effect... for images to appear unpixelated they require a minimum of 300 ppi... an iphone 4 and 5 have around 336ppi screens. The only thing that putting the video up on a tv would do is to just make the pixels in the original footage larger: Translation = putting it up on a tv would make it a bare minimum sharper since the iphones have nearly as many pixels and although have ppi values at which the human eye cannot distinguish the actual pixels, it is close.

Like let's face it... a guy, claiming to be an auto worker, somehow automagicaly is an Adobe After Effects and tracking expert. It fucking makes me laugh if it were not so pathetic because it's a targeted video and so obviously for the Ford nation.