Scammers Vortex: Regency Fitness ...

5hummer

Active member
Sep 6, 2008
3,802
15
38
:mad:

Background (in 2011): My CC got compromised so I got a new CC number. Premier (now Regency) called to mentioned my dues weren't paid for a couple of months, so I decided to just cancel my membership and dropped by to cancel it. A Request Form was filled out, where I paid what was owed and they gave me 3 additional months free.
Note: No new credit CC info was given.

In Jan 2012: Got a call by Premier, said my dues were overdue, I told them I cancelled my membership? No further calls.

Now 2013: Regency calls, and says I never cancelled my membership. I owe them money? Slimebags!?!

Maybe it was my mistake, I thought the Request Form was a cancellation form? I didn't submit a new CC# or was asked (since I thought I cancelled the membership). And, I haven't been to gym since supposed cancellation.

So, now they are threatening to send "Collections".

Yup, I'm in the Fitness Club Slimebag Vortex. Anyways that I can get out of this?
 
Ignore it until the collections calls start.

Then get the Collection Agency info, names and telephone number address.

Call them to verify. If you can, record your call and take notes . Then advise them specifically that you dispute their client's claim, that it is a contractual dispute, not a collections matter. Further advise them that you are demanding they cease and desist their collections activities, including credit bureau reporting or you will make a complaint to the MCCR. Suggest they and advise their client (Premier) that you will not be paying unless they obtain a judgement in Small Claims Court.

If they call again, complain to the MCCR.
 
Some time back, a number of fitness clubs were hi-lighted on Marketplace for scams such as this and the Premier was the worst, more than all others combined. The consumer protection against this is so weak it, boils down to jumping through all the hoops and not letting you grinding you down. One reason why I absolutely fight tooth and nail against automatic withdraw or CC monthly charges.
 
If there's a written, contractural obligation between the OP and Regency withe terms and conditions clearly identified, then complaining to the MCCR won't do much. I don't know the contract details but if there's any wording to suggest membership will automatically continue unless the OP provides a minimum notice period, then the OP is liable. However, it does sound strange that Regency makes no contact until a year later and no payment was made over that period.

If the collection agency has documentation to prove the OP owes money under certain terms and conditions then the collection agency can continue to collect. Hard to prove there's a contractural issue to the collection agency if it's in writing, and the agency will report this to the credit reporting agency. Then it's a bitch to clear it with them.

There's just too many unknowns from the OP at this point, but if there's nothing in writing to prove the OP owes Regency, then I'd fire off a letter to Regency asap putting them on notice for any damages if the collection agency persists or reports to a reporting agency. Yes, now is a good time to report the agency to the MCCR, and try to get the collection number of the collector and tell him/her you will be reporting him/her for harassment.

One thing I can tell you for sure the Owner of Regency is a slime ball. He's screwed over so many members over the years and worst, screwed many employees out of pay. Never, ever, ever give them, of any fitness club for that matter, your CC number or a cheque with your banking info. Always pay by debit card, monthly preferred.
 
Some time back, a number of fitness clubs were hi-lighted on Marketplace for scams such as this and the Premier was the worst, more than all others combined. The consumer protection against this is so weak it, boils down to jumping through all the hoops and not letting you grinding you down. One reason why I absolutely fight tooth and nail against automatic withdraw or CC monthly charges.

Premier = Regency
 
Name change just after all this shit hits the fan, go figure. To the lawyers in the crowd, does this make the legal actions and investigations against
Premier/Regency moot?
It's not a name change. Premier, as a legal separate entity is under receivership. The Premier owner decided to give it a go with another, separate legal entity, Regency. Creditors from Premier can't touch assets of Regency, but the scamming techniques on members and issues with employees are the same. If anyone was a member of Premier they had the option to finish their annual membership at Regency and then sign contracts going forward with Regency. You'll also note some of the Premier personal trainers are at Regency now.

I say keep your eyes, ears and nose open, lol. Be wary with fitness clubs, not just Regency, all of them have had their issues. My first experience with fitness club scams was with Vic Tanny's in the 70's, lost money with them in just over a week! The only one that seems to have a bit of credibility today is Goodlife due to their affiliation with Loblaws, and still be careful as well.
 
If there's a written, contractural obligation between the OP and Regency withe terms and conditions clearly identified, then complaining to the MCCR won't do much.....
If the collection agency has documentation to prove the OP owes money under certain terms and conditions then the collection agency can continue to collect. Hard to prove there's a contractural issue to the collection agency if it's in writing, and the agency will report this to the credit reporting agency. Then it's a bitch to clear it with them. .


I think you are mistaken fun guy.

The collection agency cannot continue contact once a contractual dispute has been raised. Otherwise I could use a collection agency to extort money.

The collection agency is not a court, nor can they rule on any copy of any paper they have in front of them. A million issues are possible. Fake sig, changed dates etc. hat is why there is a court system.

However, after having a quick look online here is what I found

http://www.sse.gov.on.ca/mcs/en/Pages/Personal_Finance_Collection_Agency_Rights.aspx


\\Your Rights When Dealing With Collection Agencies


Right off the bat

The first step a collection agency must take is to send you a written notice through the mail (email doesn’t count). This notice must include:

the name of the creditor (the person or business that says you owe them money)
the amount the creditor says you owe
the name of the collection agency and its authority to demand payment on behalf of the creditor.
After sending the notice, the agency must wait six days before it can contact you in person or by phone.

What if they’re wrong?

The agency cannot continue to contact you if:

you send a registered letter to the agency saying that you dispute the debt and suggest the matter be taken to court


you (or your lawyer) send a registered letter to the agency providing your lawyer’s contact information and notifying the
agency to communicate only with your lawyer

you have told them that you are not the person they are looking for, unless they take reasonable precautions to ensure you are that person.


Exercise your rights

If you believe a collection agency has violated any of these practices in dealing with you:

send the agency a letter outlining why you believe they have acted inappropriately and notifying them that you expect them to comply with the law

if their behaviour persists, file a complaint with the ministry.
 
:mad:

Background (in 2011): My CC got compromised so I got a new CC number. Premier (now Regency) called to mentioned my dues weren't paid for a couple of months, so I decided to just cancel my membership and dropped by to cancel it. A Request Form was filled out, where I paid what was owed and they gave me 3 additional months free.
Note: No new credit CC info was given.

In Jan 2012: Got a call by Premier, said my dues were overdue, I told them I cancelled my membership? No further calls.

Now 2013: Regency calls, and says I never cancelled my membership. I owe them money? Slimebags!?!

Maybe it was my mistake, I thought the Request Form was a cancellation form? I didn't submit a new CC# or was asked (since I thought I cancelled the membership). And, I haven't been to gym since supposed cancellation.

So, now they are threatening to send "Collections".

Yup, I'm in the Fitness Club Slimebag Vortex. Anyways that I can get out of this?

I would go about this situation in a completely different way from what you've done.
If Regency doesn't feel inclined to cancel the membership, I would show up at the gym and start upping the ante of being the rudest, loudest douchebag in the gym until they insisted I leave and they ripped up my membership contract immediately.
No dropping weights? I'd do military press and toss the barbell at the wall.
No grunting? I'd be louder than their PA
My whole 'workout' would consist of moving as much equipment out of normal position as possible. Benches would go to the far side of the room. Dumbells would be scattered everywhere. Kettlebells would be left on treadmills.
I'd go around telling people what they were doing wrong. I'd interrupt the PTs to tell their clients that they're wasting their money. If someone had left a towel on a bench to secure it, I'd toss the towel and just use the bench to sit on while texting. In my street clothes.
When the staff or manager told me to behave better I'd say, "I'm not going anywhere, I have a contract!"
I expect within an hour or two my membership would be over. Probably with a lifetime ban too :Cry:

But that's just me.
And I've been going to Goodlife for a few years without a problem, it's a good organization.
 
I learned long ago that fitness clubs were high on the list of shady business practices and so whenever I had cancelled my memberships I have done so in writing and kept a copy for my files along with the date and person it was delivered to. I also made sure to provide the proper notice (usually 30 days).

When entering into the initial contract, I also make sure to read the fine print. In case I had them write into the contract that my 1 year pre-paid membership would NOT automatically convert to monthly payments.

Knock on wood, I haven't had any problems to date.
 
I would go about this situation in a completely different way from what you've done.
If Regency doesn't feel inclined to cancel the membership, I would show up at the gym and start upping the ante of being the rudest, loudest douchebag in the gym until they insisted I leave and they ripped up my membership contract immediately.
No dropping weights? I'd do military press and toss the barbell at the wall.
No grunting? I'd be louder than their PA
I'd go around telling people what they were doing wrong. I'd interrupt the PTs to tell their clients that they're wasting their money. If someone had left a towel on a bench to secure it, I'd toss the towel and just use the bench to sit on while texting. In my street clothes.
When the staff or manager told me to behave better I'd say, "I'm not going anywhere, I have a contract!"
I expect within an hour or two my membership would be over.

But that's just me.
And I've been going to Goodlife for a few years without a problem, it's a good organization.


I'd expect you'd be doing pushups in jail awaiting bail shortly thereafter! And hoping i'd left my steroid works at home!
 
Is grunting in a gym actually illegal now?! Is being rude against some law?! If that were the case most of our city council would be locked up.
 
Is grunting in a gym actually illegal now?! Is being rude against some law?! If that were the case most of our city council would be locked up.


Grunting on its own is not. Jerking off while grunting is reason to call the police. Don't as how I know. (Shhhhhhhh simon482, this is our secret!)
 
Gawd I hate collection agencies. Seriously.

From my own experience, to make a long story short, I had an outstanding bill for a little over 3 months that I finally paid and it was accepted. At the exact moment my account was sold off to a collection agency. So this agency starts calling, I tell them it was settled with the vendor. But after talking with both, neither of them would talk to each other to figure it out. Why? I dunno. So I gathered my statements and crap and sent it to the collection agency and they were cool with it. Calls stopped. Fast forward a year, I start getting calls again. From a different agency. I tell them the story and tell them to bugger off. Calls stop. Fast forward another year. Calls start again, from a different agency. This is ridiculous, I figure, but I really want to make this go away. I can't find original paperwork I used so I go through the whole routine again (getting statements from the bank and stuff, now about 3 years ago). Calls stop again. Are we done yet?

The scam was, each agency just kept selling their old shit to a new agency, regardless of the outcome. It was ridiculous.

Btw, to the OP, I wouldn't lawyer up unless I really really had to.
 
I think you are mistaken fun guy.

The collection agency cannot continue contact once a contractual dispute has been raised. Otherwise I could use a collection agency to extort money.

The collection agency is not a court, nor can they rule on any copy of any paper they have in front of them. A million issues are possible. Fake sig, changed dates etc. hat is why there is a court system.

However, after having a quick look online here is what I found

http://www.sse.gov.on.ca/mcs/en/Pages/Personal_Finance_Collection_Agency_Rights.aspx


\\Your Rights When Dealing With Collection Agencies


Right off the bat

The first step a collection agency must take is to send you a written notice through the mail (email doesn’t count). This notice must include:

the name of the creditor (the person or business that says you owe them money)
the amount the creditor says you owe
the name of the collection agency and its authority to demand payment on behalf of the creditor.
After sending the notice, the agency must wait six days before it can contact you in person or by phone.

What if they’re wrong?

The agency cannot continue to contact you if:

you send a registered letter to the agency saying that you dispute the debt and suggest the matter be taken to court


you (or your lawyer) send a registered letter to the agency providing your lawyer’s contact information and notifying the
agency to communicate only with your lawyer

you have told them that you are not the person they are looking for, unless they take reasonable precautions to ensure you are that person.


Exercise your rights

If you believe a collection agency has violated any of these practices in dealing with you:

send the agency a letter outlining why you believe they have acted inappropriately and notifying them that you expect them to comply with the law

if their behaviour persists, file a complaint with the ministry.

Collection agencies can take you to court if you think there's a contract issue if directed by the creditor, but you don't have a hope in hell if it's in writing that you're liable to pay, you're just avoiding the inevitable and you will pay more in the end anyway. If it was that easy for debtors to get away with not paying on a contract, then debtors will use the technique you suggest above if they think they can get away with it. There are professional debtors who skip around the country trying to evade payment. Most debtors don't write letters to the ministry, they just keep moving and hiding, and even if they did, the collection agencies don't stop, they will take you to court if they think the case is black and white and if the amount is worth it. Agencies have a collection of outside lawyers who specialize in collections and know all the tricks, they know the law, they know the line they could walk but don't step over it, and trust me you don't want to piss them off.





Let's just say I have a lot of experience in collecting, lol.
 
Gawd I hate collection agencies. Seriously.

From my own experience, to make a long story short, I had an outstanding bill for a little over 3 months that I finally paid and it was accepted. At the exact moment my account was sold off to a collection agency. So this agency starts calling, I tell them it was settled with the vendor. But after talking with both, neither of them would talk to each other to figure it out. Why? I dunno. So I gathered my statements and crap and sent it to the collection agency and they were cool with it. Calls stopped. Fast forward a year, I start getting calls again. From a different agency. I tell them the story and tell them to bugger off. Calls stop. Fast forward another year. Calls start again, from a different agency. This is ridiculous, I figure, but I really want to make this go away. I can't find original paperwork I used so I go through the whole routine again (getting statements from the bank and stuff, now about 3 years ago). Calls stop again. Are we done yet?

The scam was, each agency just kept selling their old shit to a new agency, regardless of the outcome. It was ridiculous.

Btw, to the OP, I wouldn't lawyer up unless I really really had to.


lol, classic. Yes, agencies can sub out some of their outstanding bad paper to other agencies, typically smaller ones who are hungrier. It doesn't take much overhead to run a collection agency, a phone and a desk, right out of one's basement, assuming you're licensed of course. Agencies only make money when they collect, they're on contingency fees, if they don't collect they starve. Collectors can be quite persistent and a pain in the rear. Mistakes are made all the time and if you've paid and think you're being harassed, report them to the ministry with their collector number, copy the president of the agency and the president of the creditor in question and they'll stop the calls.