Antigua is both more expensive and safer than Jamaica.
Jamaica is relatively safe...but only on the north and west side of the isle...Kingston is dangerous..but its mostly local problems..Negril, and MoBay are safe...albeit , you have to get around alot of haggling on tourist beaches and markets..and every dude is selling weed..don't buy from them, its a rip off...go to a local market and ask a old lady...they have the good stuff..lol