Is Teleworking the only real solution to traffic gridlock?

Plan B

Race Relations Expert
Jun 7, 2008
1,055
5
38
Subways, LRTs, new toll highways.....the reality is that all of these things cost a lot of money..and most of us are not willing to pay more taxes and tolls, so that the next generation can benefit from our payments and still bitch about us at the same time. What about a more cost effective solution, one that is not as difficult to manage, and requires less government meddling? I'm talking about teleworking...or working from home. How many of us could do the same job, and do it just as effectively if given the chance by our companies to do the work at home? Think about it..less people on the roads, on transit, less money spent on gas...better for air quality etc. Obviously many jobs are not in a position where this is feasible..but especially for some office jobs..even working a couple of days a week from home could be beneficial. The incentive for companies might come from the different levels of government in terms of tax breaks....or we can keep on with divisive arguments over who's going to pay for two new subway stations every decade or so...hardly a reasonable solution.

Any thoughts?
 
Subways, LRTs, new toll highways.....the reality is that all of these things cost a lot of money..and most of us are not willing to pay more taxes and tolls, so that the next generation can benefit from our payments and still bitch about us at the same time. What about a more cost effective solution, one that is not as difficult to manage, and requires less government meddling? I'm talking about teleworking...or working from home. How many of us could do the same job, and do it just as effectively if given the chance by our companies to do the work at home? Think about it..less people on the roads, on transit, less money spent on gas...better for air quality etc. Obviously many jobs are not in a position where this is feasible..but especially for some office jobs..even working a couple of days a week from home could be beneficial. The incentive for companies might come from the different levels of government in terms of tax breaks....or we can keep on with divisive arguments over who's going to pay for two new subway stations every decade or so...hardly a reasonable solution.

Any thoughts?
Giving into one's least generous, most miserly side has never been any successful philosophy or religion's message. It's certainly not how you got roads to drive on or clean drinking water coming out of your tap, nor does it explain the huge investment those who came before you put into taking away your shit. Utter selfishness is what babies are supposed to learn to grow out of, as they see the advantages of doing things together and creating something like Adam Smiths' well-ordered society as the best way to personal fulfillment. Won't never get there without taxes, son.

But if I imagine you're actually talking sense, how could anyone make your computer by telecommuting, or the TV and movies you watch? Or the car you imagine parking on those freebie roads. (PS no roads built from basement offices) And how would your vegetables telecommute onto your plate? There's only one way to successfully eliminate gridlock; get rid of the cars that create it. If you're not willing to do that, you'll have to suck up the inconvenience of everyone else using the the stop and go roads along with you.

Incremental benefits sure, and you're a decade or more behind the folks who pioneered telework, flex schedules and such, but if you see a future where everyone still wants, has and uses a private car, you'd better start thinking your tax-money's a better expenditure than your cable bill, or a few of those car washes, or the latest in-dash infotainment teat, 'cause you'll need a lot more roads. And they don't come free.
 
Giving into your least generous, most miserly side has never been any successful philosophy or religion's message. It's certainly not how you got roads to drive on or clean drinking water coming out of your tap, nor does it explain the huge investment those who came before you put into taking away your shit.

But if I imagine you're actually talking sense, who would make your computer by telecommuting, or the TV and movies you watch? ajnd how would your vegetables telecommute onto your plate? There's only one way to successfully eliminate gridlock; get rid of the cars. IOf you're not willing to do that, you'll have to suck up the inconvenience of everyone else using them along with you.

Incremental benefits sure, and you're a decade or more behind the folks who pioneered telework, flex schedules and such, but if you see a future where everyone still wants and has a private car, you'd better start thinking your tax-money's a better expenditure than your cable bill, or a few of those car washes, or the latest in-dash infotainment teat.


Like I said, many jobs are can simply not be done by teleworking. By the way..those TV shows I watch are made in a place called Hollywood. I'm talking about Canada.
There are so many jobs that can be done at home, through dedicated phone lines, internet, Skype, etc.
So many people go to work and sit in a cubicle and work on their desktop computer.
The other incentive for companies, might be less office space, since there will be less need for that...which will result in more money savings...and we know that companies love to save money
 
Like I said, many jobs are can simply not be done by teleworking. By the way..those TV shows I watch are made in a place called Hollywood. I'm talking about Canada.
There are so many jobs that can be done at home, through dedicated phone lines, internet, Skype, etc.
So many people go to work and sit in a cubicle and work on their desktop computer.
The other incentive for companies, might be less office space, since there will be less need for that...which will result in more money savings...and we know that companies love to save money
Yup, and many of those Hollywood shows are made right here in the GTA. If I coulda telecommuted instead of driving to Hamilton at 5AM all that winter to keep the commercials apart, believe me I woulda. But Mr. Harris didn't want movies made in TO

Nothing wrong with the telecommuting idea, and as I said it is far from new, but it is also far from being a solution to the gridlock problem. That's gotta be fixed by more public spending on roads and transit or fewer people spending on cars and driving. Likely both. Either way it'll cost you, so get used to it, when you're shopping for the desk, the boss used to give you and figuring out how to load it into your car at IKEA.

You know, my Dad bought his home desk from the Eaton's catalogue and they delivered it right to the second floor. Later he bought a car, when the grocery store stopped delivering, but I bought my house because the local supermarket still does, and I can walk to my choice of espresso bars. That's telecommuting old style, tele- means distance, nothing at all to do with electronics.

When you're struggling in the IKEA loading bay with all the other weekend amateur teamsters, ask yourself if giving up everything for private cars really is all it was supposed to be.
 
Yup, and many of those Hollywood shows are made right here in the GTA. If I coulda telecommuted instead of driving to Hamilton at 5AM all that winter to keep the commercials apart, believe me I woulda.

Nothing wrong with the telecommuting idea, and as I said it is far from new, but it is also far from being a solution to the gridlock problem. That's gotta be fixed by more public spending on roads and transit or fewer people spending on cars and driving. Likely both. Either way it'll cost you, so get used to it, when you're shopping for the desk, the boss used to give you and figuring out how to load it into your car at IKEA.

You know, my Dad bought his home desk from the Eaton's catalogue and they delivered it right to the second floor. Who needs a car?

You aren't being realistic.This is North America..people love their cars...its the goal of every 14 year old to save up for a car by working at McDonald's for a few years.
North American cities are built for cars..they are not going away any time soon..In fact I think Harper recently gave a bunch of money to Toyota. You are talking about decisions that require will require government decades to get their act together...and I a talking about cost effective solutions that are in the interest of companies to implement in a quick manner.
My debate and your debate--no comparison
 
There are some jobs which can be done remotely, and many which cannot.

But it's certainly not the only solution to gridlock.

And probably not even the best solution.

Toronto is absolutely horrible for encouraging every office-based business to locate downtown, when there is absolutely no reason to do so. City planners should force more employment zones out of the downtown core and out along the commuter corridors, particularly along the GO Lakeshore lines and the extended TTC subway lines.

If a commuter from the east end or the west end is happy to take transit to downtown, then they will have little difficulty going just a few extra minutes past downtown to reach their work. And for many, it would be a shorter trip.

Over time, people would choose to work and live in closer proximity and you would have fewer instances of people having to "cross the city" to reach their work. Downtown would still be bustling and easy to reach when you need to, but would also be less crowded (as would the suburbs and exurbs as people spend less time on those roads as well).

When you have a better balance between people commuting into an area and commuting out of that area you will reach a much more optimal load on the roadways.
 
You aren't being realistic.This is North America..people love their cars...its the goal of every 14 year old to save up for a car by working at McDonald's for a few years.
North American cities are built for cars..they are not going away any time soon..In fact I think Harper recently gave a bunch of money to Toyota. You are talking about decisions that require will require government decades to get their act together...and I a talking about cost effective solutions that are in the interest of companies to implement in a quick manner.
My debate and your debate--no comparison
I'm not offering a solution; I'm pointing out why your idea—tried and true over the past coupla decades—has not and will not solve anything. As you very persuasively made my case, the problem is the cars we all want and won't easily be persuaded to do without.

Oops, except car-sharing is the trend in the newly-populated downtown where people bought homes they could walk to work from. Gosh, whatta concept! only telecommuting and living in your workplace could get you closer. You are definitely right, we remade our societies so Car could be King, but that doesn't mean it will always be so. Until The Revolution however, there will never be enough roads for the cars. Your telecommuting proposal didn't involve you giving yours up did it?
 
9 to 5 is archaic and counter productive. Not everyone is a parent who has to balance their work day out with their children's school day.

There is no reason why you can't choose your eight hours of work (if you work that) between 7, 8 or 9am to 3, 4 or 5pm. In fact, I'm sure there are people who would prefer to work from 12noon to 8pm as well as people who would work from 6am to 2pm. This would make offices efficient from 6am to 8pm by staggering employees and hours. It would make it easier for traffic, shopping and scheduling.

The world is no longer in the 1950's where 9am to 5pm was the norm.
 
The simple fact of the matter is that unless you have an effective way to supervise people working at home then you're not going to be getting 8 hours work out of most people. Ask yourself, how many co-workers do you know who are dedicated, committed employees to their jobs? Whoever isn't (which is likely the majority) will take advantage of lack of supervision/accountability to work fewer hours and be less productive. That's why it's never really taken off as a concept. I know two really big companies that tried it and both got rid of it soon after for the very reasons I cite above. It's just too hard to supervise employees remotely.

Don't get me wrong, I think the concept of working remotely is a fabulous idea. I can unofficially do it in my job and I find it works really well. If I did a time study I'd probably find I'm working no more hours than normal, producing the same, but spending less time in transit or commuting (which is often my unpaid time). So I'm all for it. But I can tell you right now I wouldn't trust the vast majority of my co-workers to work an "honest" day's work if they were sitting at home.

If you have the technology that allows a supervisor to see what you're doing, how much you're doing, and for how long you're doing it, then it may be workable. But there was an article in the paper just the other day about a teleworker programmer who outsourced his own job to China by hiring a guy there for peanuts to do his job for him and he managed to get around all the security features (e.g., he shipped his login fob to the guy in China). Not surprisingly, he eventually got busted when the IT department got concerned about security when they found someone logging in every day from China.

Believe it or not, there's also liability issues with people working at home. You fall down your stairs during working hours and your company is on the hook for WSIB.

Great idea, hard to implement.
 
i wouldn't worry to much about what the old boy has to say planb, he is kinda negative about most things.
 
teleworking from home also has the plus of safety for emplyees, especially when the weather is bad. As long as you get your work done, teleworking should work for most office type jobs.
 
teleworking from home also has the plus of safety for emplyees, especially when the weather is bad. As long as you get your work done, teleworking should work for most office type jobs.

And SPs can just provide phone sex as well?
 
Don't get me wrong, I think the concept of working remotely is a fabulous idea. I can unofficially do it in my job and I find it works really well. If I did a time study I'd probably find I'm working no more hours than normal, producing the same, but spending less time in transit or commuting (which is often my unpaid time). So I'm all for it. But I can tell you right now I wouldn't trust the vast majority of my co-workers to work an "honest" day's work if they were sitting at home. Great idea, hard to implement.

Good and informative post.

I have consulted a number of firms over the years and aside from what Keebler Elf posted, the timing for telecommuting is not here - Yet.

Working from home will be easier to implement when the current group of workers and management have left the workplace. There are still a lot of senior managers who possess the "Old School" style of management and expect people to show up, on time and do their respective tasks and duties. A lack of trust is evident in that old school managers believe that if given the opportunity to work away from the office, people will slack off. Funny thing is, they turn a blind eye to the vast amount of "presenteeism" that goes on the workplace. We see presenteeism in the workplace every day - People chatting, taking extended breaks, surfing the net, etc.

When we shift our way of thinking from a "task based approach" to a "results based approach" of managing, it gives much more autonomy to the worker and ultimately the "Whens & Wheres" become less important than they are in today's workplace.

This does not mean that co-workers will rarely meet face-to-face, the need to congregate will still exist, but it will be in a more formal arrangement.

What I find interesting is how fast the typical office is becoming isolated* through technological advances. Meetings (large and small) are easily set up on-line with a simple link in an email - These meetings have video and share presentation software. Many "Face to Face" questions are addressed 100% electronically (request sent via email, information saved to a file, then sent back via email).

* By being isolated, I am referring to the fact that many workers can spend a day at work and address all questions/tasks etc without any inter-action with co-workers.

Ever evolving technology combined with a change in how we think and manage people will bring us to the reality of being able to work from home. Right now we are currently "telecommuting at the workplace". Progress will seem slow, but if you take a hard look at how much has changed over the last 20 years, you will be amazed.
 
I think you'll find employers far less enthusiastic about embracing telework than employees would like to believe (which is why 99 times out of 100 when you read about this topic it's from the view of the employee thinking how great it would be). At the end of the day it comes down to productivity. If you produce more, the employer will embrace it. If you produce less, the employer won't. And measuring productivity can be very difficult to do when your employees aren't in the workplace.

I'm not old school at all when it comes to work but I realize the fundamental problem of employees not performing a full day of work when they're sitting at home with all the allures of TV, video games, internet surfing, family, etc., etc., etc. And you're right that people slack off at work. But think how much MORE they will slack off when there's no manager around to observe them.

Where telework works and works well is for types of work that are easily measurable (e.g., piece meal type work where someone takes calls that you can count/track). It doesn't work so well for professions where output isn't as easy to quantify.
 
Telecommuting is already here, it's called OFF SHORING, where someone in India or China is now doing your job thus cutting down on the number of people driving or taking transit here!
 
You aren't being realistic.This is North America..people love their cars...its the goal of every 14 year old to save up for a car by working at McDonald's for a few years.
North American cities are built for cars..they are not going away any time soon..In fact I think Harper recently gave a bunch of money to Toyota. You are talking about decisions that require will require government decades to get their act together...and I a talking about cost effective solutions that are in the interest of companies to implement in a quick manner.
My debate and your debate--no comparison

Plan B, you have made a lot of good points. But debating with oldjones is somewhat pointless. He always seems to have the time to endure for the last word, and the tone of his engagement with you is less cordial than the spirit in which you have engaged him. Solving our transportation problems is multifaceted, and requires examination of every aspect. And that includes cars being here to stay. Anyone that says that teleworking has been around for a long time is therefore not the answer is right as a sole source solution. But that is not your proposal, which, if I understand, is part of an overall solution. Also, any comparison with teleworking from home from a few years ago to today is invalid. It has changed big time and the change continues.

I have been around the teleworking solution since it's inception. I work for one of the world's largest multinationals and I have seen a great deal of exponential acceleration in off site working. We have closed some satelite offices entirely. Some of the duties have been centralised, and people that need to work locally, sales, service etc now work out of home only. Some roles in our head office and distribution centres are 75% work from home. The employees do not have a workstation at head office. When they are in, they "hotel" at assigned areas. The employees like it a lot, and it saves the company office space and the associated overhead.

Our organisation is also taking other steps to combat commuting stress and do our part to relieve congestion. Consideration is given to employees that carpool. We have a formal program that recognises employees that contribute to this program. At a very large facility in the west end, employees that take transit are in a program that pays 75% of their monthly pass. As companies move towards optimising these programs, it is not only a question of making a contribution to traffic relief. Some small pressure could be taken off the transit systems. We also have programs where, if possible, folk can work from 6-2 or 10-6 if it gets them out of the worst of the rush hour.

I like a great deal of what ref had to say in post #18. I can only speak for my own organisation, but part of our culture is encouraging folk to work from home where possible. If trust in meeting objectives comes into play, it is a bigger issue than can the person be trusted to work from home. I am not sure that the age (older) factor is as big an issue any more. I have 83 folk rolling up to me in different departments and have evaluated evryone as a work from home candidate. And I am older than Methuselah. Ref made an interesting point about working in the office all day (electronically) and not coming face to face during interactions. I often have to tell some employees "go see the guy!". There has to be a balance. There are some things that I want to discuss face to face. Body language and voice inflection can sometimes tell me more than what is said, and there is no chance of picking up on this via email etc.

Good stuff from ref and Plan B.