Plastic bag ban

It's hard to tell through the dust the Ford clown show kicks up, but I believe the bag ban is still around, just been put on hold while the usual expert study and public consultations get done. If we actually had some brains in the Mayor's office, that sorta thing woulda happened way back, when the stupid idea of making everyone pay for free poo bags for some was floated.
 
It's hard to tell through the dust the Ford clown show kicks up, but I believe the bag ban is still around, just been put on hold while the usual expert study and public consultations get done. If we actually had some brains in the Mayor's office, that sorta thing woulda happened way back, when the stupid idea of making everyone pay for free poo bags for some was floated.

There were a number of studies presented to council that showed it did not make sense to ban plastic bags as most retailers would likely switch to paper which has been proven to be far more harmful to the environment but they chose to ignore them. It doesn't make sense to ban something that people need and use everyday. F'ing idiots.
 
It's hard to tell through the dust the Ford clown show kicks up, but I believe the bag ban is still around, just been put on hold while the usual expert study and public consultations get done. If we actually had some brains in the Mayor's office, that sorta thing woulda happened way back, when the stupid idea of making everyone pay for free poo bags for some was floated.

Wasn't that on Miller's watch?
 
The five cent fee was on Miller's watch. The proposed ban was on Ford's.

The 5 cent fee was was poorly thought out to begin with, as was banning them altogether. I mean seriously, banning something that you can go buy off the grocery store shelf. I mean what's wrong with being able to take your groceries home in plastic bags then reusing them for garbage and compost. If you have too many, put the extras in a bag and place them in the recycling bin. Seems pretty simple to me but some on city council would have you believe they know better.
 
The 5 cent fee was was poorly thought out to begin with, as was banning them altogether. I mean seriously, banning something that you can go buy off the grocery store shelf. I mean what's wrong with being able to take your groceries home in plastic bags then reusing them for garbage and compost. If you have too many, put the extras in a bag and place them in the recycling bin. Seems pretty simple to me but some on city council would have you believe they know better
Not to mention plastic bags arent the only non-biodegradable things we throw in the garbage every day. If you're gonna ban plastic bags on those grounds you have to start banning all plastic waste we throw out daily, things like wrappers, containers, plastic packaging......etc.....etc.

There's very little these days that doesnt contain some plastic to a degree, or other non-biodegradable materials. And much of that cannot be recycled
 
The 5 cent fee was was poorly thought out to begin with, as was banning them altogether. I mean seriously, banning something that you can go buy off the grocery store shelf. I mean what's wrong with being able to take your groceries home in plastic bags then reusing them for garbage and compost. If you have too many, put the extras in a bag and place them in the recycling bin. Seems pretty simple to me but some on city council would have you believe they know better.

The ban is stupid. The five cent fee I am ok with. The fee does make me think, "oh yeah I should bring a bag" but it is such a trivial sum that it does not make me put off my shopping if I haven't got one.

The bag ban will probably make me skip the store if I find myself passing by without a bag. That is a major inconvenience, where five cents is just a reminder.
 
Wasn't that on Miller's watch?
Nope. What happened on his watch was the original user-pay law. Want a bag, buy it; no more pretence that they're free.
 
Not to mention plastic bags arent the only non-biodegradable things we throw in the garbage every day. If you're gonna ban plastic bags on those grounds you have to start banning all plastic waste we throw out daily, things like wrappers, containers, plastic packaging......etc.....etc.

There's very little these days that doesnt contain some plastic to a degree, or other non-biodegradable materials. And much of that cannot be recycled
The trouble with the 'free' bags for all, was how many of them never even made it into the trash, but just blew around until they washed into the watershed, or stuck in a bush, fence or hydro-wire.

Everything can be recycled and/or reused (but why bother even taking that 'free' bag home to re-use after you eat the bananas you bought?) whether the economics of a given city's waste operation make it feasible or not at any given time. But since we all pay to landfill the stuff, the more we recover by recycling, and by reducing waste, the more we have to spend. And maybe we can even find a better use for our nickels. Let those who 'need' poo bags buy their own.

Really want to 'save'? Downsize your grey bin, and see it on your next utility bill.
 
The trouble with the 'free' bags for all, was how many of them never even made it into the trash, but just blew around until they washed into the watershed, or stuck in a bush, fence or hydro-wire
You wanna completely ban bags because a few of them get stuck in some bushes or on some fences??! Are you a retard?! (wait, dont answer that)

What if we switch to paper bags and they too get stuck on a few fences?? Are you then in favor of banning them too??! Lets just ban all packaging then, because plastic bags aren't the only trash that gets stuck on fences or in bushes
 
You wanna completely ban bags because a few of them get stuck in some bushes or on some fences??! Are you a retard?! (wait, dont answer that)

What if we switch to paper bags and they too get stuck on a few fences?? Are you then in favor of banning them too??! Lets just ban all packaging then, because plastic bags aren't the only trash that gets stuck on fences or in bushes

Patience and understanding are two of 'oldjones' many virtuous qualities,
 
The ban is stupid. The five cent fee I am ok with.

I'd be okay with 10 cents a bag but I'd like to see it go to something other than the retailer's pocket. Some like Shopper's say they donate the 5 cents to charity, but really, don't they just claim that as a tax right off?
 
.......Some like Shopper's say they donate the 5 cents to charity, but really, don't they just claim that as a tax right off?

they collect the 5 cents for the bag from the customers, they get the tax receipt for the donation which the customers actually donated .
same as when Canadian Tire , Shoppers or other retailers ask for a donation to xyz charity @ the cash register, the corporation gets the tax receipt.
 
I'd be okay with 10 cents a bag but I'd like to see it go to something other than the retailer's pocket. Some like Shopper's say they donate the 5 cents to charity, but really, don't they just claim that as a tax right off?

Yeah, it would be better if it was a tax.
 
You wanna completely ban bags because a few of them get stuck in some bushes or on some fences??! Are you a retard?! (wait, dont answer that)

What if we switch to paper bags and they too get stuck on a few fences?? Are you then in favor of banning them too??! Lets just ban all packaging then, because plastic bags aren't the only trash that gets stuck on fences or in bushes
No. Never said so. I simply want people to pay for the bags they want, and not be forced to subsidize 'free' bags that ignoramuses treat as throwaways. A very right-wing conservative view: User-Pay I call it. Socialist like you, who want a bag-tax hidden in every price to pay for your poo bags wouldn't understand.

Paper bags rapidly return to wood pulp if treated treated the same way, and are just go back to nature. As for banning all packaging—most of which is just advertising, aimed at hogging shelf space and only inconveniences me—it's a place to start, but again, that's your looney idea. I'd be content with a bit more regulation of materials, and shortening the disposal chain, so packagers had a more direct stake in reducing the cost of getting rid of their crap, and I didn't have to buy special tools just to get at the product I bought. Requiring retailers to accept the discarded packaging, as an example.

If you've bought goods packaged for Europe, you can see how that approach has minimized the waste. Going back to your earlier post about all the non-recyclable plastics that haver defeated you; my newspapers have carried City ads for sometime, telling us about their continuing expansion of the list of recyclable plastics, latest this morning. You should revise that thinking too.
 
At one point TNT provided bags that would break down after some time , but since Loblaws bought them up you have to pay for the bag.
 
i don't think grocery stores should be permitted within the city. think of the waste that goes to the dump in uneaten food, packaging (get a four litre bag of milk- four bags right there), and store coupons/flyers.

just keep all such places outside of toronto.
 
I simply want people to pay for the bags they want, and not be forced to subsidize 'free' bags that ignoramuses treat as throwaways. A very right-wing conservative view: User-Pay I call it
I never disagreed with that stance though :confused:

Socialist like you
Socialists like me??!! LOL, I think you got the wrong person :biggrin1:

Paper bags rapidly return to wood pulp if treated treated the same way, and are just go back to nature. As for banning all packaging—most of which is just advertising, aimed at hogging shelf space and only inconveniences me—it's a place to start, but again, that's your looney idea. I'd be content with a bit more regulation of materials, and shortening the disposal chain, so packagers had a more direct stake in reducing the cost of getting rid of their crap, and I didn't have to buy special tools just to get at the product I bought. Requiring retailers to accept the discarded packaging, as an example
I think the best solution is to have all plastic bags and packaging made from biodegradable material. Even if that will cost quite a bit more

Going back to your earlier post about all the non-recyclable plastics that haver defeated you
Wut??!!! :confused:

my newspapers have carried City ads for sometime, telling us about their continuing expansion of the list of recyclable plastics, latest this morning
Cool story bro
 
I never disagreed with that stance though :confused:


Socialists like me??!! LOL, I think you got the wrong person :biggrin1:


I think the best solution is to have all plastic bags and packaging made from biodegradable material. Even if that will cost quite a bit more


Wut??!!! :confused:


Cool story bro
You just assumed, without evidence, that I favoured banning plastic bags, as I took your rant about plastics on post #66, and bags being less harmful than most to be advocating 'free' bags for all, paid for by an unavoidable tax on all. Nothing could be more socialist, or encourage more irresponsible use and disposal. The city and others in the recycling game actually make a fair buck from it. making bags biodegrade means they cannot be recycled, and would cut thet revenue stream just to cater to those godless commie free-riders who pollute the world with the bags you and I bought for them.

But for a mere 5¢ a bag, they learned sense. And fopr a few months Toronto was noticeably tidier. Until Rob decide to fix things, and bring back 'free' bags, 'cause there was just nothing more important for his Council to do.

Just for fun, here's a little human-nature quirks that vaguely relates: Lots of dog walkers pass up and down my street, and they all stoop and scoop and use a mix of re-purposed and store-bought baggs. But some only carry their bag as far as the nearest bush or lamposts and drop it. Always in a bought bag. Thoughts?
 
Paper bags rapidly return to wood pulp if treated treated the same way, and are just go back to nature.

Here's where you're wrong. Nothing, and I mean nothing decomposes in a landfill site as once you bury the crap there's no oxygen and therefore nothing decomposes.

The ban was to eliminate the plastic bags retailer's handed out. If they were forced to eliminate these, they would have to find an alternative to satisfy their customer's who at the last minute decided to pop in to purchase something but didn't have a reusable bag with them at the time. You can bet their their choice would be paper, because it doesn't harm the planet like evil plastic.

Two things wrong with this. First, paper is much more harmful to the environment. Secondly, it's typically only used once and takes up significantly more space than plastic in landfill sites. Remember, nothing decomposes in landfill sites as there's no oxygen for decomposition.

The other thing is that they were only going to ban the plastic bags at the check out. The ones you stuff your fruit and veggies into would still be available. I'd imagine if there was a ban, a lot of people would simply put groceries into those bags which never get used more than once, unlike the carry out bags which get reused as garbage bags.

This is why I had to shake my head when the LCBO switched to handing out heavy bottles in plastic bags to paper ones. :confused:

Where do brown paper bags come from?

Paper comes from trees -- lots and lots of trees. The logging industry, influenced by companies like Weyerhaeuser and Kimberly-Clark, is huge, and the process to get that paper bag to the grocery store is long, sordid and exacts a heavy toll on the planet.

First, the trees are found, marked and felled in a process that all too often involves clear-cutting, resulting in massive habitat destruction and long-term ecological damage. Mega-machinery comes in to remove the logs from what used to be forest, either by logging trucks or even helicopters in more remote areas. This machinery requires fossil fuel to operate and roads to drive on, and, when done unsustainably, logging even a small area has a large impact on the entire ecological chain in surrounding areas.

Once the trees are collected, they must dry at least three years before they can be used. More machinery is used to strip the bark, which is then chipped into one-inch squares and cooked under tremendous heat and pressure. This wood stew is then "digested," with a chemical mixture of limestone and acid, and after several hours of cooking, what was once wood becomes pulp. It takes approximately three tons of wood chips to make one ton of pulp.

The pulp is then washed and bleached; both stages require thousands of gallons of clean water. Coloring is added to more water, and is then combined in a ratio of 1 part pulp to 400 parts water, to make paper. The pulp/water mixture is dumped into a web of bronze wires, and the water showers through, leaving the pulp, which, in turn, is rolled into paper.

Whew! And that's just to make the paper; don't forget about the energy inputs -- chemical, electrical, and fossil fuel-based -- used to transport the raw material, turn the paper into a bag and then transport the finished paper.

Yeah, paper bags, so much better than plastic!