Torrent downloading, is it on its way out in canada?

hungry

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2005
1,532
99
48
I heard some talk of this on the 640 radio today. Some Montreal firm already has a list of thousands of people who download movies, etc. Then some talk how they can be fined 5k for doing so. Also, if you are downloading a lot, your ISP will block you from entering a site until you call them and explain yourself. Then on another thread I saw a link by Rubmeister100 this link

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/business/?ref=topbar

Sounds like Bill C11 got passed, and the future of downloading has changed. Anyone have any updates?
 
i think what the news says and what the reality are, are 2 different things.
 
I don't download.I stream..ta -da . Seriously though.The sites I use have Advertising from the big 3 car companies and just about every brand name product you can think of.If these sites did not have advertisers, they would not be around.
 
I don't download.I stream..ta -da . Seriously though.The sites I use have Advertising from the big 3 car companies and just about every brand name product you can think of.If these sites did not have advertisers, they would not be around.

That's hilarious.

Do you think that speeding is legal because you can still read the ads on the side of the road?

Just because a site may have a secondary revenue source doesn't mean that what they do is legal. Most ads are served through brokers, and most companies have no idea whether a particular site showing their ad is legit or not.

And there is no distinction in law between streaming and "downloading". Both are receiving a copy of some material. The law doesn't care if you keep it for milliseconds or years: it's either legal or illegal.
 
I stream a lot too. Your ISP knows what you are doing by the amount of bandwith you consume, so streaming and downloading are the same. The scary part, is this Montreal company supposedly has already amassed a list of a few thousand names of people who download. Is there no privacy anymore? I have to agree, if everyone does it, they can't go after all the people.
 
I have to agree, if everyone does it, they can't go after all the people.

You are correct, they can't go after everyone. Of course, if YOU are the one that they go after you are well and truly fucked.

Just like speeders, enforcement officials know that for every speeder they catch, they miss out on 100 more. Basically it's a numbers game. I suspect that in order to prioritize they will go after the biggest offenders first, if for no other reason than it will probably be easier to find evidence and prove in court.
 
That's hilarious.

Do you think that speeding is legal because you can still read the ads on the side of the road?

Just because a site may have a secondary revenue source doesn't mean that what they do is legal. Most ads are served through brokers, and most companies have no idea whether a particular site showing their ad is legit or not.

And there is no distinction in law between streaming and "downloading". Both are receiving a copy of some material. The law doesn't care if you keep it for milliseconds or years: it's either legal or illegal.

My point was.....if i'm hauled into court over it you can be sure my lawyer would be asking why a rep for Toyota is not standing there next to me.Them being the worst offender by actually making a profit off the site far exceeding anything I am doing.Get the companies who advertise involved.THEN watch the fireworks fly.They will go after individuals who do not want to spend thousands on legal fees....and ONLY them.I would make sure that did not happen.As to the quote above, i'm sure ignorance of the law works for multinational corporations also.
 
I stream a lot too. Your ISP knows what you are doing by the amount of bandwith you consume, so streaming and downloading are the same. The scary part, is this Montreal company supposedly has already amassed a list of a few thousand names of people who download. Is there no privacy anymore? I have to agree, if everyone does it, they can't go after all the people.

Apparently it over a million names.

Is it easy to hide your ISP?
 
Nibs and Woody, what are you doing?

We need to keep the dummies in the dark, so they get pinched and not us. Sheesh. :(
 
LOL!!!
Fear not djk, doubt they will be able to use them tools.......:biggrin1:
 
What's scary is how this Montreal firm gathered info even before the bill was passed. LoL.
And the funny thing is...they can't shut down the uploaders (being Piratebay as the biggest of 'em all)so they play the other field. LoL again.