RSP contribution

Itsamansworld

Member
Mar 10, 2004
173
0
16
Toronto
My accountant has advised me to invest 250k into an rsp account for tax resons that I do not have to go into, my question is for anyone who has knowledge in this area.

At this time I have my bank after the investment as well as a private financial advisor, the bank is telling me they are the way to go and the private guy has had some of my investments and made an average of 7 1/2% over the years.

So if you can help stear me in one direction or questions to fire back at either party I would appreciate it.

Thanks
 
Your bank and your private guy are likely both full of shit. They are good at making money for themselves but not necessarily for their customers. Many RSP's are market investments and that is extremely volitile with slow growth predicted for a few years and perhaps worse depending on the fiscal cliff resolution in the US.

Have a look ar RSP's that contain a variety of assets including real estate etc and make sure you are not over exposed in one area. You will likely have to do your research but don't take either your bank or private guy at their word.
 
When your bank / financial advisor tells you what's good for you, it's usually what's good for them too...you / them...25% / 75% split. I put my investment where I felt it would gain...if it fails it's on me. I hate it when someone loses or uses your money for you.
 
Make them compete for your business. What can the bank offer that will out-perform your private guy?

Also, those investments which attract a higher rate of tax (interest, non-dividend or non-capital gain income) generally are held within an RRSP for the greater tax-sheltering and compound growth.
 
No one cares about your money like you do. For tax sheltered RRSP investments and investors that want a consistent return without a lot of ups and downs (mostly downs these days) I usually recommend a bond ladder strategy. Oh sure, yields are at an all time low but really they aren't when we throw in some junk, corporate and foreign bonds in the mix. You can now find some ETFs that will manage this for you at a far lower MER than the mutual fund guys (like big banks). Even if the ETF does go up and down a bit it isn't long before you realize that the position is still in the green (even if red today) given that it keeps throwing dividends at you and I wouldn't go with a single ETF, how about a mixture of fixed income, super safe investments from several different sources? I over did it with Turkish bonds once (too many eggs in one basket) but I was getting 11 7/8 and it turns out the government of Turkey didn't default so I was fine.
 
You have a track record with your private Fin advisor - do you have a similar record with the bank (not that past performance is a reflection of future potential)...7 /12 % return over x years would be pretty good (depending on the number of x) - especially if less than 10 or so - The S&P 500 10 year return is 6.7 percent, for example
 
Would he get a tax deduction for the full $250,000?

An RRSP deduction is NOT a tax deduction but an income deduction to arrive at taxable income (technically-speaking).

The answer is yes, if his cumulative unused deductions amount to that and that his current taxable income is high enough to absorb such a huge deduction, but I would only use what's necessary to lower the income below the highest tax bracket if he doesn't need all of his previously remitted or withheld taxes refunded.
 
Don't forget that you pay tax on anything you withdraw from an RRSP.
 
Don't forget that you pay tax on anything you withdraw from an RRSP.

Someone mentioned making these guys bid for work. The first thing I'd do is get them to explain how they intend to make the most of sheltering the money as pre-tax $ within a complete financial plan. If these guys are not willing to help you paint a complete picture that is in your interest, learn to manage the money yourself.
 
As mentioned, he is going to need to have income this year of at least the $250K or else he'll run into issues with overcontributions and then tax penalties. Depending on income levels, you may be much better off staggering the contribution over a few years time.