US/Israel considering joint surgical strike on Iran

Thanks for conceding, I guess you have had your ass kicked enough.

It would be a mistake on your part to confuse concession with condescension.
I've had enough of my time being wasted by a blowhard prone to fantasy. That's condescension.
 
Slither some more. Your arguments have become increasingly ludicrous. After conceding that they declined a truce offering equality and citizenship, you were ridiculously trying to say Haganah didn't have the ability to implement the deal , when history shows it's a fact that they did.
 
Slither some more. Your arguments have become increasingly ludicrous. After conceding that they declined a truce offering equality and citizenship, you were ridiculously trying to say Haganah didn't have the ability to implement the deal , when history shows it's a fact that they did.

They weren't negotiating with Haganah, it was the Carmeli brigade, the ones with 'shoot to kill' orders.
From your favourite book excerpt:
The principle representative of the Jewish side was not Levy but "Motki" Maklef, operations officer of the Carmeli Brigade.

Before discussing evacuation plans, the delegation registered its strong protests at the continuing acts of gratuitous violence against the departing Arabs by the Carmeli Brigaed and the Stern and Irgun (which the Haganah had allowed to participate in Bi'ur Hamatz): the shooting of unarmed civilians, firing on ambulances and paramedics, stealing of cars, breaking into homes and the wholesale looting of their contents, the arrest of a large number of civilians whose fate remained unknown, and the prevention of people from entering their homes.
 
Not according that new US report, ....

I guess that means you realize your arguments about the past are just failed blather.

I'm sure in groggy world, in 1948 the Arabs were sitting peacefully in their homes when the evil Jews came and killed them and there were not numerous unprovoked Arab attacks on Jewish settlements for 30+ years before the partition with a massive uptick as the British began withdrawal.

Of course serious historians are clear that there weren't offensive Jewish operations for the first 4 months of the civil war in 1948 but many Arab attacks.
 
They weren't negotiating with Haganah, it was the Carmeli brigade, the ones with 'shoot to kill' orders.
From your favourite book excerpt:

Can you find that shoot to kill cited anywhere other than by Khalidi? I can't. It isn't in the original text sourced in that article. I did spent some time trying to find other source for it--but everywhere I can find it quoted, it's being quoted from Khalidi.

In any case, you seem to be confused. Carmeli Brigade is part of Haganah, which was the military arm of the Jewish Agency, which under the partition plan was set to become the State of Israel--and did. So certainly Haganah spoke with authority on behalf of the Jewish Agency and therefore on behalf of the future Israel government.
 
Which terrorist group has Canada sponsored?

Flag 1. Canada has supported United States of America in ww2. at which it ended in 2 nuclear bombing of Japanese city.

Flag 2. Canada has supported United States of America in "war on terror" which resulted in 1 million + men, woman + children. Bombings city's and villages caused displacement of millions. Iraqis view USA the real terriosts and Canada is supporting.
 
Flag 1. Canada has supported United States of America in ww2. at which it ended in 2 nuclear bombing of Japanese city.

If you review my posting history, you will find that I have been incredibly critical of that bombing attack, and asserted that the perpetrators of it ought to have been prosecuted. They're all dead of old age now, so that won't happen, but it would be good if one day the US could issue an apology for it. I find that nuclear attack to be HIGHLY problematic, because there is considerable evidence that the Americans in fact knew that the Japanese were on the verge of surrender, and that in reality it was the entry of the Soviet Union into the Pacific War that precipitated the surrender, and not the bombing itself, which is the traditional highschool narrative.

In any case, that's an event so far back in history that I can't really see it as all too relevant, and it would not be terrorism anyway--that would be a war crime, if the allegations prove true.

You can find direct cases of Canadian forces committing war crimes in WW2 as well. The Princess Patricia's appear to have summarily executed some prisoners under their control, in one case, for example. In general, when you have a war as big as WW2, you are bound to find some instances of violations of the Geneva Conventions on all sides. The nuclear attack on Japan probably deserves its own thread (in fact, has had several, on which I posted extensively, if you go find them.)

Flag 2. Canada has supported United States of America in "war on terror" which resulted in 1 million + men, woman + children. Bombings city's and villages caused displacement of millions. Iraqis view USA the real terriosts and Canada is supporting.

Too vague. Pick some more specific examples. I might agree with you in some cases, and I will disagree with you on others. The US has an absolute, undeniable right to defend itself from terror attacks. The justification for the initial sanctions on Iraq, and for the invasion of Afghanistan, are crystal clear, cut and dried. The conduct of the war in both places left something to be desired. The ultimate invasion of Iraq appears to have been the result of negligence--I don't buy into the conspiracy theory versions that the US always knew there were no WMD's. I think in reality that they convinced themselves they were there, despite not really having enough evidence--so there is some sort of negligence there.

None of this makes Canada a state sponsor of terror.
 
None of this makes Canada a state sponsor of terror.

Is a matter of opinion. Maybe you should try to convince Iraqis that Canada's roll in support of America's war was for a good cause. I doubt you'll be successful
 
Is a matter of opinion. Maybe you should try to convince Iraqis that Canada's roll in support of America's war was for a good cause. I doubt you'll be successful

First of all, what role did Canada play in the Iraq war? I recall our government making a vocal point of sitting that one out.

Secondly, even if we look just at the US, and even if you conclude that the US made a mistake in invading Iraq, that doesn't make them a sponsor of terror!
 
First of all, what role did Canada play in the Iraq war? I recall our government making a vocal point of sitting that one out.

Secondly, even if we look just at the US, and even if you conclude that the US made a mistake in invading Iraq, that doesn't make them a sponsor of terror!

1st of all what part did Iran played when Hezbollah caused havoc?

2nd even if Hezbollah accidentally kill civilians because they ran to bullet which caused their death. Does not make them terroists
 
In any case, you seem to be confused. Carmeli Brigade is part of Haganah, which was the military arm of the Jewish Agency, which under the partition plan was set to become the State of Israel--and did. So certainly Haganah spoke with authority on behalf of the Jewish Agency and therefore on behalf of the future Israel government.

You are making things up again.
'so certainly'
That statement is based on wishful thinking, not fact.

Lets just accept the work of your research as what it is, accurate reporting.
 
1st of all what part did Iran played when Hezbollah caused havoc?

There's the obvious part of providing weapons, military 'advisers' (like they are doing in Syria), and money as well as the less clear discussions of how much influence Iran has on Hezbollah's decision making.

2nd even if Hezbollah accidentally kill civilians because they ran to bullet which caused their death. Does not make them terroists

WTF is this supposed to mean?
 
You are making things up again.
'so certainly'
That statement is based on wishful thinking, not fact.

Lets just accept the work of your research as what it is, accurate reporting.
Bull. Looking at wikipedia for sake of ease,

As the end of the British Mandate of Palestine was fast approaching, the leadership of the Haganah drafted Plan Dalet for its subsequent organization and operations. The plan divided the fighting militia (Field Corps) into six regional brigades – Levanoni in the north, Alexandroni in the Sharon region, Kiryati in the Tel Aviv area, Givati in the Shephelah, and Etzioni in the Jerusalem area. On February 28, 1948, the Levanoni Brigade was split into two—Carmeli in the northwest, and Golani in the northeast.[2]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golani_Brigade#Founding_and_initial_organization

As usual with grog, facts don't count, just attempts to bash Israel.
 
There's the obvious part of providing weapons, military 'advisers' (like they are doing in Syria), and money as well as the less clear discussions of how much influence Iran has on Hezbollah's decision making.

That still doesn't mean you have hard evidence Hezbollah is directly under Iran's control.
 
1st of all what part did Iran played when Hezbollah caused havoc?

Iran provided the funding, the training, the weapons, and in some specific cases, explicitly, the targets (e.g., Rushdie). Note that Iran continued to supply these things even after Hezbollah carried out various terrorist attacks--Iran did not cut off the money, weapons, or training when it was very obvious that Hezbollah was engaging in terrorism, war crime, and acts of war. Moreover, Iran did all these belligerent things in the context of genocidal threats against Israel uttered by the Iranian leadership, a leadership that helped found Hezbollah, the Supreme Leader of which Hezbollah refers to as its "chief".

2nd even if Hezbollah accidentally kill civilians because they ran to bullet which caused their death. Does not make them terroists

Absolutely. If Hezbollah accidentally killed civilians that would not be terrorism. If Hezbollah were aiming weapons at an Israeli military target, and it went awry and killed some civilians, that too would not be terrorism. However, we know that Hezbollah intentionally targets Israeli civilians (and others--like Rushdie) because Hezbollah say that they do, and because many of their actual attacks are very obviously targeted at Israeli towns that have no military presence.
 
You are making things up again.
'so certainly'
That statement is based on wishful thinking, not fact.

Be clear on what it is that you are disputing, so that I can very clearly kick your ass. Here are the facts that you could be disputing, tell me which one you don't believe, and get ready for an ass kicking:

-- The Carmeli Brigade was a Haganah division
-- Haganah was the military arm of the Jewish Agency
-- The Jewish Agency was set to form the Israel Government under the UN Parition Plan
-- The UN Partition Plan had by then been ratified by the UN, with 2/3rds of nations in the world voting in favour

In fact Haganah, the Jewish Agency, and the Israeli Government were all led by the same single individual: Ben-Gurion. Ready to get your ass kicked? What do you dispute here?