US/Israel considering joint surgical strike on Iran

Nope. I never agree on using nuclear weapons on civilians.

I think if NATO were to strike Iran on fear of development of a nuclear weapon is wrong. I believe it will escalate its tension to the brink of war. And if in fact NATO were to invade Iran like they did with Iraq, I would agree on Iran to retaliate on using nuke as a defensive measure.

So you would support Iranian nuclear attacks on our civilians, contradicting your first sentence.
 
This what I meant. If we invade Iran "first" then yes.

So, yes, you support attacks on Western civilian targets by Iran .

We differ. I don't support attacks on civilian targets under any circumstance and view you as a moral bankrupt who condones atrocity and war crime.
 
So, yes, you support attacks on Western civilian targets by Iran .

We differ. I don't support attacks on civilian targets under any circumstance and view you as a moral bankrupt who condones atrocity and war crime.

In all out war between nations I do not believe western civilization are above Iranian civilization.

Would you agree?
 
So, yes, you support attacks on Western civilian targets by Iran .

We differ. I don't support attacks on civilian targets under any circumstance and view you as a moral bankrupt who condones atrocity and war crime.

Actually, you do, as long as the US and Israel state that they do not do it on purpose.
 
Further more I would like to state that in defense of its people and country Iran should whatever it takes to stop invading forces
 
I don't support strikes either. Severe sanctions are as far as I'm comfortable with. Unlike grog though, I think that Iran has absolutely no right to nuclear weapons and I won't come up with BS justifications
But what are we gonna do if Iran thumbs its nose at sanctions, and winds up getting nukes anyways??
 
But what are we gonna do if Iran thumbs its nose at sanctions, and winds up getting nukes anyways??

The reality is that this is what is going to happen, unless a negotiated settlement is reached, or a regional war is fought.
 
Actually, you do, as long as the US and Israel state that they do not do it on purpose.

I think you failed to comprehend what I wrote: "I don't support attacks on civilian targets under any circumstance"

The word "targets" is crucial there. There is a big difference between targeting civilians, and killing civilians incidental to an attack on a military target.
 
Further more I would like to state that in defense of its people and country Iran should whatever it takes to stop invading forces

In particular, you would consider attacks on civilians legitimate "in defense of its people and country".

In short, you wholesale advocate in favor of war crime and atrocity. You and al Assad in Syria would get on famously, you have the same sick view of the legitimacy of attacking civilians.
 
The reality is that this is what is going to happen, unless a negotiated settlement is reached, or a regional war is fought.

This is true. That is why all military action must focus on the regime itself. Until the regime is persuaded to agree to terms, they will inevitably develop nuclear weapons. The next step is to move from sanctions implemented on an honour sytem, to sanctions enforced by a military blockade.
 

It looks like this story might be false...fingers are pointing to the story being planted by Israel's US ambassador.

"What happened? I've been told that military officers in the US and Israel privately denied the report: the U.S. military not only opposes Israeli military action but sees the possibility of a joint strike as remote at best.

This led to speculation that Rothkopf's piece had been planted by the Israeli embassy.

That's when the other shoe dropped. I'm told that the piece sparked a major confrontation between Oren and Baruch Bina, Israel’s number two man in Washington, with Bina arguing that it was inappropriate of the ambassador to feed such a line to Rothkopf, because it could only damage U.S.-Israeli relations."

http://mondoweiss.net/2012/10/did-f...y-ambassadors-reassignment-to-copenhagen.html
 
I disagree completely. You are one of those idiots who think terrorist regimes, dictatorships, and all manner of tyranny should be treated as if equal to democracy. Like Israel, whose leader's campaign fund is funded mostly by foreign contributions? Does that sound democratic to you?




Sorry but you are wrong. Neither the US nor Israel is in violation of any binding UN resolution. It's a fact. You get to have an idiotic, anti democratic opinion, but you don't get to make up your own facts.
What did you have stuck in your ears all the times the Americans have slagged the U.N. over the years?




And when they give nukes to terrorists believing it won't be traced back to them ?
And what is to stop them from simply purchasing some from other sources ( Russian or Pakistani black market) and doing the same thing?
????
 
We should do a poll on who thinks its a good idea to send Iran an airmail message, and who doesnt think its a good idea
 
Wigglee: "Like Israel, whose leader's campaign fund is funded mostly by foreign contributions? Does that sound democratic to you?"

It's absolutely democratic. Even holding a primary election at all is not essential to democracy. So long as come election day voters have a free and fair choice between the parties and candidates who are running, you have a democratic system. The minor differences between democracies are just fine tuning issues. Do democratic primaries matter? Is a presidential system better or worse than a parliamentary one? Is proportional representation better or first past the post? I have preferences on these matters, but fundamentally they are all democratic. The key is free and fair elections.

Any other civics lessons I can help you with?

Wigglee: "What did you have stuck in your ears all the times the Americans have slagged the U.N. over the years?"

I have no idea what you are talking about, so I'll just re-iterate the fact--a fact that seems to be so in conflict with your ideology, that you should probably question your ideology: Neither Israel nor the United States is in violation of any binding UN resolution.

Wigglee: "And what is to stop them [terrorists] from simply purchasing some from other sources ( Russian or Pakistani black market) and doing the same thing?"

Russia is not a state sponsor of terror. It's certainly an undemocratic nation with some very questionable policies and some severe internal human rights problems--say, in Chechnya--but it is not a state sponsor of terror.

Pakistan is indeed a very big worry and we really ought to be working as hard as possible to persuade Pakistan to disarm. India, too, should probably disarm just as a means of persuading the Pakistanis of doing so. While Pakistan is not currently listed anywhere as a state sponsor of terror it does indeed have very worrying connections to terror organizations. If the Haqqani Network is declared a terror organization, which it probably should be, that's going to be troubling.

Certainly the last thing we need is to compound the problem by having ANOTHER dodgy nation, like Iran, with nuclear weapons. In fact, the mistake of letting Pakistan have nuclear weapons is directly related to our problems in Iran--Pakistan itself was instrumental in providing nuclear technology to Iran, and to several other troubling states as well.
 
In particular, you would consider attacks on civilians legitimate "in defense of its people and country".

In short, you wholesale advocate in favor of war crime and atrocity. You and al Assad in Syria would get on famously, you have the same sick view of the legitimacy of attacking civilians.

HAHAHAHAHA. You actually think moral reason is on top of the piority list when it comes to war?! You think the United States marine corps don't target civilian at all when they invade Iraq?

I have to think for my own countrymen 1st before I think about anyone else
 
Yes, I think that moral reason is at the top of the priority list, as a guiding principle behind the international law on the matter, and certainly should be right up there at or near #1 in determining how we, the voting citizens of a democratic nation, evaluate these sorts of situations. No, I do not believe that US marines targeted civilians when they invaded Iraq.

You need to give your head a shake, your moral compass is pointing in the wrong direction. You've abandoned some of the most important moral principles that we have to guide us through difficult things like war--principles like, targeting civilians is wrong, terrorism is wrong, war crimes are wrong, atrocity is wrong.
 
Yes, I think that moral reason is at the top of the priority list, as a guiding principle behind the international law on the matter, and certainly should be right up there at or near #1 in determining how we, the voting citizens of a democratic nation, evaluate these sorts of situations. No, I do not believe that US marines targeted civilians when they invaded Iraq.

You need to give your head a shake, your moral compass is pointing in the wrong direction. You've abandoned some of the most important moral principles that we have to guide us through difficult things like war--principles like, targeting civilians is wrong, terrorism is wrong, war crimes are wrong, atrocity is wrong.

Like I said you have misunderstood my position once again. It is not that i don't believe in moral reasons. You have to understand that I do not wish for war but it you force me to jump off a cliff I rather throw you off instead of me. Hence I said that "IF" it is necessary to defend my "OWN countrymen" I would use desperate measures to make sure the survival of my own men.