US/Israel considering joint surgical strike on Iran

Moreover, you obviously don't give a shit about the UN or its resolutions, or anything else. It's very obvious now that the extent to which you ever cited anything connected to the UN before, it was just self-serving hate. You don't really believe that any part of the UN has any credibility. You just like any source that is critical of Israel--random blogs, postings on internet forums, fake tribunals, UNHRC reports--it's all good with you so long as it's critical of Israel. You also hate any source that is critical of your terrorist buddies in Iran and Syria.

You really should cut down on your caffeine, Geller, its sounding a bit like you're getting blue in the face. Try to mellow it out a bit, take a breath, realize that we are in Canada and we hopefully will have no part in stupid, pointless and criminal wars in the middle east.

I approve of the UN and the legal system. Its not perfect but its the best we've got. So if Iran has a legitimate beef with the UN SC resolutions they should be able to take those into negotiation or into court. All real courts allow appeals, now don't they? And in the meantime while the trial goes on you have to go with the 'innocent until proven guilty' bit. And its pretty easy with Iran. They haven't started a war in hundreds of years, haven't been building a bomb, are allowing IAEA inspections to continue and are contesting UN SC resolutions through the proper channels, negotiations. That sounds like the system is working ok there, its only when you consider the countries that aren't part of the NPT when you realize its not all working yet.
 
Iran has no "legitimate beef ", it has been ordered to stop enriching uranium and it blatantly continues to do so.

And the here you are saying it should be able to pick and choose what resolutions it adheres to?

Should every murderous nation be able to defy the UN by claiming bogus grievances???
 
I'm torn between 2 beliefs:

1. Let Iran have their couple of nukes. Its not like they would likely ever use them. Any country which uses nukes will be turned into a glass parking lot by the superpowers (Russia, US and EU).

2. If you let Iran have nukes, then every other middle-east country will want one. Pretty soon we'll have dozens more countries with nukes, is that what we really want?? Especially with so many crazy religious fanatics.

Problem is, if US/Israel strike Iran to try and knock out their facilities, they risk starting WW3.

Is it worth it??!
 
You support Iran developing a nuclear weapon??????

yes...every sovereign nation should have that right. No one stopped the U.S. or Israel or China from developing them so why the double standard? And please stop using U.N. declarations as gospel. The U.N. is a manipulated political arena and all countries (especially the U.S. and Israel) have mocked and ignored the U.N. in the past. The fact is, if Iran tries to launch a nuke , they will be immediately be obliterated from the face of the earth...within minutes....and they know it.
 
So you'd be okay with every single country in the world having nukes??

It would be better for the middle east (and the world) to be nuke free zones.
But the middle east will never be nuke free unless Israel got rid of theirs, and that won't happen.
Without it, and with the continual threats of war from Israel, its only a matter of time until every country in the region sees them as a necessary evil to stop invasions.
 
You want a fair fight between the world's democracies, and nasty dictatorships? I would rather have an unfair fight, in our favour. Are you cheering for Iran to nuke Toronto? Or only our allies?

If, it means stopping Iran from having nuclear bomb means to invade, I would vote against. If Harper helps NATO invade Iran and we get nuked here in Toronto, I would blame Harper. If Iran is in all out war with NATO then yes nuke em.
 
It would be better for the middle east (and the world) to be nuke free zones.
But the middle east will never be nuke free unless Israel got rid of theirs, and that won't happen.
Without it, and with the continual threats of war from Israel, its only a matter of time until every country in the region sees them as a necessary evil to stop invasions
Okay, but you didnt answer my question.

At what point do you guys start to get uncomfortable with countries around the world acquiring nukes?? 20 countries?? 50?? 100??? 200??
 
Okay, but you didnt answer my question.

At what point do you guys start to get uncomfortable with countries around the world acquiring nukes?? 20 countries?? 50?? 100??? 200??

I believe goggy has answered UR question alrdy I also think you misunderstood hm
 
Okay, but you didnt answer my question.

At what point do you guys start to get uncomfortable with countries around the world acquiring nukes?? 20 countries?? 50?? 100??? 200??

At this point the cat's out of the bag. Once Sweet Daddy Dubya proclaimed his Axis of Evil and North Korea developed it's nuclear capabilities, the tipping point happened. Getting all butt hurt over Iran doesn't change matters. And Iran is the world's foremost producer of high grade cement, you can bet that most of their facilities are sheathed in high stress concrete. A so-called surgical strike would be futile and the Israelis and the Americans know this.
 
Okay, but you didnt answer my question.

At what point do you guys start to get uncomfortable with countries around the world acquiring nukes?? 20 countries?? 50?? 100??? 200??

I'm already uncomfortable.
All nukes should be banned.

Hey, Iran is in the news today for offering to end 20% enrichment in exchange for processed fuel for their research reactor.
Would that end any possible bomb building from them?

http://www.haaretz.com/news/middle-east/iran-offers-to-halt-20-percent-enrichment-if-given-fuel-for-research-reactor-1.469758
 
If, it means stopping Iran from having nuclear bomb means to invade, I would vote against. If Harper helps NATO invade Iran and we get nuked here in Toronto, I would blame Harper. If Iran is in all out war with NATO then yes nuke em.

And who will you blame if we don't do anything and then Hezbollah acquires one of Iran's nukes and uses it?

I don't think you are dealing intelligently with Iran's penchant for sponsoring terror.
 
yes...every sovereign nation should have that right.

I disagree completely. You are one of those idiots who think terrorist regimes, dictatorships, and all manner of tyranny should be treated as if equal to democracy.


And please stop using U.N. declarations as gospel. The U.N. is a manipulated political arena and all countries (especially the U.S. and Israel) have mocked and ignored the U.N. in the past.

Sorry but you are wrong. Neither the US nor Israel is in violation of any binding UN resolution. It's a fact. You get to have an idiotic, anti democratic opinion, but you don't get to make up your own facts.

The fact is, if Iran tries to launch a nuke , they will be immediately be obliterated from the face of the earth...within minutes....and they know it.

And when they give nukes to terrorists believing it won't be traced back to them ?
 
And who will you blame if we don't do anything and then Hezbollah acquires one of Iran's nukes and uses it?

I don't think you are dealing intelligently with Iran's penchant for sponsoring terror.

I think you have misunderstood where I'm positioned here.
 
I'm already uncomfortable.
All nukes should be banned
Okay, so now I'm confused. You dont like nukes, think they should be banned, yet you dont support a US/Israel strike on Iran to knock out their nuke plant.

Is that right?? Or do I have you confused with another poster :confused:
 
I'm already uncomfortable.
All nukes should be banned.
Yet you have repeatedly focused only on Israel.

Hey, Iran is in the news today for offering to end 20% enrichment in exchange for processed fuel for their research reactor.
Would that end any possible bomb building from them?

http://www.haaretz.com/news/middle-east/iran-offers-to-halt-20-percent-enrichment-if-given-fuel-for-research-reactor-1.469758

Except they keep building up their enrichment capacity. What are the odds they're going to dismantle the millions of dollars worth of centrifuges they've installed? Each month they can/do make 10+kg of 19.75% uranium and unless they dismantle the centrifuges, a start-up from 3% instead of 20% would only mean one months delay.
 
Okay, so now I'm confused. You dont like nukes, think they should be banned, yet you dont support a US/Israel strike on Iran to knock out their nuke plant.

Is that right?? Or do I have you confused with another poster :confused:

I don't support strikes either. Severe sanctions are as far as I'm comfortable with. Unlike grog though, I think that Iran has absolutely no right to nuclear weapons and I won't come up with BS justifications.
 
I think you have misunderstood where I'm positioned here.

Your position appears to be that a nuclear arms buildup in Iran should met with with policies of appeasement, and that in the event of a nuclear attack by fanatical terrorists affiliated with the regime in Iran, the appropriate response should be a massive attack on the civilian population of Iran.

My view is that a nuclear attack on the civilian population of Iran would only add one horrific atrocity on top of another and that the only thinking solution is to prevent terrorist regimes from acquiring nuclear weapons in the first place.
 
Your position appears to be that a nuclear arms buildup in Iran should met with with policies of appeasement, and that in the event of a nuclear attack by fanatical terrorists affiliated with the regime in Iran, the appropriate response should be a massive attack on the civilian population of Iran.

My view is that a nuclear attack on the civilian population of Iran would only add one horrific atrocity on top of another and that the only thinking solution is to prevent terrorist regimes from acquiring nuclear weapons in the first place.

Nope. I never agree on using nuclear weapons on civilians.

I think if NATO were to strike Iran on fear of development of a nuclear weapon is wrong. I believe it will escalate its tension to the brink of war. And if in fact NATO were to invade Iran like they did with Iraq, I would agree on Iran to retaliate on using nuke as a defensive measure.