US/Israel considering joint surgical strike on Iran

Your blog writer is wrong, the resolution explicitly calls out what section of the charter it is operating under, it is very clearly binding under article 41. Explicitly says so.

Iran's compliance with the additional protocol is not optional. Meanwhile even your site agrees that Iran is in breech for enriching uranium.

You didn't read the post nor understand the article, its obvious.
How legit can a resolution be if it both calls for Iran to ratify the Additional Protocols and then calls them out for not abiding by it?

Resolution 1737 calls for Iran to abide to a treaty it didn't agree to and submit to powers that the IAEA doesn't have.

Meanwhile Iran is submitting to the inspections they agreed to and has reduced by about half their stock of higher enriched uranium. I'm pretty sure, judging by previous articles, that if the US were to agree to end or lessen sanctions then Iran would agree to allow the IAEA to once again inspect Parchin. But the sticking point in negotiations right now is that the US refuses to offer to end sanctions unless Iran ends its nuclear industry entirely and give up all rights offered by the NPT.
 
How legit can a resolution be if it both calls for Iran to ratify the Additional Protocols and then calls them out for not abiding by it?

The binding resolution instructs Iran to ratify and then comply with the treaty. What is so hard to understand?

The UN SC identified the Iranian nuclear program as a threat to peace and security. Article 41 of the UN Charter authorizes the UN SC to order the implementation of whatever non-military actions it feels are necessary to eliminate the threat. The UN SC identified two actions that it has ordered be implemented: Iranian ratification (and compliance with) the Additional Protocol, and an end to Iranian enrichment of uranium.

Iran has not complied with either directive, and the UN SC responded by imposing sanctions on Iran to try and force compliance.

It is pretty bloody straight forward, there is nothing difficult to understand here. That it is a binding directive issued under Article 41 was made pretty explicitly clear in the resolution ,when they wrote right into it that it was being carried out under Chapter VII Article 41...

Meanwhile Iran is submitting to the inspections they agreed to and has reduced by about half their stock of higher enriched uranium.

Any enrichment of any uranium at all by Iran is a flagrant violation of the binding resolution. Moreover, Iran has no option about ratifying the Additional Protocol. They have been required to do so by order of the UN SC under Article 41.

If they refuse to comply, Article 41 will continue to be used to impose more and more sanctions on Iran, until they do comply. If that doesn't work, then eventually there will be an Article 42 resolution authorizing military force--unless the obvious threat to peace and security results in earlier defensive action by one of the nations in the region under Article 51.
 
The binding resolution instructs Iran to ratify and then comply with the treaty. What is so hard to understand?

A binding resolution to agree to a treaty?
Imagine the reaction if the UN SC issued a binding resolution for the US and Israel to abide by the ICC.
UN SC resolution 1737 is a house of cards.
 
A binding resolution to agree to a treaty?

That is correct. Iran is subject to a binding resolution ordering it to ratify the treaty. It is also subject to a binding resolution ordering it not to enrich uranium. Iran continues to defy the UN by refusing to ratify the treaty, and continuing to enrich uranium, both in flagrant violation of its obligations under the binding resolution.

Imagine the reaction if the UN SC issued a binding resolution for the US and Israel to abide by the ICC.

Don't hold your breath.
 
That is correct. Iran is subject to a binding resolution ordering it to ratify the treaty.

And that's where it becomes comical.
They are under a binding resolution to sign a treaty, but that same binding resolution already holds them to the terms of that treaty.
That's just nonsense.

The point here is that they have legitimate arguments, and following that their arguments hold enough merit to warrant this debate then the resolutions themselves have to be questioned. Given that, and the fact that they are in fact still upholding the terms of the treaty that they actually signed and verified, then there is a legit argument to say that they are in fact still following the terms of the treaty that they signed.

When, by the way, does Israel sign the same treaty so that a nuke free middle east can be discussed?
 
And that's where it becomes comical.
They are under a binding resolution to sign a treaty, but that same binding resolution already holds them to the terms of that treaty.
That's just nonsense.

It's not nonsense at all. It is what Iran must do to cease being a threat to peace and security. You just don't like it . Too bad for you.

The point here is that they have legitimate arguments, and following that their arguments hold enough merit to warrant this debate then the resolutions themselves have to be questioned.

Nonsense. Iran is in flagrant violation of the resolution by refusing to ratify and implement the additional protocol. It is in flagrant violation by continuing to enrich uranium. It is a threat to peace and security and it must be stopped.

Why do you believe it is OK to pick and choose which binding resolutions to follow? Iran is in flagrant violation of international law.

Plainly you don't put much stock in the UN, or in international law.
 
Nonsense. Iran is in flagrant violation of the resolution by refusing to ratify and implement the additional protocol. It is in flagrant violation by continuing to enrich uranium. It is a threat to peace and security and it must be stopped.

Why do you believe it is OK to pick and choose which binding resolutions to follow? Iran is in flagrant violation of international law.

Plainly you don't put much stock in the UN, or in international law.

I put lots of stock in the UN and international law, which is why if there are beefs with resolutions, as Iran has with 1737, then you have to treat them with respect and follow the letter of the law.
Iran continues to negotiate with the IAEA about these matters, though the US is not working in good faith these days, and is still making moves that are the opposite of aggressive, such as trying to get the IAEA to be responsible for disarmament as well as non-proliferation.
Diplomats said Iran and Egypt had wanted to include language in the resolution suggesting the U.N. agency should have a role also in nuclear disarmament, apparently reflecting frustration on their part at the lack of faster progress on this issue.
http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/09/22/nuclear-iaea-safeguards-idINL5E8KLNII20120922

and as for the resolution:
Robert Wood, the chief U.S delegate to the IAEA, said he hoped he board's near-solid backing for the resolution would serve as a wake-up call for the Islamic Republic to heed international demands to replace its words with actions that prove it has no interest in nuclear weapons.

"What we are hoping is that this resolution will keep ... diplomatic pressure up and convince Iran that it has really no other option than to comply with its international obligations," he told reporters.

But the resolution has its limitations, despite the broad support it received.

As 11 others before it, the document cannot be enforced by the IAEA board, and as such, may be shrugged off by Tehran, which already is ignoring U.N. Security Council sanctions and other increasingly harsh international penalties meant to force it to compromise.

Iran appeared unimpressed Thursday. The country's chief IAEA delegate, Ali Asghar Soltanieh, said pressure on his country came from "a few Western countries, especially the United States (which) are trying to change the IAEA into a mere U.N watchdog" trying to penetrate countries' national security.

Because it is largely symbolic, the document is also unlikely to persuade Israel that diplomacy is working. Israel views a nuclear-armed Iran as a mortal threat, citing Iran's persistent calls for the destruction of the Jewish state, its development of missiles capable of striking Israel, and Iranian support for Arab militant groups.

...

While expressing "serious concern" over continued Iranian uranium enrichment in defiance of the U.N. Security Council, the six nations say they back the "inalienable right" of countries that have signed the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty to develop nuclear energy for peaceful purposes. That is a bow to arguments by Iran, an NPT signatory, that it has a right to enrich uranium.

The resolution "stresses" that the IAEA has not reported any nuclear material missing from Iran sites it is monitoring. Missing material could mean that Tehran is using it elsewhere for weapons purposes.

The language is also weaker than it could be because it only "notes" that the agency cannot conclude there is no hidden nuclear activity going on because of "lack of co-operation" by Iran on agency requests that it be given greater powers to monitor.

http://www.canada.com/news/harshly+criticizes+Irans+nuclear+defiance+says+diplomacy+resolve/7236939/story.html
 
Your only beef with the resolution is that it is critical of your terrorist buddy Khameini and his goons. The Iranians have not respected the law, they are in flagrant violation of a binding resolution. Even YOUR conspiracy oriented blog, which was flat out wrong about the status of the resolution in general--ridiculously wrong, the resolution declares explicitly what section of the charter it is under--even your conspiracy blog acknowledged that Iran was flagrantly violating the prohibition on enriching uranium. Of course you didn't quote that part, because it didn't suit your love of terror and tyranny to quote that even your reference cited Iran as being in breech.

The sanction is real, compliance is not voluntary, and the consequence of Iran choosing to be a threat to peace and security are the sanctions that are kicking in now. Soon enough, if Iran does not start complying with the law, there will be an article 42 resolution authorizing military force.

Your terror buddy Khameini is not going to be allowed to play around with nuclear weapons.
 
Your terror buddy Khameini is not going to be allowed to play around with nuclear weapons.

He's no friend of mine, but your worries are pointless. As the US NIE state, Iran stopped working on a nuclear weapons program in 2003.

Now when does Israel sign the NPT and allow inspections?
 
He's no friend of mine, but your worries are pointless. As the US NIE state, Iran stopped working on a nuclear weapons program in 2003.

Now when does Israel sign the NPT and allow inspections?

When they want to. You complain a NPT state being expected to follow the NPT yet you want to force another country to join (and ignore the few other non-NPT nuclear powers).

As for nuclear weapons, everyone agree Iran is not making nuclear weapons right now but their MASSIVE enrichment program and suspicious activity in their weapons programs give the IAEA and the entire world concerns, especially in light of Iran's intransigence to inspectors.
 
He's no friend of mine, but your worries are pointless. As the US NIE state, Iran stopped working on a nuclear weapons program in 2003.

Now when does Israel sign the NPT and allow inspections?

Iran's enriching uranium puts them in a position to restart that program at a much more advanced stage. Their enrichment of uranium is an illegal violation of the resolution. Their refusal to ratify the additional protocol is another flagrant violation.

Plainly you just don't care about violations of binding UN resolutions when it is your terror buddies violating them. Please don't ever cite anything from the UN ever again.
 
Iran's enriching uranium puts them in a position to restart that program at a much more advanced stage. Their enrichment of uranium is an illegal violation of the resolution. Their refusal to ratify the additional protocol is another flagrant violation.

And yet they reduced their stock of higher enriched uranium by close to 50% as stated by the last IAEA report.
That puts them further away from any possible bomb making, not closer.
 
They are required by international law to stop enriching uranium completely. They are blatantly flouting that requirement. They are also blatantly flouting the requirement to open their facilities to inspection under the additional protocol.

You probably aren't honest enough to admit that Iran is in full breech of binding resolutions. Moreover, you obviously don't give a shit about the UN or its resolutions, or anything else. It's very obvious now that the extent to which you ever cited anything connected to the UN before, it was just self-serving hate. You don't really believe that any part of the UN has any credibility. You just like any source that is critical of Israel--random blogs, postings on internet forums, fake tribunals, UNHRC reports--it's all good with you so long as it's critical of Israel. You also hate any source that is critical of your terrorist buddies in Iran and Syria.

I take it you will agree never to cite the UN for anything again, as you have rejected its most authoritative pronouncements as being meaningless.
 
And yet they reduced their stock of higher enriched uranium by close to 50% as stated by the last IAEA report.
That puts them further away from any possible bomb making, not closer.

Not at the rate they are making more. Every month is another years worth of 'peaceful' uses even though they already have more than 20 years worth of stockpile.
 
My , oh my.. if those evil Iranians fashion a crude sling shot and try to use it, it will probably miss the target and be followed by a massive surgical strike by the Americans/Israelis which will make Nagasaki look like a cherry bomb... yet you war mongers continue to sound the alarm bells
 
My , oh my.. if those evil Iranians fashion a crude sling shot and try to use it, it will probably miss the target and be followed by a massive surgical strike by the Americans/Israelis which will make Nagasaki look like a cherry bomb... yet you war mongers continue to sound the alarm bells

You support Iran developing a nuclear weapon??????
 
My , oh my.. if those evil Iranians fashion a crude sling shot and try to use it, it will probably miss the target and be followed by a massive surgical strike by the Americans/Israelis which will make Nagasaki look like a cherry bomb... yet you war mongers continue to sound the alarm bells
And this crude nuclear slingshot will kill how many?
 
Yea sure every country should have one in their back pockets. It'll be a fair fight when US starts using it on innocent people

You want a fair fight between the world's democracies, and nasty dictatorships? I would rather have an unfair fight, in our favour. Are you cheering for Iran to nuke Toronto? Or only our allies?