Great News for Driving while using Cellphone Law

Phil C. McNasty

Go Jays Go
Dec 27, 2010
32,208
9,502
113
An Ontario judge has overturned a $200 fine for using a cellphone while driving, ruling that holding a phone while the car is stopped at a light isn't the same as using it.

Thats good because I always thought that was unfair. Lets say you wanna check your GPS location while at a light, how is that dangerous exactly??

Its no different then turning the dial on your carstereo

http://www.moneyville.ca/article/1242025---200-cellphone-while-driving-fine-overturned

An Ontario judge has overturned a $200 fine for using a cellphone while driving, ruling that holding a phone while the car is stopped at a light isn't the same as using it.

In an unusual case, Oshawa Children's Aid worker Khojasteh Kazemi was driving home when she was pulled over soon after getting off the Don Valley Parkway. Kazemi had taken the Gerrard Street East exit and was stopped at a light on River Street. She told a court that her cell phone had slipped off the passenger seat onto the floor and she waited until she was stopped at the light to pick it up. She didn’t intend to use it.

Kazemi was pulled over by a police constable and given a ticket for driving while holding or using a cellphone. The ticket was initially upheld by a Justice of the Peace, but Kazemi appealed to the Ontario Court of Justice.

Judge Shaun Nakatsuru who heard the case, noted that 'holding' and 'using' a cell phone are banned for good reason. Holding a phone means both hands are not on the wheel. It can also be a dangerous distraction, because there is a temptation to use it to look at incoming messages.

But the judge accepted Kazemi’s evidence that she did not intend to use the phone, based in part on her cell phone records which revealed no calls at the relevant time. He also ruled that touching a handheld device is not the same as holding it and reversed the conviction and $200 fine
 
im pretty sure checking your gps location is using your cellphone and not the same situation as the lady here.
 
im pretty sure checking your gps location is using your cellphone and not the same situation as the lady here
Its not entirely, but you could take it to court and show your cellphone records to the judge, and if no calls were made you might get off the charges.

At least now there's some precedent thats been set
 
I dont think I have seen a more ignored law than this.

'Hey Officer, just on the phone to Bob here. Give me a minute and I'll be with you'
 
The judge is ruling that incidental handling is different than usage. Incidental handling is not the distraction that usage is, whether it's to make a call, check the time, or your GPS location. Usage is usage, and it means you're not focused on what's going on around you, which is the main point of the distracted driving law.

I won't disagree that there are many other distractions as well - people applying makeup, having a meal, futzing with their GPS device, having a conversation with their passenger(s), minding the children in the back seat, etc.
 
This is bad news. The point is that even using the stereo is a proven distraction, and anything done with a handheld device even more so. Good news would be stuff that further discourages such use. Anything that suggests to the silly and impressionable that it's OK to get away with using your attention and your hands for anything but safe driving is bad.

I know it's hard to conceive, but knowing where you're going before you started your trip would eliminate the need for any GPS.
 
Last edited:
I dont think I have seen a more ignored law than this.

'Hey Officer, just on the phone to Bob here. Give me a minute and I'll be with you'

A close second would be the HOV lane on the 404 going south. If I was a cop, I just stand down at the bottom and pull them over one after the next.
 
An Ontario judge has overturned a $200 fine for using a cellphone while driving, ruling that holding a phone while the car is stopped at a light isn't the same as using it.

Thats good because I always thought that was unfair. Lets say you wanna check your GPS location while at a light, how is that dangerous exactly??

Its no different then turning the dial on your carstereo

http://www.moneyville.ca/article/1242025---200-cellphone-while-driving-fine-overturned

You're wrong in your interpretation of the judgment.

Here's the decision: http://www.canlii.org/eliisa/highli...on/oncj/doc/2012/2012oncj383/2012oncj383.html

The distinction is between holding a cell phone and using it, and even then, such "holding" must be temporary ( in this case, to pick up a dropped phone). The Highway Traffic Act prohibits holding or using a mobile device.
 
This is bad news. The point is that even using the stereo is a proven distraction, and anything done with a handheld device even more so. Good news would be stuff that further discourages such use. Anything that suggests to the silly and impressionable that it's OK to get away with using you attention and your hands for anything but safe driving is bad.

I know it's hard to conceive, but knowing where you're going before you left would eliminate the need for any GPS
Even when you're at a stoplight??

Come on now :rolleyes:
 

You asked if it's illegal to use your phone while stopped at a red light.... and it is.

I believe that for it not to be illegal, you need to be off the road, and in park.

Kinda dumb, but then it ain't like a ear-bud is a big inconvenience. And I believe you can still use your phone to the extent that you can push "answer" or activate the voice dialing.
 
The judge is ruling that incidental handling is different than usage. Incidental handling is not the distraction that usage is, whether it's to make a call, check the time, or your GPS location. Usage is usage, and it means you're not focused on what's going on around you, which is the main point of the distracted driving law.

I won't disagree that there are many other distractions as well - people applying makeup, having a meal, futzing with their GPS device, having a conversation with their passenger(s), minding the children in the back seat, etc.

Yeah, i think its a great law. I was in a small accident with a guy i was dating. He just bought a new car and was stopped at a red light. Some woman in a dirty old sunfire rolled right into him. She was obviously on her phone. How do roll into someone who's stopped? She walked out with her keys and phone in her hand. It ended up costing her nothing... She had no money and gave some sob story about her insurance going up blah blah blah...if your that poor you shouldnt be driving, take a damn bus! So anyway. She obviously didnt care about the damage to her vehicle since it was already beat up and ready for the scrap yard. It likely cost the guy a grand or more to fix it. He paid out of pocket. He didnt want his insurance to go up either and his deductable was pretty high. It wasnt worth reporting. But stuff like that shouldnt happen, she was in her thirties. You'd think someone that age with kids in the car would be a bit more responsible.
 
He didnt want his insurance to go up either and his deductable was pretty high.
If your b/f was rear-ended while he was stopped, he should have reported it. There is zero-fault on his part. Mind you, if the repair was "only" $1000 to fix, then he was probably right. A lot of us have $1000 deductible to help keep rates down.

As to how and why someone hits someone who is sitting at a red-light, I have no idea, but it has happened to me seven times in all my years of driving. Most recently it was a straight truck and I could see the guy texting as he approached. $3500 later, I was good to go...
 
If your b/f was rear-ended while he was stopped, he should have reported it. There is zero-fault on his part. Mind you, if the repair was "only" $1000 to fix, then he was probably right. A lot of us have $1000 deductible to help keep rates down.

As to how and why someone hits someone who is sitting at a red-light, I have no idea, but it has happened to me seven times in all my years of driving. Most recently it was a straight truck and I could see the guy texting as he approached. $3500 later, I was good to go...

Oh my god...that's awful. I felt especially bad for the guy because he came out to see me when i was like an hour and a half away. He was laid off at the time and was waiting for a phone call for work. There are a lot of people that do it... But i trust their driving skills and im never really worried about it but then there's people like my sister... WHo can barely drive and hit objects that dont even move that should in no way be able to have a phone near them when they are driving... It's kind of scary to think about it, because everyone i know that isnt over fourty does it.
 
Chantelle: Your guy isn't too bright. If he was struck from behind, it's 100% the other party's fault. He would not pay any deductible, and his insurance is not affected at all. I know this, because it happened to me 18 months ago.
 
Chantelle: Your guy isn't too bright. If he was struck from behind, it's 100% the other party's fault. He would not pay any deductible, and his insurance is not affected at all. I know this, because it happened to me 18 months ago.

True for the vast majority of cases, unless you're a serial no fault driver, lol. Too many claims to your insurance company whereby you're not at fault will piss off your insurance company because they still have to pay for your damages and they will make it hard for you in many ways so they can get rid of you.
 
You asked if it's illegal to use your phone while stopped at a red light.... and it is.

I believe that for it not to be illegal, you need to be off the road, and in park
You are right, I'm not disputing that. I just think its a stupid law when you're at a stoplight
 
... I know it's hard to conceive, but knowing where you're going before you left would eliminate the need for any GPS.

AMEN! Amazing how the concept of "hey, let's look at the map first" seems to have gone the way of the dodo. *sigh*

Besides, if I had wanted to hear a voice telling me which way to go every 15 seconds I would have gotten married. :Eek: (I'm sorry, did I say that out loud?)
 
A close second would be the HOV lane on the 404 going south. If I was a cop, I just stand down at the bottom and pull them over one after the next.

They have done that on multiple occasions. I know this because I got caught once. Though I got caught on the day of the biggest snowstorm and I don't usually travel that far down south and did not realize I was on HOV as all the signs were snow covered. Charge got mysteriously dropped after I applied for a court date.