Is that a Ferrari, I am impressed.

Obviously the douche thought that if he drove away...no ticket. He thought he had the right to, we've all tried that, usually with a meter maid and not a cop. It's more complicated because the cop didn't necessarily have any right to stop him from driving away (a meter maid would never do that). So not necessarily as simple as the video suggests.

Not only that but the cop threw a punch at someone who was not at all running or resisting. Why did he give himself that right? I smell a great lawsuit.

Being a douche or being a cop does not mean the law will side with you. We'll see.

(Of course the driver was just a stupid fucking idiot)
 
Mr. Ferrari was stupid enough to give the police exactly what they wanted. If he had merely just leaned against his car and kept his mouth shut - none of this (save for the parking ticket) would have taken place.

Agreed, he was a red herring, that driver. But what is it we always hear that police officers are trained to defuse conflicts. In this case both parties wanted a confrontation, and got it. The policeman could just have written the ticket. He did not need to prevent the car from leaving.
 
Agreed, he was a red herring, that driver. But what is it we always hear that police officers are trained to defuse conflicts. In this case both parties wanted a confrontation, and got it. The policeman could just have written the ticket. He did not need to prevent the car from leaving.

Exactly. He simply should have backed away when the douche wanted to drive away and mailed him the ticket.

Some of you are confusing morality with the law. It's clear the driver was a douche, but he was trying something lots of people do every day: I drive away and I get no ticket (or in the mail). Cop has no right to block him (I don't think).

Of course, the cop will invoke some bullshit law as his defense. Driver threat to public peace or something.

edit: Here's more info about the story
 
Agreed, he was a red herring, that driver. But what is it we always hear that police officers are trained to defuse conflicts. In this case both parties wanted a confrontation, and got it. The policeman could just have written the ticket. He did not need to prevent the car from leaving.
It turns out that there is more to the story.

The Driver was being summonsed for two motor vehicle violations as well: a registration violation and an inspection violation, on top of the parking violation which was a fairly important one: parking in a no standing zone

According to the court documents before the video starts the officer told him that he was writing him a summons and to stand on the sidewalk, the driver (Julien Chabbott) then tried to snatch the summons away (arrestable offense right there) then walked back inside when he comes back out is when the video starts. He then was then “specifically told by the officer to not get into the car and to not leave.”

So now on top of the Motor Vehicle Violations and the Parking Violation Mr. Ferrari has been charged with: second-degree assault, vehicular assault, obstructing governmental administration, and disorderly conduct. (The first of which is a felony).
 
I believe part of the more to the story is bull shittt .
If he did in fact grab the ticket book he would have already been on the ground and arrested .
If the cop was not bright enough to move when he seen the guy was going to leave .. too bad for him ..
All he had to do was move so he would not have a sore foot versus putting his foot in front of the tire .
Some one stupid enough to put their foot in front of a car tire need no sympathy..
As the saying goes you can not fix stupid ..
He caused his own injury .. by his own actions and therefore should not even get pay off work
 
Forget about the cop's foot.
The cop positioned himself at the front (albeit to the side ) of the front fender, and the driver still tried to drive away,
nudging the cop. You're saying that's acceptable?
That's when the cop lost it, when he got bumped.
I get that cops overstep their boudaries some of the time and I won't defend everything they do, but there has to be a minimum amount of respect
for enforcers of the law or things go into the shitter. Everything is a slippery slope,
How civilized do you think society really is.
 
I think the judge who ultimately winds up hearing this case will not be impressed with the conduct of either the driver or the cop.

The driver should have waited for his ticket though, at least in Canada, there is no obligation for him to do so. He was not under arrest and the cop has no right to detain or arrest him for a city parking bylaw violation.

I doubt Mr. Ferrari could possibly have seen or known that the cop was stupid enough to put his foot in front of the wheel and let it run him over -- if in fact that happened! -- until the cop shouted it out. Clearly, the cop created that situation and put himself in danger.

There is no justification for the cop opening the door and dragging Mr. Ferrari out; that is an assault by the cop!

The cop was the aggressor here. Without a power of arrest, he should have stood aside. I am sure that would not be the first time that happened to him when issuing a parking ticket. When he puts himself in a position to impede a person that he has no power to arrest, there is no justification whatsoever for the very aggressive and forceful take down. It sure looks like abuse of authority to me...

I would bet a tidy sum that a skilful cross examiner could tie down what the cop did to the fact that the car was a Ferrari... you know, "I'll teach this arrogant Ferrari pig a lesson he will never forget" kind of thing! What else could explain the cop's stupidity?

But I don't know if the what we see on the video is the whole of the evidence, and what a judge may do will depend on all the evidence...

Obviously, 2 idiots in one place at the same time. The cop's ego is at least as big as the driver's... and the driver's ego is something people may want to erroneously assume or infer just from the fact he has a Ferrari, eh? That, too, is prejudice!

Perry

p.s. Looks like a nice Saturday afternoon crowd in SoHo...
 
It turns out that there is more to the story.

The Driver was being summonsed for two motor vehicle violations as well: a registration violation and an inspection violation, on top of the parking violation which was a fairly important one: parking in a no standing zone

According to the court documents before the video starts the officer told him that he was writing him a summons and to stand on the sidewalk, the driver (Julien Chabbott) then tried to snatch the summons away (arrestable offense right there) then walked back inside when he comes back out is when the video starts. He then was then “specifically told by the officer to not get into the car and to not leave.”

So now on top of the Motor Vehicle Violations and the Parking Violation Mr. Ferrari has been charged with: second-degree assault, vehicular assault, obstructing governmental administration, and disorderly conduct. (The first of which is a felony).

I don't think that changes much.

My guess is that if you look on the officers patrolcar, it says "To serve and Protect", not "To intimidate and show authority". Who was he serving, and who was he protecting?
 
Perry while I entirely agree with you that they both acted more or less like jerks, presuming that New York law is similar - the Unregistered Motor Vehicle offense is arrestable so right there Mr. Ferrari was being done a favour by being summonsed rather than arrested, further, at least where I'm admitted it is a separate criminal offense to refuse to sign a summons.

Further what I mentioned above in #26 was supposedly submitted to the Court on Oath, if so. . . either it is or an officer is going to be looking for a new job when he is impeached on the stand.
 
Further to some of the above, different places have different police cultures. Would I expect behaviour like this in some small town in Vermont - No, is this quite typical of the NYPD - it surely is.
 
Just wanna add, the video does NOT show that the driver drove over the cop's foot. Important issue come court time.

In fact looking at the youtube replay a few times and going by the angles, it looks like he didnt touch his foot at all. Especially when the cop freely moves his left-foot backwards right after
 
I looked carefully at the video again...

At 23 seconds the car is moving forward very, very slowly and the cop, as in one motion, (a) moves his foot towards the rolling wheel, (b) pulls it back, (c) knocks on the window, (d) says something about his foot, (e) begins to open the door and (f) drags the guy out from his seat...

The wheel did not roll over his foot!

To me, it seems obvious that the cop first instigated something and then faked an incident in order to pretend to have an excuse to arrest the driver...

I call it FAKE!

Perry
 
I looked carefully at the video again...

At 23 seconds the car is moving forward very, very slowly and the cop, as in one motion, (a) moves his foot towards the rolling wheel, (b) pulls it back, (c) knocks on the window, (d) says something about his foot, (e) begins to open the door and (f) drags the guy out from his seat...

The wheel did not roll over his foot!

To me, it seems obvious that the cop first instigated something and then faked an incident in order to pretend to have an excuse to arrest the driver...

I call it FAKE!

Perry
While I cant say for sure, I think you're probably right.

This was a clash of 2 ego's. On one side a rich playboy, on the other a cop with a god-complex who's pissed he'll never get to own a Ferrari himself on his $50K a year wages :D
 
YOU should know better as a lawyer. Either he WAS under arrest, or he wasn't.
An Arrestable Offense means that that the person can legally be arrested for the offense. In this case the officer chose not to arrest him at first but rather to summons him.

Assault: The threat or use of force on another that causes that person (the officer) to have a reasonable fear or apprehension of imminent harmful or offensive contact. In a number of states the charge incorporates Battery which is the actual harmful or offensive contact.

Bumping your car into the officer or running over his foot is indeed assault.
 
I looked carefully at the video again...

At 23 seconds the car is moving forward very, very slowly and the cop, as in one motion, (a) moves his foot towards the rolling wheel, (b) pulls it back, (c) knocks on the window, (d) says something about his foot, (e) begins to open the door and (f) drags the guy out from his seat...

The wheel did not roll over his foot!

To me, it seems obvious that the cop first instigated something and then faked an incident in order to pretend to have an excuse to arrest the driver...

I call it FAKE!

Perry
Going by the evidence you can see in the video, there is no indication that the policeman's foot was injured. If you give the policeman the benefit of the doubt, he can argue that the wheels of the car turned and caused injury to his toes.



Bumping your car into the officer or running over his foot is indeed assault.

It does not look good for Vic Ferrari that he stepped into the car, started the car and cause it to be in motion causing the policeman to order him to stop before the policeman indicated that the car was on his foot. The actions of Mr. Vic Ferrari constitutes intent and opens up the possibility that he has indeed injured the policeman.

The policeman can claim a few days off if he has pain in his foot, he can only claim some long term compensation and time off if he can back it up with physical injury from x-rays.
 
I don't think that changes much.

My guess is that if you look on the officers patrolcar, it says "To serve and Protect", not "To intimidate and show authority". Who was he serving, and who was he protecting?

to serve and protect the greater law-abiding community, not the ego-centred douche who thinks he can break the law and get away because he has money and drives a Ferrari. Imagine if everyone was like him and started violating laws
 
Why the fuck are we still discussing about this? Didn't we concluded that the Ferrari driver is a douche? Those who support the douche, I like to see you rev-up your engine and try to drive away when a cop is giving you a ticket, but you'd probably won't do that because you know better when you are in the real world. No one in this thread would do a stupid thing like that.

The cop had to do what he did (either a foot in front of the tire, or standing right in front of the car), or else he'll just let the engine-reving, Ferrari-driving douche getaway thinking he is above the law.
 
Oooooooh!

I see a lot of Ferrari envy here!

Just because a guy drives a Ferrari he is a douche?

My, oh my!

Perry
 
But at 2:02 he was LIMPING SO BADLY after that he had to be consoled and assisted by a brother officer!
I'm thinking he has a nice lawsuit planned, and wanted to make sure the camera caught his "limp" :D

Christmas time might come early for this cop ;)