The lightbulb conspiracy

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
 
Bright idea

Use a dimmer, and you'll never have to replace them.

If you need 60 watts, use a 100 watt, and a dimmer, etc.

FAST
 
The video ends with the line, "Can we free ourselves from the tyranny of planned obsolescence?" Wtf? Anyone who wants to put products on the market that last longer is perfectly free to do so. Where does the "tyranny" come it?

You don't need light bulb makers to get together in secret to conspire to make bulbs that last 1000 hours - it just happens that that is the service life that makes most economic sense and best value for money. If a mfr thinks he can clean up, selling bulbs that last 10,000-hours, how are the conspirators going to stop him?

Total crock, from someone who doesn't understand the L of S&D.
 
Planned obselescence is old news.
I took the video to be more than just referring to light bulbs. You buy a computer which is at the time, the best all you will ever need. Talk to the same sales guy three months later and it is now a piece of junk. Apple and the rest constantly bring out new models every year.I have heard it before that if you bought a car that fucked up as much as computers and their related software do, nobody would stand for it. If you read "Your money or your life" there is a chapter discussing how the average American worker back in the twenties,felt they had enough and didn't need to consume more and more. This threw government and industry into a panic and consumerism for it's own sake became the rule.
 
If they made stuff to last forever the manufacturers would be out of business.
 
I took the video to be more than just referring to light bulbs. You buy a computer which is at the time, the best all you will ever need. Talk to the same sales guy three months later and it is now a piece of junk. Apple and the rest constantly bring out new models every year.I have heard it before that if you bought a car that fucked up as much as computers and their related software do, nobody would stand for it. If you read "Your money or your life" there is a chapter discussing how the average American worker back in the twenties,felt they had enough and didn't need to consume more and more. This threw government and industry into a panic and consumerism for it's own sake became the rule.

If you think the world is waiting for a computer that will not become obsolete, you are perfectly at liberty to design one (if you can) and to put it on the market for a little more than it cost you to make it. If people buy it, that shows you were right, and all is good.

There's no conspiracy (not in that, anyway.) Just the free market.

The big thing about the free market is, if you don't like a product, and if you think others don't like it either, you don't whine about conspiracies - you put your own product on the market, and you show the bastards how wrong they were.

Or are you too timid to venture, yourself, into the risky world of freely competitive commerce? Most economic-conspiracy theorists are.
 
If you think the world is waiting for a computer that will not become obsolete, you are perfectly at liberty to design one (if you can) and to put it on the market for a little more than it cost you to make it. If people buy it, that shows you were right, and all is good.

There's no conspiracy (not in that, anyway.) Just the free market.

The big thing about the free market is, if you don't like a product, and if you think others don't like it either, you don't whine about conspiracies - you put your own product on the market, and you show the bastards how wrong they were.

Or are you too timid to venture, yourself, into the risky world of freely competitive commerce? Most economic-conspiracy theorists are.

The problem is marketing often gets in the way of good, sound product development decisions. If you could make a light bulb, say, that would cost 5% more to produce, but would last 10% longer.. it sounds like a no brainer, right? But will people buy it?
 
This is a hard one. Buttercup is right, "Anyone who wants to put products on the market that last longer is perfectly free to do so" -- but they don't, and it appears that they don't because of something that is fundamentally broken in our economy. That there is a problem is actually pretty clear. What the problem is, and how to fix it--far less obvious.

Plainly we can't just go around ordering people to build longer lasting products, what we really want to do is fix whatever broken incentive structure causes this semi-evil behavior on the part of our businesses. But what is the broken incentive, and how would we fix it, isn't all that obvious to me.
 
In many cases (televison, computers, phones) it really doesn't make sense to have them last forever. Technology is moving too fast. I just threw away a 36" tube television that was in perfect working order - great picture! But obsolete...
 
In many cases (televison, computers, phones) it really doesn't make sense to have them last forever. Technology is moving too fast. I just threw away a 36" tube television that was in perfect working order - great picture! But obsolete...

True. But things like light bulbs are another story.
 
The problem is early light bulbs were 'over engineered'....they lasted too damn long.

This 'over engineering' problem has been 'corrected' and they no longer last as long....:eyebrows:
 
is this even an issue ?

Yes. I have some bulbs that are quire difficult to change and it pisses me off every time one burns out. I put CFC's there awhile back and they still burned out. So now I will be replacing them with LED's. I don't care about the price of the bulb, I am sick of climbing up the goddam ladder.
 
LED lightbuld are expensive but last for 20 years.

Planned obselescence is old news.

Probably a BS claim on lasting 20 yrs.

I switched all my mainly used bulbs to CFLs a few years ago because they were advertised to last 7-11 yrs!
Kept the receipts because of doubts they would last that long.
Sure enough after 2-3 yrs they started to fail.
So far have replaced ~16 failed CFL bulbs under warranty at no cost to me and have another starting to go bad.

On the plus side my electric bill did drop noticeably since switching over to CFLs.
 
I will never ever use CFLs.

Hate the light

Hate the look

Don't want to deal with the environmental issues.
 
I will never ever use CFLs.

Hate the light
There are two types. One gives off that harsh bright light and the other is softer like incandescent. I have no problems with the ones giving off the softer light. Would never use the harsh ones.
 
Yes. I have some bulbs that are quire difficult to change and it pisses me off every time one burns out. I put CFC's there awhile back and they still burned out. So now I will be replacing them with LED's. I don't care about the price of the bulb, I am sick of climbing up the goddam ladder.

i have never put any thought into lightbulbs. a bulb blows i put in a new one. in under a minute i am moving on with my life.