Is this child abuse?

babemagnet

Banned
Jul 5, 2011
747
0
0
I was in a food court at a mall the other day and a Chinese mum and dad were having lunch with their little one. He was a cute little two year old nipper, sitting there minding his own business, when the mum decided he had to eat. He didn't want to and started to protest whereupon she grabbed him by the head, scooped up a handful of noodles and forced them into his mouth. He tried to spit them out because it was more than he could handle and she simply clamped her hand over his mouth and forced them back. He was crying loudly but his dad just looked on without intervening so he just had to choke them down. I was upset, as were others who looked over their shoulders and shook their heads. Is this child abuse?
Yesterday I saw a couple get out of their suv with another two year old girl who was crying and protesting about something and they kept walking and talking and ignoring her. She seemed to want to be picked up and comforted,but they would have none of it. I guess they were teaching her tough love or something. I guess she will be grateful when she is twenty. Am I wrong in thinking this is fucked up parenting?
 
The first example sounds like child abuse to me. The second example, not so sure. Maybe the parents had their reasons for not picking her up. Many kids are spoiled by overly attentive parents.
 
I hope that question isn't directed to any members from Asia, Africa, South America or so. What you described - force feeding a kid - is probably LOVE by their standards of child abuse. Spoilt brats who need food to be stuffed into their mouths while thousands of unfortunate kids are out daily digging landfills just to find something worthy enough to give them their day's meal.

In the words of Russell Peters, "Beat your kid!"
 
I hope that question isn't directed to any members from Asia, Africa, South America or so. What you described - force feeding a kid - is probably LOVE by their standards of child abuse. Spoilt brats who need food to be stuffed into their mouths while thousands of unfortunate kids are out daily digging landfills just to find something worthy enough to give them their day's meal.

In the words of Russell Peters, "Beat your kid!"
Yes, Russell Peters is my go to guy for inspirational intelligence. No my question wasn't racially slanted,intentionally. I just have a soft spot for Asian kids I suppose.Nothing more to be read into that. He didn't appear to be a spoiled brat, and stuffing food down his throat to make amends for the starving kids in Asia doesn't really cut it.I didn't see any love in her actions.Just an abusive power trip. I looked after a little boy who is Asian when he was a toddler and we never had a moment like that in the years I looked after him. He grew up just fine.
 
There are several different things going on here: Behaviour which either we don't believe should take place or that we would hope not to do. OR physical abuse causing permanent injury which rises to the level of notifying authorities. Both of these seem to be in the former rather than the later category.

While I realize that sometimes there is a thin line, merely because it isn't the way you or I would do it, doesn't mean the "Child Protective Agency Gestapo" should be called in.
 
I was in a food court at a mall the other day and a Chinese mum and dad were having lunch with their little one. He was a cute little two year old nipper, sitting there minding his own business, when the mum decided he had to eat. He didn't want to and started to protest whereupon she grabbed him by the head, scooped up a handful of noodles and forced them into his mouth. He tried to spit them out because it was more than he could handle and she simply clamped her hand over his mouth and forced them back. He was crying loudly but his dad just looked on without intervening so he just had to choke them down. I was upset, as were others who looked over their shoulders and shook their heads. Is this child abuse?
Yesterday I saw a couple get out of their suv with another two year old girl who was crying and protesting about something and they kept walking and talking and ignoring her. She seemed to want to be picked up and comforted,but they would have none of it. I guess they were teaching her tough love or something. I guess she will be grateful when she is twenty. Am I wrong in thinking this is fucked up parenting?
To me, the examples that you described are perfectly normal parenting behaviour.

I'm curious to know how old you are and what race and planet you are from.
 
The first story is a bit much but the second story doesn't sound so bad. Parent's shouldn't be giving in to a child's temper tantrum anyway.
 
nip·per (npr)
n.
1. A tool, such as pliers or pincers, used for squeezing or nipping. Often used in the plural.
2. A pincerlike part, such as the large claw of a crustacean.
3. Chiefly British A small boy.
In case that's what you were referring to.
 
Without knowing what happened before any of these events, we have no idea. Walking and ignoring a 2-year old begging for something? Maybe begging for another Blackberry to play with? Ignore her! Maybe the other kid had been protesting by not eating anything his parents have been trying to give him for the last 12 hours. Then they had enough and decided to stuff the food down his throat, for his own good. The point is, we don't know what happened before, and what their lives are like so we should not judge. And don't think for a minute that these 2 year olds don't know what they are doing...
 
To me, the examples that you described are perfectly normal parenting behaviour.

I'm curious to know how old you are and what race and planet you are from.
Normal parenting behavior eh? Never seen it done before and judging by the reaction of others who witnessed it, I can only guess that your idea of normal is slightly different. Talking about shoving food down a kid's throat to the point where he was choking. As for the other one. I wasn't really putting it in the same category. Just struck me as unnecessary, but none of my business obviously.
 
first example is a little weird. second seems about right, can't give in to everything the kid wants as soon as they want it.