Why do ponds fill with water ?

How could you not know this?

Because I am not as smart as you?

To go further it is the shape of the pond that allows this mud to build under the pond as an inch of rain becomes a foot at the bottom (when the pond is empty) because water runs down the slope and turns into mud before it can sink through the soil

This is why ponds fill quickest at the bottom then slower as they reach the top then stop filling altogether as the slope becomes covered with water which answers my second question which is "why do ponds have a tendency to fill near the top then stop before they overflow?"


A square pond, in a natural setting, would not fill with water, I presume

There is also the effect of water polarization which is the tendency for water to attract itself and bond (I suspect it is this force that actually creates the mud)

This is why some insects can walk on water and is why the fizz does not come out of the Coke unless shaken

Shake a Coke and notice the force of the explosion

All that force was being held inside the water by water polarization, for an example of the strength of this force

But of course you knew all this
 
Last edited:
Dude - there are natural ponds and man-made ones, both of them have a impermeable or semipermeable basin that could be made of a whole bunch of things, from rock to clay to sandy clay to plastic. The reason they don't leak is because water is unable to pass through the material, whatever it may be. Maybe you mean to ask about the formation of such material in a natural setting?

Yes. Specifically why do ponds form above the water table

Why does the water not sink to the natural water table
Ponds DO NOT stop before they overflow, I don't now where you got this idea from.

Not a hard rule, of course, as a strong rain will cause overflow or a lack of rain will cause a natural pond to lower (because of evaporation ) but my observation is that they have a tendency to do this
A square pond is a swimming pool and yes it will fill with water, unless the sun is so hot or the air so dry that the water evaporates faster than the replenish rate, or maybe an elephant comes and drinks it all.

Now you are being silly

Of course a square pond made of cement will fill

A square hole in a natural setting ... will it fill ? Because the water is not collecting in the center (because there is no slope) I suspect mud will not form as the water will sink too fast but if there is a slope enough water will collect to form mud
Bugs walk on water because of surface tension, surface tension is related to the polarization of water molecules.
I don't know where you are going with shaking a can of coke, but that can is also held together by atomic forces, all matter is. Or maybe you are talking about Divide and Conquer versus Unit and win.

The coke example is an excellent example of water polarization and its amazing strength

When shaken the water polorization is overcome and a rather large explosive force comes out of the top of the bottle

this force was in the bottle all along but was being held inside the pop by water polarization which shows how strong this force of water to bond to itself is

As you correctly stated, surface tension is another example of water polarization

I doubt mud would form without this force and therefore the only natural pond formation would be created by the water table unless an impermeable foundation, such as rock , was involved
 
If sufficiently stable walls can be dug for a square hole then yes it will in time fill with water.
Capillary action will cause water to climb the vertical walls and help "create" the mud you seek IF the soil is of a suitable consistency.
Ponds form anywhere that the soil has sufficient ability to seal the cracks that exist between particles of soil.
Clay is superfine compared to sand therefore while each "grain of clay" may have more surface area then a corresponding "grain of sand" the absorption of water - or clay's ability to retain water is much greater than sand.

The question is hypothetical as the walls would collapse forming a sloped hole but if they did not collapse I doubt they would fill unless subjected to a torrent as the water would sink or evaporate

Ponds overflow all the time once the capacity of a given pond is exceeded. A pond is a place where water is temporarily accumulated, much like a lake or a puddle.
Puddles are very small ponds.

There is a tendency of ponds to seek a natural level just below ground level

This is my observation from having lived on a farm with a natural pond

Of course strong rains will make it overflow
 
As far as I understand it, the level of a stable pond -- one that won't dry up -- is typically at the water table level. If the pond's water is above the water table, it will seep into the soil and dry up, like puddles after a rain storm. How fast it will seep will depend on the permeability of the soil. If there is a lot of clay in the soil it will seep slowly. If there is a lot of sand in the soil, it will seep out fast. The following web site talk about different types of ponds and seepage if the ponds level is above the water table.

https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/ae013

It also answers your questions about why a pond doesn't overflow. As the ponds water level rises above the water table, the seepage increases. So more water seeps out near the top. See their Figure 1.
Note that ponds will overflow during an intense rainstorm.

Even ponds at the water table will dry up during a dry summer when the water table drops. If your pond has a supply of water such as run off that replenishes the water, the water table around that pond would rise in that area due to the seepage from the pond.

You can artificially create an barrier so the pond won't dry up (concrete, plastic, clay, etc.). Clay works well to reduce seepage from the pond and its often used in garbage dumps to prevent seepage from the dump into ground water.

There is no reason you cannot have a square pond, but a curved bank is more stable, so the square would gradually reform into a circle and the straight sides would collapse in the middle where they are unsupported.

"water polarization" The term is surface tension and it doesn't really have anything to do with the topic at hand.
 
It might as it contributes to water shape and possibly the entrapment of these uber tiny particles that will eventually form the basin water barrier.
Regarding cube like ponds, its totally material dependant as to whether the walls will erode, and how fast that will happen, if ever.


But the topic of surface tension in the water/air barrier has always fascinated me, more so the lack of it in the Air/Vacuum interface. So thanks for indirectly bringing it up Yoga.

Without Water polarization I suspect mud could not form although I am guessing

I am not sure why water molecules bond but I had no idea it did not happen in a vacuum so it may be air pressure that causes it and not gravity but I believe water bonds to itself even when it is not surface water and water surface tension is just one example of this bonding

It is amazing how without simple things like this life would be so different we may not have evolved

The square pond in nature is hypothetical and I still say the shape of the pond is a major element to if and how fast the pond will fill with water (assuming it is above water table)

The other major factor is the material the earth is composed of
 
>Without Water polarization I suspect mud could not form although I am guessing

No. You can remove surface tension by adding soap to the water and you'll get even more mud because mud is supersaturated soil -- soap works by making water "wetter". The only possible relevance of surface tension would be is reducing the absorption of water by the humus (dead plant material) in the soil. Sandy soils would be porous anyway regardless of surface tension, and heavy clay soil would be hydrophobic regardless of surface tension.
 
Thanks nntsci, especially for telling me why dugout ponds want to be round. The repeated use of the term 'square pond' perfectly illustrates how much of this amusing diversion has circled around semantics and definitions. To say a pond is square is only to describe its surface shape (and why it would matter that it be square rather than rectangular I cannot fathom) and says nothing about its wall and bottom surfaces.

Likewise to ask why a filled pond stops seeping away before it reaches 'the water table' begs the question*. When it stops seeping is the local water table unless there's been some purposeful construction to prevent seepage. But if seepage has only been retarded and the WT is below, eventually—even if we're all long dead—it will all seep away. It only looks like it's stopped, perhaps because average rainfall tops it up, but it's still on the way down. There is no Absolute World-Wide Water Table, only what is generally the hydrological/geological case in a given area. When your pond stops seeping you are there.

*'Beg the question'-properly means arguing by assuming what you are supposed to be proving, although i often incorrectly use it to mean 'raises the question'. At last a chance to use it properly! Y F, you are assuming the water table is lying somewhere below this pond which has stopped seeping. If it truly has—and I take you at your word in your own question thread—you've just proven where that water table is. And it ain't down below.

But you guys are onto other hydro matters anyway., so I'll settle for the hobbyist's answer to the title question: Because they can.
 
Late at night, when no Humans are around, and usually a few hours before dawn so even the Owls are starting to return to their roosts, small gnomes make their way to the ponds from their homes with buckets and hoses and carefully fill the pond so all their frog and turtle friends have a place to live and play.
 
But most ponds seem to fill up near to the top then stop filling ... at that point they are well above the water table yet they kept filling with water

While no doubt some ponds are filled with some ground water I suspect a lot of ponds are big puddles and the reason the water does not sink is because the ponds are self insulating with mud

For example, my neighbor dug a small fish pond then filled it with water yet the water does not sink into the ground even though it is above water table

Ponds are a natural outcome of drainage...surface water drains into them from some larger area (larger than the pond surface itself)...so are formed by gravity acting on water.

They fill up, or stay full, because the amount of water coming into them exceeds the amount leaving them...either by surface drainage or by seepagae/drainage below.

They do not necessarily drain down to the level of the water table because the bottom of the pond is built of materials through which water does not flow quickly or easily. Or, in a few cases, they may be at the water tabel level if "spring fed".

Clay, as an example of one of the 3 main components of soil, is a very effective barrier to water movement. Pure clay can be used as a liner for ponds and virtually no water can flow through it...the only movement of water is by capillary action.

Silt and sand, the other two components of soil, conduct water both through capillary action and water flow. Soil, being made of all three of these, plus various organic materials, will allow varying degrees of water movement.

Your neighbor probably put a liner in his fish pond.
 
Ponds are a natural outcome of drainage...surface water drains into them from some larger area (larger than the pond surface itself)...so are formed by gravity acting on water.

They fill up, or stay full, because the amount of water coming into them exceeds the amount leaving them...either by surface drainage or by seepagae/drainage below.

They do not necessarily drain down to the level of the water table because the bottom of the pond is built of materials through which water does not flow quickly or easily. Or, in a few cases, they may be at the water tabel level if "spring fed".

Clay, as an example of one of the 3 main components of soil, is a very effective barrier to water movement. Pure clay can be used as a liner for ponds and virtually no water can flow through it...the only movement of water is by capillary action.

Silt and sand, the other two components of soil, conduct water both through capillary action and water flow. Soil, being made of all three of these, plus various organic materials, will allow varying degrees of water movement.

Your neighbor probably put a liner in his fish pond.

SO if clay is stopping the water why is not this the water table ? (this question is for ponds above the water table)

I say it is because the water would normally pass through but because the pond is u shaped the water floods the center of the pond when it rains and so much rain creates mud that greatly slows down the seepage

This accumilation effect remains until then water nears the top and the pond's u shape is all under water and at this point of zero accumilation ponds have a tendency to stabilize
 
To say a pond is square is only to describe its surface shape (and why it would matter that it be square rather than rectangular I cannot fathom) and says nothing about its wall and bottom surfaces.


I meant the pond is a 3 dimensional square

Because the bottom is flat and the sides are straight this hole will not fill with water because it has no slope

Slopes are essential for the water to collect to such a degree it creates permanent mud (assuming no major drought)

this mud stops seepage to the point that the water eventually fills the pond with rain water
 
North Pole said
>There are plenty of lakes and ponds above the water table, just visit the himalayas.

Bet you those ponds are not above the water table!

If they are entirely in rock then ok, but thats because rock is a barrier to seepage (though some will seep through faults and eventuallly forms caves, but I digress). But if the pond is in glacial till, the till up to the level of the lake and slightly higher due to capillery action is saturated with water (e.g., the water table). For some small glacial ponds, the gravel is so porus, they run out entirely through the gravel so that the glacial melt pond has no apparent outlet. There is a lake in Ontario that does that too (at Warsaw caves). The water runs out of a lake into a stream which then disappears under gravel only to emerge in a canyon a couple hundred feet away.

I think the problem is that some people do not understand where the water table is. Its typically is slightly higher than the level of any pond, river or lake you find. Key point here, the surface of a typically stable pond with no lining is below the water table. Water in the soil will be slightly higher then the surface of the pond. So odds are that unless a pond has been artificially lined with clay, plastic, or concrete, the level of that pond will be the level of the water table, and if it rains, the level of the water table will rise. If you add water to a pond, to fill it up, the level of the water table will rise. The neighbours fish pond is likely lined with plastic -- you can buy the plastic at Sheridan nursery and I think home depot. You can buy a whole fish pond kit. My wife wants me to build a pond. It must be lined with plastic or the fish may catch diseases from the soil.

What puzzles me the most about all this is why are people speculating about the water table and pond seepage on this web site, rather than going to the scientific literature on hydrology, geology, ground water, the water table, or similar topics. I mean its not like there is no scientific literature on the topic of the water table.
 
>Because the bottom is flat and the sides are straight this hole will not fill with water because it has no slope

it will fill with water if there is drainage into it, or if it is below the water table. A square whole will fill just as fast as any other shape hole. Mines are sometimes squarish, but if they stop pumping the water out, they will fill up with ground water pretty quickly.

The article I referred you befor recommends rectangles as a convenient shape for a pond that makes effecient use of space (a more efficient use of space than a round pond).
 
I meant the pond is a 3 dimensional square
Like Scrooge McDuck's three cubic acre money-bin? Actually I think you meant a pond with straight up and down sides—i.e. plumb— and a flat bottom, but it's hard to say. Your clarification actually suggests a dug-out cube, but why must all the sides be equal dimensions?

A pond which is specified simply as "square" can have a dished out bottom and sides (Imagine a handkerchief, pinned at the corners to a horizontal frame and bellying down. Why you keep specifying the sides be equal I cannot say. Isn't the real issue that the corners be square? And for that matter wouldn't your point below be the same for a cylindrical hole? That's why we have technical language.

Because the bottom is flat and the sides are straight this hole will not fill with water because it has no slope

Slopes are essential for the water to collect to such a degree it creates permanent mud (assuming no major drought)

this mud stops seepage to the point that the water eventually fills the pond with rain water
I'm not sure quite what this is meant to describe, but any time it rains a hole or depression in the ground will collect water, irrespective of its shape, or the slope of its sides. To me that means it will "…fill with water". Whether it then seeps away and how fast depends on what the underwater sides and bottom are composed of, not their shape. As was pointed out above, those straight sides at 90º vertical will tend to collapse in any case, if they're ordinary earth and eventually you'll have that round pond with sloping sides.

Anyone who has simply dug a rectangular hole with vertical sides—as for a basement—without bracing the sides has seen it happen. And anyone whose dug out or visited a quarry with no provision for drainage has seen shape is immaterial to water retention.
 
Actually I think you meant a pond with straight up and down sides—i.e. plumb— and a flat bottom,
.
Yes whether it is a rectangle or not could not possibly have relevance or it could be a cylinder hole with a flat bottom or a triangle hole with a flat bottom and straight sides or ....
I'm not sure quite what this is meant to describe, but any time it rains a hole or depression in the ground will collect water, irrespective of its shape, or the slope of its sides. To me that means it will "…fill with water". Whether it then seeps away and how fast depends on what the underwater sides and bottom are composed of, not their shape. As was pointed out above, those straight sides at 90º vertical will tend to collapse in any case, if they're ordinary earth and eventually you'll have that round pond with sloping sides.

Once again, if there is a slope of the sides and the bottom then more water will collect in one spot during a rain storm

This is essential as the ground will now become saturated ( assuming the soil is clay )before all the water can seep out so you now have a pond above the water table as the clay becomes a natural lining

If the bottom was flat then water would not collect in one spot meaning a much greater rain storm would be needed to saturate the clay before all the water seeped out
 
My wife wants me to build a pond. It must be lined with plastic or the fish may catch diseases from the soil.

What puzzles me the most about all this is why are people speculating about the water table and pond seepage on this web site, rather than going to the scientific literature on hydrology, geology, ground water, the water table, or similar topics. I mean its not like there is no scientific literature on the topic of the water table.

Because the type of pond I am describing is not mentioned - a pond above the water table such as on a farm, and they do exist because I dug one with a backhoe when I lived on a farm. When I dug the hole the bottom of the pond was empty IE no water table but the pond eventually filled with natural rain fall and the question is why does not that pond water seek the water table ?


Also, there is fish in that pond and it is not lined

The fish could get there without human intervention as a bird could shit out a fish egg but in this case I think they were put there by humans
 
Because the type of pond I am describing is not mentioned - a pond above the water table such as on a farm, and they do exist because I dug one with a backhoe when I lived on a farm. When I dug the hole the bottom of the pond was empty IE no water table but the pond eventually filled with natural rain fall and the question is why does not that pond water seek the water table ?


Also, there is fish in that pond and it is not lined

The fish could get there without human intervention as a bird could shit out a fish egg but in this case I think they were put there by humans

A pond with a gravel or sand bottom would not hold water. And water does flow down to wherever the water table is. If the pond retains water it is clear that the inflow is faster than the outflow...at least until it gets to a level at which it flows out somewhere else or it reaches equilibrium through water seeping out.

In Ontario there is more precipitation than evaporation. In some other places in Canada this is not true and the pond would dry out from evaporation throughout the summer...even if it did not leak.
 
>a pond above the water table such as on a farm, and they do exist because I dug one with a backhoe when I lived on a farm. When I dug the hole the bottom of the pond was empty IE no water table but the pond eventually filled with natural rain fall and the question is why does not that pond water seek the water table ?

The pond was not above the water table, the water table does not run quickly like a stream, it seeps. It will take time for it to fill because the water moves slowly through the soil unless the soil is very sandy. Secondly, when it rains the water table rises, and falls as the land dries out.
 
square ponds are created often for farming certain foods. and yes, they do fill up naturally.