Breaking a lease early :(

The misinformation on this board is mind boggling at times, hopefully those asking for opinions take everything with a grain of salt and for humour

lmao, wow its rare to find a lawyer practicing at the Landlord and Tenant court, it's mostly paralegals

in any case if that's your advise than I'd say you are a lousy lawyer

I rest my case. I've worked with lawyers numerous times on cases I can't handle, in fact I never used paralegals except to fight speeding tickets for me. If you're a serious landlord you don't fool around with dead beat tenants, use a good lawyer and it will save you time and money in the end.

btw Honeybee, I read that very same section of the L&T Act trying to help out a friend get out of the lease and Greenwin, the landlord, sent a lawyer's letter so fast it made your head spin.
 
I rest my case. I've worked with lawyers numerous times on cases I can't handle, in fact I never used paralegals except to fight speeding tickets for me. If you're a serious landlord you don't fool around with dead beat tenants, use a good lawyer and it will save you time and money in the end.

key point and good lawyers usually charge a hefty premium where a paralegal can do the same job at a much lesser cost

you don't normally find lawyers in landlord and tenant tribunal because it doesn't pay enough
 
key point and good lawyers usually charge a hefty premium where a paralegal can do the same job at a much lesser cost

you don't normally find lawyers in landlord and tenant tribunal because it doesn't pay enough

Of course you don't typically find lawyers at tribunals because good lawyers get the issues resolved before it gets to that point, that's why they save me time and money in the end. But that doesn't mean you don't find lawyers practicing landlord and tenant law but only paralegals, that's completely wrong.
 
it costs for a landlord to go to the L&T board. time and money. the ruling then would have to be pursued thru small claims court. do you really think any landlord will do that? with even a small risk of losing? I doubt it.

re: those small bar fridges. that's how they all work. not very well.
 
Honeybeeisfree,

You might want to consider how much further you want to embarrass yourself. I am also a lawyer. I don't do Landlord and Tenant law much anymore but I have done it in the past - mostly as a law student, like many, many other lawyers.

The one thing lawyers do is actually read. The OP did not say the mini fridge was not working - he/she said the Freezer component of the mini-fridge is not working. Given these freezers are generally big enough to hold about two trays of ice cubes the OP is not being deprived of alot of food storage space.

Second, try actually reading the material you post:

http://www.ltb.gov.on.ca/en/Key_Information/STEL02_111482.html

How a Tenant Can End a Tenancy

How much notice does a tenant have to give if they want to move out?

When a tenant decides to move, they must provide a written notice of termination to the landlord. In most cases, this is a 60-day notice. The termination date must be the last day of their rental period or their lease, even if this is more than 60 days.

...

Can a tenant break a lease?

Breaking a lease means that a tenant wants to leave their unit before their tenancy agreement is over. For example, a tenant who signed a one year lease might want to leave their unit in the eighth month.

A tenant and landlord can agree to break a lease. It is best for both parties if this agreement is in writing and is signed by the landlord and the tenant. If the landlord is not willing to break the lease, the tenant has the right to assign the unit to a new tenant with the landlord's consent.

Nowhere in your information does it say that a tenant, WHO IS SUBJECT TO A LEASE, can simply give 60 days notice and walk away from the lease.
 
I'm a super at a rental home, people in their mid 20s mostly.

So when I get called out for giving bad advice, I'm going to respond.


I was a student who was renting out for a long time as well, and I've yet to hear anyone get sued unless it was a full house rental. There are some houses in St. Catharines where you can rent out the whole house for about $950-$1,200. In those cases, an individual who breaks their lease say, 8 months before it's up, may get sued. However let me tell you about some instances of bad tenants.

Sure, the smart thing to do is a credit check and all that, but when you're in the business of renting out rooms, potential tenants are rarely kind enough to wait out the process when they're looking for a place. So all you do in most cases is get some references, multiple phone numbers and an alternate residence, all of which you can check out for yourself. What can happen is a tenant can give you post-dated cheques, leave abruptly and then you find out all the numbers are now not in service, the alternate residence is owned by another individual and the bank is looking for this guy too. Good luck suing someone you have to catch.

Honestly, it's incredibly easy to screw over a landlord and in most cases the landlord will simply try and find another tenant as soon as possible instead of wasting their time tracking you down. Moving to another province would be ideal if you're completely paranoid.


Now when I was a student renting rooms, I use to sign 8-12 month leases and I had the option in all of them to break the lease 60 days in advance. That is the status quoa just like if you're the landlord you can kick out a tenant with 90 days notice for personal reasons or 60 days notice for persistent late payment.


And this is of course, Ontario, where tenants have way too many rights as it is. So if you want to leave a place, give 60 days notice, that way they cannot kick you out before then anyway and you give them a fair head start on finding a replacement tenant. You will not have any problems, and if your landlord tries to pull some bull, you give them the notice anyway and do as you would.
 
thanks for the replies.
for the record. I am not trying or going to screw over my landlord. he seems like a very nice person. its mostly the noise that keeps me up at night that is mostly the problem, like a freaking dog barking at midnight
 
Honeybeeisfree,

You might want to consider how much further you want to embarrass yourself. I am also a lawyer. I don't do Landlord and Tenant law much anymore but I have done it in the past - mostly as a law student, like many, many other lawyers.

The one thing lawyers do is actually read. The OP did not say the mini fridge was not working - he/she said the Freezer component of the mini-fridge is not working. Given these freezers are generally big enough to hold about two trays of ice cubes the OP is not being deprived of alot of food storage space.

Second, try actually reading the material you post:



Nowhere in your information does it say that a tenant, WHO IS SUBJECT TO A LEASE, can simply give 60 days notice and walk away from the lease.
http://www.ltb.gov.on.ca/en/Key_Information/STEL02_111482.html
Can a tenant break a lease?

Breaking a lease means that a tenant wants to leave their unit before their tenancy agreement is over. For example, a tenant who signed a one year lease might want to leave their unit in the eighth month.

A tenant and landlord can agree to break a lease. It is best for both parties if this agreement is in writing and is signed by the landlord and the tenant. If the landlord is not willing to break the lease, the tenant has the right to assign the unit to a new tenant with the landlord's consent.


You guys read but often don't comprehend. I've beaten lawyers with well over 30 years experience in LLT. This flucken clown who represented my former landlord said at the tribunal: "I object to the affidavit, as I haven't seen it." The member says "frankly, thats your clients affidavit" omg I was literally rolling on the floor laughing my guts out.

At the end of the day the landlord had to pay me $8800. So I guess I knew the RTA law much better than a LAWYER with 30+ years experience.
 
The OP sounds like he is in a house that has been divided into multiple rental rooms? If parts of the house are shared, then it may not fall under the Residential Tenancies Act. Required notice could be different depending on the situation.

If the house has been divided up into rental units. Is it legal, taxed? If not, then the OP could just tell the landlord he is uncomfortable living in this situation, and work out an agreement to terminate.
 
The OP sounds like he is in a house that has been divided into multiple rental rooms? If parts of the house are shared, then it may not fall under the Residential Tenancies Act. Required notice could be different depending on the situation.

If the house has been divided up into rental units. Is it legal, taxed? If not, then the OP could just tell the landlord he is uncomfortable living in this situation, and work out an agreement to terminate.

You are exactly right, that's why I asked if its a rooming house. Otherwise if you can hear your neighbours as he does, the unit is possibly illegal. Building standards state all must be soundproof.
 
honeybee, you need to read and understand the entire paragraph....
what it's saying is a lease can be broken by mutual consent , and that a tenant can assign the unit to a new tenant... with the consent of the landlord.... that's a far cry from the "Tenant being able to break the lease"
h....... [B]A tenant and landlord c...h the landlord's consent[/U].[/b] .[/QUOTE]
 
Assuming the property OP is in has been divided up into rental units, and the units are not legal, in that they do not meet fire code, zoning, etc.

Is the rental agreement enforceable? There is something in law about not being able to enforce a contract that binds someone to something that is not legal.
 
But the legal question of quiet enjoyment (or whatever it is called now) being grounds to terminate?

Unreasonable interference with quiet enjoyment can absolutely be grounds to terminate a lease. However the issue is that the tenant cannot unilaterally decide that their quiet enjoyment has been interfered with and decide to end their tenancy. They have to apply to the Tribunal for an Order terminating the lease. The Tribunal may grant the Order or may decide that a less severe remedy (e.g., rent abatement) is appropriate in the circumstances. Or they may decide the tenant is just looking for an excuse to get out of his/her lease. In this regard the Tribunal has held landlords responsible for the conduct of other tenants (e.g., loud music, drums, etc.) and for repairs / renovations being conducted in a manner that interfered with quiet use and enjoyment of a rental unit.
 
I would say it makes a difference if she is renting from a landlord is simply renting one property rather than Greenwin or major property mgmt company.

Sometimes the lawyers on TERB apply the legal letter of the law. Real life can sometimes be different. Sometimes landlords have little interest in going to Tribunal and will just find another tenant. Or perhaps the tenant above is behind in rent and this will be an added push to get them out. Hard to give specific info for a situation without knowing all the facts.

Klute