Breaking a lease early :(

amaya777

Member
Jan 11, 2005
216
0
16
Cambridge
I would like to know if these are good enough reasons for breaking a lease early.
1. the freezer on the mini fridge does not really work, so i cant keep things there cuase im afraid to get sick from food going bad.
2. I was told it would be quite after 10:30pm but i can hear them talking loud(not everyday) and walking around and i cant sleep when that happens.
other than that its good. but those two are important to me.
any input either way would be appreciated. thanks
 
Tell them nicely to have the fridge fixed and don't be afraid to tell them about the noise problem also. You have a right to not be disturbed after 10pm. Hopefully they're considerate people who will understand your situation and adjust. If they don't heed, call the cops next time they make a noise. If they still continue, then proceed with breaking the lease.
 
I would like to know if these are good enough reasons for breaking a lease early.
1. the freezer on the mini fridge does not really work, so i cant keep things there cuase im afraid to get sick from food going bad.
2. I was told it would be quite after 10:30pm but i can hear them talking loud(not everyday) and walking around and i cant sleep when that happens.
other than that its good. but those two are important to me.
any input either way would be appreciated. thanks

You can break the lease for any reason you want to, as long as you give your landlord the appropriate notice.
Do you live in a rooming house?
Noise complaints are not valid until after 11pm.
for more information read here:
http://www.ltb.gov.on.ca
 
mini fridge?

They cost about $200 go get yourself one that works.
 
Actually, I've called in noise complaints for my neighbours at all times of the day and night. The police have always responded (sometimes very slowly, though) and they have told me that there is no particular time at which a complaint is valid or not valid.

Edit: You should clarify the noise complaint situation in your area by calling the local police station. I'm in the City of Toronto so my experience may not be applicable to your area.
 
I would like to know if these are good enough reasons for breaking a lease early.
1. the freezer on the mini fridge does not really work, so i cant keep things there cuase im afraid to get sick from food going bad.
2. I was told it would be quite after 10:30pm but i can hear them talking loud(not everyday) and walking around and i cant sleep when that happens.
other than that its good. but those two are important to me.
any input either way would be appreciated. thanks

No reason at all for breaking your lease. Get the ll to fix the fridge. Write him a letter.

If the place still drives you crazy, see if the ll will let you move out on agreed upon notice.
 
No reason at all for breaking your lease. Get the ll to fix the fridge. Write him a letter.

If the place still drives you crazy, see if the ll will let you move out on agreed upon notice.

This, sends request in writing to have the fridge fixed, and allow him a reasonable (two week days)amount of time to fix it. If your not month to month you have to stay until the end of your term, and serve your landlord 60 days notice from the day your rent it normally due.
 
Ontario Landlord and Tenant Act will stipulate that you can break your lease with a 60 day notice.

You can give most any reason for breaking your lease, as long as it's halfway decent. Things such as noise can be used but as said, if it's before 11p.m. then you might not have much of a case.

In terms of the fridge, if it's stipulated under the lease agreement as an amenity, then maybe you can ask the landlord to fix it. Generally speaking a fridge is not mandatory but if it's listed then they should address it. Most places have full fridges to begin with so a mini fridge for them shouldn't be a big deal, although don't expect them to buy you a brand new one.

It also depends what you're paying them and it seems like you're living in a basement apartment? If you're getting a good deal I'd suck it up. If you're paying the standard rental price in your area it may be time to find a better place. Maybe one where it's an entire rental home or find a person to share an apartment.
 
as a tenant in ontario, you can pretty well do anything you want. your reasons seem petty to me but if you want to leave, give them notice that you will be out September 1st. they will say "but we have a lease!", but in the end the landlord is powerless. don't be using them as a reference.
 
I used to rent a very nice basement apartment in a brand new house for a pretty good price and was inclusive of all bills except internet. The tenant above me was a nightmare, when he was home, every few minutes there was a bang on the floor and at night he would snore so loud you could hear it down the road. He also was a big fat ass so he spoke like a giant and you could hear it all through the house.

I never complained and just tolerated it because in my experience complaining just makes things worse, I still don't know what the bang was but it stopped after he moved out. When he moved out I was in heaven for the last few months I stayed there. The landlord was a Chinese woman who couldn't speak English and was never home anyway, and I don't think the police would say anything to the guy for snoring.
 
Err, I'm a lawyer and I practice Landlord and Tenant law. You cannot just give 60 days' notice and break the lease. You will get sued if you break the lease and move out. Try it.

When you're hit for thousands of $$ in damages by the L&T adjudicator, you can tell him "the guys on TERB told me I could do this".
 
Err, I'm a lawyer and I practice Landlord and Tenant law. You cannot just give 60 days' notice and break the lease. You will get sued if you break the lease and move out. Try it.

Glad to hear this. I was reading all of the advice above and (as a former landlord), I kept thinking, ahhh, nope, that's not right.

The whole point of a lease is to commit both parties for the term of the lease. Unless there is an egregious violation from one party or the other, you're stuck.

Having said this, it might be that the landlord would be fine with you leaving, assuming you "negotiate" this departure and perhaps pay a penalty of some sort. I would be inclined to try a "friendly" discussion first. I don't think a noisy mini-fridge or somewhat noisy neighbours is going to be much of an excuse.
 
The misinformation on this board is mind boggling at times, hopefully those asking for opinions take everything with a grain of salt and for humour, and then get some real professional input. As a landlord for over a decade with hundreds of tenants to manage I've seen it all, nothing surprises me anymore. We need a lot more info to respond than just the few points the OP makes, it's not that cut and dry to respond to, it never is.
 
Err, I'm a lawyer and I practice Landlord and Tenant law. You cannot just give 60 days' notice and break the lease. You will get sued if you break the lease and move out. Try it.

When you're hit for thousands of $$ in damages by the L&T adjudicator, you can tell him "the guys on TERB told me I could do this".

lmao, wow its rare to find a lawyer practicing at the Landlord and Tenant court, it's mostly paralegals

in any case if that's your advise than I'd say you are a lousy lawyer


www.ltb.gov.on.ca/
 
Glad to hear this. I was reading all of the advice above and (as a former landlord), I kept thinking, ahhh, nope, that's not right.

The whole point of a lease is to commit both parties for the term of the lease. Unless there is an egregious violation from one party or the other, you're stuck.

Having said this, it might be that the landlord would be fine with you leaving, assuming you "negotiate" this departure and perhaps pay a penalty of some sort. I would be inclined to try a "friendly" discussion first. I don't think a noisy mini-fridge or somewhat noisy neighbours is going to be much of an excuse.

Pretty much what Stoo says.
 
lmao, wow its rare to find a lawyer practicing at the Landlord and Tenant court, it's mostly paralegals

in any case if that's your advise than I'd say you are a lousy lawyer


www.ltb.gov.on.ca/

I used to practice L&T law and some of my friends still do. I would agree with oagre's position. And having read the complaints in the OP I would be surprised if a hearing officer would find they are sufficient to terminate a lease prematurely.
 
lmao, wow its rare to find a lawyer practicing at the Landlord and Tenant court, it's mostly paralegals

in any case if that's your advise than I'd say you are a lousy lawyer


www.ltb.gov.on.ca/

Sure, Sweetie. You read the "one size fits all" information blurb on the website for 15 seconds, misinterpreted it and now you get to shoot off your fat-ass mouth and tell the lawyer (with 30 years' experience) that he's wrong.

You rock.
 
I used to practice L&T law and some of my friends still do. I would agree with oagre's position. And having read the complaints in the OP I would be surprised if a hearing officer would find they are sufficient to terminate a lease prematurely.

if the fridge doesn't work, where is the OP supposed to store his food?
 
Sure, Sweetie. You read the "one size fits all" information blurb on the website for 15 seconds, misinterpreted it and now you get to shoot off your fat-ass mouth and tell the lawyer (with 30 years' experience) that he's wrong.

You rock.

omg 30 years experience and you still don't know the RTA

http://www.ltb.gov.on.ca/en/Key_Information/STEL02_111482.html

How a Tenant Can End a Tenancy

How much notice does a tenant have to give if they want to move out?

When a tenant decides to move, they must provide a written notice of termination to the landlord. In most cases, this is a 60-day notice. The termination date must be the last day of their rental period or their lease, even if this is more than 60 days.

For example, if it is a monthly tenancy that begins on the first day of each month and the tenant gives the landlord notice on June 15th, the termination date would be August 31.

In the case of a weekly tenancy, the tenant must give the landlord at least 28 days notice before the last day of the final week of the tenancy.

If the tenant pays rent on a daily basis, 28 days is also required.

For more information, see the brochure on How a Tenant can End Their Tenancy.

Can a tenant break a lease?

Breaking a lease means that a tenant wants to leave their unit before their tenancy agreement is over. For example, a tenant who signed a one year lease might want to leave their unit in the eighth month.

A tenant and landlord can agree to break a lease. It is best for both parties if this agreement is in writing and is signed by the landlord and the tenant. If the landlord is not willing to break the lease, the tenant has the right to assign the unit to a new tenant with the landlord's consent.

For more information see the brochure on How a Tenant can End Their Tenancy.

What is the difference between assigning and subletting a unit?

Assigning a unit means that the tenant moves out of the unit permanently and transfers their tenancy to another person. All the terms of the original rental agreement stay the same – the amount of the rent and what services are included etc. For more information about the rules for assigning a tenancy, see our brochure on How a Tenant Can End Their Tenancy.

Subletting a unit means that the tenant moves out of their unit for a specific period of time but the tenant plans to move back into the unit before the end of the tenancy. The person who moves in is known as a subtenant. They are responsible to pay the rent to the original tenant who then pays it to the landlord. A landlord cannot refuse the idea of subletting the unit, but they can refuse to allow the tenant to sublet to a specific person if they have a good reason.

How can a tenant sublet their unit?

If a tenant has to leave their unit for an extended period of time but they want to return to it, they can ask their landlord for consent to sublet the unit. For example, if a tenant’s job is being transferred to another city for six months and then they want to return to their unit, they might ask their landlord if they can sublet the unit. They must tell the landlord when they are leaving and when they will be returning to the unit, and they must get the landlord’s consent before subletting.

A landlord cannot refuse the idea of subletting a unit, but they can refuse a specific person if they believe the person is unsuitable. However, if the tenant thinks that the landlord is being unreasonable in withholding their consent to sublet to someone, the tenant can file an application with the Board.

The application that a tenant may file is the Application About a Sublet or an Assignment (Form A2).

What happens if a tenant assigns or sublets their unit without the landlord’s consent?

If a tenant assigns or sublets their unit without their landlord’s consent, it is an unauthorized assignment or sublet. A landlord can file an application with the Board to evict both the tenant and the unauthorized occupant. However, if the landlord does not file the application within 60 days of discovering the unauthorized occupant, the unauthorized occupant will become a tenant.

The application that a landlord may file is the Application About a Sublet or an Assignment (Form A2).