The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

Having the queen on our money? No biggie. I would rather have her than dead prime ministers - IMHO I would prefer to have Canadians who genuinely cared about this country on our money, people like John Candy.

I think I'd prefer dead PM's, sadly I can only recognize Sir John A, and although I don't recognize him I know Sir Robert Boredom in on the 100, and of course Elton John from the 20.

There is enough ignorance of history as it is, not that the bills help much but having the first, and the two war time dudes on the bills isn't a bad thing. [OK the two real wars]

However if they were to replace any of them or King and Laurier with Trudeau, I would not like that very much. Bad enough they changed the name of the Dorval airport to Cunty McCunt Bag air port.

As for other people, you know "they" would fuck it up. Instead of having folks like Banting and Best or the Rocket they would probably put a bunch of unknown PC asswads on the bills. Oh look our hundred has the first black disabled dude who went ass to mouth in a bathhouse on an Indian reserve... ohh I feel all fuzzy inside. Perish the thought.


265px-Canadian_bills2.jpg
 
I think I'd prefer dead PM's, sadly I can only recognize Sir John A, and although I don't recognize him I know Sir Robert Boredom in on the 100, and of course Elton John from the 20.

There is enough ignorance of history as it is, not that the bills help much but having the first, and the two war time dudes on the bills isn't a bad thing. [OK the two real wars]

However if they were to replace any of them or King and Laurier with Trudeau, I would not like that very much. Bad enough they changed the name of the Dorval airport to Cunty McCunt Bag air port.

As for other people, you know "they" would fuck it up. Instead of having folks like Banting and Best or the Rocket they would probably put a bunch of unknown PC asswads on the bills. Oh look our hundred has the first black disabled dude who went ass to mouth in a bathhouse on an Indian reserve... ohh I feel all fuzzy inside. Perish the thought.


265px-Canadian_bills2.jpg
It's fucked up now, with Elizabeth's out of date visage on our money.
And the queen has done nothing to deserve this honour. We'd be better off putting pictures of random Canadians who actually live (or lived) here on our money than the face of some foreign monarch.
 
The monarchy is part of Canadian history. I for one do not want to forgo that history.

God save the Queen.
As a fan of history I'd much prefer to read about how, in the year 2012 we began the political negotiations which would culminate in finally gaining independence rather than, in 2015 or whenever, Canada bent over, took it up the ass again from the outmoded British monarchy, and meekly and humbly welcomed undeserving King Charles as the new head of state.
 
Last edited:
As a fan of history I'd much prefer to read about how, in the year 2012 we began the political negotiations which would culminate in finally gaining independence rather than, in 2015 or whenever, Canada bent over, took it up the ass again from the outmoded British monarchy, and meekly and humbly welcomed undeserving King Charles as the new head of state.

You should probably go back to school and study history. We gained independence long ago.
 
As a fan of history I'd much prefer to read about how, in the year 2012 we began the political negotiations which would culminate in finally gaining independence rather than, in 2015 or whenever, Canada bent over, took it up the ass again from the outmoded British monarchy, and meekly and humbly welcomed undeserving King Charles as the new head of state.
Somehow I missed how Canada is not a fully and completely independent state. Further, amazingly enough I know to folks from Toronto, there are siginificant portions of Canada where the monarchy is honoured.
 
The Queen herself?

Nothing.

Canada only picks up the cost for the Queen when she visits Canada.

The cost of the framework (i.e. the Governor General, overhead, etc.) - $1.50 a head.
Not that we'll save a penny with any other arrangement. The more relevant question would be: What meaning and significance would attach to the new Head of State, elected to be as powerless and symbolic as the now retired monarchy, but without any of the history, whether personal or national?

Essentially all we'd be doing is re-titling the GG and picking the lucky devil some other way. But losing our connection with centuries of history. Whoopee!

For all those who can see His Excellency David Johnston in their dreams, I guess that's no loss, but it would be for all the rest of us, fairy-tale though such things as Heads of State may be.
 
It is amazing, that all in favour of the monarchy here neglect to comment on the major point in the article, namely:

"In the 21st century, it is unfathomable that Canada, a modern, multicultural nation that champions diversity, still tolerates having a foreign queen or king as its head of state. "

All the arguments that are dragged out of the barn in favour of the monarchy are about cost. Obviously, principles matter not.

If canadians are so enamored of a monarchy, why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. let us rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.
 
It is amazing, that all in favour of the monarchy here neglect to comment on the major point in the article, namely:

"In the 21st century, it is unfathomable that Canada, a modern, multicultural nation that champions diversity, still tolerates having a foreign queen or king as its head of state. "

All the arguments that are dragged out of the barn in favour of the monarchy are about cost. Obviously, principles matter not.

If canadians are so enamored of a monarchy, why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. let us rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.

Sorry Dan, we are not going to make you king.
 
It is amazing, that all in favour of the monarchy here neglect to comment on the major point in the article, namely:

"In the 21st century, it is unfathomable that Canada, a modern, multicultural nation that champions diversity, still tolerates having a foreign queen or king as its head of state. "

All the arguments that are dragged out of the barn in favour of the monarchy are about cost. Obviously, principles matter not.

If canadians are so enamored of a monarchy, why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. let us rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.

Perhaps because the articles main point is not unfathomable to many here, just the writer, you, and a couple of others. We have a Canadian monarch, just not one to your liking. She's not unemployed nor is she a parasite, which has been proven many times in the past but you keep shouting it from your soapbox. We have many vestiges of our colonial past, first and foremost our parliamentary system of government. Shall we throw that out to for a made in Canada system? It's not the colonial connection you don't like,m it's just the monarchy.
 
We have many vestiges of our colonial past, first and foremost our parliamentary system.
Frankly I believe a Westminster style Parliament is at least in theory far more problematic than the Monarchy.






n.b. For those with problems reading. I nether wrote or implied that I have a problem with either democracy or constitutional monarchy.
 
danmand said:
It is amazing, that all in favour of the monarchy here neglect to comment on the major point in the article, namely:

"In the 21st century, it is unfathomable that Canada, a modern, multicultural nation that champions diversity, still tolerates having a foreign queen or king as its head of state. "
Quite an anti-diversity opinion from the quoted writer—fitting for the XIXthC days of 'No English or Irish need Apply' signs. Not to mention entirely entirely self-contradictory.

In a country as diverse as ours I meet and deal with other nationalities all the time and their differences enrich us all; why does the nationality* of someone in a ceremonial job matter? It's a greater priority for me to see only Canadians on our movie and TV screens, although they too are just symbols. The debate worth having would be about getting all the writers behind those symbols, and the politicians behind the symbol of the monarchy to express a Canadian point of view, rather than aping what they imagine Americans think.

To that end, the longer we hang onto any and all visible differences, the better. Vive la reine.

*We could have a long and foolish debate about the technical citizenship of the monarch to whom every new citizen of this country, and every serving officer swears allegiance. If it really mattered in any real way, she could be granted a certificate of Canadian citizenship as fast as the ink could dry on the papers; we did it for Mandela. But it does not matter, and to reduce the entire matter of our Head of State to a person's nationality of birth, smacks of prejudice and racism of the crudest kind, whether yesterday's KKK or today's birthers. It demeans all Canadians who were born elsewhere and the very idea of the citizenship they earned.
 
It's fucked up now, with Elizabeth's out of date visage on our money.
.

Not to dispute the point, but there is a new 20 coming out soon. Perhaps they will use a new pic.

At least get a canadian king.

We had one in the 70's
A036986.jpg


Quite an anti-diversity opinion from the quoted writer—fitting for the XIXthC days of 'No English or Irish need Apply' signs.

Lot of No English need apply signs in the 19th century? Really? Perhaps today in Quebec although it is more implied then explicit except of course for the wording of bill 101


As for this
"*We could have a long and foolish debate about the technical citizenship of the monarch to whom every new citizen of this country, and every serving officer swears allegiance. If it really mattered in any real way, she could be granted a certificate of Canadian citizenship as fast as the ink could dry on the papers; we did it for Mandela. But it does not matter, and to reduce the entire matter of our Head of State to a person's nationality of birth, smacks of prejudice and racism of the crudest kind, whether yesterday's KKK or today's birthers. It demeans all Canadians who were born elsewhere and the very idea of the citizenship they earned. "

It just shows how cheap citizenship is. There is a big difference between citizenship and nationality. The government of Denmark can give me citizenship but it won't turn me into a Dane, it won't reverse over 40 years of living in the great white north, drinking beer, eating back bacon, saying eh and apologizing for everything. [all praise Jebus].

Liz isn't Canadian, the government can no more turn her into one then my mother can turn herself into a tractor or a dude can turn himself into a chick with some labeling.

As for comparing the KKK to the Birthers, nice, but you do know that there is a legal requirement for the US prez to be born in the US. Call the law bullocks if you want, and I am sure Arnold would agree, but it is still a thing.
 
Quite an anti-diversity opinion from the quoted writer—fitting for the XIXthC days of 'No English or Irish need Apply' signs. Not to mention entirely entirely self-contradictory.

In a country as diverse as ours I meet and deal with other nationalities all the time and their differences enrich us all; why does the nationality* of someone in a ceremonial job matter? It's a greater priority for me to see only Canadians on our movie and TV screens, although they too are just symbols. The debate worth having would be about getting all the writers behind those symbols, and the politicians behind the symbol of the monarchy to express a Canadian point of view, rather than aping what they imagine Americans think.

To that end, the longer we hang onto any and all visible differences, the better. Vive la reine.

*We could have a long and foolish debate about the technical citizenship of the monarch to whom every new citizen of this country, and every serving officer swears allegiance. If it really mattered in any real way, she could be granted a certificate of Canadian citizenship as fast as the ink could dry on the papers; we did it for Mandela. But it does not matter, and to reduce the entire matter of our Head of State to a person's nationality of birth, smacks of prejudice and racism of the crudest kind, whether yesterday's KKK or today's birthers. It demeans all Canadians who were born elsewhere and the very idea of the citizenship they earned.

Nice dancing around the issue of having a foreign monarch. Why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere, from the junchers of Windsor if the population prefers. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. Let the canadian monarchists rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.
 
Nice dancing around the issue of having a foreign monarch. Why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere, from the junchers of Windsor if the population prefers. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. Let the canadian monarchists rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.
As we all know the Queen is in fact of German extraction. Nor is she the first foreign national in that line. I thought we modern folk were supposed to be above all that old-fashioned prejudice. As the old-fashioned folk of the past managed reasonably well to be, apparently.

Not that I cannot imagine a 'made-in Canada' monarchy of some kind, but after the last constitutional debacle, where a reasonable proposal for change got swamped in everybody's personal Kitchen Sink Toss, I'll stay firmly for no change until the your King Canuck bandwagon's rolling strong. I you care, my personal preference would be the chosen Grand Chief of the Assembly of First Nations as Canadian Head of State.

We mustn't forget that one casus belli in 1812 was the British conviction that a British subject born could not ever cease to be one, stood up against the novel American concept that 'naturalization' made one a citizen as good as being born one. Of course when it came to their monarchy/presidency the Americans caved and did indeep put a 'natural-born' requirement in their Constitution. They soon had to qualify that, because it excluded children of military and diplomatic officers posted abroad. While MacArthur could have run for President using that loophole, many is the qualified naturalized citizen who could not. Nor can we ever forget that for almost its entire first century, the US excluded all slaves from citizenship no matter where born. Whether a former slave born into that condition who was recognized as a citizen after the Civil War would be considered 'a natural-born citizen' I cannot say. But I can say that, although the birthers may have a point in law—as FatOne says, "It is a thing"—their ethical and logical grounds are as shaky as their forefathers were.

And, with no relevance to the Queann at all, their evidence is as phony as Yankee Doodle's macaroni.
 
Nice dancing around the issue of having a foreign monarch. Why not create a canadian king. In the best european tradition, it is not hard to find an "unemployed" prince somewhere, from the junchers of Windsor if the population prefers. At least get a canadian king. and get rid of the last vestige of a colonial past. Let the canadian monarchists rejoice in our own parasite, instead of one from afar.

No dance, she is the Queen of Canada and will be till dies or stands down. She may not be a Canadian, but there is no requirement that she be one to be our monarch. Get the law changed and then get back to us. You can't even be interested enough to post something original as you've just C&P another post of yours from earlier, see post #30. Talk about lazy.
 
The monarchy is part of Canadian history. I for one do not want to forgo that history.

God save the Queen.

And it will still be apart of Canadian history regardless of whether we drop them or not.
I cannot stand being apart of them in anyway.

I am Canadian ... period.
 
Let it be known. Danmand hates:

America
Conservatives
England
The British monarchy

Funny thing he's Danish, he has absolutely no stake in Canada or England whatsoever
 
Let it be known. Danmand hates:

America
Conservatives
England
The British monarchy

Funny thing he's Danish, he has absolutely no stake in Canada or England whatsoever

Do remember DM was sent by his bosses in Denmark to the land of snow, ice, and igloos. I wonder who he pissed off, but then I don't for a second think he said, hell I'm not going to that backwater country.