The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

Published On Wed May 30 2012


By Bob HepburnEditorial Page






God save the Queen!

That famous cheer will ring out across England this weekend as the country stages massive Diamond Jubilee celebrations marking Queen Elizabeth’s 60 years on the throne.

In Canada, many of us will watch the televised festivities as a gesture of affection — even loyalty in some cases — for the woman who has served with distinction as the Queen of Canada.

For most of her reign, the Queen has been a symbol of stability, dedication and continuity.

But with her reign nearing an end, the time is right for Canadians to start the process of cutting our formal ties to the British monarchy, an outmoded institution that dates back to the days when Canada was a British colony.

It’s obvious why we need to begin the process now, rather than after the Queen is no longer on the throne.

When the Queen dies, her successor, likely Prince Charles, will be proclaimed King of Canada within hours — not days, weeks or months later. That’s what happened when Elizabeth succeeded her father, King George VI, when he died on Feb. 6, 1952.

Once that occurs, Canada will be stuck with yet another foreign monarch as our head of state, possibly for decades.

In the 21st century, it is unfathomable that Canada, a modern, multicultural nation that champions diversity, still tolerates having a foreign queen or king as its head of state.

It’s especially true when you realize that no Canadian will be our next head of state, no Catholic, no Jew, no Muslim, no woman and definitely no one who isn’t a member of the Church of England. In fact, Canada is one of only a handful of countries that has absolutely no voice in who will be its next head of state.

At the same time, we still force new citizens to swear or affirm loyalty to the Queen and her heirs and have her face adorn our coins. And Canadian women are expected to curtsey — a ridiculous custom — whenever they are introduced formally to her.

The reality is that the monarchy in modern-day Canada has been reduced to little more than a royal soap opera, a “Royal Coronation Street” if you like. Princes and princesses are revered and treated like pop-culture celebrities, with adoring fans following their ups and downs as they do with Kim Kardashian or Justin Bieber, although I bet Bieber would attract a far larger crowd anywhere in Canada than the Queen or the next king.

Over the years, small efforts to rid us of the monarchy have all faltered, including a bid last January by the federal Liberal party’s youth wing, which proposed a policy resolution for an elected head of state.

Now, however, with the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee coming to an end, it’s the perfect time to look seriously at how best to cut our colonial ties.

Michael Bliss, a retired University of Toronto history professor, wrote recently that “a government seriously in tune with the long-term evolution of the country would be quietly laying the groundwork for a dignified phasing out of the monarchy, the last relic of our colonialism.”

A three-step process should be considered.

First, Ottawa should hold a national referendum on a Yes-or-No question: “Should Canada sever ties with the British monarchy?” A simple majority would be sufficient to proceed further.

Second, if the answer is yes, a federal commission (please don’t call it a “royal commission”) should examine how we could select a head of state. The commission, with a one-year mandate, could be appointed jointly by the prime minister and provincial premiers. The commission could look at various models for choosing a head of state, such as direct election or appointment by the federal Parliament.

Third, a second referendum would be held on the commission’s top two recommended methods of choosing the next head of state.

The entire process, including the formality of each province agreeing to the necessary constitutional amendments, should take just two years.

Once completed, Ottawa could delay any formal severing of ties until the Queen died. That would show respect for the Queen, who has served us graciously — and save us from scraping and bowing to the next King of Canada.

Bob Hepburn’s column appears Thursday. bhepburn@thestar.ca
 
Once completed, Ottawa could delay any formal severing of ties until the Queen died. That would show respect for the Queen, who has served us graciously — and save us from scraping and bowing to the next King of Canada.

Bob Hepburn’s column appears Thursday. bhepburn@thestar.ca

You can sure tell he is a historian not a constitutional scholar.

And for the record, while I have sworn an oath to this Queen I have never scraped and/or bowed to her, nor do I recall be asked to. Pity he had to try and colour the waters with such childish purple prose.
 
Typical Star nonsensical communist verbal diarrhea
 
You can sure tell he is a historian not a constitutional scholar.

And for the record, while I have sworn an oath to this Queen I have never scraped and/or bowed to her, nor do I recall be asked to. Pity he had to try and colour the waters with such childish purple prose.

About as knowledgeable as DM is on this matter. She is not a foreign Queen. She is the Queen of Canada.
 
How much does it cost to have the Queen as our head of state?

The Queen herself?

Nothing.

Canada only picks up the cost for the Queen when she visits Canada.

The cost of the framework (i.e. the Governor General, overhead, etc.) - $1.50 a head.
 
The monarchy is part of Canadian history. I for one do not want to forgo that history.

God save the Queen.
 
So, the author is ok with the Queen, but has a problem with Chuck? Makes no sense to me....a monarch is a monarch.

There would be no Canada without Britain & that includes the Crown. It behooves us to remember what happened 200 years ago.
 
So, the author is ok with the Queen, but has a problem with Chuck? Makes no sense to me....a monarch is a monarch.

There would be no Canada without Britain & that includes the Crown. It behooves us to remember what happened 200 years ago.

Maybe he's shorter than Prince Charles and tired of looking up at him all the time.
 
You can sure tell he is a historian not a constitutional scholar.

And for the record, while I have sworn an oath to this Queen I have never scraped and/or bowed to her, nor do I recall be asked to. Pity he had to try and colour the waters with such childish purple prose.
You covered this well enough that there is a serious temptation just to leave it as is.

Certainly Danmand should know the requirements, even if Bob Hepburn didn't bother to research them, they have been pointed out here on Terb a number of times.

Unlike Continental Monarchies all we (men) do is deeply nod and I have.
 
Last edited:
The Queen herself?

Nothing.

Canada only picks up the cost for the Queen when she visits

The cost of the framework (i.e. the Governor General, overhead, etc.) - $1.50 a head.[/QUOTE

Can we keep the Queen but get rid of the frAmework and overhead? We can they'll her that we have to dowsize
 
I hate the queen of England, can't stand seeing her undeserving nonnative mug on our money, have no allegiance to her or the rest of her family of inbred layabouts, and wish we severed the ties to the foreign British monarchy back in 67 when our country was displaying a bit of national pride.

I'm actually quite shocked there are terbites who are afraid for Canada to let go of her skirt and stand on our own.

It's bad enough our senate is appointed, not elected but she didn't even do any work at all for her position as our head of state, that was simply undeserved nepotism.

james t kirk said:
The monarchy is part of Canadian history. I for one do not want to forgo that history.

God save the Queen.
There are many parts of history to remember but put in the past. I don't see many people saying, "God save the Indian residential schools".
 
I don't say this very often, but I agree with Bob Hepburn (maybe it's easier to say I agree with Michael Bliss. :)).
 
The monarchy is part of Canadian history. I for one do not want to forgo that history.

Personally not a fan of the monarchy, but agree with Kirk.

It's a little cost to the taxpayer, and more than likely generates more than enough tax revenue through merchandise sales, travel, etc. to cover any costs.

However it is a BIG thing to many people, both young and old. The hoopla surrounding the recent wedding was evidence of that.

Having the queen on our money? No biggie. I would rather have her than dead prime ministers - IMHO I would prefer to have Canadians who genuinely cared about this country on our money, people like John Candy.
 
I'll give you 10 bucks and a bonsai kitten.

$10, that is a start. If enough terbites come forward with $10 each, we may have a deal. Maybe Blackrock will contribute a larger amount?
 
I would be happy to say goodbye to the monarchy BUT in order to do that we HAVE to open our constitution. That's the way our country works - we can't amend one portion of our constitution - we have to open the entire Act when we change any part of it. So, to get rid of the monarchy we have to open ourselves to the political might of every rich or populous or connected special interest group. Recipe for disaster.