your opinion..

Terminator2000

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
3,495
170
63
she's a friend. not dating her. but a very good friend.

i asked her a favor and said i want to thank her with a case of smokes. She replies, "U don't owe me anything for being yur friend'. The favor is small. Nothing big like moving furniture.

I heard that buying/paying for a girl's time/attention is a sign of weakness.

Also, I don't want to seem like my friendship isn't valuable enough that I have to make up for it by buying/paying for her time/friendship.

Then again, I like saying thank and showing appreciation.

but then again, I don't want to seem like a try hard just to be someone's friend.

Thoughts? Opinions? Suggestions?

do i buy her the smokes for the favor or not?
 
My opinion... you sound like a woman yourself.
 
You don't need to give things to friends for favours done. Eventually she will undoubtedly ask you to help her with something, that will be your chance to return the favour. End of story.
 
I don't think being nice to someone (a woman) can be labelled "a sign of weakness". That seems absurd to me to even suggest it. It's a sign of weakness if you let someone take advantage of you in hopes of gaining something (sex).

If you're truly just being a decent guy, I say why not.

(Though buying someone a carton of cigarettes seems like encouraging a bad habit. I would have suggeted you just buy her some chinese food or something.)
 
To the OP, your friend was right when she said that you don't owe her anything for being your friend. That being said, I don't see any problem with showing appreciation, as long as it's not extravagant (although I think buying her cigarettes is a bad idea, as it's encouraging a bad habit). Maybe treat her for coffee or lunch, or simply return the favour if she asks you for a favour.
 
"Some day, and that day may never come, I will call upon you to do a service for me. But until that day, consider this justice a gift on my daughter's wedding day."

- Don Corleone
 
who cares. i think like 30 bucks? im not cheap.

Didn't say you were. I wanted to know so I could give my opinion. $30 for a small favour from a friend is a bit high imo. If I were your friend I would not appreciate it as I would view it that you felt you had to pay me because you didn't view me as your friend. I agree with the other poster, buy me a drink or just be there when I need a favour and that'd be perfect compensation from a friend.
 
1) Your in the friend zone - don't expect sex unless it's already happening.

2) Friends do favours for each other. It's how it works.
 
True friends do not require payments for favours nor should they expect one. That is what friends do.
The only payment I expect from a friend be it male or female is a sincere thank you.
 
I hate to break it to you:rolleyes: but I think a case of smokes cost close to a hundred bucks now..............LOL

Yeah about 10/pack so depends on how many are in a carton.

Unless he is buying native or under the table cigs.
 
she's a friend. not dating her. but a very good friend.

i asked her a favor and said i want to thank her with a case of smokes. She replies, "U don't owe me anything for being yur friend'. The favor is small. Nothing big like moving furniture.

I heard that buying/paying for a girl's time/attention is a sign of weakness.

Also, I don't want to seem like my friendship isn't valuable enough that I have to make up for it by buying/paying for her time/friendship.

Then again, I like saying thank and showing appreciation.

but then again, I don't want to seem like a try hard just to be someone's friend.

Thoughts? Opinions? Suggestions?

do i buy her the smokes for the favor or not?

Here's a good rule of thumb. IF she was your male friend would you do the same for him? If so then by all means go ahead.

Case of beer to a buddy who helps you move is not uncommon or say some pizza and beer.

$100 though might be a bit much depending on what the favour was.