Cops no longer luring johns...

Cops put john sweeps on hold 0

By Terry Davidson ,Toronto Sun
First posted: Sunday, May 13, 2012 08:46 PM EDT | Updated: Sunday, May 13, 2012 10:07 PM EDT

(QMI IMAGE)
Tweet Change text size for the storyPrint this story Report an error
Toronto police have put a full stop on john sweeps — operations designed to nab men who hit the streets to buy sex.

The Toronto Police Service confirmed Sunday the force has put “on hold” the sweeps in which female officers pose as street prostitutes to arrest men who pay for sex. The stop to the long-standing stings comes in the wake of court rulings which have declared some of Canada’s prostitution laws as unconstitutional, said spokesman Mark Pugash.

“The law surrounding this issue is in some state of uncertainty, and I think everybody is looking for the definitive word,” said Pugash, adding that john sweeps take up a “significant” number of police personnel. “The information we’ve given our people is that we won’t be starting sweeps, that we’re asking them to consider other charges if circumstances permit, and that there is a wide variety of other laws that we can use to do what we have to do.”

The Ontario Court of Appeal determined in March that provisions of the Criminal Code — the prohibition of keeping a brothel and living off the avails — were unconstitutional. The appeal court, however, ruled that the offence of communicating for the purposes of prostitution should remain on the books.

The court gave the federal government a year to address the laws, meaning the status quo remains in effect for the time being.

The federal government recently launched an appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada which will have final say on the issue.

Pugash said the decision to shelve John sweeps is based on the force’s reluctance to use “finite” resources to arrest people when so much “uncertainty” currently surrounds prostitution laws.

Pugash said investigations into illegal massage parlours, brothels and escort agencies will carry on as usual. (A police source inaccurately reported in Sunday’s Toronto Sun that police were no longer investigating escort agencies.)

“If we receive complaints, we’ll investigate,” said Pugash.

It was reported in March that Toronto’s finest had been gradually backing off John sweeps, and that fewer and fewer men had been passing through the doors of the Toronto John School — a class where those charged learn about the hazards of fornicating with street walkers.

City Councillor Giorgio Mammoliti, an outspoken critic of any legalising of prostitution, hopes Toronto Police decision makers change the policy.

Allowing street prostitution to freely continue willy-nilly, he argued, poses a health risk to both hooker and customer.

“As far as I’m concerned, the laws still exist and there is no way we should not be enforcing them,” said Mammoliti. “When you’re sleeping with a prostitute, you’re probably sleeping with 150 guys at the same time ... It only adds to the difficulties across the city.”
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't they leave the communication aspect alone in order to deal with street solicitation? But instead they leave the street alone and continue to go after what goes on behind closed doors? Shouldn't it be the reverse? Street solicitation is a visible nuisance, and I would guess that almost all the girls out there are being used against their will by pimps. So the police are going to let that continue, but they're still busting bawdy houses. This is seriously fucked up.
 
I will let the lawyers on the board give an official definition of "entrapment", but my understanding is that entrapment is that it is when police strictly INDUCE you into committing a crime you may not have otherwise committed.

With current prostitution stings, a female cop is undercover on a street corner, and a John has to drive up to her, roll down his window and engage in communication with her and then offer to purchase sex for money. The John is engaging in most of the criminal behaviour on his own by approaching her and talking to her to begin with. Entrapment would be where an unsuspecting guy, who has no intention of talking to a streetwalker, is told or asked to approach a hot looking woman on a corner by an undercover cop and then gets busted for solicitation. The undercover cop has induced someone into a crime in this case.


The majority know that 'crack addicts', or addicts in general are not the healthiest people to walk the streets. Could it not be entrapment simply due to the fact that most female officers are far more 'attractive' than the average streetwalker?
 
I will let the lawyers on the board give an official definition of "entrapment", but my understanding is that entrapment is that it is when police strictly INDUCE you into committing a crime you may not have otherwise committed.

With current prostitution stings, a female cop is undercover on a street corner, and a John has to drive up to her, roll down his window and engage in communication with her and then offer to purchase sex for money. The John is engaging in most of the criminal behaviour on his own by approaching her and talking to her to begin with. Entrapment would be where an unsuspecting guy, who has no intention of talking to a streetwalker, is told or asked to approach a hot looking woman on a corner by an undercover cop and then gets busted for solicitation. The undercover cop has induced someone into a crime in this case.

Certainly for TERB purposes, that covers the bases.
 
Nikki2 said:
The majority know that 'crack addicts', or addicts in general are not the healthiest people to walk the streets. Could it not be entrapment simply due to the fact that most female officers are far more 'attractive' than the average streetwalker?

Nope. All they have done is provide the opportunity to commit a crime. They have done nothing to pressure any passing motorists to commit one.
 
Nope. All they have done is provide the opportunity to commit a crime. They have done nothing to pressure any passing motorists to commit one.

Are you sure you're a man? I'm joking, OK. :D I understand what you're saying, however, the 'hotness' factor rises significantly when undercover female police officers 'man' the corners. As far as I'm concerned, it is safe to 'assume' that a man who wouldn't bother stopping for an addict ( tired looking, somewhat unkempt, emaciated etc) may be tempted to pull over for a well groomed "hot' female - no?! ;)
 
One should also note the Canada and the United States have entirely different statute, criminal law jurisdictions and legal definitions of stuff like 'entrapment'. We only sound like we speak a common language.

So, a great deal depends on what you mean when you ask, "Isn't this entrapment?", and where you're asking from. Check TheKittensMEOW's post below.
 
Last edited:
I'm just curious, is this type of thing not considered entrapment?

http://www.torontosun.com/2012/05/13/cops-put-john-sweeps-on-hold


There are two different forms of entrapment in Canadian law.


The first type of entrapment, "random virtue testing", occurs when the police offer an individual the opportunity to commit a crime without reasonable suspicion that either that individual, or the place where that individual is located, is associated with the criminal activity under investigation. If police do have such a reasonable suspicion, they are still limited to providing only an opportunity to commit the offense.

The second form of entrapment occurs when the police go beyond merely providing an opportunity to commit an offense, and instead actually induce the commission of the offense. Some factors a court may consider when deciding whether police have induced the offense include the type of crime being investigated, whether an average person would have been induced, the persistence and number of attempts made by the police, the type of inducement used (e.g. fraud, deceit, reward), and the existence of express or implied threats.

The question of entrapment is only considered after there has been a finding of guilt. If, after finding the accused guilty, the court determines that the accused was entrapped, the court will enter a judicial stay of proceedings. In effect, this is similar to an acquittal.
 
Cops who bust Johns are gayer than gay. For you gay cops out there, the upside is that Obama supports your right to marry.
 
Where were they sweeping in the first place these days forest hills or rosedale ? :)

I say that in jest as in the late 90's I was dating a girl who happen to live close to one of the notorious areas for street walkers downtown (rent was cheaper there then). In my regular visits I had to navigate through one of these areas and the street walking traffic was very high. I drove through that same area recently and it is now condo city with hipsters galore and chi chi restos and bars. So the street tarffic must have moved and forest hills and rosedale came to mind.
 
I was called to a hotel once, and the guy said he liked to party, but was from out of town, and didn't know where to score. I told him sorry I can't help you, officer. This is the new stink of shit in the industry.

was it after he got naked etc or before anything even started? if it was after he likely was legit, if before he may have been a cop. From the perspective of a guy who wants to score in an unknown town, hitting an SP is a very reasonable move as she is likely not a cop.
 
Does anyone actually go for "streetwalkers" these days? In the age of the Internet.. why would anyone want to work off of a street corner, or find a "date" there? Is there something I'm missing? It has the feel of "nothing good will come of this", to me..
 
Does anyone actually go for "streetwalkers" these days? In the age of the Internet.. why would anyone want to work off of a street corner, or find a "date" there? Is there something I'm missing? It has the feel of "nothing good will come of this", to me..

it's cheaper, and, more importantly in my eyes, you see who you get.
 
If

I was called to a hotel once, and the guy said he liked to party, but was from out of town, and didn't know where to score. I told him sorry I can't help you, officer. This is the new stink of shit in the industry.

Next time tell him Petro Canada. He can buy a can of gasoline legally and sniff it all night long.