Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

On the unsupported assertion that there have been many more believers than atheists in history, belivers making the immoral decisions that caused historic crimes and evils large and small, the more interesting question would be: Where do gods hide morals from their believers?
 
Last edited:
yes we know what the cop golden rule is..."Do onto others............and never get caught"

We do? You just keep on chucking spears in fish barrels, don't you? All cops or are you going to back off from that one also? Is that written anywhere, like these are? Somehow I doubt it. You might want to ask Cpl Robinson if they never get caught.
 
Very good

On the unfounded assumption that there have been many more believers than atheists in history, making the immoral decisions that caused crimes and evils large and small, the more interesting question would be: Where do gods hide morals from their believers?

I can't wait for the very entertaining replies.


FAST
 
On the unfounded assumption that there have been many more believers than atheists in history, making the immoral decisions that caused crimes and evils large and small, the more interesting question would be: Where do gods hide morals from their believers?

It may be a question, interesting or not, in your mind, but certainly with no one I know and talk to. It seems to be in the same file as the classic 'angels on the head of a pin'.
 
It is amazing how prevalent the view is that "we need God to be good".... Conservatives tend to endorse this view whenever arguing with atheists.
In practice, what that usually means is we need belief in God to provide moral cover for the structures of society as they currently exist. This comes across as somewhat blasphemous (viewed from a strictly religious standpoint) because it is invoking the name and concept of God to validate a particular human construct (e.g. a society existing at a particular place and time with a particular power structure etc). Basically "God" is being invoked as a mechanism to endorse and further particular human goals and ends. "God" becomes an instrument of human society. If "God" exists he/she/it probably would not be pleased. All that said, being an atheist, I would take the moral vagaries of existing with out God than the certainties that supposedly come from believing in something that is not true and doesn't exist. Choose your poison...

Well put.
 
It is amazing how prevalent the view is that "we need God to be good".... Conservatives tend to endorse this view whenever arguing with atheists.
In practice, what that usually means is we need belief in God to provide moral cover for the structures of society as they currently exist. This comes across as somewhat blasphemous (viewed from a strictly religious standpoint) because it is invoking the name and concept of God to validate a particular human construct (e.g. a society existing at a particular place and time with a particular power structure etc). Basically "God" is being invoked as a mechanism to endorse and further particular human goals and ends. "God" becomes an instrument of human society. If "God" exists he/she/it probably would not be pleased. All that said, being an atheist, I would take the moral vagaries of existing with out God than the certainties that supposedly come from believing in something that is not true and doesn't exist. Choose your poison...

This kind of argument shows a fundamental lack of knowledge of how Christianity and Judaism work, or how they conceive god and his role.

I can't speak for other religions.

Atheism is effectively incapable of generating its own morality. Atheists tend to borrow or imitate the dominant morals of the society they find themselves in, and then deny history.
 
On the unfounded assumption that there have been many more believers than atheists in history, making the immoral decisions that caused crimes and evils large and small, the more interesting question would be: Where do gods hide morals from their believers?

It is not an "unfounded assumption" that there have been many more believers in history than atheists. Feel free to find a legitimate historian or anthropologist, or classicist who would suggest otherwise.

And the question is not properly laid out. The rules or directions were in plain sight. Some people, no matter what their professed faith chose not to obey them.

And life, and religion, are complicated. Even when looking at the same sacred text, reasonable people can come to different conclusions.
 
ever heard of empathy? morality is built in, millions of years ago our ancestors realize that we need to co-operate and work together. this how clans and tribes form.
 
It may be a question, interesting or not, in your mind, but certainly with no one I know and talk to. It seems to be in the same file as the classic 'angels on the head of a pin'.
Yet the believers, completely ignore the dastardly, immoral deeds of the religious and act as if they'd score an unbeatable point by asking the title question. Answer: Same place believers do. Morals, ethics and rules of behaviour are part of the social inheritance of our species.

If you want to imagine gods back then, whoopee! But nothing about the existence of moral codes demonstrates it. Does anyone imagine we don't eat our tasty, tender, meal-sized offspring only because some burning bush said not to? Some species do y'know, but it didn't work for ours.
 
Yet the believers, completely ignore the dastardly, immoral deeds of the religious and act as if they'd score an unbeatable point by asking the title question. Answer: Same place believers do. Morals, ethics and rules of behaviour are part of the social inheritance of our species.

If you want to imagine gods back then, whoopee! But nothing about the existence of moral codes demonstrates it. Does anyone imagine we don't eat our tasty, tender, meal-sized offspring only because some burning bush said not to? Some species do y'know, but it didn't work for ours.

So the only people who are outraged at the atrocities of the various religion are non believers, really?

As for the burning bush show, I'm suspecting you miss the point of it. The rules had existed in the scriptures and laws of the lands, but somehow had never been in one place at one time and then actually seeing it written by the 'hand of God' was a real attention grabber for the soft vote.
 
Most religions offer a system of punishment (i.e. hell) or reward (i.e. heaven) or even both (i.e. karma). Atheists would pretty much have to live with their own conscience, or be judged by their peer group. I don't think peer groups are that relevant to today's urban society - you can easily avoid your 'village' just by moving a few blocks down the street...
 
ever heard of empathy? morality is built in, millions of years ago our ancestors realize that we need to co-operate and work together. this how clans and tribes form.

I have heard of empathy. It is lovely. IT is not universal. It is not a sufficient principle to build a civilization around.

And my understanding is that virtually every clan or tribe studied...had a religion.

Morality is not built in.

And by-the-by despite your speculation, we really don't know how clans and tribes first formed.
 
... we really don't know how clans and tribes first formed.

WTF?!?!?!
Sure we do. Any Intro Sociology course will tell you that, along with telling you all religions ARE 'man-made' cults created by primitive ignorant tribes/folks ....;)
 
Most religions offer a system of punishment (i.e. hell) or reward (i.e. heaven) or even both (i.e. karma). Atheists would pretty much have to live with their own conscience, or be judged by their peer group. I don't think peer groups are that relevant to today's urban society - you can easily avoid your 'village' just by moving a few blocks down the street...

Even religious societies have peer judgement, think healing circles in North America. You may only be told to go to the edge of town, but the communities reach is more powerful than that. I'm not sure I draw the parallel between heaven and hell with karma. The are urban communities that have amazing influence and power through peer/community pressure taht isn't truly impacted through religious ties, but rather cultural ties.
 
From the Golden Rule - same as religious people.

The Golden Rule appears where in religious texts?

Obviously, my point was that even religious people get their morals from the Golden Rule.

They sure don't get their morals from God -- the most vicious mass murderer ever -- wiped out whole nations just for not believing in him. Plus countless murders of identified individuals. God slew Onan for refusing to obey order to shag brothers wife. Turned Lot's wife into a pillar of salt for the crime of looking back.

Religious people sure don't get their morals from the bible, either. If any religious person tells you they get their morals from the bible, ask them if they've ever actually read Leviticus.

The ten commandments? Modern religious people only rate TCs 6,7,8,9 as having any moral force these days. 1,2,3,4 are free choice. (5,10 have to do with attitudes, not behaviour -- and morals are concerned only with behaviour.)

The bible tells us to hold children responsible for the sins of their fathers -- for seven generations. (It might not be seven, but even if it's some other number, that doesn't negate my general point.)

Even Pat Robertson recognizes that biblical morals are fit only for baboon society.
 
Obviously, my point was that even religious people get their morals from the Golden Rule.

They sure don't get their morals from God -- the most vicious mass murderer ever -- wiped out whole nations just for not believing in him. Plus countless murders of identified individuals. God slew Onan for refusing to obey order to shag brothers wife. Turned Lot's wife into a pillar of salt for the crime of looking back.

Religious people sure don't get their morals from the bible, either. If any religious person tells you they get their morals from the bible, ask them if they've ever actually read Leviticus.

The ten commandments? Modern religious people only rate TCs 6,7,8,9 as having any moral force these days. 1,2,3,4 are free choice. (5,10 have to do with attitudes, not behaviour -- and morals are concerned only with behaviour.)

The bible tells us to hold children responsible for the sins of their fathers -- for seven generations. (It might not be seven, but even if it's some other number, that doesn't negate my general point.)

Even Pat Robertson recognizes that biblical morals are fit only for baboon society.

Pretty primitive grasp of theology there.

At the root of you fail to distinguish between laws and morals. And the covenant and the covenant laws and morals.

But feel free to keep cherry picking and taking things out of context if it makes you feel better.

So put this quote in the context of your analysis:

Ezekiel 18:20 (New International Version)

The soul who sins is the one who will die. The son will not share the guilt of the father, nor will the father share the guilt of the son. The righteousness of the righteous man will be credited to him, and the wickedness of the wicked will be charged against him.
 
So the only people who are outraged at the atrocities of the various religion are non believers, really?

As for the burning bush show, I'm suspecting you miss the point of it. The rules had existed in the scriptures and laws of the lands, but somehow had never been in one place at one time and then actually seeing it written by the 'hand of God' was a real attention grabber for the soft vote.
Not at all. But it's only believers whose minds boggle at the concept of humans without religion nonetheless having morals, and that is the topic. I simply wanted to point out that the case for morals being god-given has yet to be demonstrated by proving a correlation between virtue and belief.

And the burning bush was not part of the gift of the laws, which if you read Leviticus, go well beyond the Famous Ten, and have continued to proliferate since. Making rules—moral ones included—is what all people do; it's only the religious who imagine none but the 'writing on the wall' code have any meaning, and deny that people actually made them up, and will change them as needed.

The real question is why any still believe god decides this stuff, absent any burning bushes, writing hands, and miracle tablets, recorded in historical times? Joseph Smith and the Angel Moroni aside. I'd be very happy to let them enjoy their fantasies and the really great poetry and stories, but they keep asking stupid questions like the title.