Real Property question in Canada?

Doot

Member
Nov 19, 2011
532
0
18
If a person owns a piece of land, under Canadian law do they own it all the way down to the center of the earth?:confused:
 
google:

In Canada, it seems, there is no case law consensus on the exclusivity of a land owner to the "depths of the Earth." The only precedent around seems to be Edwards v. Sims, which was a split decision and which dealt more with equity than with subsurface rights.

One issue which appears to be law in many Canadian provinces is the reservation of mineral rights to the Crown. Under common law and the feudal system, the grant of land usually included all minerals except gold and silver which, if discovered, belonged to the Crown or land Lord. But provincial laws have changed that in certain provinces. The rights of a fee simple owner in Alberta are not extended to include mineral rights. In England, all coal and petroleum belongs to the Crown. Thus, the Crown can take advantage of its status of original grantor of the land and retained mineral rights.

It is also possible for a private land owner, who owns the mineral rights, to sever these rights and to sell them as a separate estate in fee simple (i.e. capable of being sold or conveyed by will).
 
We're all just renters. You can't actually own any land.
 
If a person owns a piece of land, under Canadian law do they own it all the way down to the center of the earth?:confused:
As I understand it not in Canada. In the U.S. depending upon the land title of the property and state law what you state might indeed be true.
 
In some mining towns the mines are actually located under the town itself so no you do not own the land to the centre of the earth just like you don't own the air above your property.
 
Short answer, yes.

TO THE OP:

We do not have property rights enshrined in our Canadian Constitution.
Because it would be impossible to define them usefully in such a document, unless we were to do so in the fairytale sort of simplicity of the original question.

When your entire nation becomes desperate for fossil fuel and a drilling company proposes to extract some from five miles under your property, drilling horizontally from a site they own, you would likely be amazed at how fast such a constitutional right could get amended away. Even simple everyday things like expressway and golf-course developments can trigger government-forced sales of property here and in the various states to the south.

But on that point, property law is pretty much local rather than nation-wide in both countries. You'd really be asking about different laws in each of the territories and provinces. And of course, since Quebec's property-law goes back to New France, it is a very special case.

And just on my own tiny city lot, where the wall of my neighbour's house is a handsbreath from the line, I can assure you, my property rights do not entitle me to bar him and his workers from doing necessary maintenance and construction using my land. Nor does he have any right to just make his house bigger because we, the community, 'own' the rights for the space he has left to build in.

We all gotta get along if we live together.
 
Last edited:
Let's sort this out a little bit.

You do have a right to own land in Canada and Trudeau did not take it away.

It was not included in the Charter (for various reasons) but forms a part of the Canadian Bill of Rights, which is still good law.

It is a myth you do not have a right to own land in Canada.

And to the OP, I have absolutely no idea.
 
If a person owns a piece of land, under Canadian law do they own it all the way down to the center of the earth?:confused:

Depends on the province, and may also depend on the history of the land in question. Mineral rights (which may not be the same as what the OP is asking) may pass with the title to land in Ontario, for example, but not in Sask, Alberta, parts of Manitoba, parts of BC. And it may depend on who owned the land and how title has subsequently been transferred.

In short...you would have to see a lawyer and do appropriate searches to know for sure....best to assume you do not have these rights.
 
When you buy or lease land you get a bundle of rights. To enjoy to sell, to fix up or improve (if the government says its okay) and blah blah blah Buying property outright gives you the most rights but the reality is you have absolute domain over nothing...but your own intermost secret feeelings and even then I have heard from a good source...
 
Let me tell y'a story 'bout a man named Jed...
 
It was not included in the Charter (for various reasons) but forms a part of the Canadian Bill of Rights, which is still good law.

One of the reasons for not enshrining property rights in the charter was fear that it could import Lochner-style jurisprudence. As for the Bill of Rights, it's good law but only applies at the federal level - and most basic property rights are governed by provincial law.

The nine common law provinces do retain the common law theory whereby the crown still owns the land and "owners" hold a fee simple. It's a holdover from feudalism, and Trudeau had nothing to do with it.
 
a drilling company proposes to extract some from five miles under your property, drilling horizontally from a site they own,

This is a scary thought. So, it is possible that 5 miles below the surface of my property some oil exploration company is drilling a hole?
 
One of the reasons for not enshrining property rights in the charter was fear that it could import Lochner-style jurisprudence. As for the Bill of Rights, it's good law but only applies at the federal level - and most basic property rights are governed by provincial law.

The nine common law provinces do retain the common law theory whereby the crown still owns the land and "owners" hold a fee simple. It's a holdover from feudalism, and Trudeau had nothing to do with it.

Fee simple is ownership. It is the highest form of ownership available in a common law country.
 
This is a scary thought. So, it is possible that 5 miles below the surface of my property some oil exploration company is drilling a hole?
Possible, not probable in these hyar parts tho'. Yet. The concern where that sort of thing is happening is that they use the hole to destabilize the substrata to release gas.

And to go back to the hypothetical: Do I own my land to the centre of the earth, (presumably in an ever diminishing pointy wedgey thing)? If you don't then that exact measurement down to where the 'splosions are happening can get very significant to the folks above.
 
Because it would be impossible to define them usefully in such a document, unless we were to do so in the fairytale sort of simplicity of the original question.

When your entire nation becomes desperate for fossil fuel and a drilling company proposes to extract some from five miles under your property, drilling horizontally from a site they own, you would likely be amazed at how fast such a constitutional right could get amended away. Even simple everyday things like expressway and golf-course developments can trigger government-forced sales of property here and in the various states to the south.

But on that point, property law is pretty much local rather than nation-wide in both countries. You'd really be asking about different laws in each of the territories and provinces. And of course, since Quebec's property-law goes back to New France, it is a very special case.

And just on my own tiny city lot, where the wall of my neighbour's house is a handsbreath from the line, I can assure you, my property rights do not entitle me to bar him and his workers from doing necessary maintenance and construction using my land. Nor does he have any right to just make his house bigger because we, the community, 'own' the rights for the space he has left to build in.

We all gotta get along if we live together.

What do they do in the USA where people have property rights? Surely property rights can be limited above and below within reason. I don't think anyone expects to own depth and height without limit.

Worse than having land expropriated for cheap, is when they expropriate the easement rights - you still have to pay the same property taxes, so you get fucked twice.
 
Of course the easements for roads, sidewalks, water, gas, sewers, hydro, telephone, cable TV and such do offer certain useful and attractive benefits, and almost no inconvenience for most owners, most of the time. Consider whether the value of your property would go up if there were no such services to it. Betcha it would go down.

And although it can be a troublesome thing when visitors park in it, the right of way I share with my neighbour on the other side, give us each a useable garage—and everyone a prettier streetscape—at half the cost of each of us buying land for a driveway.

The reason so many of us want to live in cities is all the shared benefits. The trick is figuring out how to do the sharing. Focussing only on "MINE!", steers us to disaster.
 
What do they do in the USA where penople have property rights? Surely property rights can be limited above and below within reason.
Basically what Mencken wrote in # 11 then look at what I wrote in # 7. It depends upon what minerals rights law is in that state. If the mineral rights have never been sold (in to the best of my knowledge all states) you the surface freeholder own to the center of the earth. Of course your rights to exploit those sub-surface rights are limited by what the mining or drilling laws are in that jurisdiction.

This basically from the Roman Law doctrine: Cuius est solum, eius est usque ad caelum et ad inferos (For whoever owns the soil, it is theirs up to Heaven and down to Hell). Which of course leads on to air rights prior to the Twentieth Century, your air-rights extended to the edge of space, however since the advent of aircraft air rights have become limited to the airspace that can be reasonably used - so you can't be suing aircraft owners for trespass. And even that can be limited by law, for instance I can't put up a copy of the Sears Tower in the flight path of the Buffalo Airport.