The Nazi King

That may very well be true, however, that does not alter the fact that the [Duke] while on duty in France gave the germans military intelligence. Therefore he without question was a traitor.
First I've never read any of this. The standard among historians is to write books or articles not to have television programs. That makes me have my doubts right there.

Second there is a difference between inappropriate conversation and the legal definition of treason. For instance there have been many cases of "pillow talk" over the millennia but there has not been a rush to charge the "talkers" as traitors.

That the Duke was recognized as being a loose cannon has already been acknowledged and discussed in this thread, it was the very reason that he was told in no uncertain terms that he was going to the Bahamas and that he was not to leave the Bahamas other than for occasional private visits to the U.S.
 
That may very well be true, however, that does not alter the fact that the Duck (apologies to Clint) while on duty in France gave the germans military intelligence. Therefore he without question was a traitor. If the germans needed or used the information is irrelevant.

It is not irrelevant to your claim at all. You claimed the German plan was modified by this information. If it was irrelevant why did you mention it? If it was not true...why did you mention it?

Do you have a source for this specific claim...that he passed on military intelligence to the Germans?
 
It is not irrelevant to your claim at all. You claimed the German plan was modified by this information. If it was irrelevant why did you mention it? If it was not true...why did you mention it?

Do you have a source for this specific claim...that he passed on military intelligence to the Germans?

It is relevant to a claim of the germans changing their plans, correct. But it is not relevant to the a claim of him being a traitor.
 
There were a lot of Nazi sympathizers the world over. At some point I believe that even Hearst was one. And Prescott Bush would certainly fall into that category.

Henry Ford would also be a notable member of that list.
 
First I've never read any of this. The standard among historians is to write books or articles not to have television programs. That makes me have my doubts right there.

Second there is a difference between inappropriate conversation and the legal definition of treason. For instance there have been many cases of "pillow talk" over the millennia but there has not been a rush to charge the "talkers" as traitors.

That the Duke was recognized as being a loose cannon has already been acknowledged and discussed in this thread, it was the very reason that he was told in no uncertain terms that he was going to the Bahamas and that he was not to leave the Bahamas other than for occasional private visits to the U.S.

Well, if you have not read it, it is likely not true.

You have forgotten to comment on my posting here:


However, to me this raises a whole different question. Does it not give you pause to think about the monarchy, when such a pitiful, weak and generally horrible human being like Edward can become King of the then greatest empire on the planet? I can hardly imagine any better argument against the monarchy. If the only qualification for the highest office in the land is to have emerged from the royal birth canal, these deplorable situations are bound to happen.
 
Well, if you have not read it, it is likely not true.

You have forgotten to comment on my posting here:

I am happy to try my hand at that one.

During the period of time that monarchs actually held real power over the state it was a great concern that a shitty one might happen. And they did. In many cases they were trained from the ground up to minimize that risk, and surrounded by powerful advisors and family members to keep them on tract if they did not have the resources to deal with it. There are examples of royal dynasties that have been successful and saw their countries and empires survive and thrive longer than any democracy today in existence.

Now, in a time period where monarchs in first world countries really only have symbolic power and can't do much damage other than being embarassing this argument is not nearly as cogent or powerful. I think you are about 100 years or so too late on this one.
 
I am happy to try my hand at that one.

During the period of time that monarchs actually held real power over the state it was a great concern that a shitty one might happen. And they did. In many cases they were trained from the ground up to minimize that risk, and surrounded by powerful advisors and family members to keep them on tract if they did not have the resources to deal with it. There are examples of royal dynasties that have been successful and saw their countries and empires survive and thrive longer than any democracy today in existence.

Now, in a time period where monarchs in first world countries really only have symbolic power and can't do much damage other than being embarassing this argument is not nearly as cogent or powerful. I think you are about 100 years or so too late on this one.

Right, your argument had to be that they are completely useless. LOL
 
What you are writing about Danmand I believe stems from the statement of the German Minister to The Hague, Count Julius von Zech-Burkersroda who in February 1940, claimed that the Duke had leaked the Allied war plans for the defence of Belgium.

That would have been right in the middle of the so called "Phoney War" on the Western Front which lasted from 3 September 1939 to until the German invasion of The Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg on 10 May 1940. If you were the German Government would you have liked to try to drive a wedge between Great Britain and Belgium and France by making such a statement? Needless to say it would also create conflict within the U.K. Now on the other hand one might ask why would the German Minister to the Netherlands be privy to this highly important Intelligence and further why on earth would he be so stupid as to let the allies know that they knew of allied plans for the defence of Belgium, further to which Belgium (not having learned much from the First World War) was officially neutral throughout the "Phoney War."
 
Right, your argument had to be that they are completely useless. LOL

I just live in the real world. Currently monarchies in first world countries are primarily symbolic. Do you disagree with that fact?

And are you ever going to give us a source for that rather aggressive claim?
 
I just live in the real world. Currently monarchies in first world countries are primarily symbolic. Do you disagree with that fact?

I agree, and let us get rid of the parasites.

As for the claim, I posted that the documentary claimed to have proof from newly released documents from the government archives that the Duck gave sensitive information to the germans. The documentary showed documents with transcripts of conversations. It was stated that Churchill was furious.
 
I agree, and let us get rid of the parasites.

As for the claim, I posted that the documentary claimed to have proof from newly released documents from the government archives that the Duck gave sensitive information to the germans. The documentary showed documents with transcripts of conversations. It was stated that Churchill was furious.

Now I have to watch the documentary. Now if I spend the time to watch the documentary is it going to say that he gave military information to the Germans or just "sensitive."? Also will it say the Germans altered their plan to attach France based on this information or is there some other source for that part of the claim?

And just because one only has symbolic value does not mean that one is a parasite.

In Canada I would be surprised if the majority wanted to get rid of the monarchy.
 
It was stated that Churchill was furious.
This strikes me as being old news "made sexy". In fact the Duke of Windsor had escaped the collapse of France to Portugal where the Germans where singing siren songs.

H.M.'s Government, which indicated that they had the King's full support told the Duke that he was to return to the U.K. aboard the warship that was being sent forthwith, and that he was to become the Governor of the Bahamas the alternative was a Court Martial.
 
Now I have to watch the documentary. Now if I spend the time to watch the documentary is it going to say that he gave military information to the Germans or just "sensitive."? Also will it say the Germans altered their plan to attach France based on this information or is there some other source for that part of the claim?

The documentary, as I posted above but will be happy to repost for your benefit, said that there were three possible routes for the german attack on France, one through the lowlands, one through the Artdennes, and a third route. While the Duck was on duty as the senior relations officer to the french military, he told Von Rippentrop that Britain expected the attack through the lowlands. I truely cannot recall if the documentary stated that the germans changed their plans to attack through the Ardennes, or if it stated that the germans subsequently attacked through the Ardennes.
 
This strikes me as being old news "made sexy". In fact the Duke of Windsor had escaped the collapse of France to Portugal where the Germans where singing siren songs.

H.M.'s Government, which indicated that they had the King's full support told the Duke that he was to return to the U.K. aboard the warship that was being sent forthwith, and that he was to become the Governor of the Bahamas the alternative was a Court Martial.

He ignored orders to return to Britain and went instead to Portugal, where he associated with other fascists. The documentary claimed that he advised the germans to intensify the bombing of Britain, as he expected the population to cave in and sue for peace.

continue your defense of the duck.
 
I truely cannot recall if the documentary stated that the germans changed their plans to attack through the Ardennes, or if it stated that the germans subsequently attacked through the Ardennes.
Gee that is sort of an important point do you not think?

In fact your entire argument rides or falls upon it.
 
Gee that is sort of an important point do you not think?

In fact your entire argument rides or falls upon it.

No, it does not, not even in the slightest. If the Duck gave sensitive information to the germans, he was a traitor.