First I've never read any of this. The standard among historians is to write books or articles not to have television programs. That makes me have my doubts right there.That may very well be true, however, that does not alter the fact that the [Duke] while on duty in France gave the germans military intelligence. Therefore he without question was a traitor.
Second there is a difference between inappropriate conversation and the legal definition of treason. For instance there have been many cases of "pillow talk" over the millennia but there has not been a rush to charge the "talkers" as traitors.
That the Duke was recognized as being a loose cannon has already been acknowledged and discussed in this thread, it was the very reason that he was told in no uncertain terms that he was going to the Bahamas and that he was not to leave the Bahamas other than for occasional private visits to the U.S.

