Adverse Possession

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
My relatively new (slightly over 2 years) next door neighbor said my backyard fence is intruding 2-6 inches over on her side of the property line. I said that has been the case for more than 10 years, hence it qualifies as "adverse possession". Do you agree?
 
Unfortunately, in 2 cases I've seen this type of situation.. no. If the neighbor received an original survey upon purchase and the fence was not defined in that survey, they have the right to conduct a new survey proving their property is being encroached on. Usually afterwards, they would have to file a complaint with the town/city where you reside, and if the town decides they are correct your neighbor can demand that the fence be removed.

You are responsible for paying 50% of a replacement fence as well, but you are permitted to have a say in the new fencing. If you have started to hate your neighbor by now, and they want something nice and fancy.. you are only responsible for half of the CHEAPEST alternative that you are comfortable with. I literally had one client I dealt with that was demanding a 2 ft high green mesh fence to seperate property lines. The green mesh was like.. $8 per foot. The neighbor had a doberman. They had to shell out quite a bit more than their half to build a reasonable fence to contain the dog.
 
My relatively new (slightly over 2 years) next door neighbor said my backyard fence is intruding 2-6 inches over on her side of the property line. I said that has been the case for more than 10 years, hence it qualifies as "adverse possession". Do you agree?
Is she hot?
 
My relatively new (slightly over 2 years) next door neighbor said my backyard fence is intruding 2-6 inches over on her side of the property line. I said that has been the case for more than 10 years, hence it qualifies as "adverse possession". Do you agree?

She just brought it up now? She bought the house where the fence is not giving it a thought and she's not sure if it's 2-6 inches over? Find out what your rights truly are and hers, find out the process that really needs to happen and ignore it until she brings it up again. If she does you will be prepared and know what needs to happen.
 
A) Adverse possession is more complicated in Canada than in the U.S.

B) In Canada TBMK it isn't so much that the adverse possessor gains title to the property, but rather the "owner" looses their right to evict so it is more that an Adverse Possessor acquires an occupation right rather than a title right.

C) It is my understanding that if the properties are now in the Ontario Land Titles System rather than the Registry System, Adverse Possession does not apply.

D) Take a look at the following

Limitations Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. L-15 (see s.15 and s.3)
Land Titles Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.6, s. 3.
Certification of Titles Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. C-6, s. 4(2)

E) Most importantly, you really should talk to a friendly local Lawyer about this.
 
She just brought it up now? She bought the house where the fence is not giving it a thought and she's not sure if it's 2-6 inches over?

This neighbor is being silly. She installed an HE furnace in November and asked me if her 2 vents could hang over my property. I politely declined. Now she is raising the fence as a "discussion" point. I'll wait until I get a formal letter before doing anything. My lawyer said if the fence has been there for more than 10 years then "adverse possession" means I don't have to do anything.
 
You have to look at whether the property is in the Land Titles system or not. Speak to your lawyer.
 
This neighbor is being silly. She installed an HE furnace in November and asked me if her 2 vents could hang over my property. I politely declined. Now she is raising the fence as a "discussion" point. I'll wait until I get a formal letter before doing anything. My lawyer said if the fence has been there for more than 10 years then "adverse possession" means I don't have to do anything.

Actually if memory serves correctly, there is a small margin of space, maybe as much as 6 inches for error and ground shift over time. I wouldn't give it another thought to be honest. If she did get a survey done when she moved in, and it shows the location of the fence, and she's waited 2 years, they'll probably laugh at her.
 
This neighbor is being silly. She installed an HE furnace in November and asked me if her 2 vents could hang over my property. I politely declined. Now she is raising the fence as a "discussion" point. I'll wait until I get a formal letter before doing anything. My lawyer said if the fence has been there for more than 10 years then "adverse possession" means I don't have to do anything.

You're probably right to do nothing on this issue, but you should probably reach out to your neighbour in other ways to try and prevent this one issue from poisoning your relationship completely. Do something nice for her somewhere.
 
You have to look at whether the property is in the Land Titles system or not. Speak to your lawyer.

I did have a brief meeting with my lawyer but he said any more time on this file would cost me $250 an hour. He said that most of not all properties in Toronto have converted to the Land Titles System and adverse possession is now very difficult to obtain but I think he said that adverse possession prior to conversion to LTS is grandfathered.
 
A) Adverse possession is more complicated in Canada than in the U.S.

B) In Canada TBMK it isn't so much that the adverse possessor gains title to the property, but rather the "owner" looses their right to evict so it is more that an Adverse Possessor acquires an occupation right rather than a title right.

C) It is my understanding that if the properties are now in the Ontario Land Titles System rather than the Registry System, Adverse Possession does not apply.

D) Take a look at the following

Limitations Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. L-15 (see s.15 and s.3)
Land Titles Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.6, s. 3.
Certification of Titles Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. C-6, s. 4(2)

E) Most importantly, you really should talk to a friendly local Lawyer about this.

Aardvark is right that AP could only apply to lands in the Registry system or if they were adversely possessed while in the Registry system for 10 years before conversion to Land Titles "Qualified" title. The designation "Qualified" means that the boundaries of the lands are not confirmed in the conversion process. Most of the lands in Toronto were converted in the last 10 years. If she's only been in the place for 2 years, it's not likely that she would know enough to claim adverse possession, and even if she could, does she want to spend the money (maybe $5000-$10000) to try to retain 2-6 inches of land? Are there old pictures or surveys of the land available?

I'd be happy to discuss this with you; my rates are the same as Mirage's.
 
Aardvark is right that AP could only apply to lands in the Registry system or if they were adversely possessed while in the Registry system for 10 years before conversion to Land Titles "Qualified" title. The designation "Qualified" means that the boundaries of the lands are not confirmed in the conversion process. Most of the lands in Toronto were converted in the last 10 years. If she's only been in the place for 2 years, it's not likely that she would know enough to claim adverse possession, and even if she could, does she want to spend the money (maybe $5000-$10000) to try to retain 2-6 inches of land? Are there old pictures or surveys of the land available?

I'd be happy to discuss this with you; my rates are the same as Mirage's.

Pretty sure when it goes to land titles all bets are off..there is no provision in that system to register a adverse possession......when the fence comes down it just goes in the right place I would guess. Municipalities are running from fence disputes and have made it a civil court matter ...and being forced to split on the fence is not an option anymore.
 
This neighbor is being silly. She installed an HE furnace in November and asked me if her 2 vents could hang over my property. I politely declined. Now she is raising the fence as a "discussion" point. I'll wait until I get a formal letter before doing anything. My lawyer said if the fence has been there for more than 10 years then "adverse possession" means I don't have to do anything.

I remember that thread.

I wouldn't do anything until she brings it to you formally.
 
This neighbor is being silly. She installed an HE furnace in November and asked me if her 2 vents could hang over my property. I politely declined. Now she is raising the fence as a "discussion" point. I'll wait until I get a formal letter before doing anything. My lawyer said if the fence has been there for more than 10 years then "adverse possession" means I don't have to do anything.

Did you have a good reason for declining or were you just being a dick?
 
The business of living trouble-free and contentedly next-door is way more important than a couple of inches here or there along a fence-line. Given your troubled history with this person and possible future disagreements, you really should get onto the mediation agencies to establish some basis for functional interaction if you're not succeeding yourselves.

That said, it can't really be 'your' fence if it's on her property. You can only really claim and enforce ownership if it's entirely on yours and she'd be trespassing if she did anything to it. As most people understand—and the old city of Toronto fence law said—a fence on the property-line belongs to both. The Toronto Fence Viewer* told me back then that if you cannot get co-operation to share a property-line fence, you need to set what you build 6" onto your side of the line and by doing so cede to you neighbour the right to garden that strip or use it as they choose. And to paint—but not damage—'their' side of your fence. But he said that did not give them ownership and their right ceased the moment the fence came down.

So it would appear you've got some squatter's rights to plant your petunias along the fence and continue to do so. But only until she decides her patience has run out and she takes it apart, and has the guy who piles the pieces on your lawn give you his bill for removing 'your' fence from her property. And if that goes before a tribunal it'll be your survey and why you didn't follow it that'll be discussed.

"Good fences make good neighbours", but a fence badly placed makes trouble. Show how reasonable you are, and you'll be 'earning' reasonable behaviour from her. She'll never get the message if you match her stubborn stupidity.

If you Google for the current bylaw you'll find there are Fence Viewers in the MegaCity, but they don't 'view' in the winter/
 
Last edited:
Tell her you will pay to the build the fence. Then show her the fence design you have chosen. Your fence taste tends to run in the fence looking like giant penises.