Legalizing Weed

I don't mean medical use. I mean that long term MJ use is shown to cause some significant mental health problems and mental health problems are expensive to treat, because they tend to involve both the legal system and the medical system.

On a philosophical basis you are entirely right, there is no logical reason to make MJ illegal if alcohol is legal. But on a practical basis it will cost us more through our taxes on the medical side, if legalization increases long term use. To give you an example. Let's say booze costs us $100 in medical costs a year right now and MJ costs us $25 (just making up numbers here to demonstrate a point). If we legal MJ the cost might rise to say $50 or so. So our medical bill goes from 125 to 150. It is a question of how much we want to spend as a society.

Like I said philosophically I am not opposed to legalization or even de-criminalization (which has been proposed in the past). And nobody has given me any real numbers on costs to think about. Of course you would have to factor in the savings from LE, but perhaps the increases in MVAs etc. We could also tax the stuff and make money. I would like to see some serious economic studies done on the cost of this idea.
I guess you are assuming that legalization would mean increased use? I am not so sure that that is the case. I don't use marijuana now and I would not use it if it were legal. In the end, I agree with you... this really comes down to an economic decision.
 
I guess you are assuming that legalization would mean increased use? I am not so sure that that is the case. I don't use marijuana now and I would not use it if it were legal. In the end, I agree with you... this really comes down to an economic decision.

I actually don't know if it would increase if use was legal. I suspect that...but cannot say for sure.

I see a lot of philosophical arguments about the issue, but not much hard data.
 
.... I don't think usage would change at all - it's not exactly difficult to find weed. People outright smoke it in bar smoking areas or walking down the street. It's already easy to find and use if one wants to partake.

It would be great if the government could capitalize on some potential profit with a tax like is charged on alcohol or cigarettes. There will still be those who grow it at home and there will be people who sell it but even if ithe governement's profit comes nowhere near what the lcbo makes, legalizing will make/save us money- perhaps one should consider the fact that there's money wasted in dealing with those caught trafficking and using this so-called drug.

I don't have stats - I do have a friend who was charged with possession of it~ I know possession of cannabis usually results in a slap on the wrist but we do end up paying to chase pot users/sellers/growers/ around..... But hell - you can make your own wine or head out to the lcbo and buy a bottle (or two or three), and it's totally-legal. Alcohol unquestionably has caused lives to be lost and is addictive..... but it's a-o-k. Cigarettes have unquestionably caused lives to be lost and are addictive ..... but they're a-o-k. Marijuana is non-addictive and has never killed a soul but it's a big bad drug.

I won't start using it just because it's legal - if I liked it, I'd be able to find it.... I don't want to smell it more than I already do just walking down Yonge st - I don't want people driving while high on it and I certainly believe workplace testing for it should continue but I think a lot of benefit would come out of legalizing it.
 
People should be aware that we are a party to an international treaty that requires us to keep MJ illegal.

What treaty is that? A link?

The more research that is done, the worse it appears to be for your health. Particularly your mental health.

I believe there was one study that said there 'might' be a link between early use and later mental issues among young people. That's not a lot of evidence...

sale of MJ for private use through the LCBO or similar, but there are some practical obstacles.


LCBO? Even now when it's illegal, in any urban area in the country it's easier to buy weed than it is to buy alcohol or even cigarettes. It has to be 'legalized' without silly regulations that nobody pays attention to. Cigarettes are regulated up the yin-yang here in Ontario, yet contraband smokes are available for $20/carton on virtually any street corner in the city - guess what the kids are buying? And guess which organized crime syndicates are making money off of them?

 
Too much of the voting public is still old/conservative/religious.

Will need the people getting high to get there shit together.
exactly...they will die, and no longer vote, where as the younger generation of people in Canada smokes em like its cigarettes!..it should be legal within 10 years
 
That's the last thing this country needs. The Dutch tried it, didn;t work out so well. Why do people always think that legalizing weed is a good thing? What precisely are all the benefits society will enjoy? I don't smoke pot and I don't see why anyone should.

Perhaps you should look at the results in a country that actually legalized drugs (and it's not the Netherlands).

"Judging by every metric, decriminalization in Portugal has been a resounding success," says Glenn Greenwald, an attorney, author and fluent Portuguese speaker, who conducted the research. "It has enabled the Portuguese government to manage and control the drug problem far better than virtually every other Western country does."

Compared to the European Union and the U.S., Portugal's drug use numbers are impressive. Following decriminalization, Portugal had the lowest rate of lifetime marijuana use in people over 15 in the E.U.: 10%. The most comparable figure in America is in people over 12: 39.8%. Proportionally, more Americans have used cocaine than Portuguese have used marijuana.

The Cato paper reports that between 2001 and 2006 in Portugal, rates of lifetime use of any illegal drug among seventh through ninth graders fell from 14.1% to 10.6%; drug use in older teens also declined. Lifetime heroin use among 16-to-18-year-olds fell from 2.5% to 1.8% (although there was a slight increase in marijuana use in that age group). New HIV infections in drug users fell by 17% between 1999 and 2003, and deaths related to heroin and similar drugs were cut by more than half. In addition, the number of people on methadone and buprenorphine treatment for drug addiction rose to 14,877 from 6,040, after decriminalization, and money saved on enforcement allowed for increased funding of drug-free treatment as well.

Read more: http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1893946,00.html#ixzz1k0ezh9l9
 
This is from 2007 but I expect the numbers would be similar today:
According to the UN report, which is a staple of police forces around the world, 16.8 per cent of Canadians between the ages of 15 and 64 smoked pot or ingested one of its derivatives last year.
There are no stats because cannabis is benign. If smoking pot actually caused serious medical problems there would be an epidemic and hospitals would be overflowing with marijuana patients. A couple of 26 ounce bottles of alcohol can cause death if drunk too fast; there is no corollary for marijuana. You can't overdose on it.
Also, it might be unCanadian to point this out but the real gateway drug that leads to harder alcoholic beverages, iimpaired judgement, fights, medical problems, other bad behaviour and hard drugs isn't pot, it's beer.

I've smoked off and on for over 30 years. Last summer I trained hard and was in 2 sprint triathlons, a couple of 10K runs, a half marathon, and a very challenging 70.3 mile Ironman. So when can I expect the ravages of marijuana to hit?!
The worst effect I can expect from pot is not the bloodshot eyes and short-term lethargy from the occasional puff, it is being jailed for possession.
 
What treaty is that? A link?



I believe there was one study that said there 'might' be a link between early use and later mental issues among young people. That's not a lot of evidence...



LCBO? Even now when it's illegal, in any urban area in the country it's easier to buy weed than it is to buy alcohol or even cigarettes. It has to be 'legalized' without silly regulations that nobody pays attention to. Cigarettes are regulated up the yin-yang here in Ontario, yet contraband smokes are available for $20/carton on virtually any street corner in the city - guess what the kids are buying? And guess which organized crime syndicates are making money off of them?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Convention_on_Narcotic_Drugs Merry Christmas, an advocate like you was not aware of this or could not find it yourself?

There are several studies showing negative mental health impact from long term MJ use. Some serious. Even on a common sense basis why do you think something that changes your brain chemistry would not have an impact?


Your arguments that it "has to be" legalized in the manner you want are just your opinion only and some of them are completely illogical. Is your argument that we should legalize everything that organized crime gets involved in because they are involved? Nothing should be regulated because people will breach the regulation? Completely nonsensical.

The government pulls in over 2 billion from tobacco tax every year. We should give that up because there is a black market for the product?
 
There are several studies showing negative mental health impact from long term MJ use. Some serious. Even on a common sense basis why do you think something that changes your brain chemistry would not have an impact?


?

thats true- reefer madness is endemic, if pot is legalised it would be an epidemic
 
This is from 2007 but I expect the numbers would be similar today:
There are no stats because cannabis is benign. If smoking pot actually caused serious medical problems there would be an epidemic and hospitals would be overflowing with marijuana patients. A couple of 26 ounce bottles of alcohol can cause death if drunk too fast; there is no corollary for marijuana. You can't overdose on it.
Also, it might be unCanadian to point this out but the real gateway drug that leads to harder alcoholic beverages, iimpaired judgement, fights, medical problems, other bad behaviour and hard drugs isn't pot, it's beer.

I've smoked off and on for over 30 years. Last summer I trained hard and was in 2 sprint triathlons, a couple of 10K runs, a half marathon, and a very challenging 70.3 mile Ironman. So when can I expect the ravages of marijuana to hit?!
The worst effect I can expect from pot is not the bloodshot eyes and short-term lethargy from the occasional puff, it is being jailed for possession.

Benign?

It seems that Harvard and the folks who write the DSM disagree with you:

http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/evidence99/marijuana/Health_1.html

And the drug certainly can by pyschologically addictive and may be physically addictive.

Of course we all know that your anecdotal experience is far more important than all the science in the area.
 
I don't smoke pot and I don't see why anyone should.

There is no rational, medical or scientific justification for cannabis smoking to be illegal.

It should be illegal because people like Hangman don't use it and thinks everyone should do as he does.

All those veterans dying and fighting for our freedom to tell our fellow citizen how to live. Just think about it, if they didn't kill those dutch farmers in South African or hold back Kaiser Bill and his hordes we wouldn't have the freedom to order our neighbors how to live. Do you hate the troops. I bet you do. If we didn't have the freedom to tell people what drugs to take, to have basement apartments, or to get them not to shop on Sunday or pay for sex or which adults to have genital contact with... well that sure isn't Sparta, that there is a little thing I like to call madness.

As for me, wake me up when they start pushing medical prostitution. That would be nice. And really dumb policy.
 
Any Political Party which

4. Besides 3, make Remembrance Day a National Holiday. ...

I always wondered about that too. But I heard an interview with a WWII vet and he said that many vets don't want to make it a holiday fearing that the meaning of the day would be lost. i.e. people would preoccupied with making long weekend plans etc. Just another holiday.
 
I had a bike accident about ten years ago and I started smoking pot. The other option is using using legally controlled substances like oxycotin which is an epidemic destroying families and lives. When you have broken the rule of Orthopedics 3 times over, suffer from multiple disc herniations and bulges, spinal cord inmpingments and can say you have never used pain killers like myself then you are in a postion to oppose legalization. I smoke daily and am sick of paying the piper upward 300 per/oz for my medicine. The medical pot here in Canada is weak so I am for it. :hippie:

I had an injury a couple of years ago that had me walking with a cane for almost 6 months. The doctors prescribed me Oxycontin for the pain and it worked well enough, but I became very much addicted to it (and it didn't take long). After 3 or 4 months of popping more and more Oxy pills every day, i realized that it was very much taking over my life.

Thanks to a tip I read online, I discovered that using pot to ween myself of Oxy helped tremendously. It helped with the pain, and it virtually killed my withdrawal symptoms. Too bad I had to buy " illegal drugs" from a "dealer" to help kick my addiction to medically prescribed pain "medication".
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Convention_on_Narcotic_Drugs Merry Christmas, an advocate like you was not aware of this or could not find it yourself?

There are several studies showing negative mental health impact from long term MJ use. Some serious. Even on a common sense basis why do you think something that changes your brain chemistry would not have an impact?


Your arguments that it "has to be" legalized in the manner you want are just your opinion only and some of them are completely illogical. Is your argument that we should legalize everything that organized crime gets involved in because they are involved? Nothing should be regulated because people will breach the regulation? Completely nonsensical.

The government pulls in over 2 billion from tobacco tax every year. We should give that up because there is a black market for the product?

Chocolate affects your brain chemistry - should that be banned?

As far as my opinion on legalization - what's the point of not legalizing it? In any case, I don't really care if they legalize it or not. I can get as much as I want any time I want - and so can just about anybody else who wants to.

Tobacco tax? The point of the tax is not revenue, but to discourage consumption - or at least that's what they keep telling us. In the meantime, school kids are buying cheap _unregulated_ smokes for 1/4 of the price.
 
I say decriminalize but don't legalize. If the LCBO sold pot then there probably would be an increase in pot usage as it might suddenly be seen as "socially acceptable". You might have folks who never tried it before suddenly think to themselves "What the heck, I'll give it a whirl." (think impulse buying).

The key is to stop wasting money on policing it, while making sure the public understands that it's still a rather pathetic way to waste away an afternoon (or day).

If it's decriminalized then people like my brother-in-law can grow his own pot instead of having to turn to an illegal source (with likely ties to a larger criminal organization).
 
I had an injury a couple of years ago that had me walking with a cane for almost 6 months. The doctors prescribed me Oxycontin for the pain and it worked well enough, but I became very much addicted to it (and it didn't take long). After 3 or 4 months of popping more and more Oxy pills every day, i realized that it was very much taking over my life.

Thanks to a tip I read online, I discovered that using pot to ween myself of Oxy helped tremendously. It helped with the pain, and it virtually killed my withdrawal symptoms. Too bad I had to buy " illegal drugs" from a "dealer" to help kick my addiction to medically prescribed pain "medication".

Your doctor, of course, had the option of writing you a prescription for MJ.
 
Chocolate affects your brain chemistry - should that be banned?

As far as my opinion on legalization - what's the point of not legalizing it? In any case, I don't really care if they legalize it or not. I can get as much as I want any time I want - and so can just about anybody else who wants to.

Tobacco tax? The point of the tax is not revenue, but to discourage consumption - or at least that's what they keep telling us. In the meantime, school kids are buying cheap _unregulated_ smokes for 1/4 of the price.
\

Your comment on chocolate is conflating two discussions. IT was suggested that there was no medical impact from MJ. That is factually wrong.

So your logic remains, if a law will be broken, it should not exist. Well thought out position.
 
OldSox said:
Chocolate affects your brain chemistry - should that be banned?
Let's not forget that sex also affects brain chemistry, inducing a cascade of endorphins and serotonin.
Keeping pot illegal only benefits criminals, and those who profit from the justice system (and therefore costs taxpayers lots of money).
I'd really expect Conservatives to be most in favour of legalization since they usually claim to be pro-business, and say they prefer less gov't intervention in peoples' lives.

Benign?

It seems that Harvard and the folks who write the DSM disagree with you:

http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/evidence99/marijuana/Health_1.html

And the drug certainly can by pyschologically addictive and may be physically addictive.

Of course we all know that your anecdotal experience is far more important than all the science in the area.
Yes, benign. Okay, I'll make the Hitchhikers' Guide To The Galaxy update and say: Mostly benign. Hard to believe that's from Harvard; the psychedelic, 90s era marbled background on that page was giving me an eyestrain headache, but there was no argument on the page that claimed smoking pot should be illegal.

There are a lot of activities I do that are potentially harmful, but as a rational adult I don't see why the gov't should be trying to protect me from myself or put in jail for it.

It's amazingly hypocritical to see your arguments on a site devoted to the high risk activity of paying anonymous women for sex. And I don't know about you but I think I'd rather that my SO, boss and family found out I sometimes smoke pot, than find out about this other 'hobby'.
 
I don't mean medical use. I mean that long term MJ use is shown to cause some significant mental health problems and mental health problems are expensive to treat, because they tend to involve both the legal system and the medical system.

On a philosophical basis you are entirely right, there is no logical reason to make MJ illegal if alcohol is legal. But on a practical basis it will cost us more through our taxes on the medical side, if legalization increases long term use. To give you an example. Let's say booze costs us $100 in medical costs a year right now and MJ costs us $25 (just making up numbers here to demonstrate a point). If we legal MJ the cost might rise to say $50 or so. So our medical bill goes from 125 to 150. It is a question of how much we want to spend as a society.

Like I said philosophically I am not opposed to legalization or even de-criminalization (which has been proposed in the past). And nobody has given me any real numbers on costs to think about. Of course you would have to factor in the savings from LE, but perhaps the increases in MVAs etc. We could also tax the stuff and make money. I would like to see some serious economic studies done on the cost of this idea.
No one who wants to smoke pot right now, has any problem scoring. So whatever mental conditions, whatever costs there are, already exist in the health care industry, and are already being paid for, with zero tax money coming in to cover the expenses. We are already spending the money as a society.
In fact we're spending unnecessary amounts: in policing, in prosecuting, in incarcerating, AND ALSO in treatment.
 
I could be wrong about this, but I think in the documentory "The Union" they said Canadian LE uses 4/5 of it's drug budget targeting marijuana...which is obviously a waste of taxpayer's dollars...$400 million per year iirc.