Christopher Hitchens dies

Their religion was statism, the absolute slavish devotion to an idea. Hitchens was correct, belief itself is the problem. Society should be governed on the basis of evidence, nothing else. Every so often a quick decision will need to be made, and a politician can be excused for going with their gut. But when it comes to setting policy, belief-based ideology should have nothing to do with it.

I've looked up a number of different sources and not not one of them compare it to a religion. The word most often used is 'political'. I'll let the lawyers discuss the 'evidence aspect, but it gets just as fuzzy in that are we talking absolute, circumstantial, testable or untestable.
 
You are certainly entitled to your opinion but the only atheist I can put in the top ten would be Stalin, most of the rest had some kind of religious angle to their evil. Personally I think you are wrong on this.

I think Hitler was essentially atheist. There was no way that any church was going to criticize him, and nor would he allow any church to have any say whatsoever.

Incidentally, the Americans (I think during Reagan) cited the Soviet Union as having a 'Godless idealogy'.
 
I won't miss him one iota. He doesn't serve aethiests well other than to vindicate the perception they are arrogant boors with an equally simplistic view of religion as the jihadist have. Good riddance. Poignant that it was throat cancer too.

You make a good point. There are many atheists who are as intolerant as many of the religious zealots. I say this as an atheist myself.
 
Religion makes people susceptible to irrational persuasion..... all you have to do is say that God says so and they will believe and follow you. Atheists have to work harder to convince you to be stupid.
 
God has silenced him. It's pretty hot down there isn't it Hitchens...
 
God has silenced him. It's pretty hot down there isn't it Hitchens...
Interesting that the two most batshit crazy posts are from people who claim to be religious. This one and the one gloating over the fact he died of throat cancer.
 
I think Hitler was essentially atheist. There was no way that any church was going to criticize him, and nor would he allow any church to have any say whatsoever.

Incidentally, the Americans (I think during Reagan) cited the Soviet Union as having a 'Godless idealogy'.

Hitler was very much not a Christian by the time he was in power. In fact he had clear plans for the complete elimination of the Christian church and made some very clear comments in that regard.

Whether he bought into that nordic pagan stuff Himmler liked to pitch or was something like an atheist is very hard to tell on the record we have available to us.
 
What about the Christian Jihad Crusades? The Dark Ages of Catholic Colonization. Adolf Hitler was a Christian. So is George W. Bush. You've got it all wrong. All wars are fought by people who think God is on their side. Atheists know better. This life is all we've got so they stay out.

This comment simply proves you are ignorant of history. Many of the great mass slaughters in history were done by people for non-religious reasons. As noted, Hitler was not christian, nor was Stalin, or Mao, Cambodia, North Korea...I could go on and on.
 
Indeed! It would be nice if all the idiots who criticize him would read his books and try for a minute to think and open their minds to the logic of his arguments, both religious and political. But then, there's a reason they are idiots...

I have read a fair bit of his stuff, mostly articles but one book. He was a very fine writer, but over his life he was a doctrinaire trotskyite, in support of the Iraq war, and very much against religion. I disagree with him on these positions. A very fine writer indeed, very witty, etc, but that does not mean people are idiots because they disagree with him, as vehemently as Hitch himself disagreed with others.
 
I have read a fair bit of his stuff, mostly articles but one book. He was a very fine writer, but over his life he was a doctrinaire trotskyite, in support of the Iraq war, and very much against religion. I disagree with him on these positions. A very fine writer indeed, very witty, etc, but that does not mean people are idiots because they disagree with him, as vehemently as Hitch himself disagreed with others.

I'm sorry that I made it sound like I consider people who disagree with him are idiots. That's not the case. People are free to agree or disagree with any position expressed by someone. The idiots I was referring to are the ones who make blanket statements about him, attack him personally, and who have never read a line of what he has written. His ability to build an argument was very strong. Reading his arguments requires quite a bit of reflection and introspection, and he challenges the reader into rethinking their position. His position on Iraq can be defended when you look at how bad Saddam Hussein was and how important it is to stand against totalitarianism. It is difficult for leftists, me included, to admit that a military action started by Bush, and based on a lie, can actually be supported. It is a challenge on which of your convictions are the strongest. The guy made you think!
 
Hitler was very much not a Christian by the time he was in power. In fact he had clear plans for the complete elimination of the Christian church and made some very clear comments in that regard.

Whether he bought into that nordic pagan stuff Himmler liked to pitch or was something like an atheist is very hard to tell on the record we have available to us.

I concur.
 
Is it just me, or does it seem Father de Souza in the National Post is almost pleased with the idea that Hitchens may be burning in the hell that de Souza believes in?:

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...er-hitchens-lived-in-service-of-plain-hatred/

How bizarre is this article? If God appointed De Souza to decide who goes to Hell, then I am forced to question His omnipotent wisdom and Goodness.

Anybody who belongs to the church or denomination De Souza calls his, should be embarrassed. De Souza has no right to call himself Christian.
 
How bizarre is this article? If God appointed De Souza to decide who goes to Hell, then I am forced to question His omnipotent wisdom and Goodness.

Anybody who belongs to the church or denomination De Souza calls his, should be embarrassed. De Souza has no right to call himself Christian.

from the article
" He was himself both hateful and cruel. Upon Bob Hope’s death, Hitchens wrote that he was a “fool, and nearly a clown.” When Ronald Reagan died, Hitchens called him a “stupid lizard,” “dumb as a stump” and “an obvious phony and loon.” On Mother Teresa: “The woman was a fanatic and a fundamentalist and a fraud, and millions of people are much worse off because of her life, and it’s a shame there is no hell for your bitch to go to.”

I take a different view, and do sincerely pray for a merciful judgment."
 
How bizarre is this article? If God appointed De Souza to decide who goes to Hell, then I am forced to question His omnipotent wisdom and Goodness.

Anybody who belongs to the church or denomination De Souza calls his, should be embarrassed. De Souza has no right to call himself Christian.

Actually he can call himself a Christian and would not be considered far from the mainstream at all.

The fact is that Hitchens was a hatemonger. He wrote himself about how hate and anger were his biggest motivating factor. And his prose and comments proved it time and again.

"For a lot of people, their first love is what they'll always remember. For me it's always been the first hate, and I think that hatred, though it provides often rather junky energy, is a terrific way of getting you out of bed in the morning and keeping you going. If you don't let it get out of hand, it can be canalized into writing. In this country where people love to be nonjudgmental when they can be, which translates as, on the whole, lenient, there are an awful lot of bubble reputations floating around that one wouldn't be doing one's job if one didn't itch to prick."

For a christian to suggest that a man who lived his life motivated by hate, and rejected the very idea of god, is going to be punished in hell, is not radical at all now is it?