Tire shops will tell you anything just to get rid of their stock. Stick with what your current size is and then there is no question as to handling and performance. Spend as much as you can afford on a good name brand. If money is an issue, you can always buy a store brand, ie; Cdn Tire, who have name brands like Goodyear that you can really only find there, for a decent price and sometimes on sale.
Winter rims are a good investment as well. Tire shops will re & re you in the fall and spring, on average $100 each time, plus making an appointment and the inevitable back log in fall/winter wait time, just to have them installed. With winter rims, if you have space, you can store them yourself, buy a good electric impact gun, if you don't have a good compressor, and a torque wrench. You can re & re yourself in no time, saving that $200 a year. Spend that hobbying.
Oh, and best to get them soon, before the snow flies, because that's when the tire shops get really crazy. Winter rims and the tire size you need could be gone.