Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
Actually, I think I see what you're saying Rub.

The uncle in question has a moral obligation to his family to get the ring back at any cost.

I still think it would be petty to demand money for the ring, but the uncle has to take some ownership of this mess....
 
I think the wisemove here is to sdecure the ring surreptiously. Should have been done aghead of time...but at this point..he needs to get into her good books...get back into the house...and take it back.

She has insurance. Prove he stole it!! Assuming he is devious enough!!

Devil's advocate over here :-p you are evil, lol
 
Update!

My aunt returned the ring to the family. Not through my uncle, but through my sister who was (and is) on good relations with her. According to my sister she was originally planning on giving it to her niece, but thought it'd be insensitive to start her own family heirloom with someone else's family heirloom lol. Generous of her to give it back just like that. She's currently held in much higher regard in the family than my uncle is....
 
Update!

My aunt returned the ring to the family. Not through my uncle, but through my sister who was (and is) on good relations with her. According to my sister she was originally planning on giving it to her niece, but thought it'd be insensitive to start her own family heirloom with someone else's family heirloom lol. Generous of her to give it back just like that. She's currently held in much higher regard in the family than my uncle is....
She did the right thing. Good for her!