Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
I think he sholud take her on one last fishing trip with a pair of custom made cement block shoes....if you catch my drift!

That's disturbing. You are contemplating murder because a woman broke off an engagement and/or didn't return the engagement ring?

I mean, I know this is an escort review board, and a certain amount of objectification of women is normal around here, and we're mostly going to get a male perspective on relationship issues, but is murderous misogyny really acceptable, even here??
 
That's disturbing. You are contemplating murder because a woman broke off an engagement and/or didn't return the engagement ring?

I mean, I know this is an escort review board, and a certain amount of objectification of women is normal around here, and we're mostly going to get a male perspective on relationship issues, but is murderous misogyny really acceptable, even here??

Surely a joke about murderous misogyny may be acceptable.... There's a cavernous leap between offering a quip and actively campaigning for something like that.
 
I disagree.. The default might be that she gets to keep the ring if the ring was purchased. But in the case of family heirlooms being passed on, I would imagine there is another "default" and that would be that the ring would be returned to the family...

The ring wasn't purchased so asking for money for it's return seems more like a ransom to me.

In my opinion the ring wasn't just a gift to the girl. If the girl wasn't joining their family, it's clear that she would not have been given this ring as a gift. To me this ring came with an "implied contract"...
I thought/imagined/expected/assumed that she would give it back sounds like a losing argument to me.
The source of the ring does not equate a prenuptual agreement.

Any implied contract attached to an engagement ring is fulfilled upon the completion of the wedding ceremony.
It would be nice of her to return it for nothing but it is hers and she does deserve some compensation.
Without this ring, he would have had to pay for an engagement ring.
He should be willing to give her the money he would have likely spent.
She would not be holding the ring for ransom.
It is her ring and she is free to sell it but she might want to be courteous and give the family the chance to buy it.

If this ring is so precious to the family, he should have bought an engagement ring and then given this ring to her to use after they were married.
Even then she could be entitled to half it`s value upon separation.
 
Surely a joke about murderous misogyny may be acceptable.... There's a cavernous leap between offering a quip and actively campaigning for something like that.

Of course I'm joking...man it's a tough crowd around here. My cousin just broke off an engagement with a girl he was wth for ten years becasue her parents were too controling over their realtionship. He asked for the $11,500 ring he bought for her back and she refused.
 
I think the wisemove here is to sdecure the ring surreptiously. Should have been done aghead of time...but at this point..he needs to get into her good books...get back into the house...and take it back.

She has insurance. Prove he stole it!! Assuming he is devious enough!!
 
I can understand that that's one way to look at it. But you do see the flip side, don't you? If the "strings attached" was being married, not just getting married, how is the wedding the "end of the deal". I'm not saying you're wrong. But it is cause for debate.

She was married for 2 years. She didn't go through the ceremony and file for divorce in 3 months. She stayed with him for 2 years. His job changed, he wanted kids. These were things that you said changed in the relationship after they got married.

Your question was simple. Should it be returned after divorce? All answers point to no. Not legal, morally, emotionally. The only reason it is up for debate is because it is a family heirloom which doesn't change the facts in the case. She did not cheat, or change the rules or anything. The marriage fell apart from you say because your uncle jumped into something he was not ready for with the wrong person without time for communication and reflection to ensure it was the right choice. By your side, she should have stayed married even if he was a cheat, a drunk etc and if not then she should still give the ring back.

You are throwing out justifications because the ring has emotional value to your family and putting it all on her to "do the right thing" and give it back. Uncle gets a little lecture in stupidity and we call it day. Sorry but I think your uncle needs to step up here and the face the music for losing the family heirloom.
 
I thought/imagined/expected/assumed that she would give it back sounds like a losing argument to me.

Any implied contract attached to an engagement ring is fulfilled upon the completion of the wedding ceremony.

I respectfully disagree. I think it would be clear that the original owner of the ring could care less about whether or not a "ceremony" took place.

I think passing on a "family heirloom" carries with it an implied understanding that item belongs to the family and should the current member of the family in possession of said heirloom die or (in this case) seize to be a member of the family, then the item should be returned to the family.

The "implied contract" is that she would remain a member of the family, not simply join it temporarily.
 
I respectfully disagree. I think it would be clear that the original owner of the ring could care less about whether or not a "ceremony" took place.

I think passing on a "family heirloom" carries with it an implied understanding that item belongs to the family and should the current member of the family in possession of said heirloom die or (in this case) seize to be a member of the family, then the item should be returned to the family.

The "implied contract" is that she would remain a member of the family, not simply join it temporarily.

I am sorry but the passing of a family heirloom only carries with it only the sentimental value of it. If the ring was given to the uncle and then he went and sold it, would we be saying to person who bought to give it back?
 
Your question was simple. Should it be returned after divorce? All answers point to no. Not legal, morally, emotionally.

"All answers" means 100%, right? Funny, it seems "no" is at 50% right now.

This is not a cut and dry issue, even with regards to being married two years. To say it is cut and dry is to disregard half the posts in this thread. I've read all the posts, listened to arguments on both sides, and my own opinion is up in the air at the moment. Which was the point of the thread. To discuss both sides and maybe get an insight into what other people think.
 
I am sorry but the passing of a family heirloom only carries with it only the sentimental value of it. If the ring was given to the uncle and then he went and sold it, would we be saying to person who bought to give it back?

If the uncle sold it then he (as the member of the family in possession of the heirloom) would have sold it with the understanding that ownership of the heirloom was being transferred to another in exchange for cash.

In this case the heirloom is handed over with the understanding that the recipient is receiving it as a new member of the family. Everybody understands that she didn't get the ring because it was Christmas, or her birthday, or as a gift for the "occasion".
 
I respectfully disagree. I think it would be clear that the original owner of the ring could care less about whether or not a "ceremony" took place.

I think passing on a "family heirloom" carries with it an implied understanding that item belongs to the family and should the current member of the family in possession of said heirloom die or (in this case) seize to be a member of the family, then the item should be returned to the family.

The "implied contract" is that she would remain a member of the family, not simply join it temporarily.
If what you say is true, then it is totally inappropriate to give such an item as an engagement ring.
Just like it would be inappropriate to give away such an item as a birthday present.
These sort of actions do not make sense in regards to a family heirloom that is meant to stay in the family forever.

Just because things didn`t work out doesn`t mean that she was not in it for the long haul and her intentions were insincere.
I think the only way to get this ring back is to be nice to her and make a deal.
Piss her off and she may sell it without even telling anybody.
 
If the uncle sold it then he (as the member of the family in possession of the heirloom) would have sold it with the understanding that ownership of the heirloom was being transferred to another in exchange for cash.

In this case the heirloom is handed over with the understanding that the recipient is receiving it as a new member of the family. Everybody understands that she didn't get the ring because it was Christmas, or her birthday, or as a gift for the "occasion".
An engagement ring is given and accepted in contemplation of a marriage taking place.
If it is simply being lent for as long as the marriage lasts, then you need to have a meeting of the minds, preferably documented, and not just a unilateral understanding/assumption.
 
If what you say is true, then it is totally inappropriate to give such an item as an engagement ring.
Just like it would be inappropriate to give away such an item as a birthday present.
These sort of actions do not make sense in regards to a family heirloom that is meant to stay in the family forever.

Just because things didn`t work out doesn`t mean that she was not in it for the long haul and her intentions were insincere.
I think the only way to get this ring back is to be nice to her and make a deal.
Piss her off and she may sell it without even telling anybody.

There's nothing inappropriate about it at all. The ring was handed over to somebody with the understanding that they would become (and remain) a member of the family.

I think the fact that she had pure intentions is irrelevant. Who cares who dumped who.. He could have been cheating on her with every woman in site.. It wouldn't change a damn thing. Her willingness to be a member of the family has no bearing on whether or not she is still a member of the family.

I do agree that if the guy really wants his ring back, he should be sweet as fucking pie about it. After all, "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned".
 
An engagement ring is given and accepted in contemplation of a marriage taking place.

I realize this. Surely there is somebody capable of reasoning though that will recognize that an engagement ring that is also a family heirloom is something different.

Most on this thread seem to agree that engagement rings are given as "conditional gifts". The widely accepted logic is that the condition is that a marriage has to take place. This is the implied contract with the engagement ring. At no point does the man on his knee say "Will you marry me? But return the ring if you or I, decide to call the wedding off? It isn't discussed at all, but most would agree that the contract is there and it says that if the engagement is called off (for whatever reason) then the engagement ring is returned.

In my opinion, a family heirloom carries with it a different implied contract. That implied contract says that while this ring has been given as a symbol of the couple's intention to wed, it should be returned to the family should there be a divorce.
 
If you have photos of the ring, get a duplicate made from a good jeweller.
Your family does not have to know. End of story.
 
There's nothing inappropriate about it at all. The ring was handed over to somebody with the understanding that they would become (and remain) a member of the family.

I think the fact that she had pure intentions is irrelevant. Who cares who dumped who.. He could have been cheating on her with every woman in site.. It wouldn't change a damn thing. Her willingness to be a member of the family has no bearing on whether or not she is still a member of the family.

I do agree that if the guy really wants his ring back, he should be sweet as fucking pie about it. After all, "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned".
If you are right, all they have to do is sue her.
No need to be nice about that.

Without a documented meeting of the minds, inappropriate is being kind.
It is at least that, if not reckless and stupid.

You keep talking about this understanding which along with $3 will get you on the TTC. :rolleyes:
 
You keep talking about this understanding which along with $3 will get you on the TTC. :rolleyes:

No need to be snarky.

You know what.. There is an implied contract. The woman obviously knows that this wasn't simply a gift from the family. She knows damn well why she was given it. She also knows damn well that when it comes right down to it, if they knew (when giving the ring to her) that if the marriage would end in divorce and she would claim the ring as her own, that they would not have handed it over. Having said that, there is likely no way to prove my point. My point draws into question things like "What constitutes a family heirloom" and "If money isn't exchanged, is it even possible to ever gift a family heirloom?".. It's too messy and it's easier for the courts to fall back on what they know. And that's that an engagement ring was handed over, and a marriage took place.

At best this woman has a truly false sense of entitlement (she perhaps figures her willingness to marry the man is more than worth the value of the ring).

At worst this woman is clearly scorned and THAT is why she wants to keep the ring. Even if this guy was physically abusive (which I sincerely hope he wasn't), she's only punishing his family by refusing the return the ring. It's just plain stupid.
 
In my opinion, a family heirloom carries with it a different implied contract. That implied contract says that while this ring has been given as a symbol of the couple's intention to wed, it should be returned to the family should there be a divorce.
Assuming that your understanding of an implied contract is universal and legally binding would be risky, to say the least.

If you expect to be able to get the ring back 10 or even 20+ years later, why wouldn`t you document this?
If it really is a mutual understanding and not just a unilateral assumption, it shouldn`t be a big deal.