Property Rights Questions?

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
There is a narrow (maybe 30"-36") walkway that separates my house from my neighbor's house. Our family are the only people who use this walkway to get from the front to the rear of our property. The wall of our house facing the neighbor's house has 2 windows. The neighbor's house wall is solid, no windows, no doors, etc.

The neighbor wants to install a high efficiency furnace and install 2 pipes on the outside of his wall facing my walkway. The pipes will extend maybe 5" onto my walkway at a height of maybe 3'-4'. Worse, one of the pipes is the furnace exhaust pipe meaning toxic fumes will be coming out. Obviously, this is not something I want.

What are my legal rights and what are my neighbor's legal rights?
 
The various guys who quoted for my furnace all agreed that the narrow space between house was prohibited—by whose code they didn't say—and that even the eight foot shared drive on the other side was dubious but do-able only because it was paved as two paths, one on each property. Call 311, in the old City of Toronto there was a building inspector just for furnace installations, the job may no longer exist but the various individual city bylaws still do. But before you talk tough you need to check your survey to find out exacly where the property-line is; do not assume it's down the middle. Three feet belonging entirely to him may be all he needs. as a matter of legality.

What alternatives does he have?
 
But before you talk tough you need to check your survey to find out exacly where the property-line is; do not assume it's down the middle. Three feet belonging entirely to him may be all he needs. as a matter of legality.

If I do have a survey, it is well hidden in a box or a closet or in the basement somewhere. I'll do a search. As a practical, and maybe also legal matter, our family are the only people using this 3 feet walkway. He has no access to this walkway unless he goes on my property (subject to what the survey might say)

What alternatives does he have?
In theory, he can install the pipes in the front, back or on the other side of his house but he said that this would be very costly and means running pipes through much of his finished basement. His furnace is right next the the wall that faces my walkway.
 
Imagine what would ensue if your neighbor was a terbite and reads this thread.

Anyway, he can't build anything that abuts onto your property. So, confirm *exactly* where your property line is. And even if he goes ahead and builds it so that it is only on his property, if dangerous fumes drift onto your property, you have a tort claim for nuisance.

Keep in mind that this is your neighbor, you will see this person all the time and threatening legal action isn't the best idea.
 
Anyway, he can't [legally] build anything that [intrudes] onto your property. So, confirm *exactly* where your property line is. And even if he goes ahead and builds it so that it is only on his property, if dangerous fumes drift onto your property, you have a tort claim for nuisance.
That indeed is the way it would be here, and I presume in Ontario as well.
 
I just had my lot re-surveyed, with stakes & lines, for $70. Money well spent, and as a secondary benefit the lines are there for any neighbors to see as well.
 
If I do have a survey, it is well hidden in a box or a closet or in the basement somewhere. I'll do a search. As a practical, and maybe also legal matter, our family are the only people using this 3 feet walkway. He has no access to this walkway unless he goes on my property (subject to what the survey might say)

In theory, he can install the pipes in the front, back or on the other side of his house but he said that this would be very costly and means running pipes through much of his finished basement. His furnace is right next the the wall that faces my walkway.
If he has no actual access to that walkway, then it is quite unlikely any useful amount of it is his property, as is the case with my neighbour, who has only six inches <giggle> of the walkway. You can't keep him out of it to do needed inspections and repairs but that doesn't require you to accommodate his preferred vent location. As others have said, that could be an actionable tort—although you really want him to take the action you'd prefer without lawyers—even if the City doesn't prohibit it. Ask them NOW.

I'd suspect your neighbour hasn't yet gotten a reputable installer to quote, as they'd certainly tell him what is and isn't permitted and, if that was a proper install option, he'd be telling you 'tough noogies' instead of musing about it to see how you'd respond. Get that survey, which likely was in the documents you got when you bought. At times like this it's precious, and well worth you getting a new one if you cannot find the old. And if he is permitted, I'd offer to cover the cost of the ceiling repair to get it vented out the other side.
 
I just had my lot re-surveyed, with stakes & lines, for $70.

Are you at liberty to disclose the name and contact info for your surveyor? $70 sounds like a very fair price.

I called 311 a couple of hours ago and the lady said to try the Provincial Land Registry office on 20 Dundas to see if they have a survey on file.
 
Have you tried talking to your neighbour? It's almost always better to try and resolve these problems through friendly negotiations before you go down the legal route.

See if you can come up with some constructive proposals that would allow him to accomplish what he is trying to do, but without aggravation to you.
 
What does your deed say?

Will have to do a search for my deed. House was purchased many many years ago. So far, I found a mortgage document from 1988 that gives a narrative description of the property boundaries.

P.S. Just noticed your post on my other thread about HE furnaces and the external exhaust pipe. My neighbor's installer said that he could run the exhaust pipe about 12 feet up my neighbor's wall above ground level. He said this should be high enough to disperse the exhaust and avoid people below.
 
Excellent advice from fuji. It never hurts to know what your rights are, but that can tempt people into being more antagonistic than is good for getting to a solution. Until you know stuff definitely, it would be best to restrict yourself to, "Gee, doesn't sound attractive, being so close to my windows and all; are you sure that's legal?"

Furnace emissions are quite acidic, which he may not realize and that's why I'd suspect the code-compliance of any vent closer than two feet (.6M) to his property-line. They won't do either house any good in the confined space.
 
Furnace emissions are quite acidic, which he may not realize and that's why I'd suspect the code-compliance of any vent closer than two feet (.6M) to his property-line. They won't do either house any good in the confined space.

Thanks. I wasn't aware of the "2 feet" rule. The exhaust pipe from my own HE furnace is more than 2 (but not more than 3) feet from his wall.

I agree with you and Fuji that a neighborly agreement is the best possible solution but it never hurts to know my (and his) legal rights. These folks bought the house 2 years ago from a very long term owner. Although we are not friends, relations are good in the sense that they mind their own business and I mind my own business, they are quiet, clean and don't have any kids (noisy) or animals.
 
Have you tried talking to your neighbour? It's almost always better to try and resolve these problems through friendly negotiations before you go down the legal route.

See if you can come up with some constructive proposals that would allow him to accomplish what he is trying to do, but without aggravation to you.

I believe he has, as his neighbour told him about the costly shift of pipes across to the opposite side of his house.
 
How about idling your car 6 inches from your neighbour's basement window, I've sure that's far more toxic. :eyebrows:
 
Will have to do a search for my deed. House was purchased many many years ago. So far, I found a mortgage document from 1988 that gives a narrative description of the property boundaries.

P.S. Just noticed your post on my other thread about HE furnaces and the external exhaust pipe. My neighbor's installer said that he could run the exhaust pipe about 12 feet up my neighbor's wall above ground level. He said this should be high enough to disperse the exhaust and avoid people below.

And since that's external it shouldn't cost too much more though that 626 pipe ain't the cheapest stuff to buy.
 
Are you at liberty to disclose the name and contact info for your surveyor? $70 sounds like a very fair price.

I called 311 a couple of hours ago and the lady said to try the Provincial Land Registry office on 20 Dundas to see if they have a survey on file.

$70 seems extremely low and would be a flag for me. Heck, I can put stakes down for $70.

I received a quote from a well known company for almost 10 times that rate.
 
And since that's external it shouldn't cost too much more though that 626 pipe ain't the cheapest stuff to buy.

Do you think 12 feet above ground level is high enough? Is the 626 pipe the white plastic type?

BTW: I found the survey. It looks like the entire walkway is on my property. According to the survey it is only 2.68 feet wide.
 
BTW: I found the survey. It looks like the entire walkway is on my property. According to the survey it is only 2.68 feet wide.

That would appear to give you a lot of clout. I'd still start out by negotiating with the guy, keeping the legal option in your back pocket. In many cases with these sorts of things even if you win, you lose.

My aunt has a property dispute with her neighbour. She's got a shed which the neighbour claims extends a couple of feet onto their property. The shed was built before the neighbour moved in, and when they moved in they promptly informed her that they believed her shed was on their property. She hired a surveyor and reviewed with her lawyer and they all agreed that the neighbour was wrong, the shed is completely on my aunt's property. The neighbour is basing his information on what his real estate agent told him, so probably his information is less reliable. The cost of moving the shed is a few hundred dollars.

She's moving the shed.

If it went down the legal route, even if she won it would cost more to fight the case than to move the shed, and this way she's still on friendly terms with the neighbours. She did leave in the surveyor's stakes that show her to be in the right, but never mentioned that to the neighbour (they can see it for themselves) and moved the shed anyway, just to avoid an acrimonious fight with someone she'll deal with frequently.
 
There is a narrow (maybe 30"-36") walkway that separates my house from my neighbor's house. Our family are the only people who use this walkway to get from the front to the rear of our property. The wall of our house facing the neighbor's house has 2 windows. The neighbor's house wall is solid, no windows, no doors, etc.

The neighbor wants to install a high efficiency furnace and install 2 pipes on the outside of his wall facing my walkway. The pipes will extend maybe 5" onto my walkway at a height of maybe 3'-4'. Worse, one of the pipes is the furnace exhaust pipe meaning toxic fumes will be coming out. Obviously, this is not something I want.

What are my legal rights and what are my neighbor's legal rights?

Dude: Natural Gas & Propane Installation Code B149.1-19, reference 8.14.8a, probably also b, possibly g
Based on what you've described, vent termination can't go there.
Licensed installers will know it can't be done to code; if somehow they do go ahead and do it, call the Technical Standards & Safety Authority to come inspect the installation.