Supreme Court Appointments

Let me ask politely...are you a legal professional?

Because based on this paragraph you have the process backwards. Things that are black and white are dealt with in settlement and via summary judgement and early resolution tools.

Grey areas are what makes it to trial courts and appellate courts. There the courts must struggle with the gaps or conflicts in the law or the facts. That is precisely what is meant by a grey area.

The legislature writes legislation, and the courts interpret it when parties cannot agree on its interpretation, application or validity. If a party dislikes a piece of legislation he has not automatic method of sending it back to the legislature to have it clarified. They can either lobby to change it, or go to the courts.

Now judges don't have the right to interpret statutes any way they so choose, they are in turn governed by fairly strict rules of statutory interpretation.

But to say judges should only deal with the black and white, and never the grey, that is backwards.
May be I am missing something but what kind of strict rule of statutory interpretation is applied to judgements by the SCC? What checks and balances are applicable to their rulings?
 
This really seems to me to be a disingenuous comment. I made my reply in response to a specific case (in a different jurisdiction) but it was specific. Scott and Plessey tarnished the reputations of the supreme court south of the border for many many years. In my opinion it is still tarnished. I will redirect you to my original objection and that is my opinion that Sharpe is more likely to make this sort of mistake. Before I cite cases that illustrate my point I have to ask. Do you really think that all the SCC judgements were correct interpretations of the law? Ifyou take issue with some of them then why are you asking me to cite cases when you agree with my premise?
In fact they are the only correct interpretation of the law. Those who disagree have two options, neither quick and easy for very good reason: to get the law changed to what they thought it should have been, or to find a case so different, but nonetheless germane, that it highlights the 'defective' interpretation enough for courts all the way up the line to want the Supremes to pronounce on it in clarification.

Ultimately Parliament is supreme and has the both the first and the next word. They could, in emergency session very speedily 'correct' an improper decision by the SCC, but they have other better things to do than second-guess the body our Constitution says is the last word on what the law is. Under the rule of law the courts must be the last word, until Parliament speaks again.

So I do not agree with your premise, and again ask you to support your various contentions with some specific instances, not just one.

As for the Dred Scott decision which you did refer to, it's a fine example of the courts being stuck with the conflicting, incomplete, and inadequately drafted laws that pols make to pacify their constituents. It eventually took a long and bloody war to sort out that mess, and no court in the land could have prevented it. But laws as a reflection of the state of the public debate and opinion of their time is a matter for another thread. It only belongs in this one insofar as expecting the Courts to assess, and bow to 'popular sovereignty' would rob every other part of the body politic of its democratic right. Their job is the law.
 
May be I am missing something but what kind of strict rule of statutory interpretation is applied to judgements by the SCC? What checks and balances are applicable to their rulings?

http://aix1.uottawa.ca/~resulliv/legdr/siinscc.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_interpretation

If you want to understand Statutory Interpretation, start with the above and then take a law school course on it. It is really dull, at least it was to me, but very important.

What checks and balances are there on the SCC? If parliament doesn't like their ruling, they either revise the legislation or clarify it, or pass something notwithstanding. If it every came to a direct showdown between the will or parliament and the SCC, parliament has all the tools to win. However, I can not think of any instances were it has been that bad.
 
For all the criticism about our courts and appointments etc the fact is that it ha never become politicized in the way the US court has. We are very fortunate to have court comprised of great jurists and we should all be thankful. The only elemt of politics which enters the selection process is the regional make-up which has more to do with history than politics.

I had the great fortune to appear before the SCC many years ago with Bora Laskin as the chief and it was great and memorable experience.
 
May be I am missing something but what kind of strict rule of statutory interpretation is applied to judgements by the SCC? What checks and balances are applicable to their rulings?
Roughly speaking the same as apply to the top dogs in the other branches of our government: almost none. That's why we make getting to be top dog a difficult process, because there's no 'topper' dog. Although in our system—unlike the American—we can sort of imagine a process by which Her Majesty's Government could, with Parliamentary approval, de-fang and disempower the SCC which dispenses Her Majesty's justice, in practice that would be quite difficult. And for very good reason.

Applying a "…strict rule of statutory interpretation" to the Supreme Court's judgements would require an Even More Supreme Court to do it, would it not?
 
Applying a "…strict rule of statutory interpretation" to the Supreme Court's judgements would require an Even More Supreme Court to do it, would it not?

The abolished Appeals to the Privy Council many years ago.
 
Roughly speaking the same as apply to the top dogs in the other branches of our government: almost none. That's why we make getting to be top dog a difficult process, because there's no 'topper' dog. Although in our system—unlike the American—we can sort of imagine a process by which Her Majesty's Government could, with Parliamentary approval, de-fang and disempower the SCC which dispenses Her Majesty's justice, in practice that would be quite difficult. And for very good reason.

Applying a "…strict rule of statutory interpretation" to the Supreme Court's judgements would require an Even More Supreme Court to do it, would it not?

No, it would require hundreds of years of precedent. Which is why statutory interpretation is foundational work in almost every Canadian law school, or it was when I was there...
 
I looked at the links you supplied and my original question stands are there any strict rules?

So in a nutshell the only recourse is the notwithstanding clause. I am troubled by this.

I grant that you are correct. In principle a party could publish a manifesto with a clear objective to override an egregious judgement in respect to a particular matter of law. The problem is this. The notwisthstanding clause only applies to very narrow rulings and is intended solely as an exception. It does not override the principles that the court establishes. We would still be stuck with the consequences of Res Judicata. The government would be caught in a perpetual need to pass notwithstanding clauses on every supporting piece of legislation. There needs to be something with more teeth to correct the court. The best solution is to appoint justices who are less ambitious and do not to want to recreate society based on their own personal principles but rather simply interpret the law of that land.
Bad legislation coming from the SCC is not good for our country.
 
No, it would require hundreds of years of precedent. Which is why statutory interpretation is foundational work in almost every Canadian law school, or it was when I was there...
And is that not what the Supremes are expected to apply to a case: a thorough understanding and knowledge of the blackletter law and the years of precedents underpinning, interpreting and applying it? On that 'statutory interpretation', do they not have the final word?

Unless I misunderstood, Sisyphus was calling for a judge of the judges to somehow hold them to account on the strictness of that interpretation. Which would then want a judge of those judges.

But my understanding is only a layman's.

NOTE: Since this dropped below a post of Sisyphus's, I'll use it to note that the Quebec National Assembly long had a tradition of prefixing words invoking the Notwithstanding Clause to every bill it passed, seeking thereby to become the sole and only arbiter of what its laws said, just as he hypothesized. But of course they could also absolve themselves of any guilt about betraying the Constitution.
 
The abolished Appeals to the Privy Council many years ago.
And weren't we all so very happy back then when the Law Lords called our uppity colonial Supreme Court to account? Buck's gotta stop somewhere, and an open Courtroom is a better place than a secret Cabinet Room.

Besides, correcting the Court just needs the Cabinet, supported by votes in the House and Senate to pass a better law, that actually does the job this time 'round. A job they should promptly get down to instead of whining about being caught out or having their pet projects frustrated.

Or maybe just quietly admit to past bad thinking and get on with new business.
 
I looked at the links you supplied and my original question stands are there any strict rules?

So in a nutshell the only recourse is the notwithstanding clause. I am troubled by this.

I grant that you are correct. In principle a party could publish a manifesto with a clear objective to override an egregious judgement in respect to a particular matter of law. The problem is this. The notwisthstanding clause only applies to very narrow rulings and is intended solely as an exception. It does not override the principles that the court establishes. We would still be stuck with the consequences of Res Judicata. The government would be caught in a perpetual need to pass notwithstanding clauses on every supporting piece of legislation. There needs to be something with more teeth to correct the court. The best solution is to appoint justices who are less ambitious and do not to want to recreate society based on their own personal principles but rather simply interpret the law of that land.
Bad legislation coming from the SCC is not good for our country.

The answer to your first question is "yes". And if you don't get it from those two posts, you can always take a course on it. The concept is quite clear.

The parliament could, if it chose, pass a peice of legislation setting aside or overriding a SCC decision and its stare decisis if it wanted. There would be no need for perpetual notwithstanding clauses. You really do not have a good handle on the process.

Our SCC has a fantastic track record. It has never been anywhere near as partisan as our neighbours to the south.

But, from time to time, major social issues make their way to the SCC. This usually happens when the government refuses to deal with a live issue through legislation. It takes years to get to the SCC, and if the government has a strong policy they want to enforce they can head the whole thing off with legislation way before it gets there. They often don't, unfortunately based on political contingencies. The government can also refer matters directly to the SCC for rulings before the legislation is even passed if it wants.

In the end you chose to misuse the word "legislation." The SCC never legislates. Ever.

But let me try a different proposition on for you..."bad legislation is not good for the country." and "bad SCC rulings are not good from the country."

I can tell you though, that the kind of SCC rulings you theorize about are thin on the ground. Are there any in particular that cause you such worry?
 
And is that not what the Supremes are expected to apply to a case: a thorough understanding and knowledge of the blackletter law and the years of precedents underpinning, interpreting and applying it? On that 'statutory interpretation', do they not have the final word?

Unless I misunderstood, Sisyphus was calling for a judge of the judges to somehow hold them to account on the strictness of that interpretation. Which would then want a judge of those judges.

But my understanding is only a layman's.

NOTE: Since this dropped below a post of Sisyphus's, I'll use it to note that the Quebec National Assembly long had a tradition of prefixing words invoking the Notwithstanding Clause to every bill it passed, seeking thereby to become the sole and only arbiter of what its laws said, just as he hypothesized. But of course they could also absolve themselves of any guilt about betraying the Constitution.

You raised a great example. It is ironic that the prov. of Quebec is responsible for one particularly bad judgment to be brought before the SCC. In Assisted Human Reproduction Act, 2010 SCC 61, [2010] 3 S.C.R. 457 we see a very good clear example of the clown show that the SCC has become. There is no serious argument that this was not a federal matter.
I have no doubt that the body of law was clear on the matter. It absolutely falls with in the purview of the federal government. This was an excellent example of good well thought out legislation congruent with the constitution struck down simply by SCC hubris.
 
I must have missed that paragraph about assisted reproduction being among the federal powers in the BNA Act. I admit I'm less familiar with Constitution, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't mentioned there either. Which would leave it a healthcare matter for the provinces I woulda thought, or no business of anyone but the parents.

But I'm sure you could support your view by other than the arguments the SCC considered and rejected. Because, oddly enough just as the name implies, they are the Supreme Court.

But as understand the case in question, the Supremes simply said of that particular federal law, 'not good enough, try again', which no government since has had the—dear me, the word that comes first to mind is totally inappropriate in the context of reproduction—will to do. As with abortion.

Once again, you seem to be asking for a More Supreme Court.