Supreme Court Appointments

For a person in his position to be so publicly critical, he must feel that there has been an injustice.
It isn't that uncommon when you know know a very well qualified candidate who is passed over, to feel they have been "done dirt." This is exacerbated in the Canadian system where a certain number of Justices have traditionally come from certain provinces so it is in reality a smaller pool and people better know the likely candidates.
 
This is exactly the point I made. Time and again we see, in many jurisdictions, justices who take it upon them selves to make public policy rather then ascertaining what the law is. We must be very vigilant that the justices we choose for the highest court of the land err on the side of popular sovereignty. Political issue are ultra vires and should be decided politically. The court wields the very dangerous powers that flow from res judicata thereby closing issues that the court has no business closing. How can long will it take to undue the damage done by the series of poor judgements the court has already rendered?
Going back to Chief Justice Marshall, if it not the duty of the Supreme Court of Canada to determine whether laws are "Constitutional" and what the Charter actually means in grey areas then whose is it?

There is a significant (in all senses) difference between "judicial activism" and Judicial Review.
 
Th[eir] job is to know what the law is. As of late one gets the impression that the standard procedure is to render a judgment and then find what ever spurious precedent that is expedient to support the judgement. Before saying what the law is I would like them to know what the law is and respect what the law is.
That may be the impression, but only one who attends the justices' sessions can know. Arguments before the Court and the decisions published make ample reference to existing statute and law as precedents have defined and refined it. I don't really see how one could ask for more.Could we ask you for a non-spurious precedent or two to support your judgment of the Court?

What frustrates folks with partisan views of a given case at issue is the fact that any statute and what it says must also be constitutionally valid, because the Constitution and the Charter are supreme over any given statute (or existing precedent). It doesn't matter a fig what the law says (even less what it might have been intended to say, but did not), nor can judges respect it if it does not accord with the Charter and/or the Constitution. Perhaps you might better address your concern to the lawmakers and governments who imagine the law is whatever they think today, and not what they actually enacted, which can be read in the statute books.

There is nothing new in this; it's what Courts do and have always done, and whining about it is a long tradition in countries where the rule of law prevails.

This is exactly the point I made. Time and again we see, in many jurisdictions, justices who take it upon them selves to make public policy rather then ascertaining what the law is. We must be very vigilant that the justices we choose for the highest court of the land err on the side of popular sovereignty. Political issue are ultra vires and should be decided politically. The court wields the very dangerous powers that flow from res judicata thereby closing issues that the court has no business closing. How can long will it take to undue the damage done by the series of poor judgements the court has already rendered?
Again, specific references instead of a vague your "[t]ime and again…" would be appropriate when you're suggesting others are 'just making it up' to suit themselves. It is of course too idealistic to imagine judges do not err, but to assume that they should favour a certain sort or error—what you call "popular sovereignty"—invites them to abandon the established law for whatever that 'popular sovereignty' might be. Or what they think it should be. That's what politicians do, and they get to try to sell their view for votes and get that view transformed into statutes. They make the laws, opining on what the law they made means is ultra vires. As would it be for the Court to interfere in the political process and dictate the 'fix' for a bad law they struck down.

Smart pols and smart judges both recognize this awkward process is a debate; shortsighted ones—the first and loudest usually—imagine it's a win-lose contest, and they are on the side of the right. They're the ones to fear.

Better judges should do just as they do now: Insist that the laws are what the laws say, and leave it to the legislators to make the laws say it better.
 
Going back to Chief Justice Marshall, if it not the duty of the Supreme Court of Canada to determine whether laws are "Constitutional" and what the Charter actually means in grey areas then whose is it?

There is a significant (in all senses) difference between "judicial activism" and Judicial Review.

With respect to grey areas it really is outside the purview and the brief of the court. The benefit of the doubt should go to our elected representatives and the interpretations they place in the constitution. The justices job is to state what is black and white. The grey areas are defined in the political realm.
 
Again, specific references instead of a vague your "[t]ime and again
This really seems to me to be a disingenuous comment. I made my reply in response to a specific case (in a different jurisdiction) but it was specific. Scott and Plessey tarnished the reputations of the supreme court south of the border for many many years. In my opinion it is still tarnished. I will redirect you to my original objection and that is my opinion that Sharpe is more likely to make this sort of mistake. Before I cite cases that illustrate my point I have to ask. Do you really think that all the SCC judgements were correct interpretations of the law? Ifyou take issue with some of them then why are you asking me to cite cases when you agree with my premise?
 
With respect to grey areas it really is outside the purview and the brief of the court. The benefit of the doubt should go to our elected representatives and the interpretations they place in the constitution. The justices job is to state what is black and white. The grey areas are defined in the political realm.
Years ago Canada like the U.K. was like this; a legacy of the Glorious Revolution which in Great Britain proper killed the idea of Judicial Review: see the opinion of Chief Justice (of England) Sir Edward Coke in Dr. Bonham’s Case

However, Canada now has a written Constitution and has become more like the U.S.A. (where by the way Judicial Review due to the influence of Coke's Institutes of the Lawes of England never died out during the Colonial Period). There is no question now in Canada that unless the "Not Withstanding" clause is invoked laws must conform to both the Constitution and the Charter. Further that it is the role of the courts to say whether there is a conflict.

Even in the U.K. the move is away from absolute Parliamentary supremacy with the creation of a Supreme Court.
 
With respect to grey areas it really is outside the purview and the brief of the court. The benefit of the doubt should go to our elected representatives and the interpretations they place in the constitution. The justices job is to state what is black and white. The grey areas are defined in the political realm.

Let me ask politely...are you a legal professional?

Because based on this paragraph you have the process backwards. Things that are black and white are dealt with in settlement and via summary judgement and early resolution tools.

Grey areas are what makes it to trial courts and appellate courts. There the courts must struggle with the gaps or conflicts in the law or the facts. That is precisely what is meant by a grey area.

The legislature writes legislation, and the courts interpret it when parties cannot agree on its interpretation, application or validity. If a party dislikes a piece of legislation he has not automatic method of sending it back to the legislature to have it clarified. They can either lobby to change it, or go to the courts.

Now judges don't have the right to interpret statutes any way they so choose, they are in turn governed by fairly strict rules of statutory interpretation.

But to say judges should only deal with the black and white, and never the grey, that is backwards.
 
Years ago Canada like the U.K. was like this; a legacy of the Glorious Revolution which in Great Britain proper killed the idea of Judicial Review: see the opinion of Chief Justice (of England) Sir Edward Coke in Dr. Bonham’s Case

However, Canada now has a written Constitution and has become more like the U.S.A. (where by the way Judicial Review due to the influence of Coke's Institutes of the Lawes of England never died out during the Colonial Period). There is no question now in Canada that unless the "Not Withstanding" clause is invoked laws must conform to both the Constitution and the Charter. Further that it is the role of the courts to say whether there is a conflict.

Even in the U.K. the move is away from absolute Parliamentary supremacy with the creation of a Supreme Court.

The comments of Sisyphus and other such comments are made by those who do not understand how courts and Constitutions and Charters etc work.

It is the rile of the SCC to ultimately resolve conflicts in the application of the Constitution and or the Charter to the Laws of Parliament. If not the SCC then who?

Disputes of that sort arise because parties cannot agree on what the effect or proper application of the Constitution or the Charter to a particular law or set of facts.

The parties who complain loudest about judicial activism etc are usually the people at the wrong end of a decisions. Their voices at much more muted when they are on the right side. One persons judicial activism is often another's reasonable and thoughtful judgement.
 
With respect to grey areas it really is outside the purview and the brief of the court. The benefit of the doubt should go to our elected representatives and the interpretations they place in the constitution. The justices job is to state what is black and white. The grey areas are defined in the political realm.
It sound s like you would prefer a civil law system. In common law countries, higher courts have always made law. You cannot get around it. BTW, elected representatives also made the Constitution Act so when it comes to the constitutionality of laws, the question is whether one set of laws made by elected representatives is consistent with another set of laws made by representatives.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying higher courts don’t sometime basically rewrite the constitution when they interpret laws. I have always thought the novel way they interpreted the reference to “indirect taxes” in the BNA ACT to allow provincial sales taxes is a perfect example. However, at some level, if you are going to have a higher law in the form of a constitution, you are going to need someone to decide if other laws are consistent with it (even in a civil law system).
 
toguy nailed it with this
"The parties who complain loudest about judicial activism etc are usually the people at the wrong end of a decisions. Their voices at much more muted when they are on the right side. One persons judicial activism is often another's reasonable and thoughtful judgement."

No doubt Harper picked a pair who will render reasonable and thoughtful judgements, at least in his subjective opinion. In other words , they lean his way politically. Harper, the master manipulator has restocked the upper civil service with frightened puppets who will do his bidding and this is just another aspect of the plan.
 
For a person in his position to be so publicly critical, he must feel that there has been an injustice.

I would respectfully disagree with your observation here. In my experience law school professors, particularly the career academics, love to criticize the courts, the government and anything remotely connected with these two institutions - it is there raison d'etre.

As far as I can tell Ziegel is a life long academic who, quite possibly, has never argued a case, never represented a client, and never had to put his opinion on the line and defend it. He has spent his career lobbing potshots from the sidelines and, while undoubtedly very intelligent and very informed on the issues, is miles away from the every day, real life practice of law. He is entitled to his opinion but we are also entitled to give it little or no weight.
 
No doubt Harper picked a pair who will render reasonable and thoughtful judgements, at least in his subjective opinion. In other words , they lean his way politically.
Gee no fooling, and U.S. President's, Provincial Premiers and State Governors don't act in entirely the same manner?

However, sometimes what you think you see is not what you get look at President Eisenhower and Chief Justice Warren or President Lincoln and Chief Justice Chase.
 
As long as we don't get saddled with a Scalia or a Thomas we will be fine...
 
As far as I can tell Ziegel is a life long academic who, quite possibly, has never argued a case, never represented a client, and never had to put his opinion on the line and defend it. He has spent his career lobbing potshots from the sidelines and, while undoubtedly very intelligent and very informed on the issues, is miles away from the every day, real life practice of law. He is entitled to his opinion but we are also entitled to give it little or no weight.

You are correct.
 
No doubt about it. He is a master of historical fiction.
Hum, here I was under the impression that it was non-fiction binding precident at least south of a certain border. Or at least it is when he is writting for the majority :)
 
Hum, here I was under the impression that it was non-fiction binding precident at least south of a certain border. Or at least it is when he is writting for the majority :)

I concede that it would be binding precedent...non-fiction...not so much. ;-)
 
can't help but think...isn't it just fucking sad that there is so many lawyers on this board?
 
Years ago Canada like the U.K. was like this; a legacy of the Glorious Revolution which in Great Britain proper killed the idea of Judicial Review: see the opinion of Chief Justice (of England) Sir Edward Coke in Dr. Bonham’s Case

However, Canada now has a written Constitution and has become more like the U.S.A. (where by the way Judicial Review due to the influence of Coke's Institutes of the Lawes of England never died out during the Colonial Period). There is no question now in Canada that unless the "Not Withstanding" clause is invoked laws must conform to both the Constitution and the Charter. Further that it is the role of the courts to say whether there is a conflict.

Even in the U.K. the move is away from absolute Parliamentary supremacy with the creation of a Supreme Court.
I am sorry if I don't understand this but what does Coke have to do with the glorious revolution?