Th[eir] job is to know what the law is. As of late one gets the impression that the standard procedure is to render a judgment and then find what ever spurious precedent that is expedient to support the judgement. Before saying what the law is I would like them to know what the law is and respect what the law is.
That may be the impression, but only one who attends the justices' sessions can know. Arguments before the Court and the decisions published make ample reference to existing statute and law as precedents have defined and refined it. I don't really see how one could ask for more.Could we ask you for a non-spurious precedent or two to support your judgment of the Court?
What frustrates folks with partisan views of a given case at issue is the fact that any statute and what it says must also be constitutionally valid, because the Constitution and the Charter are supreme over any given statute (or existing precedent). It doesn't matter a fig what the law says (even less what it might have been intended to say, but did not), nor can judges respect it if it does not accord with the Charter and/or the Constitution. Perhaps you might better address your concern to the lawmakers and governments who imagine the law is whatever they think today, and not what they actually enacted, which can be read in the statute books.
There is nothing new in this; it's what Courts do and have always done, and whining about it is a long tradition in countries where the rule of law prevails.
This is exactly the point I made. Time and again we see, in many jurisdictions, justices who take it upon them selves to make public policy rather then ascertaining what the law is. We must be very vigilant that the justices we choose for the highest court of the land err on the side of popular sovereignty. Political issue are ultra vires and should be decided politically. The court wields the very dangerous powers that flow from res judicata thereby closing issues that the court has no business closing. How can long will it take to undue the damage done by the series of poor judgements the court has already rendered?
Again, specific references instead of a vague your "[t]ime and again…" would be appropriate when you're suggesting others are 'just making it up' to suit themselves. It is of course too idealistic to imagine judges do not err, but to assume that they should favour a certain sort or error—what you call "popular sovereignty"—invites them to abandon the established law for whatever that 'popular sovereignty' might be. Or what they think it should be. That's what politicians do, and they get to try to sell their view for votes and get that view transformed into statutes. They make the laws, opining on what the law they made means is
ultra vires. As would it be for the Court to interfere in the political process and dictate the 'fix' for a bad law they struck down.
Smart pols and smart judges both recognize this awkward process is a debate; shortsighted ones—the first and loudest usually—imagine it's a win-lose contest, and they are on the side of the right. They're the ones to fear.
Better judges should do just as they do now: Insist that the laws are what the laws say, and leave it to the legislators to make the laws say it better.