Supreme Court Appointments

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Prime Minister Harper has appointed Andromache Karakatsanis and Michael Moldaver to the Supreme Court of Canada. Does anybody know if they are "escort friendly" judges?:confused:
 
I know nothing about the Greek lady, but Moldaver would bring an open and liberal mind to the subject.
 
I know nothing about the Greek lady, but Moldaver would bring an open and liberal mind to the subject.

LOL.
he's not considered a "liberal".
And the "greek" lady is ultra conservative whom is scarey bad. She WON'T be escort friendly considering she is known as a miserable jaded cunt.
 
An interesting comment from Jacob S. Ziegel in a letter to the editor in the Globe and Mail yesterday;

Partisan picks
Re PM Taps Ontario Judges Karakatsanis, Moldaver For Supreme Court (Oct. 17): Mr. Justice Michael J. Moldaver is a very experienced criminal law expert and long-time member of the Ontario Court of Appeal. His appointment will no doubt strengthen this side of the Supreme Court’s appellate work.

Madam Justice Andromache Karakatsanis is in a different category. She has only been on the appeal court for about two years; her experience on the trial bench was not much longer. By all accounts her swift elevation to the Supreme Court was based on ideological considerations and to please the Greek community.

The Court of Appeal justice who should have been elevated was undoubtedly Robert Sharpe, an outstanding jurist and legal scholar, as highly regarded overseas as here, a former dean of the University of Toronto law school, fluently bilingual, with first-hand experience of the Supreme Court while serving as senior legal counsel to chief justice Brian Dickson.

The fact that he has been passed over twice is convincing proof why appointments to the Supreme Court should be taken out of the hands of highly partisan politicians and entrusted to a much better balanced national appointments commission.

Jacob S. Ziegel, professor of law emeritus, University of Toronto
 
I have appeared before both. Not too sure about Karkatsanis but Moldaver is an outstanding jurist. he is a great addition to the SCC.
 
An interesting comment from Jacob S. Ziegel in a letter to the editor in the Globe and Mail yesterday;

Partisan picks

The Court of Appeal justice who should have been elevated was undoubtedly Robert Sharpe, an outstanding jurist and legal scholar, as highly regarded overseas as here, a former dean of the University of Toronto law school, fluently bilingual, with first-hand experience of the Supreme Court while serving as senior legal counsel to chief justice Brian Dickson.

The fact that he has been passed over twice is convincing proof why appointments to the Supreme Court should be taken out of the hands of highly partisan politicians and entrusted to a much better balanced national appointments commission.

Jacob S. Ziegel, professor of law emeritus, University of Toronto
Sharpe said "Charter adjudication is anything but the mechanical application of pre-established rules. The judges are called upon to delve deeply into the very foundations of our legal system and political culture to answer questions of the most fundamental nature, and many of these questions cannot be answered adequately by reference only to traditional legal sources."
Sharpe isn't suitable for traffic court. If he wishes to devle deeply, I suggest that he run for Parliament.
 
i'm afraid these are the good old days right now, things are going to start going downhill for personal freedoms
 
Mahi Karakatsanis. I went to law school with her. Pleasant, very bright lady who is considerate of counsel. Not sure about her political stance.

Bear in mind that Canada does not have the extreme left /right split that the US bench has. Most higher court Canadian judges have been brought up to be somewhat centre-left. My guess is that there are shades and nuances, but it's all much the same flavour of mild, liberal progressive.
 
Sharpe said "Charter adjudication is anything but the mechanical application of pre-established rules. The judges are called upon to delve deeply into the very foundations of our legal system and political culture to answer questions of the most fundamental nature, and many of these questions cannot be answered adequately by reference only to traditional legal sources."
Sharpe isn't suitable for traffic court. If he wishes to devle deeply, I suggest that he run for Parliament.

Apparently loved by Ziggy.

Maybe ol' Sharpe could help with the small claims court thread.
 
Sharpe said "Charter adjudication is anything but the mechanical application of pre-established rules. The judges are called upon to delve deeply into the very foundations of our legal system and political culture to answer questions of the most fundamental nature, and many of these questions cannot be answered adequately by reference only to traditional legal sources."
Sharpe isn't suitable for traffic court. If he wishes to devle deeply, I suggest that he run for Parliament.

You sir are a fuckwit.

Sharpe is arguably the most respected jurist in Ontario. He literally wrote the book on injunctions and specific performance, which are incredibly complex areas of law. Injunction motions can be brought to allow someone to search your home and remove records and computers without a warrant and without prior notice to you. Injunction motions can be brought to freeze your assets and force you to come begging to court to justify your living expenses. Specific performance can be ordered to force you to sell your house or artwork or other unique object, whether you want to or not.

Sharpe is also one of the most respected Charter authorities in Canada. The application of Charter protections almost always involves balancing rights. The Charter itself includes a "notwithstanding" provision that permits the government to breach a Canadian citizen's Charter rights if the breach is necessary and limited. Guess who decides whether the breach is sufficiently warranted? Judges like Robert Sharpe.

This is how Canadian citizens' rights are determined. You would prefer judges who simply kowtow to the government's wishes perhaps?
 
Fanofdo, can you or Professor Ziegel tell us of any state where appointments to their "Supreme Court" are made by an appointments commission? This sound like straight academic pipe dream.
 
What I would prefer is they kowtow to the law. If they want to make law they should run for office. It amazes me how this nabob feels entitled to make the law of the land. We have had a belly full of this sort of jurisprudence. Our supreme court has been a clown show for way to long. There have been too many poorly reasoned judgements and judges with the sole intent of making law and not interpreting. You raised the issue of balancing rights. I suggest that clearly expressed rights as stated in the charter should trump imagined rights.
 
What I would prefer is they kowtow to the law. If they want to make law they should run for office. It amazes me how this nabob feels entitled to make the law of the land. We have had a belly full of this sort of jurisprudence. Our supreme court has been a clown show for way to long. There have been too many poorly reasoned judgements and judges with the sole intent of making law and not interpreting. You raised the issue of balancing rights. I suggest that clearly expressed rights as stated in the charter should trump imagined rights.
Perhaps while it comes from the U.S. Supreme Court rather than the Supreme Court of Canada you might consider Chief Justice John Marshall's famous statement in the opinion in Marbury v. Madison "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is. . . ."
 
Perhaps while it comes from the U.S. Supreme Court rather than the Supreme Court of Canada you might consider Chief Justice John Marshall's famous statement in the opinion in Marbury v. Madison "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is. . . ."
There job is to know what the law is. As of late one gets the impression that the standard procedure is to render a judgment and then find what ever spurious precedent that is expedient to support the judgement. Before saying what the law is I would like them to know what the law is and respect what the law is.
 
There job is to know what the law is. As of late one gets the impression that the standard procedure is to render a judgment and then find what ever spurious precedent that is expedient to support the judgement. Before saying what the law is I would like them to know what the law is and respect what the law is.

It is obvious that you know nothing about the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. While the effect of judgements in Charter cases is to make law the Justices in making their decisions and making findings of what the law is not what they think it should be. The fundamental rights and freedoms which are guaranteed to all Canadians ar not necessarily codified in them law and are dependent upon interpretation. Instead of talking out of your ass and spouting cliches which for the most part come from the GOP and tea bagger types you should make some attempt to understand how the SCC works in Charter cases.
 
There job is to know what the law is. As of late one gets the impression that the standard procedure is to render a judgment and then find what ever spurious precedent that is expedient to support the judgement. Before saying what the law is I would like them to know what the law is and respect what the law is.

Pray tell me, in novel situations, where did the precedents come from? Should those precedents last forever? Consider the Dred Scott case...
 
Fanofdo, can you or Professor Ziegel tell us of any state where appointments to their "Supreme Court" are made by an appointments commission? This sound like straight academic pipe dream.

I don't' have a dog in the race - really only know what I read. I find it very interesting that Ziegel would publicly state his opinion. It really is quite rare. For a person in his position to be so publicly critical, he must feel that there has been an injustice.
 
Terrific thread and one of the few forums where lawyers can weigh in without fear of political correctness or reprisals for stating their point of view. As for me I don't think that it makes any difference who was appointed from the list of candidates. They all bring their own point of view to the Court. To a large extent going to court has always been and always will be a toss of the dice. Notice yesterdays Supreme Court defamation ruling where the court was split all over the place. It's often impossible to know what the law really is and Judges exercise tremendous discretion despite the law. They generally listen to the facts and then apply the law that they think properly fits to reach the result that they think is best.
 
Pray tell me, in novel situations, where did the precedents come from? Should those precedents last forever? Consider the Dred Scott case...
This is exactly the point I made. Time and again we see, in many jurisdictions, justices who take it upon them selves to make public policy rather then ascertaining what the law is. We must be very vigilant that the justices we choose for the highest court of the land err on the side of popular sovereignty. Political issue are ultra vires and should be decided politically. The court wields the very dangerous powers that flow from res judicata thereby closing issues that the court has no business closing. How can long will it take to undue the damage done by the series of poor judgements the court has already rendered?