I think they are overhyping Irene. The projections I looked at said by the time it hits New York it will be a Cat 1 storm with only 80 mph winds. I've rode out a Cat 1 before down south and it really wasn't that bad. Now a Cat 3 or 4 is another matter - if it was a Cat 4 that hit the northeast it would cause a real mess. However a Cat 1 will not wreck large buildings in cities. All the Cat 1 did in Florida when I was there was blow some lawn furnture around and knock down the odd palm tree. There was some surface flooding of streets, but not that big a deal. If it hits the outer banks of NC as a Cat 2, it will cause some damage there.
That said, if it dumps a ton of rain on NYC that could cause flooding damage unrelated to the wind. I'm talking about wind damage when I say the Cat 1 I was at home during was no big deal.
The Bahamas got it today, but in Nassau damage was minimal with 60 - 70 MPH winds (not a direct hit):
(from The Palm Beach Post)
NASSAU, Bahamas — Despite the straw market destruction of their tent, other damage on this island of about 249,000 people appeared mostly confined to uprooted trees, downed tree limbs, a few broken windows on Bay Street and dangling electric lines, sometimes falling from snapped electric poles.
On New Providence, the Bahamas Electricty Corp. reported that that 30 percent of the island continued to have service Thursday afternoon. It either doesn't know the status of the remainder of the households, or the service is spotty or out completely.
By 4 p.m. many residents here were leaving their homes to investigate Irene's handiwork, despite scattered rain, still gusting winds and the threat of live electrical wires.
Kirkwood Evans, owner of Goldie's Conch House at the beachside Fish Fry Village, arrived to find his back pool room and pool tables soaked from driving rain that made its way under loose roof tiles. His sign too was torn from the front of the restaurant he said he's owned for 22 years.
"As long as the building is still standing, that's good," Evans said. "All this stuff, I can buy again."
Nassau resident Christine Mackey had no electricity, and didn't expect to for at least 48 hours, but she had her home intact and for that she was grateful.
"I was expecting it to be much worse than this," she said.
Indeed, while some Bahamians expressed concerns about tourism rebounding from the storm that has raked the entire chain of islands, Anthony "Grouper" Higgs said he's not worried.
"They'll come back," said Higgs, who is manager of a soon-to-open downtown restaurant called, Blu. "Putting the island back together won't take that much effort and we look really good in the wintertime especially."
-----------
Now Cat 3 damage, as did hit some of the Bahamas, caused more damage, with roof damage and even entire houses destroyed. Big difference between a tropical storm/Cat 1 and a Cat 3 or 4.
My Florida house is built to withstand a direct hit from a Cat 3 with no structural damage, though that strong a storm hasn't hit since it was built so I'm taking the architect's word on that lol. Of course it is built in the Florida style of concrete block wall construction and metal storm shutters over all the windows that can be closed with the flick of a switch. Northeast housing is not all built to withstand that kind of wind unscathed, esp concerning the roof and windows. So a direct hit on the greater NYC area from a Cat 3 or 4 would cause a lot of broken windows and roof damage. A Cat 1 not so much. Most damage from a Cat 1 is from flying objects left outside and broken tree branches being propelled at windows that are not behind shutters. If a tree branch hits your living room window at 80 MPH...