Layton and prostate cancer

Sisyphus

New member
May 10, 2011
112
0
0
I find it disturbing that prostate cancer is being down played as Layton's cause of death. In general prostate cancer is not given the funds and attention it deserves simply because it is a cancer men get. The lives of men are simply not as valuable as women in societies eyes. It is all the more disturbing that in a high profile case such as this prostate cancer is downplayed. If the leader of the opposition had been a woman and if she had died of breast cancer there would be a marshalling of fund raising resources. It is even more ironic that Jack did not mention prostate cancer in his last letter. :frown:
 
I don't know if that's actually true. It must just be your take on the matter. My friend had prostate cancer and they used a revolutionary new treatment at the Princess Margaret hospital. They inserted a radioactive pellet into the prostate and left it there for a year while they monitored him. Apparently it worked, because they've now given him a clean bill of health. The other most important factor with any cancer really, is to catch it early. If it's caught early you have a fighting chance.
 
I don't know if that's actually true. It must just be your take on the matter. My friend had prostate cancer and they used a revolutionary new treatment at the Princess Margaret hospital. They inserted a radioactive pellet into the prostate and left it there for a year while they monitored him. Apparently it worked, because they've now given him a clean bill of health. The other most important factor with any cancer really, is to catch it early. If it's caught early you have a fighting chance.

You mean jack Layton is not dead?
 
I find it disturbing that prostate cancer is being down played as Layton's cause of death. In general prostate cancer is not given the funds and attention it deserves simply because it is a cancer men get. The lives of men are simply not as valuable as women in societies eyes. It is all the more disturbing that in a high profile case such as this prostate cancer is downplayed. If the leader of the opposition had been a woman and if she had died of breast cancer there would be a marshalling of fund raising resources. It is even more ironic that Jack did not mention prostate cancer in his last letter. :frown:

It's true that some cancers like breast cancer, are getting more money, but it's changing. The biggest thing to deal with is mens resistance and that damn machismo thing; it's nothing serious dear, I alway piss in two directions. Lung cancer in women and colon cancer in everyone are also getting noticed. I lost a friends to ovarian cancer because she wouldn't get a pap test as they were not nice.
 
AFAIK, PAP smears do not detect ovarian cancers.

I stand corrected, my friend died of cervical cancer 7 years ago, but according to Medical professionals there is a logical connection;

http://health.howstuffworks.com/diseases-conditions/cancer/ovarian/ovarian-cancer-diagnosis.htm

"There is no reliable screening tool available for ovarian cancer. If you have any unusual symptoms, consult with your health care professional. Diagnosis starts with a pelvic exam and Pap smear, a relatively painless test that involves taking a scraping of cells from your cervix and examining them under a microscope. Although the Pap doesn't detect ovarian cancer, it may detect cancer cells that have migrated to the uterine cervix from the ovaries or abnormal cells in the uterine cervix."

After the Pap smear, there are other tests your health care professional may perform.
 
And why is it not covered by OHIP? Is it not important? No, they just don't want to spend the money. Even hearing tests are not covered. You could be going deaf and what do they give a fuck! Those lousy bastards.
 
And why is it not covered by OHIP? Is it not important? No, they just don't want to spend the money. Even hearing tests are not covered. You could be going deaf and what do they give a fuck! Those lousy bastards.

I believe the cost for PSA have been covered at one time, but in todays politics say no. Hearing tests are covered if ordered by a specialist. I get them regularly and have never paid a penny.
 
I believe the cost for PSA have been covered at one time, but in todays politics say no. Hearing tests are covered if ordered by a specialist. I get them regularly and have never paid a penny.


Well my MD sent to me a specialist and it was not covered, so i don't know.
 
The entire health care system here is totally fucked up. They know the benefits of chiropractic treatment, physiotherapy, massage therapy and accupuncture. They just won't cover it cuz it's considered alternative medicine. That's their fucking excuse. My MD even recommended physiotherapy for me and they still wouldn't cover it. I'm on ODSP and they wouldn't cover any of those treatments!
 
And why is it not covered by OHIP? Is it not important? No, they just don't want to spend the money. Even hearing tests are not covered. You could be going deaf and what do they give a fuck! Those lousy bastards.

Actually the reasoning behind it is due to it possibly giving false positive results, and therefore not being 100% accurate so it is not considered a primary diagnostic test supposedly... Or at least that is the rhetoric I heard spewed at a man who complained.
 
Well there is simply no end to the amount of money that we can spend on health care. NO LIMIT.

Where do you want it to stop?

Most people want it to stop just past their present needs.

If you don't use much, then neither should others. If you want a lung transplant for your 82 year old ex-smoker father, then "the bastards" should not be so heartless to deny him another three years with his grandchildren for a measly $2-3 million bucks!


I understand. And i agree with you, to a point. But if you're going to use smoking as an example then the gov't should just make it illegal. They spend billions to treat the effects of smoking on people's health and anti smoking ads, but they sure as hell like collecting the taxes on cigarettes, don't they?
 
It is not uncommon for people to have two types of cancer, completely unrelated to either cancer.

But you knew that!

The president of the company where i used to work died of lung cancer. But they didn't find out about the lung cancer till later. He was first diagnoed with a brain tumor. It is often the case that there is a secondary cancer.
 
Does anyone know specifically what type of cancer killed Layton? That seems to be a bit of a mystery, I haven't seen the specific cancer mentioned, other than the prostate cancer that was cured. Colon cancer? Lung cancer? Pancreatic?
 
Does anyone know specifically what type of cancer killed Layton? That seems to be a bit of a mystery, I haven't seen the specific cancer mentioned, other than the prostate cancer that was cured. Colon cancer? Lung cancer? Pancreatic?

I was kind of wondering that myself.

Now that he's gone, it should not be such a big secret.
 
I agree and I think it should be public knowledge right now. I'm saddened that he passed away but we need to create awareness of all cancers.

So where do you put a limit to it. Should they be expected to offer a DNA sample to look for the possibility of debilitating diseases or family traits It's crazy. If a parent's has Alzheimer's disease or a prevalence to heart disease or stroke, or if there was a record of mental illness in previous generations, do we say no thanks you may be half way there.
 
I agree and I think it should be public knowledge right now. I'm saddened that he passed away but we need to create awareness of all cancers.

I am no expert but my understanding is that metastasis can be induced by cancer surgery.
The link between cancer surgery and recurrence is probably well established knowledge.
But if Layton's cause of death is the operation that was supposed to have cured him of
his first cancer it might not be a good idea to publicize his second cancer.
 
I am no expert but my understanding is that metastasis can be induced by cancer surgery.
The link between cancer surgery and recurrence is probably well established knowledge.
But if Layton's cause of death is the operation that was supposed to have cured him of
his first cancer it might not be a good idea to publicize his second cancer.

Matastisized cancer is the spread of the original cancer, in this case prostate, usually to other organs. The cancer cells are the same just in a different location usually having travelled through the lymp node system. I have been told as well that surgery, in some cases, can facilitate that. In many cases if you have a stage 3 tumour (tumour has spread to a lymph node) you get pre-surgery treatment such as radiation.

The implication from the released statements is that it was a different cancer, not prostate related. If it had been matastisized in would have been in other organs and the last days or week would have likely required significant doses of morphine to be bearable and he would not have been lucid enough to pen that final letter. I have seen this first hand and it is gut renching but you are happy the patient is comfortable even if it means they are too drugged to communicate.
 
It is all a question of early detection and treatment. If you can catch it in stage 1, or even stage 2, there are very good treatments, including surgery. In stage 4, the prognosis is very poor. As Christopher Hitchens said: "I have stage 4 cancer, and there are no stage 5".

The moral is: don't wait going to the doctor, and do not accept long wait times for treatment.