Was I ripped off?

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
Took my car to a very well known auto maintenance shop because my car was making noise.

There was a leak in the exhaust system. It cost me $350 to have it welded.
 
Took my car to a very well known auto maintenance shop because my car was making noise.

There was a leak in the exhaust system. It cost me $350 to have it welded.

could have booked a good SP and continue making noise
 
well if you are any sort of mechanically inclined you could have done it yourself for about 100$ or less. as for the welding they charge about 75$ an hour depending on the shop. so yeah you got taken but not that bad, they saw a suit and "my car is making noise please fix it" and padded the bill.
 
Seems a bit high for a weld job

BUT
What kind of car?
How much is the shops hourly rate?
How long was your car up the lift? Therefore preventing work being done on other vehicles.
Did they use any new parts?
Did they have to track down where the noise/leak was coming from?
Did they have to 'drop' your whole exhaust system to ensure that top was welded properly?

So many ?s that could alter the price.
 
I imagine they gave you a Bill, so check that out and see what you think. I recently needed two back brake pads, that cost me $560. A day after that the power steering in this (fairly new) car went. Took it back to the shop and that cost me $950 for a new steering box, on top of that the steering is still noisy a month later. I had to get the work done due to time constraints.

I now think that getting a good session with an asian agency on backpage is probably more likely to happen than finding a good auto mechanic.

But if I have more problems I am going to try taking it to a college, or training centre. At least you know they are not trying to swindle you.
 
Took my car to a very well known auto maintenance shop because my car was making noise.

There was a leak in the exhaust system. It cost me $350 to have it welded.

It depends where the leak was and if they had to remove anything to get at it. There are areas of the car where you can't get the equipment in, are going to burn up wiring or insulation if you try and weld it right on the vehicle.

Doing exhaust is dirty thankless work.
 
2 Flex pipes $90 total
Labour @$90 per hour = $200
Tax = $40


There was a leak, and they had to weld the pipes together. I timed how long the car was on up, it was only 1.5 hours at most.
 
When you say a leak in the exhaust system. do you mean it was a hole in the pipe or muffler. When I was in my teens I use to have a Honda Civic 92 that I fixed myself. I often had to fix leaks in the exhaust system in the pipe or muffler. You could do it for under $20 yourself by wrapping it with a muffler band and clamping it with hose clamps. ( Pipes and mufflers are better these days, they use to be crap back then )

Now that you posted the parts, I suspect you could have bandaged and clamped the leaks or you could have bought a pipe cutter and cut the sections out and clamped in new sections without welding. Go to CDN Tire and check out their muffler and pipe section and you will get an idea of what I mean.
 
Labour rate goes by the book.
Not by how many actual hours your car was hoisted up.
 
2 Flex pipes $90 total
Labour @$90 per hour = $200
Tax = $40


There was a leak, and they had to weld the pipes together. I timed how long the car was on up, it was only 1.5 hours at most.

Shops do not do jobs by the hour per say. They follow rates outlined either by the manufacturer, or by a company like Chilton's that estimates the time it takes to complete a job. Some manufacturers are more generous on times than others. Saab gives very unrealistic times for a mechanic to get the job done and mechanics are chronically underpaid working on Saabs. An experienced mechanic may be able to get the job done more quickly than the quoted rate.

There are lots of jobs where they go over book time and some that are under. If he is under, he is either very proficient at the job, or taking shortcuts he shouldn't.

Your original post was a bit misleading. There was the replacement of 2 pipes and some welding, not an existing pipe that was welded because of a crack.
 

Check out this video. Basically this is the way to do the repair. You could either cut out and replace the section of pipe or you can bandage it with a fabric tape dipped in silica solution ( no, not silicone )
On the bend I would use the fabric tape and aluminum tape with hose clamps. You can get all this stuff at CDN Tire.

The work that was done was reasonable in price, but there was the option for you to do it yourself for $20 - $30 of parts and 1 hour of your time.
 
sls3n6.jpg

You can get these bandages at CDN Tire.
 
Exactly but when the actual time is less, shouldn't they charge less, especially if you ask?
If it takes more time than the book states should they be allowed to charge more?

2 Flex pipes $90 total
Labour @$90 per hour = $200
Tax = $40


There was a leak, and they had to weld the pipes together. I timed how long the car was on up, it was only 1.5 hours at most.
Seems fair by their billing. Try to find a shop that doesn't upcharge so much for the parts or has a cheaper shop rate.
The above suggestions also vary with the type of car you drive.
 
Ceiling Cat;3630131[FONT="Comic Sans MS" said:
You can get these bandages at CDN Tire.[/FONT]

And you can buy more in 3-6 months once the band-aid wears through.
 
And you can buy more in 3-6 months once the band-aid wears through.

Ahh! Go back to post no. 13 and you will see what the secret is. Wrap the hole in the pipe with the bandage soaked in silica solution. Then put aluminum tape over it and clamp it. On the straight sections you can used beer can sections like in the video to cover the muffler bandage and then use clamps. In my teens, I use to make the muffler repairs last years. it would be the other rusted sections of the pipe that would blow out and I would have to make other repairs.
 
I imagine they gave you a Bill, so check that out and see what you think. I recently needed two back brake pads, that cost me $560. A day after that the power steering in this (fairly new) car went. Took it back to the shop and that cost me $950 for a new steering box, on top of that the steering is still noisy a month later. I had to get the work done due to time constraints.

I now think that getting a good session with an asian agency on backpage is probably more likely to happen than finding a good auto mechanic.

But if I have more problems I am going to try taking it to a college, or training centre. At least you know they are not trying to swindle you.
What type of 'fairly new' car does not have warrantee for a steering problem?
 
Then put aluminum tape over it and clamp it. On the straight sections you can used beer can sections

If you really want to use the redneck method a soup can works much better than a beer can due to the thicker wall of a soup can.
or you could fix it right.
 
As long as the material in the can is aluminum and not steel, you can test this out by using a magnet. A magnet will not be attracted to aluminum. Steel will rust out quickly. Ribbed cans may also be a problem.