Gay Pride??

No, but parents who are unable to have an intelligent conversation with their children educating them on these issues would be bad parents.

You're being argumentative again.

I'm not talking about gay issues. I'm talking about exposing kids to some of the hardcore displays of the GPP (the two guys walking isn't the worst I've seen).

I recall in one year, there were leather-clad guys with collars around their necks on leashes. Just like porn, a good parent isn't going to expose their kids to this. Why try to explain it when they're not mature enough to understand?
 
If you don't feel comfortable stay away whats the debate all about ? The solution is simple DONT GO !

The debate was started by people bashing the Mayor for taking your advice not to go. Your daughter's trite response to your question was predictable and wrong. We can and do judge public behavior and define what is acceptable.

You bring up an interesting point in your hypothetical breast cancer scenario. Do any breast cancer survivors bare their breasts at any of the annual Terry Fox Runs? If not, why do you think that is the case?
 
Last edited:
Exposed genitalia is not the same as nude. Your decision defines that to be competely bare. The act makes no special mention of genitalia, instead the test of whether a non-naked person counts as nude is whether they are dressed in a way that offends public decency.

As I've tried to educate you a few times the gay community would love nothing better than an opportunity to fight a charge that political expression of gay sexuality offends public decency. Given the way community standards tests for public decency works, and the presence of so much of the community, and so many community and political leaders in attendance, clearly tolerating their behavior--they'd win.

The fact that you have a terrible track record on matters legal only gives me further confidence in my opinion.
 
If you don't feel comfortable stay away whats the debate all about ? If you don't want your children to be exposed don't bring them . If your homophobic and a bigot then stay home and sit in your Archie Bunker chair and fix whats wrong with the world from your own living room . The solution is simple DONT GO !

Yes, the public should be forced to abandon their streets for a fringe element, of a legitmate group, who want to break the law.

How about ladies should stay home at night and not go out if they don't want to be sexually assualted...

I guess you don't think much of those take back the night marches...

Society has boundaries and borders, nudity and public exposure of genitals violates them.
 
Yes, the public should be forced to abandon their streets for a fringe element, of a legitmate group, who want to break the law.

How about ladies should stay home at night and not go out if they don't want to be sexually assualted...

I guess you don't think much of those take back the night marches...

Society has boundaries and borders, nudity and public exposure of genitals violates them.

You mean like the G20 cops and security forces? ;)

And your straw man non-sequitor about staying home at night to avoid sexual assault diminishes your points. You're better than that.


Now to the issue without directly pointing at any one individual:

Have any of the anti-Priders ever even been to the parade? The amount of nudity is minimal at best. About the same as you find when a sports team wins (beyond fuji's example, I still remember streakers of both sexes for the Jays WS wins and numerous tit flashes for Leafs wins and when Team Canada won the gold) or at the SlutWalk. These were all public events - no arrests were made, there were no complaints about lewdness and none of these incidents had the positive economic impact that Pride has. So again I ask, what's the problem?

I have never once heard any of the so-called defenders of societal boundaries complain about any of these incidents. Again, the anti-Pride element may claim otherwise, but their argument smacks of hypocrisy... and homophobia. Sorry, but unless you treat all public nudity the same, you're being a hypocrite; to ignore that and only single out the LGBT communities' nudity at Pride is homophobic.

If the majority of society actually cared about nudity, we would hear about it loud and clear. Since most either chalk it up to a couple of goofy individuals getting naked and silly or don't care whatsoever it is not turned into an issue. The 200,000 or so that attended the parade obviously didn't mind. Neither did the "law and order" police on assignment. That to me says society has spoken and they are not bothered by the occasional cock, breast or pussy. It's only the silent (internet) minority that come out of the woodwork around Pride that seem to have anything negative to say. Again, funny that it was gay pride that brought out this vitriolic fringe element...
 
Fuck the parade, nobody wants to be an part of an sausage fest.
 
You mean like the G20 cops and security forces? ;)

And your straw man non-sequitor about staying home at night to avoid sexual assault diminishes your points. You're better than that.


Now to the issue without directly pointing at any one individual:

Have any of the anti-Priders ever even been to the parade? The amount of nudity is minimal at best. About the same as you find when a sports team wins (beyond fuji's example, I still remember streakers of both sexes for the Jays WS wins and numerous tit flashes for Leafs wins and when Team Canada won the gold) or at the SlutWalk.

I have never once heard any of the so-called defenders of societal boundaries complain about any of these incidents. Again, the anti-Pride element may claim otherwise, but their argument smacks of hypocrisy... and homophobia.

If the majority of society actually cared about nudity, we would hear about it loud and clear. Since most either chalk it up to a couple of silly individuals getting naked and silly or don't care whatsoever it is not turned into an issue. The 200,000 or so that attended the parade obviously didn't mind. Neither did the "law and order" police on assignment. That to me says society has spoken. It's only the silent (internet) minority that come out of the woodwork around Pride that seem to have anything to say. Again, funny that it was gay pride that brought out this element...

I have some concerns about the G20 handling, but that is a different topic.

The don't go out argument has to cut both ways. The streets are a public place, people have a right to go out in them without having illegal, and potentially upsetting displays foisted upon them. People with a parade permit don't own the streets or get to say who can go out on them, they have the privilege of being allowed to use them for lawful and acceptable displays. They are public streets, and thus have limitations on what you can do on them.

I know having any limitations or acting responsibly is out of fashion for many, but that need, and that legal obligation continue, whether radicals like it or not.

Your comment about "if society actually cared about nudity" runs contra to most of what we know about political science. The term "silent majority" really applies in many circumstances, and may in this one. Many typical members of the public disapprove of a lot of things, but don't have the time or motivation to lobby or protest them. The silent majority also don't get much attention. But it looks like they just gave Harper a minority.

It didn't take long to roll out the homophobia label. I am not the slighest bit homophobic or even homo-hostile, and I support the Pride parade, but I don't support public nudity or overtly sexual displays in public. As I noted above, I don't like the idea of women giving birth on sidewalks either. Going to call me a misogynist now?
 
It didn't take long to roll out the homophobia label. I am not the slighest bit homophobic or even homo-hostile, and I support the Pride parade, but I don't support public nudity or overtly sexual displays in public. As I noted above, I don't like the idea of women giving birth on sidewalks either. Going to call me a misogynist now?

Once again, where is your and other voices of the "silent majority" when we see nudity in public for other events? It's that simple to me - you cannot have it both ways. Instead you use an absurd example of women giving birth on the sidewalks. That doesn't make you a misogynist, it just makes you a fool.

So far, you and your ilk have only been able to document two old queens in S&M gear walking down the street on Pride. There were no orgies, no blowjobs, no mass nudity and yet you still have your knickers in a bunch. Why is that? And why do you not show the same outrage for similar nudity at other, non-Pride events?
 
I have some concerns about the G20 handling, but that is a different topic.

The don't go out argument has to cut both ways. The streets are a public place, people have a right to go out in them without having illegal, and potentially upsetting displays foisted upon them. People with a parade permit don't own the streets or get to say who can go out on them, they have the privilege of being allowed to use them for lawful and acceptable displays. They are public streets, and thus have limitations on what you can do on them.

I know having any limitations or acting responsibly is out of fashion for many, but that need, and that legal obligation continue, whether radicals like it or not.

Your comment about "if society actually cared about nudity" runs contra to most of what we know about political science. The term "silent majority" really applies in many circumstances, and may in this one. Many typical members of the public disapprove of a lot of things, but don't have the time or motivation to lobby or protest them. The silent majority also don't get much attention. But it looks like they just gave Harper a minority.

You missed the point about the G20 entirely. You wrote that the public shouldn't be forced to abandon their streets by a fringe element (of a legitimate group) who want to break the law. My point was the scenario you posited was exactly like Torontonians were made to do by rogue cops during the G20, and that it was much more egregious breakdown of law and order.

...

So the fact that no one - not even Sun TV, the Sun or any right-leaning media - had anything to say about nudity or "sexual debauchery" at Pride doesn't make you think that the so-called "silent majority" were silent for a reason... as in they don't care. It's only fringe (internet) radicals like yourself that seem to care about the occasional naked man at Pride. And that is your right. But please don't try to speak for society as a whole - at least without some evidence of a "silent majority" being against Pride because of occasional nakedness and alleged obscenity (that doesn't exist.)

PS - The (not-so) silent majority gave Harper a full majority. But there was nothing "silent" about them, so I'm not sure what your point is...
 
Substitute rogue G20 police officers for naked fags, and then Pride organizers for G20 Police presence and see how your argument holds.

Are you really suggesting that police officers at the G20 and people in a parade are the same thing?

Were any of the offices nude and thus violating s. 174 of the CCC?
 
You missed the point about the G20 entirely. You wrote that the public shouldn't be forced to abandon their streets by a fringe element (of a legitimate group) who want to break the law. My point was the scenario you posited was exactly like Torontonians were made to do by rogue cops during the G20, and that it was much more egregious breakdown of law and order.

For the sake of the argument let's say the officers went well beyond the pale and assualted people. I trust you would agree that they should be charged and convicted. Would you say the same for the nude paraders, or is there a double standard you are advocating? I bet you would be upset if people told you the police should not be prosecuted making them above the law. Is there some reason that gay radicals should be above the law? IF what they are seeking, is equal treatment...they should have equal treatment.


So the fact that no one - not even Sun TV, the Sun or any right-leaning media - had anything to say about nudity or "sexual debauchery" at Pride doesn't make you think that the "silent majority" were silent for a reason... as in they don't care. It's only fringe (internet) radicals like yourself that seem to care about the occasional naked man at Pride. And that is your right. But please don't try to speak for society as a whole - at least without some evidence of a "silent majority" being against Pride because of occasional nakedness and alleged obscenity (that doesn't exist.)

Actually it was others who suggested society thought this nudity was okay. So if they support your view, they can speak for society, and if they disagree they can't? This is your idea of honest reasoning?

Is your argument now that the Sun or some other paper's complaint level is how we should chose to prosecute crimes or not?

The fact is, being nude in public is illegal. Many people find the idea of public nudity offensive or inappropriate. And from my point of view, that kind of silliness and childish negative attention seeking behaviour hurts the gay rights movement, not helps it. Being gay is not about cock rings and fetish gear, it is about two people of the same sex loving and desiring each other. In this case, the radical fringe is hurting the message of the quality majority.
 
Once again, where is your and other voices of the "silent majority" when we see nudity in public for other events? It's that simple to me - you cannot have it both ways. ...

Seriously ... why can't I have it both ways? I acknowledge that graphic nudity on a public street is likely illegal and (depending on which community you ask) also inappropriate. If, on the other hand, the nude display is of a very good looking young woman, why can't I agree that her display is both inappropriate and still pleasant ... at least to me? Why should I be required to express outrage if the woman is hot? Why is it hypocritical to point out that a nude display of a man (or ugly woman) is illegal/inappropriate and keep silent when the nude is hot? It doesn't make the hot nude woman (on a public street) any more appropriate. Let the people who were not pleased by nude woman complain about it.

On another note, a lot of the argument on this thread is in absolutes. The community this ... and the community that ... You are all talking about different communities. For fuji, the fact that many people marched in the parade and many others came to watch is somehow "proof" that the "community" is willing to tolarate genital nudity in a public street. For rld, the fact that many people did not come to watch the parade is "proof" that the "silent majority" disapproves. As has been pointed out many times in this thread, many of the people who did not watch the parade are probably okay with the occasional genital exhibition and some of the people who were actually marching were probably not pleased with the same exhibition.

Who here actually thinks they are speaking for more than their own point of view? Done any polling to back up your assertion?
 
Who here actually thinks they are speaking for more than their own point of view? Done any polling to back up your assertion?

You bring up a very good point. I can tell you I did a search for attitudes about public nudity in Canada and could not come up with anything scientific either way.

But there was an interesting case of a nude golfer who just got convicted...
 
Seriously ... why can't I have it both ways? I acknowledge that graphic nudity on a public street is likely illegal and (depending on which community you ask) also inappropriate. If, on the other hand, the nude display is of a very good looking young woman, why can't I agree that her display is both inappropriate and still pleasant ... at least to me? Why should I be required to express outrage if the woman is hot? Why is it hypocritical to point out that a nude display of a man (or ugly woman) is illegal/inappropriate and keep silent when the nude is hot? It doesn't make the hot nude woman (on a public street) any more appropriate. Let the people who were not pleased by nude woman complain about it.

Because rld and his ilk are talking about laws.

Would I prefer to see a hot woman vs. the guys in the link from the original post? Damn right. But would I argue that it is in some way different? No. And even if I were offended, I couldn't in good conscience label one as appropriate and the other inappropriate. In the eyes of the law, both are considered the same. My point is simply that you cannot pick and choose how you apply the law. Preferences are a whole other matter... but not the topic of discussion here.

As far as polling, I would suggest the fact that there is huge attendance and no public or media backlash against Pride would be the first reason to think that Torontonians support it or don't care. Secondly, I would go to the 2009 Angus Reid polling that shows most Canadians and the vast majority of Torontonians either support or have no opinion on gay marriage (a pretty controversial topic - far more contentious than Pride and parade.) Finally, as someone who was born, raised and grew up in Toronto, and as someone who has dealt with the public in my work life, I have rarely ever heard anything negative against Pride and the parade. As far as a Pride parade-specific poll, I will leave that to the organizers or those opposed to it to come up with.
 
Because rld and his ilk are talking about laws.

I take your point about the law. However, fuji has been repeatedly using the argument that if you did not complain about a hot naked woman, then you have no right to complain about an ugly, naked man. I do not agree. I see no hypocrisy in complaining about one and not the other, so long as your position on legality does not change.
 
For the sake of the argument let's say the officers went well beyond the pale and assualted people. I trust you would agree that they should be charged and convicted. Would you say the same for the nude paraders, or is there a double standard you are advocating? I bet you would be upset if people told you the police should not be prosecuted making them above the law. Is there some reason that gay radicals should be above the law? IF what they are seeking, is equal treatment...they should have equal treatment.

I would suggest that assault is very different - and much more serious - than public nudity. (If you can't see that, then there is no point in further discussion.) Further, as those who are entrusted to uphold the laws, police should be held to an even higher standard.

But we are moving away from the point at hand: Pride and the parade. And you still have not once answered the question as to why you and your ilk are outraged at gay (male) nudity and yet continuously silent about female nudity. That is the only double standard being advocated here.

rld said:
Actually it was others who suggested society thought this nudity was okay. So if they support your view, they can speak for society, and if they disagree they can't? This is your idea of honest reasoning?

Is your argument now that the Sun or some other paper's complaint level is how we should chose to prosecute crimes or not?

The fact is, being nude in public is illegal. Many people find the idea of public nudity offensive or inappropriate. And from my point of view, that kind of silliness and childish negative attention seeking behaviour hurts the gay rights movement, not helps it. Being gay is not about cock rings and fetish gear, it is about two people of the same sex loving and desiring each other. In this case, the radical fringe is hurting the message of the quality majority.

No one can claim to speak for society without having at least some basis in fact and being able to show that their views represent the majority. I am using simple logic: high participation/attendance + no public/media backlash + societal acceptance of nudity in general + society's acceptance of gay rights = society is more in favour of the Pride parade than opposed. It may not be as scientific as I would like, but it certainly shows that society is more tolerant than not. Can you show anything contrary?

And honestly, is that the best you can do? Whether the Sun or any media outlet complains has nothing to do with prosecuting crimes. The fact is, no one on those traditionally conservative outlets complained. And why? Because the vast majority don't care about a little bit of nudity.

...

The gay community doesn't give two shits about what you think is appropriate for the gay movement. If there was a concern, they would deal with what you call "the radical fringe" (a couple of nude queens in leathers) - all of the gay folks and Pride organizers are pretty straightforward and have no problem being confrontational when the need arises.

...

Let's be honest here, parades and events are not meant to be for everyone. They are not inclusive. Look at all of the other examples (Santa Claus, Easter Procession, Easter Bunny, St. Patrick's Day parades, various cultural street festivals etc.) - they are cultural or religious. People can choose to go or not. It is up to the City to decide if they should continue. The same with Pride. Until the so-called silent majority (minority at best) actually speak up and express their real and legal concerns with Pride, then you and your ilk can continue to ineffectually whinge and complain on the internet. Over a little nudity... (shaking head)
 
But we are moving away from the point at hand: Pride and the parade. And you still have not once answered the question as to why you and your ilk are outraged at gay (male) nudity and yet continuously silent about female nudity. That is the only double standard being advocated here.

I am happy to answer your direct question, and ignore the less useful part of your post.

I think women who show their genitals in public should also be charged.

If there have been other threads about nude women in public where this was discussed, I must have missed them or not bothered to comment.

Just because I do not read and comment on every terb thread does not make me a hypocrite.

Are you sure they gay community doesn't care what people think about them? Are you their spokesman? I thought they were struggling for acceptance...I guess your argument is that they are happy to be isolated.
 
I take your point about the law. However, fuji has been repeatedly using the argument that if you did not complain about a hot naked woman, then you have no right to complain about an ugly, naked man. I do not agree. I see no hypocrisy in complaining about one and not the other, so long as your position on legality does not change.

It is hypocritical if you complain about the legality of one and remain silent about the legality of the other. The law is the law. You might not like the sight of a naked fat dude and complain among friends, etc., (hell, we all do it in some way) but once you choose to talk about legally charging one but ignore the other just because you find it (her) pleasing to the eyes, you are being a hypocrite. And if it happens to be only gay dudes that you want to bring charges against for public nudity while ignoring other nude incidents, then yes, I feel you are being a homophobe as well.

(The "you" does not refer to you, Narg, but the "yous" in general.)