Gay Pride??

Gee ... Fuji. I'm sorry that I did not express the right degree of outrage over something you think I should be outraged about. For the record, until I read this thread, I was entirely unaware of any woman at the Stanley Cup "dressed in nothing but body paint". You want me to express outrage over events I have no knowledge of? Fine. Please be advised that right now, somewhere in the world, someone is certainly doing something that would outrage me if I knew about it. Happy now?

On a more serious note, I can simultaneously hold two separate view points. Most of us can. So, for example, were I to stumble upon a supermodel wandering naked around the Eaton Centre, I would enjoy the sight, while still considering it to be inappropriate and illegal. I see no contradiction in these two views.
 
Last edited:
Also nobody here has yet managed to make any case that it is illegal. It's not clear to me at all that people who are naked, or semi-naked, in a parade for reasons of political expression are in fact committing any crime at all.

Being painted may be a clever way to defeat a public nudity or indecency charge, or that the law isn't enforced for such a particular event if nobody else complains.

I know a criminal lawyer who successfully defended a stripper from a nudity charge years ago (guess laws were different?) because she was wearing an ankle bracelet, so maybe you have to exceed a certain threshold of conditions before they can charge you.
 
If being painted defeats the public nudity law then I can't see why wearing some leather fetish gear wouldn't similarly defeat it.
 
For the record, until I read this thread, I was entirely unaware of any woman at the Stanley Cup "dressed in nothing but body paint".

If you watched Hockey Night in Canada they were featured in the between period coverage on the Game 6 broadcast. I did not detect any outrage the next day from anyone anywhere. I am pretty sure that most of "Ford nation" would have been tuned into that.. but not a peep, well except the guys hooting about how great that was.
 
But I doubt those guys would walk like they are in the pic through the Eaton Centre, or around King and Bay, on any other hot summer day.

I agree, but I think those who are claiming there is anything illegal about marching that way in PRIDE are just plain wrong. There seems to be a tradition in Canada of tolerating nudity at major public events and particularly for political expression.
 
If you watched Hockey Night in Canada they were featured in the between period coverage on the Game 6 broadcast. I did not detect any outrage the next day from anyone anywhere. I am pretty sure that most of "Ford nation" would have been tuned into that.. but not a peep, well except the guys hooting about how great that was.

So am I to assume that you agreed with the second paragraph of my comment at #229 above? I assume you are willing to admit that an opinion of whether something is, or should be, illegal or inappropriate is not dependent on the aesthetics of the sight.
 
John you were previously demanding the whole parade be abolished and claiming that a "silent majority" of people would want that.
 
So am I to assume that you agreed with the second paragraph of my comment at #229 above? I assume you are willing to admit that an opinion of whether something is, or should be, illegal or inappropriate is not dependent on the aesthetics of the sight.

Absolutely agree with that.
 
It's the people who are calling for pride to be abolished that I am calling bigots, and I stand by that as accurate use of the word.
Who called for Pride to be abolished? I've read posts saying it was tasteless, I've seen posts saying the Mayor was entirely correct in staying away, I've seen posts that say they need to get their act together, I've also seen some posts that just plain don't like homosexuality, but banning the parade?
 
With Messi around, it's very easy to classify anyone with a more nuanced view of the Pride Parade, or of public nudity in general, as a homophobe or bigot. Unfortunately, that's just another way of trying to crush debate. It's like using "Nazi", "fascist", "communist", "pinko", "bigot", "racist", "whore", "nigger", "slut", "faggot", "misogynist" or similar terms to describe someone whose opinions you disagree with. The intent is not to communicate or persuade, but rather to silence dissent. For example, both Fuji and rld (among others) have made some good points from differing positions. Of course, once Fuji dismisses all oposition as "bigots", he's essentially admitting that he cannot continue rational discourse and has to resort to ad hominem attacks.

Personally, I have no problems with the Parade other than the display of genitalia. If you want to be nude below the waist, do so in private or in a semi-public area (nudist beach). If you want to be nude on a public street, in a store or at an airport lounge, then you risk arrest. Canadian society is gradually becoming more permissive (at least in certain major urban centres). This happens as people push the boundaries of behaviour deemed acceptable. However, just as some want to push the boundaries, there are others who want the boundaries to contract or stay the same. None of these positions, unless clearly motivated by hate (hello Messi ...), merits accusations of bigotry.
+1!
.
 
I didn't see the parade this year, but in other years, the genital nudity ( forget about tits, which are already legal) makes up far far less than 1% of the crowd.....it is being blown way out of proportion.
 
Who called for Pride to be abolished? I`ve read posts saying it was tasteless, I`ve seen posts saying the Mayor was entirely correct in staying away, but banning the parade?

Yes. For example, John Begood`s first post on the subject:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...d-Homophobic&p=3610364&viewfull=1#post3610364

Toronto is becoming the gay capital of the world, and I for one am not comfortable with that. Am I homophobic? If that`s what you want to label me, that`s fine. I don`t think I am. I have no problems with Gay people of Gay marriage, etc. I`m just so sick and tired of the Gay community shoving their shit in my face and then getting pissed off if I don`t smile about it. Gaood for Ford for not going. I think that by not going, his IS representing his constituents. The silent majority that would like to see the Gay Pride event in Toronto abolished all together.

Don`t worry. Between Harper, Ford, and soon Hudak, Pride days are numbered
.

I think there is no other word for that than "bigot". Wouldn`t you agree that I`m using the word correctly, in light of that post, Aardvark?
 
Fuji, I have been posting over and over again how I support gay rights, but am against the overt sexual nature of the PRIDE parade. I don't want to see the parade abolished. I want to see it cleaned up. That is my position and you have called me a bigot many times in this thread. Narg stated it more eloquently than I could. Those who revert to name calling in a debate do so because they cannot develop counter points to arguments made.

As far as outrage over the painted lady at the Stanley cup parade, you have not seen our outrage because there is no channel through which we could express it and you could see it, so let me state it here. It would offend me to see a nude, painted lady at a family oriented sporting event. I also thought the slut walk was stupid and immature, although I support the reason for the walk in the first place. I support nudity at designated nude beaches because the nudity can be contained to the designated area without fear that someone's child may be exposed to it unless the parents make a concerted effort to expose them to it by taking them there. I also don't approve of women walking down the street topless. I find it tasteless and offensive.

Get it Fuji? I don't think nudity (male or female, homo or hetero) belongs in public spaces. That does not make me a bigot or a homophobe. And when you make such statements, it not only exposes your inability to engage in meaningful debate, but it also shows that you, in fact, are the intolerant one.

I agree with you.. You are likely not a homophobe.. You're just prudish. I hear they're doing good things in Utah for your kind.
 
I agree with you.. You are likely not a homophobe.. You're just prudish. I hear they're doing good things in Utah for your kind.

There are other people on this thread claiming to be against public nudity that might just be prudish. I deeply suspect most of those people do not actually object to nudity unless it's homosexual, and I've got a list of who they are, and will be monitoring future terb threads on public nudity (e.g., women) to see whether they turn out to be hypocrits. But for now, I'll take those people at their word, and assume they are prudes.

John Begood, while he's saying he's against public nudity now, was previously saying that he wants the whole PRIDE event abolished, and that he isn't "comfortable" with the fact that "Toronto is becoming the gay capital of the world". That is not simply a prudish opinion, that is a bigoted opinion. He is a bigot. It's the correct use of the word.

He's since retreated to the prudish against-public-nudity position to cover up his bigotry with false arguments.
 
I didn't see the parade this year, but in other years, the genital nudity ( forget about tits, which are already legal) makes up far far less than 1% of the crowd.....it is being blown way out of proportion.

Basically - YOU'RE RIGHT!
 
I agree, but I think those who are claiming there is anything illegal about marching that way in PRIDE are just plain wrong. There seems to be a tradition in Canada of tolerating nudity at major public events and particularly for political expression.

Okay but you agree that it may be illegal elsewhere.

(I get your point though that for Pride or similar events, it's acceptable or tolerable. Mind you, such nudity is in the extreme minority, and the spectators accept it regardless).
 
There are other people on this thread claiming to be against public nudity that might just be prudish. I deeply suspect most of those people do not actually object to nudity unless it's homosexual, and I've got a list of who they are, and will be monitoring future terb threads on public nudity (e.g., women) to see whether they turn out to be hypocrits. But for now, I'll take those people at their word, and assume they are prudes.

John Begood, while he's saying he's against public nudity now, was previously saying that he wants the whole PRIDE event abolished, and that he isn't "comfortable" with the fact that "Toronto is becoming the gay capital of the world". That is not simply a prudish opinion, that is a bigoted opinion. He is a bigot. It's the correct use of the word.

He's since retreated to the prudish against-public-nudity position to cover up his bigotry with false arguments.

I couldn't agree more. I've been arguing it in another thread about whether or not Rob Ford is a homophobe. Most people applaud is lack of attendance because they figure he was against all of the "lewd" acts that would be taking place, and that's why he wouldn't endorse it. They figure this ties in with their own "family values" (which is a complete joke on an escort review board).

However Rob Ford then discovers that his own neice is the new captain of the new Lingerie Football League in Toronto, and tells everybody "I can't wait to see her first game"... Well if he refused to endorse pride week because of lewdness (not that he has ever claimed to doing so), then how can he endorse lingerie football? Most people will say that the two are entirely different, and I agree.. One is flaunting heterosexual activity, and the other is flaunting homosexual activity... That's pretty much it.
 
Fuji keeps saying the nudity at the parade is political, which I disagree with completely. It's a few exhibitionists under the guise of a politcal march (I don't even think a lot of the marchers regard it is a political march so much as a celebration) having their chance to expose themselves, which OBVIOUSLY brings them pleasure. Are the nudists angry? Waving signs, shouting angry slogans? No, I don't think so, they are generally having fuyn: they are having a party. I would be interested in people like Jennifer who I recall saying "it was a blast" disagreeing with that.

Historically, politcal demonstrations that involved nudity used it expressly for the purpose of shocking and getting attention, not as a way of showing that 'this is what they are like".
 
Now on the other hand, if it IS political, then politicians certainly shouldn't feel compelled to attend demonstrations and the like. So if it WAS a political march, then Rob Ford was no more required to attend than he was required to march with the Tamils on the Gardiner expressway.

So either way you lose Fuji.