Germany Invades Russia

The Nazis did have a socialist wing within the party but were eventually purged when Heydrich carried out The Night of the Long Knives.

Unfortunately for Germany the only man that could have blocked Hitler's path to the Chancellery, Paul von Hindernburg, was dying of cancer. There is a very interesting mini-series on the subject with Robert Carlyle as Hitler and Peter O'Toole as Hinderberg.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Gsy4xs02Hs

Field Marshall Montgomery followed Hinderburg,s Russian strategy from WW I to defeat the Afrika Korps in Egypt. However, Hindenburg made a crucial error when he allowed Lenin safe passage to Russia. Without him, Stalin and Trotsky would have cancelled each other out and Russia may never have been taken by the Bolsheviks.
 
Interesting to speculate on the different outcome if Germany had persuaded Poland to join in an invasion of the Soviet Union across its territory. By standing intransigently opposed to Germany's territorial ambitions to the East instead of joining in, they shifted Hitler's focus to speedily disposing of Poland's Western allies before he could get back to the business of defeating Russia and acquiring its empire.

Easy to imagine FDR and Churchill—and the French— prudently watching from the sidelines while Hitler did the dirty work of removing the Communist threat.
 
^^^

I severely doubt that the Poles would have ever agreed to such an idea. Although there was a "history" between Poland and White Russia, I don't think the Poles could have been convinced in 1939 to attack their slav cousins at the say so of a mad man.
 
^^^

I severely doubt that the Poles would have ever agreed to such an idea. Although there was a "history" between Poland and White Russia, I don't think the Poles could have been convinced in 1939 to attack their slav cousins at the say so of a mad man.

After Uncle Joe took over Poland, I think they wished they had... :D
 
^^^

I severely doubt that the Poles would have ever agreed to such an idea. Although there was a "history" between Poland and White Russia, I don't think the Poles could have been convinced in 1939 to attack their slav cousins at the say so of a mad man.
And clearly they weren't buying the concept at the time. But as diehard says below, after Adolf and Joe carved Poland up, the hindsight musta been running strong.

What happened is inarguable (unless you're a historian) but speculating on what might have happened, say if Poland had doubted France's military steadfastness, or Britain's, is quite entertaining. Poland's history of being invaded from every direction, by every available nationality should have made them as wary of their slav cousins as their teutonic ones.
 
Well, one could argue that if it weren't for Adolf being a madman, Stalin would never have had the opportunity to enslave all of eastern Europe for 50 years.

If there had been no Hitler, I don't think Uncle Joe would have started WW2 from his end. The Jerries came withing a hair's breadth of capturing Moscow. Hell, they were right outside the city limits, but they just didn't have what it took to beat the Russians and the Russians wore them down slowly but surely. Supposedly Stalin was completely and utterly shocked that Hitler had betrayed him. For days, he refused to believe it.

It took the combined armies of the USSR, USA, Canada, UK, Australia, Poland, France et al to defeat Germany. The Germans were way too naive, and stretched way too thin, and were taking orders from a madman. How they ever went for it, I'll never understand.

In the end, Stalin capitalized on his armies being so massive, so powerful and simply "being there" to enslave eastern europe.

The Western Allies could have combined to turn around and attack Russia, but we would have had our asses handed to us by the meanest most battle hardened merciless enemy ever to strap on boots in the history of the world.
 
Interesting to speculate on the different outcome if Germany had persuaded Poland to join in an invasion of the Soviet Union across its territory.

That's one of the more bizarre theories I've heard.

Germany had no use for Poland. None at all. Of course, neither did the Soviets.

In fact, a better argument is that Germany benefited from the invasion of Poland because by treaty they divided up the country and the Soviets moved their armed forces westwards to occupy eastern Poland. That pulled the Soviets out of their border defenses, something that had disastrous consequences for them when the Germans invaded in 1941.
 
Wrong.

In fact, Hitler eventually regretted including Socialist in the name due to the connotation with communism.

Would bet Hitler regretted many things.

Was looking for a video that compared the election propaganda of the Nazi and Russian socialist party, but can’t find it. The propaganda was all the same, power for the worker socialist stuff. Neither promoted that we are going to take over business one way or another, control the media and your lives, and be blood thirsty dictators.

Under the Nazi system, to be or remain in control of a business, you had to be a member of the Nazi party. Under the Russian socialist, the business would be controlled by a member of the party. Small difference.

http://mises.org/daily/1937


I’m not so up on the details of either party, just grateful not to have had to live through it all. But if Hitler calls himself a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, I’ll call him a duck.
 
Was looking for a video that compared the election propaganda of the Nazi and Russian socialist party, but can’t find it. The propaganda was all the same, power for the worker socialist stuff. Neither promoted that we are going to take over business one way or another, control the media and your lives, and be blood thirsty dictators.

That's a very superficial view of socialism. Not to mention incorrect when it comes to Nazi political theory.

The Nazis were not about the workers (as the communists and socialists were), despite the name of the party. The Nazis were about the German people (Volk) and in particular its culture and race.

It's also incorrect that the Nazis took over business. They did no such thing (except for companies that refused to play ball). Nazi Germany was as close to capitalist as you can get for a war economy. Big business made big bucks arming the German armed forces. If anything, the Nazis were pro-business not pro-workers.
 
The Western Allies could have combined to turn around and attack Russia, but we would have had our asses handed to us by the meanest most battle hardened merciless enemy ever to strap on boots in the history of the world.

The Russians were quaking in their boots when they saw what the US did to Japan. They wanted no part of the US at that time. If the US had a time to dominate it, that was it... before the Soviets developed their own atomic weapons.
 
Hitler made many mistakes in the Russian campaign. His worst was refusing to allow the 6th Army to make a tactical retreat. Instead they got encircled and captured by the Ruskies.

Postscript: The saddest part of the Great Patriotic War was after Germany surrendered and 800 million captured Russian soldiers and civilians were repatriated back to Russia and almost none were ever heard from again.
 
Hitler made many mistakes in the Russian campaign. His worst was refusing to allow the 6th Army to make a tactical retreat. Instead they got encircled and captured by the Ruskies.

Postscript: The saddest part of the Great Patriotic War was after Germany surrendered and 800 million captured Russian soldiers and civilians were repatriated back to Russia and almost none were ever heard from again.
Absolutely.
 
The Russians were quaking in their boots when they saw what the US did to Japan. They wanted no part of the US at that time. If the US had a time to dominate it, that was it... before the Soviets developed their own atomic weapons.
Well thanks to Klaus E J. Fuchs, Donald D. Maclean, Morris Cohen, Theodore A. Hall, Allan N. May, George A. Koval, Morton Sobell, Ethel and Julius Rosenberg, Harry Gold, David Greenglass etc. . . that time was far briefer than it should have been.
 
Wrong.

In fact, Hitler eventually regretted including Socialist in the name due to the connotation with communism.

But to say the Nazis started out as communists is as dumb a statement as a person could make. The whole raison d'etre of the Nazis (even in the early days with the Friekorps and other right-wing paramilitary groups) was to combat the communists (first in the beer halls and streets, then on the battlefield).

I suggest you go read the Richards Evans trilogy and educate yourself: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Third_Reich_Trilogy

Correct. Nice to find someone on this board who has actually read Evans.
 
Hitler made many mistakes in the Russian campaign. His worst was refusing to allow the 6th Army to make a tactical retreat. Instead they got encircled and captured by the Ruskies.

The battle of Stalingrad was important for Hitler as it tied down the bulk of the Red Army around the city. That gave time for Army Group Center to dig in and prepare for the main invasion. It delayed the inevitable for almost two years (operation bagration 1944).

Hitler always blamed his generals for not obeying his strategic orders and ultimately losing the war in the Ostfront. He was in favor of encircling the Red Army in pincer movements, thus destroying it.

The frontal assault against Moscow is one example of Wehrmacht generals going against Hitler's directives. After that failure the Red Army realized it could beat the Germans, even at the cost of countless lives in frontal assaults.

One of the saddest moments of the Great Patriotic War was the repatriation of Cossacks to Russia, who were betrayed by Churchill at Yalta.